What is broken in 3.5?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
steveflam
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 12102
Joined: Sun Sep 17, 2006 7:12 pm

Post by steveflam »

Let's see: first off I stopped playing D&D as soon as 3.0 came out like some people. Others just stayed within 2nd edition. I started playing again 3 years ago. So my thoughts on 3.5:

1) The first thing I noticed was holy jesus there sure is a lot of preparation that goes into creating a p.c. This is for players.

Skills

Ok as some people have stated some are useful and some useless. I have only dmed online and let me tell you I still have to get used to "Spot check..... Search....... Sense Motive......" you get the drift. Um anyone ever having played WoD knows where WOTC got their ideas for feats, traits and skills..... (Or any other game that used them this way before WOTC did). Oh also the int bonus and such are kind of crappy for some classes.

Feats

I find that though they are nice for p.c's they tend to make some classes more powerful than others. There are way too many as well. [I'll get to that in a second re books]

Experience & calculating it

Ok so all classes have the same xp. I don't much like that idea. The older system was better and made more sense.

As to calculating xp it's a lot harder. You shouldnt have to refer to a chart for HD and all that, each monster should have its xp alreeady marked down like in 2nd edition. If the said monster or foe has classes and what not you can adjust.

Combat
Where to begin. Well I don't know about you, but I have played in a tabletop game where we spent 5, YES 5 HOURS, in a fight. I think that the combat system is way too much. Imagine for a player how hard it is, just put that many times harder to control for a DM. It has to be simplified. Too many rules.

Books

OK so how many books were there in 3.5????? Just a thought here. I know we all love the game but does HAsbro really need all that extra cash? Some of us are students or can't afford all these books[yes ven those of us who work heh]. Ever try to read a pdf on the pc it's not all that fun.

All I'm saying is that by having too many books you don't know where to look for things. It should all be in one or perhaps two books for the pcs, same for dm's.

AC, BAB, Saves....

Well guess what? I like this system. It simplifies it.



Thieving ablilities as skills?

Yeah so whatever happened to thieving being strictly a thief skill. Now anyuone can use those skills. The good ole % and only for rogues or bards was fine. Now pretty much anyone can pick a pocket?

Spells & Magic Users

Well let's see. Spells are pretty much fine. I think they did a good enough job of making the spells at good levels and also by adding 8th n 9th level spells for Priests made it more interesting of course. I know some of you may be disappointed that Wraithform is now a much higher level spell.... but think about it, that was a pretty powerful spell for 3rd level! OK whatever happened to Know Alignment? This convetrsation came up between me and Van somewhere else actually, we thought it existed.

I think Magic users are now much more powerful at lower levels thanks to feats. Before a mage was a wimp until a higher level and now he is pretty good up there with fighters. At higher levels the mage is still powerful.


Monks and prestige classes

I am happy to see this class back(Just ask Joel or Jonathan Winters or even Nathan or NT - I use it a lot!) Iactually like what they did with this class as compared to 1st edition.

I think the Assassin should be a class period and just use the old 1st edition rules on them.

Most other prestige classes, well someone mentioned here about the mystic theurge. Yeah that kind of makes a pc one powerful dude. I stil think that lots of prestige classes could be added to classes instead of making them prestige classes. BY this I mean after attaining a certain level you gain a title say at 8th level you are a thaumaturgist etc.
Most prestige classes are pretty lame IMO.

Well that was my rant for 3.5!
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

tarlyn wrote: Books

OK so how many books were there in 3.5????? Just a thought here. I know we all love the game but does HAsbro really need all that extra cash? Some of us are students or can't afford all these books[yes ven those of us who work heh]. Ever try to read a pdf on the pc it's not all that fun.

All I'm saying is that by having too many books you don't know where to look for things. It should all be in one or perhaps two books for the pcs, same for dm's.
Opposed to what?
The Complete ____ Handbook (fighter's, ranger's, priest's, paladin's, bard's, druid's, wizard's, barbarian's, gladiator's, psionic, ninja's, necromancer's)
The Complete Book of ____ (elves, dwarves, humanoids, gnomes and halflings)
The Tome of Magic, Legends & Lore The Book of Artifacts, Arms & Equipment
the multi-volume compendiums of wizard and cleric spells, the multi-volume compendiums of magic items
The half-dozen era books and DM option books
The player's option books (combat & tactic, high level adventures, skill & powers, spells & magic)

