Prestige classes that grant +1 level spellcasting are normally designed so that you can enter it only if you have some spellcasting ability in the first place.Jester of the FoS wrote:Well currently ALL KotS get spells, including the fighter/rogue types. But KotS spells which don't stack with paladin or ranger spells so they get a wide variety of 1st level spells but no 4th or 5h-level.
Fixing the KoS PrC
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
- Dimitri Mazieres
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 278
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 8:15 pm
- Location: Your friendly local mental health asylum.
Indeed. And we must not forget that alignment can't be detected in Ravenloft, so "good" could only be deduced by roleplaying, and as per the current description, the ability certainly leads to metagaming, as you said, with players trying to deduce which NPCs are good based on the attack rolls.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Or better yet, make the benefits apply when protecting defenseless creatures, period. One of the problems with the ability as written is that it invites metagaming, in that players could catch on that the "Innocent" their KotS is trying to defend is really one of the bad guys. Eliminating the alignment stricture altogether would allow the KotS to defend a Neutral PC who's been rendered helpless, while sparing the DM from blown plot-twists or having to track the alignments of every character who might need the Knight's protection.Dimitri Mazieres wrote:Maybe the Guardian of Innocence ability could be modified so it would only apply when defending good, defenseless creatures. That would avoid the tag-team exploit you mention, while still allowing you to use it if one of the other party members becomes helpless in a fight.
Good spotting there, Rotipher. We must not forget the poor neutral people that might be stalked by the darkness!
My point exactly! And I don't see the KotS as one of those classes. In fact, I think it's more geared towards a Rogue than to a Paladin.The Giamarga wrote:Prestige classes that grant +1 level spellcasting are normally designed so that you can enter it only if you have some spellcasting ability in the first place.
Edit: Credit given where credit is due
Last edited by Dimitri Mazieres on Wed Apr 09, 2008 5:21 pm, edited 1 time in total.
[i]"Many point out that this battle against the darkness is an impossible one, and they may well be right. Impossible or not, however, the battle for righteousness is one that only a few heroes are brave enough to undertake"[/i]
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
You mean good spotting Rotipher.
Defense is good but limiting a power like that really awkward. Defending "innocents" or "defenseless" is using descriptive terms to define a game mechanic. From a rules perspective (R.A.W.) that means that an KotS only gets their bonus when fighting monsters about to coup de grace or otherwise attack someone considered "helpless" in game mechanics terms.
The intent of the ability is defense, so I really don't see a reason it can't be used to defend allies. Otherwise it's use is sharply limited and during a dungeon crawl or offensive strike on the BBEG's lair the ability becomes useless.
But for defending the weak (non-combatants, or those the KotS believes are non-combatants) the bonus might increase.
Defense is good but limiting a power like that really awkward. Defending "innocents" or "defenseless" is using descriptive terms to define a game mechanic. From a rules perspective (R.A.W.) that means that an KotS only gets their bonus when fighting monsters about to coup de grace or otherwise attack someone considered "helpless" in game mechanics terms.
The intent of the ability is defense, so I really don't see a reason it can't be used to defend allies. Otherwise it's use is sharply limited and during a dungeon crawl or offensive strike on the BBEG's lair the ability becomes useless.
But for defending the weak (non-combatants, or those the KotS believes are non-combatants) the bonus might increase.
- Dimitri Mazieres
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 278
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 8:15 pm
- Location: Your friendly local mental health asylum.
Oops! Sorry about that! I'll correct it right away. (You sneaky FoS members and your look-alike avatars...Jester of the FoS wrote:You mean good spotting Rotipher.
You're right, Jester, it would be hard to nail that situation down as a game mechanic. The fix could be done as you stated, or maybe the Defensive Stance ability from the Knight Protector (CW) could be considered:Jester of the FoS wrote:Defense is good but limiting a power like that really awkward. Defending "innocents" or "defenseless" is using descriptive terms to define a game mechanic. From a rules perspective (R.A.W.) that means that an KotS only gets their bonus when fighting monsters about to coup de grace or otherwise attack someone considered "helpless" in game mechanics terms.
The intent of the ability is defense, so I really don't see a reason it can't be used to defend allies. Otherwise it's use is sharply limited and during a dungeon crawl or offensive strike on the BBEG's lair the ability becomes useless.
But for defending the weak (non-combatants, or those the KotS believes are non-combatants) the bonus might increase.
