Say hello to the 4E Lich and Vampire Lord! (4E DMG Excerpt)
- Lord Soth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 264
- Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
- Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus
That's not the same as "no weaknesses nor vulnerabilities whatsoever".
And while I don't care for the lack of damage from sunlight, that's not without precedent. Van Richten's Guide to Vampires states that vampires, as they age, gain increasing immunity to sunlight, until the oldest are no longer affected by sunlight. It also says that some younger vampires also share that immunity. This is a Vampire Lord, so it's likely meant to represent the older vampires. Looks like a compromise between vampires of a certain age and the oldest. There's no time limit on how long they can stay out in the sun, but it always weakens them (keeping them from regenerating).
And an important thing to note is, just because it doesn't state it in the combat stats, it doesn't mean things don't exist. For instance, you'd think from the combat stats that NPC's and monsters don't have Healing Surges, but they have them. Likewise, there may be other things which are true about vampires aside from what's listed in their combat stats.
And while I don't care for the lack of damage from sunlight, that's not without precedent. Van Richten's Guide to Vampires states that vampires, as they age, gain increasing immunity to sunlight, until the oldest are no longer affected by sunlight. It also says that some younger vampires also share that immunity. This is a Vampire Lord, so it's likely meant to represent the older vampires. Looks like a compromise between vampires of a certain age and the oldest. There's no time limit on how long they can stay out in the sun, but it always weakens them (keeping them from regenerating).
And an important thing to note is, just because it doesn't state it in the combat stats, it doesn't mean things don't exist. For instance, you'd think from the combat stats that NPC's and monsters don't have Healing Surges, but they have them. Likewise, there may be other things which are true about vampires aside from what's listed in their combat stats.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
FWIW, these may not be the complete DMG entries on the templates, just the portion they saw fit to release at the moment. If there are additional chunks of flavor-text to accompany the templates -- which is likely, if they're to adequately introduce unique D&D monsters (liches, death knights, etc) to newbies -- they might've left that "fluff" out, as it's the "crunch" which established gamers will be most interested in.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Am I the only one that thinks the vampire lord's description is so abruptly cut off after the mist that seems there is more text there... except not in the blurb?
Perhaps we haven't seen all of it.
Perhaps we haven't seen all of it.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Le Noir Faineant
- Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 4592
- Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 12:25 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Barovia
Yepp - "Shadowfell" is something like "Ravenloft in cheap". The *mist rising* element is apparently indeed coming back, but in a very generic form. - The entire points of light/shadowfell idea screams TSR Birthright, by the way. *Waits for Marauder and Mortepierre to whip him.*alhoon wrote:Am I the only one that thinks the vampire lord's description is so abruptly cut off after the mist that seems there is more text there... except not in the blurb?
Perhaps we haven't seen all of it.
I for my part will rather buy those books on ebay than this new stuff.
Lord Soth wrote:there may be other things which are true about vampires aside from what's listed in their combat stats.
Jester of the FoS wrote:Very true. And these might be included in the larger "Vampire" entry while we are only seeing the "vampire lord" template information.
Uhm, I don't see your point. Yes, there could be much more, they could have reprinted the whole VRGs as an add-on to the Monster Manual, why not.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:these may not be the complete DMG entries on the templates, [...] they might've left that "fluff" out, as it's the "crunch" which established gamers will be most interested in.
There could be anything. But we can't discuss what is not there, can we?
There could be a line saying "we are trying to bring this game as closer as possible to World of Warcraft", but until we see it, I can't use it to prove my point.
But we can discuss about what we have: combat stats for vampire and liches. That's what I was doing. Lord Soth pointed out a mistake I made, not noticing the part about phylactery. All of the vampire weaknesses I quoted from the SRD are combat stats, so unless the WotC guys are very tricky previewing some vampire combat stats and not others, they won't have vulnerabilities and weaknesses. Obviously by these I don't mean energy vulnerabilities and resistance (necrotic resistance and radiance vulnerability are common undead traits) but everything vampire-related, like garlic, running water and so on.
I hope my point is clearer now.
Coltiviamo per tutti un rancore
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
True, the combat stats do leave out some of the specific weaknesses and traits. But things like garlic and running water are really ways to avoid engaging a vampire in combat, not ways to beat it up. Keeping it at bay is more fluff than crunch, assuming they haven't changed things so that garlic actually damages a vampire. And approaches to killing a vampire that lie outside the bounds of the standard combat rules -- e.g. driving a stake through the heart -- will most likely require far more of an explanation than the stat-block's concise one-liner entries can afford.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Exactly. For my buck, I like that the templates are just templates. If I want my vampire lord archvillain to basicly be a corrupted paladin, well, gosh, here's the tool I need to add "vampire" to my NPC. If I want a villain that's just an archtypical vampire, I apperently have other options.Let's not forget, folks, that all your seeing here is the template info from the DMG chapter on customizing monsters. These critters also appear in the MM, and some of what you're looking for might be described therein. (Not guaranteeing it will, of course; just that it could be.)
