Mmm... I don't see it as a paladin-specific PrC. While it certainly filled the paladin niche in the 2nd edition kit (due to the lack of paladins in the DoD era), I think the KoS is more of a freedom fighter type of character, and the 3e PrC could very well be taken up by a non-spellcasting class, like the Rogue.Jester of the FoS wrote:Problems I see:
1) it's still a paladin-specific prestige class that doesn't allow full spell progression. They still end up with lots of 1st and 2nd-level spells but far fewer 3rd and 4th.
I don't think that having proficiency with heavy armor means that the class specializes in its use (though, again, the 2nd Ed kit did look that way).Jester of the FoS wrote:2) Hide in plain sight is useless for a class that specializes in heavy armour. It favours ranger-KotS but does nothing for fighters and pallys.
I don't mean to sound repetitive, but a Rogue or Ranger character could take up this class and be a light-armored shadow-cloaked warrior.
The Shadowfriend ability sounds good, but I think it'd be better to lower the penalty by 1 per KoS level. Including the Wis bonus might make the progression (in this ability) useless for characters with high Wisdom scores.DeepShadow wrote:Hence my Shadowfriend ability. In light of your comments, I'd lower the check penalty by an amount equal to the KoS level + Wis bonus, but only to Hide and Move Silently.
And maybe follow Isabella's friend's idea and apply said bonus only to the Hide skill.
I don't think I understand this. A 10th-level Pal/2nd-level KoS would be able to use his Smite ability 4 times per day (3 from his Pal levels + 1 from his KoS). As a single class Paladin he would get 4 uses of Smite Evil at 15th level. Where does he lose a use of Smite?Jester of the FoS wrote:3) Why is KotS smite mechanically different from a paladin's smite? Why only one extra time? It seems odd that a 10th level paladin would lose a use of smite when they became a 10pal/2KotS.
Your reasoning is quite sound, DeepShadow. Hide in Plain Sight as a CL 11 (at the very least) ability maybe isn't that overpowered.DeepShadow wrote:True, but Shadowdancers get it at first level, and I see the Knight of the Shadows as far closer to them than the ranger. Moreover, the level differences are not so great when you recall that these are prestige classes, which are bound to already have some levels under their belts. A 9th level KoS is at least 6 levels in another class, making this effectively a 15th level ability--later than the ranger. OTOH, a Shadowdancer must be at least 7th level in something else, so that's a total of 8 levels there before they can have HiPS.Dimitri Mazieres wrote:Wouldn't Hide in Plain Sight be too powerful as a 5th level ability? Because, for instance, Rangers get it at about 13th level, IIRC.
Finally, remember you used the Shadowdancer version of HiPS, which again suggests a stronger tie to that class.