How about that?Defensive Stance (Ex): At the start of any turn when a knight protector is within 5 feet of an ally who has fewer Hit Dice than he does, the knight protector can transfer up to 2 points of Armor Class to the ally (making his own Armor Class worse by the same number). The maximum number of points he can transfer increases by 1 for every three levels beyond 1st.
[i]"Many point out that this battle against the darkness is an impossible one, and they may well be right. Impossible or not, however, the battle for righteousness is one that only a few heroes are brave enough to undertake"[/i]
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
No offense taken, Dimitri. My own EwtF PC specializes in being mistaken for people he's not, so on Crow's behalf, I'll take your confusion as a compliment.Dimitri Mazieres wrote:Oops! Sorry about that! I'll correct it right away. (You sneaky FoS members and your look-alike avatars...Jester of the FoS wrote:You mean good spotting Rotipher.)
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Dimitri Mazieres
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 278
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 8:15 pm
- Location: Your friendly local mental health asylum.
Good to know. I wouldn't want to be summoned to La Maison Soulombre to explain myself to the Fraternity.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:No offense taken, Dimitri. My own EwtF PC specializes in being mistaken for people he's not, so on Crow's behalf, I'll take your confusion as a compliment.
Back to the topic at hand, based on the discussion so far, I've been playing around with what could be an improved and updated progression table for the Knight of Shadows:
Code: Select all
Class Base Fort Ref Will Spells per Day
Level Attack Save Save Save Special 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
Bonus
1st +1 +2 0 +2 Mettle, 0 — — —
Guardian of Innocence +1
2nd +2 +3 0 +3 Smite 1/day 1 — — —
3rd +3 +3 +1 +3 Bonus feat 1 0 — —
4th +4 +4 +1 +4 Guardian of Innocence +2 1 1 — —
5th +5 +4 +1 +4 — 1 1 0 —
6th +6 +5 +2 +5 Smite 2/day 1 1 1 —
7th +7 +5 +2 +5 Guardian of Innocence +3 2 1 1 0
8th +8 +6 +2 +6 - 2 1 1 1
9th +9 +6 +3 +6 Hide in Plain Sight 2 2 1 1
10th +10 +7 +3 +7 Smite 3/day, 2 2 2 1
Guardian of Innocence +4Guardian of Innocence (Ex): The Knight of Shadows commitment to the protection of others is so strong that it provides her with unnatural drive when her charges are in danger. Whenever a Knight of Shadows is fighting to defend her allies, she receives the listed number as a sacred bonus to attack rolls, saving throws and skill checks, and can transfer the same amount of points to a single ally's Armor Class, while worsening his own by said amount. This bonus applies for as long as the both the defended character and the attacking creature are within the Knight of Shadows' line of sight. If the defended creature is an Innocent, this bonus is doubled.
Smite (Su): Once per day, a Knight of Shadows of 2nd level or higher may make a single melee attack with a +4 attack bonus and a damage bonus equal to her Knight of Shadows level (if she hits). The Knight of Shadows must declare the smite before making the attack. Starting at 6th level, a Knight of Shadows can smite twice per day and at 10th level, three times per day.
If a Knight of Shadows has a smite evil or smite ability (for being a paladin or a cleric with the Destruction domain) already, she can use the ability one extra time per day (two extra times at 6th level). The attack bonus does not increase, but the damage bonus is based on the character’s combined level (Knight of Shadows level plus cleric or paladin level).
Hide in Plain Sight (Su): A Knight of Shadows can use the Hide skill even while being observed. As long as she is within 10 feet of some sort of shadow, a Knight of Shadows can hide herself from view in the open without anything to actually hide behind. She cannot, however, hide in her own shadow.
I still have to go over the spell list, as there are a few spells, like Negative Energy Protection, that no longer exist in 3.5.
I was also pondering about adding Wall of Gloom to the spell list, but I don't know what changes should be made to the spell as it appears in VRA, as it looks quite a bit more powerful than the version presented in the Spell Compendium, while both being a 2nd level Wiz/Sor spell.
What do you think of the changes so far? Too powerful? I must admit that the KoS is a personal favorite of mine, so I might have gone overboard with the improvements.
[i]"Many point out that this battle against the darkness is an impossible one, and they may well be right. Impossible or not, however, the battle for righteousness is one that only a few heroes are brave enough to undertake"[/i]
No, it looks like something more worthwhile now. Is the bonus feat from a list or just any feat you want? Are the hit die and skills the same as the original class?Dimitri Mazieres wrote: What do you think of the changes so far? Too powerful? I must admit that the KoS is a personal favorite of mine, so I might have gone overboard with the improvements.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
- Dimitri Mazieres
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 278
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 8:15 pm
- Location: Your friendly local mental health asylum.