The simplicity of 4e's monster customization is a hell of a lot more user friendly than 3e's stuff-generally, it seems like the 4e guys want to present us with flexable rules that let the DM say, "Okay, I want this guy to do XYZ, how do I make that fair for my players? Oh, I do this! Okay." and handle the fluff aspects with that whole "imagination" thing.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Yeah... not get tired of that at all.Sorti wrote: There could be a line saying "we are trying to bring this game as closer as possible to World of Warcraft", but until we see it, I can't use it to prove my point.
If the goal was to be more like Warcraft why are there no orcs and gnomes in the PHB? Why are gnomes being pushed more to fey illusionists than tinkerers? Why aren't they dividing the races in half and pitting them against each other? Why don't warlocks summon demons as minions? Why are there no shapechanging druids? Or shamanistic healers?
Warcraft's gameplay did things differently because they were good ideas. Most of them were not new ideas (heck, most of them were a good decade old) but the implementation was solid and well though out.
Innovations like giving everyone 'powers' and having them increase with level so you're often using the same ability at level 1 as you are at level 70/20.
Those are solid ideas and I don't think D&D should cross them off just because they're mostly found in online games.
It's not a deliberate "hey, WoW is popular; let's make the game like that", it's "hey, this idea works with the direction we're going, let's see how we can make something like it work in our game."
If they were actually, deliberately setting out to make the game more like WoW there are so-ooOOoo-oooo many more things they could do.
or check out this link:
clicky
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Jester:

Relax a bit, 4th edition is a good system. It doesn't need so much defence or you push people on the other side.
You seem so ready to jump into defence of 4th edition that you see attacks against it where there's none.Sorti wrote: There could be a line saying "we are trying to bring this game as closer as possible to World of Warcraft", but until we see it, I can't use it to prove my point.![]()
Relax a bit, 4th edition is a good system. It doesn't need so much defence or you push people on the other side.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
It's actually the Warcraft line that gets me. It's becoming a really sore pet peeve. 90% of the time it's thrown around without a single example and back-up solely but gut feeling and strong emotion.
It's the D&D equivalent of "immigrants are taking our jobs". I keep expecting it to show up on the Colbert Report.
But it just keep coming up again and again and again...
It's the D&D equivalent of "immigrants are taking our jobs". I keep expecting it to show up on the Colbert Report.
But it just keep coming up again and again and again...
Nah.It's the D&D equivalent of "immigrants are taking our jobs". I keep expecting it to show up on the Colbert Report.
It's because D&D is, in fact, taking some pointers from MMORPGS, especially with buffing the fighter-paladin-big warrior into a full fledged "Tanker" role. Weather or not this is a good thing, World of Warcraft, being the largest MMORPG on the market right now, is inevitably going to be the source of comparison.
Personally? I think firmer class roles work. It makes combat work better, and that's where you really need the rules to be smooth, fun, and not alienating any particular player. I can see the other end of the argument too.
As for gnome inventors, personally I've always seen that as taking the gnomes's origional inspiration from the "good fairies" that make stuff in exchange for saucers of milk or butter to its logical conclusion-the dwarves are the craftsmen, so the gnomes are the innovators. I usually let players play goblins-orcs-the big green humanoids because "half-X" feels kind of silly to me. If you wanna do a noble savage/monster race trying to be civilized, might as well go all the way.
But, anyway, back to the point: Yeah, I can see how it'd get old quick. But until another major fantasy video game comes on the market, that's the comparison people are going to naturally make.
- Le Noir Faineant
- Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 4592
- Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 12:25 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Barovia
- A G Thing
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1216
- Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
- Gender: Female
- Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan
Just some comments on the post...
One is that while I am shocked at the thought of the missing vulnerabilities I think that since these are templates that we are not looking at a base vampire so perhaps the vampire lord has gotten to the point where it nolonger fears any of those weaknesses. Definitely not good for all vampires or even all old vampires but perhaps a unique old vampire or an example of such. Adding a weakness is easy enough so like others have said perhaps it is a good thing to have such flexability and easy enough to change.
Two is the Lich. No phylactery is fine and perhaps it is a supreame achievement for a lich. As for if they need the chill touch effect or that it is a caster I have good experiences where a character is immobilized and the others have had to save them. It creates the turn around scenario especially when the PC's now must bargin with the Lich who has the unfortunate PC's friend in a helpless state. Plus it is another thing that they must work out to get past. While they do not need it, it also is a part of their dark mystque so it is part of what they are known for. Once more what would stop you from adding such your self. No big deal the way I see it. Perhaps there is a varient lich that just cannot do such and that could be something he studies about himself or something he fears enemies could exploit.
Three is that as for paralysis and level draining as I am currently running a Dwarf Barbarian who is subject to frustrating freezing effects or circumstances so often that the other party members have nicknamed him Freezy.
The other members found it hilarious that I under the effect of a curse was randomly frozen in the doorway before a combat in a cults underground jail/river slave transport room. They were all fighting desperately, and I only unfroze to run in and freeze again after they had all been reduced to unconciousness and two had died eight rounds later. I was pushed into a cell frozen but while raging I bashed the door down ran full tilt with a horn helm and skewered the ship captian. Then I turned and took down the Huge size amphibious Otyugh that they had weakend. From there I managed to salvage the party with some potions and we sailed the boat out of the dungeon to report to the town. It is one of our groups favorite combats ever and much roleplay came from us being in such a dire circumstance and then ribbing my character who hates the nickname.