That's 37 before I get into the monster books or the mammoth collection of campaign setting books.
Really, before campaign settings 2e and 3.5 are almost even for the number of books. Yeah, 3e in generally probably has more (reprinted books and such) and it lasted for a shorter length of time, but WotC doesn't have stretches of dead months when bankruptcy cut into products. And if you add in campaign settings, TSR blows WotC out of the water.
steveflam
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 12102
Joined: Sun Sep 17, 2006 7:12 pm

Post by steveflam »

YOu're right on all those books, but what I meant was in 2nd edition we didn't use all of those books for p.c creation. If you created a pc in 2nd edition it was a lot easier.You could chose from say 3 books. In 3.5 there are more books to chose from which comes back to what I said about p.c creation.... holy moly!
User avatar
Le Noir Faineant
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 4592
Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 12:25 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Barovia

Post by Le Noir Faineant »

I have the honor of quoting myself on this:
Rafael wrote: So, here goes my rant about 3e:

1. I generally dislike systems that require players to read books before the game itself starts. At least from my experience, all players had to have at least rough knowledge about the game before one could really enjoy it.
My alternatives were pretty simplistic, because I personally relied stuff like Mentzer D&D or the new Basic Fantasy RPG.

2. Feat/Talents: Too many, scattered around in too many books. To fully understand especially high level chars, one had to do a lot of out-of-game research, which is also very bad imo. Games should not require extensive rules research IMO, and the only tough job for a DM should be to prepare the respective adventures.

3. Skills: NEVER used them in my game. Maybe that's just me, but no player ever asked "Hey, I am out there in the wilderness, can I make a use rope check to see if I can build our tent?". The only skills that where of use were the knowledge slots, and I usually skipped those things, the oldschooler that I am, by an INT or WIS check. It only slowed the game down for us and killed a lot of the atmosphere.

4. Magic: Two objections here. First, the magic system lacked of concept IMO, and a point-buy like later introduced in Zeitgeist Games' Wizards Cabal or Green Ronin's Thieves World books prooved to be easier to understand, and it was easier to rule about the players actions as a DM.
Plus, magic being so overpowered in 3e, it destroyed party equilibrium at higher levels, at least in the games I participated in.

5. Furthermore, I disliked the dungeoneering emphasis of the game. All one can do well with d20 is fight. Especially for RL, this just not enough.

For me personally, my dissatisfaction with 3e has lead me to other role playing systems I had not known before, mainly NWoD for Gothic style play and Warhammer FRP, which is the funniest fantasy RPG I played so far.

So, 4e is likely a no-go for me if it doesn't fix the major concerns I had with the game... :)
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

tarlyn wrote:YOu're right on all those books, but what I meant was in 2nd edition we didn't use all of those books for p.c creation. If you created a pc in 2nd edition it was a lot easier.You could chose from say 3 books. In 3.5 there are more books to chose from which comes back to what I said about p.c creation.... holy moly!
True, that's been a pattern with 3E/3.5. It's probably going to be true of 4E too, I'm afraid. It was WotC's solution to the fact that products which don't include PC-creation options tend to sell poorly: there are a lot fewer DMs than players out there, so DM-oriented books have a smaller audience built right into them.

That's probably why we never saw a 3E version of the World Builder's Guidebook -- for its price, one of the most useful products in 2E's history -- and a few other DM-specific resources from old editions.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
The Giamarga
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2313
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
Location: wandering

Post by The Giamarga »

tarlyn wrote: Thieving ablilities as skills?

Yeah so whatever happened to thieving being strictly a thief skill. Now anyuone can use those skills. The good ole % and only for rogues or bards was fine. Now pretty much anyone can pick a pocket?
So you'd rather have it as in 2E where only Thieves can Listen or Climb?

Sure anybody can learn to Pick Pockets or Open Locks, hell i do own a set of lockpicks and though i'm nto very good with them i can open a few padlocks. But Sleight of Hand and Open Locks are class skills only for a select few classes so only they can excel in it.

While i do think there are some problems with the Skill System by and large it is a biiiig improvement over 2E.
steveflam
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 12102
Joined: Sun Sep 17, 2006 7:12 pm

Post by steveflam »

I agree with you on that, Roti. Jester Im not putting it down I am just stating my opinion. I just feel that for p.c creation there are a lot of books to chose from.
User avatar
The Giamarga
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2313
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
Location: wandering

Post by The Giamarga »

tarlyn wrote:You're right on all those books, but what I meant was in 2nd edition we didn't use all of those books for p.c creation. If you created a pc in 2nd edition it was a lot easier.You could chose from say 3 books. In 3.5 there are more books to chose from which comes back to what I said about p.c creation.... holy moly!
Same thing in 3E. You can create a PC from the PHB alone or only use the PHB and the Complete Warrior for a Fighter for example. There's no need to use all available books, the same that there was no need to use Character Kits in 2E. It's all options.