Glad you think so.Isabella wrote:No, it looks like something more worthwhile now.
The bonus feat would be from the Fighter's list of bonus feats, as is usually the case with martial Prestige Classes. Hit dice and skills remain the same (although I confess that I didn't take a critical enough look at skills).Isabella wrote:Is the bonus feat from a list or just any feat you want? Are the hit die and skills the same as the original class?
The other change that I made was to give the class a good Will saving throw, since I like to think that KoS have to be strong willed people to endure the fight against darkness.
[i]"Many point out that this battle against the darkness is an impossible one, and they may well be right. Impossible or not, however, the battle for righteousness is one that only a few heroes are brave enough to undertake"[/i]
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
I'd at least require that the GoI ability needs the "charges" to be/seem weaker--lower HD that the KoS, maybe? Otherwise, this would be a constant bonus as long as the character is in combat alongside the rest of the party.
I'd also lower Hide in Plain Sight to 5th level, and add my Shadowfriend ability to 1st level abilities. Finally, as clumsy as it sounds, I would use Jester's option to increase spells from previous classes OR use the table provided. Non-spellcasters get a few spells, and preevious spellcasters don't get gypped.
I'd also lower Hide in Plain Sight to 5th level, and add my Shadowfriend ability to 1st level abilities. Finally, as clumsy as it sounds, I would use Jester's option to increase spells from previous classes OR use the table provided. Non-spellcasters get a few spells, and preevious spellcasters don't get gypped.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- Dimitri Mazieres
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 278
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 8:15 pm
- Location: Your friendly local mental health asylum.
We could use the mechanic from the Knight Protector's Defensive Stance ability (from which I borrowed the AC-granting part) which requires that the defended be at least 2 HD lower than the character.DeepShadow wrote:I'd at least require that the GoI ability needs the "charges" to be/seem weaker--lower HD that the KoS, maybe? Otherwise, this would be a constant bonus as long as the character is in combat alongside the rest of the party.
Wouldn't Hide in Plain Sight be too powerful as a 5th level ability? Because, for instance, Rangers get it at about 13th level, IIRC.DeepShadow wrote:I'd also lower Hide in Plain Sight to 5th level, and add my Shadowfriend ability to 1st level abilities. Finally, as clumsy as it sounds, I would use Jester's option to increase spells from previous classes OR use the table provided. Non-spellcasters get a few spells, and preevious spellcasters don't get gypped.
[i]"Many point out that this battle against the darkness is an impossible one, and they may well be right. Impossible or not, however, the battle for righteousness is one that only a few heroes are brave enough to undertake"[/i]
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Problems I see:
1) it's still a paladin-specific prestige class that doesn't allow full spell progression. They still end up with lots of 1st and 2nd-level spells but far fewer 3rd and 4th.
2) Hide in plain sight is useless for a class that specializes in heavy armour. It favours ranger-KotS but does nothing for fighters and pallys.
3) Why is KotS smite mechanically different from a paladin's smite? Why only one extra time? It seems odd that a 10th level paladin would lose a use of smite when they became a 10pal/2KotS.
1) it's still a paladin-specific prestige class that doesn't allow full spell progression. They still end up with lots of 1st and 2nd-level spells but far fewer 3rd and 4th.
2) Hide in plain sight is useless for a class that specializes in heavy armour. It favours ranger-KotS but does nothing for fighters and pallys.
3) Why is KotS smite mechanically different from a paladin's smite? Why only one extra time? It seems odd that a 10th level paladin would lose a use of smite when they became a 10pal/2KotS.
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
True, but Shadowdancers get it at first level, and I see the Knight of the Shadows as far closer to them than the ranger. Moreover, the level differences are not so great when you recall that these are prestige classes, which are bound to already have some levels under their belts. A 9th level KoS is at least 6 levels in another class, making this effectively a 15th level ability--later than the ranger. OTOH, a Shadowdancer must be at least 7th level in something else, so that's a total of 8 levels there before they can have HiPS.Dimitri Mazieres wrote:Wouldn't Hide in Plain Sight be too powerful as a 5th level ability? Because, for instance, Rangers get it at about 13th level, IIRC.
Finally, remember you used the Shadowdancer version of HiPS, which again suggests a stronger tie to that class.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Yeah, I don't see any way to justify not giving them their full spell progression for a class that is so paladin-esque.Jester of the FoS wrote:Problems I see:
1) it's still a paladin-specific prestige class that doesn't allow full spell progression. They still end up with lots of 1st and 2nd-level spells but far fewer 3rd and 4th.
Hence my Shadowfriend ability. In light of your comments, I'd lower the check penalty by an amount equal to the KoS level + Wis bonus, but only to Hide and Move Silently.2) Hide in plain sight is useless for a class that specializes in heavy armour. It favours ranger-KotS but does nothing for fighters and pallys.
Combine this with HiPS, and tell me if this doesn't sound like the writeup in VRA:
"The Knights walk in darkness, emerging whenever they are needed and vanishing just as suddenly."
Yeah, this needs to be cleaned up. Still, it's nice to see the KoS get a smite ability at all!3) Why is KotS smite mechanically different from a paladin's smite? Why only one extra time? It seems odd that a 10th level paladin would lose a use of smite when they became a 10pal/2KotS.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
How would you prevent this, though? If you change the KoS spell list to "+1 of original class", it's no longer a martial class. Could you instead say that instead of progressing in the KoS spell list, a paladin may instead choose to continue in his own?Jester of the FoS wrote:Problems I see:
1) it's still a paladin-specific prestige class that doesn't allow full spell progression. They still end up with lots of 1st and 2nd-level spells but far fewer 3rd and 4th.
My brother made his own version of the KoS fix, but the powers in charge of the board won't let him register. So I thought I'd share for him:
Skill Points: Change to 6+ Int Mod skill points per level
Weapon and Armor Proficiency: All simple and martial weapons, and all types of armor, but not with shields.
Code: Select all
Class Base Fort Ref Will Spells per Day
Level Attack Save Save Save Special 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
Bonus
1st +1 +2 0 0 Guardian of Innocence 0 — — —
2nd +2 +3 0 0 Armored Stealth 1 — — —
3rd +3 +3 +1 +1 Virtue is its Own Reward +2 2 0 — —
4th +4 +4 +1 +1 Keep up the Pressure 3 1 — —
5th +5 +4 +1 +1 — 3 2 0 —
6th +6 +5 +2 +2 Slippery Mind 3 3 1 —
7th +7 +5 +2 +2 Righteous Sacrifice 3 3 2 0
8th +8 +6 +2 +2 Determination 3 3 3 1
9th +9 +6 +3 +3 Virtue is its Own Reward +4 3 3 3 2
10th +10 +7 +3 +3 Final Blow 3 3 3 3
(Instead of all these variables with AC and damage and whatnot, lets just have them protect innocents by stopping some jerk from hitting them in the first place. Now they can defend whomever without a metagame argument over alignment. Yes, we put that final bit in so no one would complain about KoS doubleteaming, although I say its a valid tactic.)
Armored Stealth (Ex): A Knight of the Shadows no longer applies armor check penalties to hide checks.
(The Move Silently still takes the penalty, so you can't send these guys to scout your dungeon, but they can hide in the crowd or set up forest ambushes no problem.)
Virtue is its Own Reward (Ex): A Knight of the Shadows receives the indicated bonus to all Diplomacy and and Gather Information checks when interacting with good aligned characters.
Keep up the Pressure (Ex): If a Knight of the Shadow hits a foe with a melee attack, at any point before her next turn, she may take an immediate action to move up to your speed when that foe moves, so long as you end your movement adjacent to the target.
(This is to keep some twit from five-foot stepping and shooting someone in the face without you being able to do anything about it.)
Righteous Sacrifice (Ex): If a Knight of the Shadow hits a foe with a melee attack, at any point before her next turn, when that foe succeeds in an attack against one for your allies, you may take an immediate action to redirect the damage to yourself instead. You must be adjacent to the foe for this ability to function.
Determination: A Knight of the Shadows no longer automatically fails fortitude saves on a natural one.
Final Blow: If a Knight of the Shadows is reduced to zero or less hit points, she may immediately move up to five feet and perform a single melee attack with a +5 bonus to the roll. She gains a bonus on the damage roll equal to her character level. This attack is considered a strenuous action. She completes this attack before taking the damage, but still takes the damage once the attack is complete, regardless of effect.
Spell List:
Replace Detect Scrying with Dispel Magic
Invisibility to Undead is now Hide from Undead
Change Self is now Disguise Self
My brother adds that he wanted to make it a unique class with unique features that does something different, not just another gish or thug that any other class can do. The class abilities are a little more spread out than he'd like, but he didn't want the class to end up as a two level dip class.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Uh-oh, not another one ... what's the problem? Did the board not accept his e-mail account?Isabella wrote:My brother made his own version of the KoS fix, but the powers in charge of the board won't let him register.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