But the 3E PHB gives a you a lot more options to create for example a Fighter than the 2E PHB. In 2E your fighter is pretty much defined by his race, ability scores, and choice of weapons. In 3E you can make a Knight or an Archer differ by more than just their chosen weapon.

The problem is the way people go about designing characters in 3E. You choose race to gain some mechanical benefit and try to tweak out the character until he is optimized. If your goal is the mechanically optimal character then yes knowing more books is good.

I think this is a philosophical problem with 3E, on the one hand now everything somehow has to be balanced, on the other hand you have to optimize your character to the limit. It's a problem with the way the game is played. I'm not sure if it is inherent in the system itself.
Last edited by The Giamarga on Wed Apr 16, 2008 10:38 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

If I may, I don't believe the needs of this thread are best met by comparing 3.5 with 2E. We need to discuss what is intrinsically wrong with 3.5, apart from comparisons with any other systems.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
The Giamarga
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2313
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
Location: wandering

Post by The Giamarga »

Good point DS.
User avatar
Lord Soth
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 264
Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus

Post by Lord Soth »

Wizards should be more powerful in higher levels because they are weaker in low levels.


Except that's not balance at all. When you have a class which is underpowered at one point, and then grossly overpowered at another point, that's the very definition of imbalance.
Also most great warriors weren't a match against most great wizards.


There're plenty instances in fantasy where Wizards didn't grossly overpower warriors. Take Conan. He killed Wizards on a regular basis. Gandalf was a Maiar, and even then, his Wizardry wasn't all that impressive, and he spent most of his time fighting hand-to-hand with Glamdring. Merlin wasn't an unstoppable death machine, either. The whole "Wizards overpower Warriors" thing is, for the most part, a convention that was born in D&D. There're some fantasy novels out there where magic is the end-all and be-all, but D&D wasn't based on them. And when you've got an RPG which involves cooperative gameplay, then magic should most certainly not overshadow everything else.
Last edited by Lord Soth on Wed Apr 16, 2008 3:50 pm, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Le Noir Faineant
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 4592
Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 12:25 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Barovia

Post by Le Noir Faineant »

DeepShadow wrote:If I may, I don't believe the needs of this thread are best met by comparing 3.5 with 2E. We need to discuss what is intrinsically wrong with 3.5, apart from comparisons with any other systems.
Seconded.

I also agree with Tarlyn's point on the structure of the books.
The publishing structure of 3e was one of the points I lost interest in it.
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

DeepShadow wrote:If I may, I don't believe the needs of this thread are best met by comparing 3.5 with 2E. We need to discuss what is intrinsically wrong with 3.5, apart from comparisons with any other systems.
Thirded, if I may. That's the original goal of this post, to see what needs tweaking. We'll see next in another thread the houserules and other adjustments we can make, and perhaps with Paizo 3.75 too.

We can argue over what another poster said, with possible examples from 2e or other systems, but the goal is not to say which one is superior to another.

This thread is for 3.5 users who want to improve the system.

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

My biggest problems with 3E are the old-school hangons like "saves" and "BAB." The skill system works just fine if you use it; why not turn "fighting" into a skill and let people take ranks in it like any other? Make it a class skill for fighters, rangers, paladins and barbarians. You get the idea. Reflex save is a Tumble skill check. Will save is a Concentration check--notice how all the classes that have strong Will saves have Concentration as a class skill? I agree that some skills need to be rolled together, like the Perception skill as a Spot/Listen/Search combo.

While I'm on the subject, I'd like to see every skill get some "ooomph" with the proper ranks. I mean ANY SKILL. If people put 15 ranks in a profession skill, I say they get extra funds, because they have a marketable skill apart from sticking things with sharp objects. In my 16 Tons RPG I solved this problem by tying magic to crafts and domestic skills, but this was in line with the folkloric tone; not all RPG's can use this solution, but something has to be done.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Yeah, that stems from 2e where there was the combat system and the entirely unrelated proficiency system.

It would be an interesting system to blend the two, and easily done. Remove the 4x skill points and first level and reduce skill DCs. Give every martial class an extra skill point and make it class for them.

The problem is feats like "skill focus" and munchkins in general. With that system a wizard who is willing to take a hit elsewhere (easy with a high Int) can hit almost as well as a fighter.
And it does rely on the already overly complicated skill system.

And since when is BAB an "old-school hang-on"?
Post Reply