Again on level drain I managed to pull a succubus from a room that was containing her when she appeared to be a captive prisoner. Thus the kiss for my heroism was at the cost of a level or as I put it "A peice o me soul!" luckily my party and I traveled back to civilization before I could feel that peice o me soul fade completely and I am indebted to them and it formed a greater bond that they would pay for such out of the parties gold.
Thus these things may be over used in some cases but I cannot say that I am against them completely. They were perhaps used badly but they are ment to be a challange and deterent as well as building blocks for party togetherness.
Fourth and finally is that while I am afraid of over simplificataion and drawing to much from WoW, (I cannot even 100% say WoW is too much of an influence!) I do not know for sure if this is a bad thing or just a very rumor distorted thing. I am worried that such could be bad but as others have said on other posts that is not absolute nor is it something I must dread. I will still have past editions and fan created support and I have imagination enough to change what ever I may disagree with in any fashion I choose. Yes the money spent could be wasted but I do not see this as an end to D&D nor am I in a position to make such changes except through protest. I just will not buy more of the new edition if I do not like it, and post my thoughts on why it was bad to them. I like simplicity to speed the game up but not to rob me of the detail of the world I have to imagine, so that is my only real concern. I am hesitent to say too much about this because I am not informed enough to go one way or the other.
From what I see of this post it is informitive and it shows nothing of which I should complain or gripe. They are ideas no more, no less and I can change them if I need my game world to be different when I run and look like possible interesing challanges for my character when I play.
Anyway, that is just how I see it...
One is that while I am shocked at the thought of the missing vulnerabilities I think that since these are templates that we are not looking at a base vampire so perhaps the vampire lord has gotten to the point where it nolonger fears any of those weaknesses. Definitely not good for all vampires or even all old vampires but perhaps a unique old vampire or an example of such. Adding a weakness is easy enough so like others have said perhaps it is a good thing to have such flexability and easy enough to change.
Two is the Lich. No phylactery is fine and perhaps it is a supreame achievement for a lich. As for if they need the chill touch effect or that it is a caster I have good experiences where a character is immobilized and the others have had to save them. It creates the turn around scenario especially when the PC's now must bargin with the Lich who has the unfortunate PC's friend in a helpless state. Plus it is another thing that they must work out to get past. While they do not need it, it also is a part of their dark mystque so it is part of what they are known for. Once more what would stop you from adding such your self. No big deal the way I see it. Perhaps there is a varient lich that just cannot do such and that could be something he studies about himself or something he fears enemies could exploit.
Three is that as for paralysis and level draining as I am currently running a Dwarf Barbarian who is subject to frustrating freezing effects or circumstances so often that the other party members have nicknamed him Freezy.
The other members found it hilarious that I under the effect of a curse was randomly frozen in the doorway before a combat in a cults underground jail/river slave transport room. They were all fighting desperately, and I only unfroze to run in and freeze again after they had all been reduced to unconciousness and two had died eight rounds later. I was pushed into a cell frozen but while raging I bashed the door down ran full tilt with a horn helm and skewered the ship captian. Then I turned and took down the Huge size amphibious Otyugh that they had weakend. From there I managed to salvage the party with some potions and we sailed the boat out of the dungeon to report to the town. It is one of our groups favorite combats ever and much roleplay came from us being in such a dire circumstance and then ribbing my character who hates the nickname.
Again on level drain I managed to pull a succubus from a room that was containing her when she appeared to be a captive prisoner. Thus the kiss for my heroism was at the cost of a level or as I put it "A peice o me soul!" luckily my party and I traveled back to civilization before I could feel that peice o me soul fade completely and I am indebted to them and it formed a greater bond that they would pay for such out of the parties gold.
Thus these things may be over used in some cases but I cannot say that I am against them completely. They were perhaps used badly but they are ment to be a challange and deterent as well as building blocks for party togetherness.
Fourth and finally is that while I am afraid of over simplificataion and drawing to much from WoW, (I cannot even 100% say WoW is too much of an influence!) I do not know for sure if this is a bad thing or just a very rumor distorted thing. I am worried that such could be bad but as others have said on other posts that is not absolute nor is it something I must dread. I will still have past editions and fan created support and I have imagination enough to change what ever I may disagree with in any fashion I choose. Yes the money spent could be wasted but I do not see this as an end to D&D nor am I in a position to make such changes except through protest. I just will not buy more of the new edition if I do not like it, and post my thoughts on why it was bad to them. I like simplicity to speed the game up but not to rob me of the detail of the world I have to imagine, so that is my only real concern. I am hesitent to say too much about this because I am not informed enough to go one way or the other.
From what I see of this post it is informitive and it shows nothing of which I should complain or gripe. They are ideas no more, no less and I can change them if I need my game world to be different when I run and look like possible interesing challanges for my character when I play.
Anyway, that is just how I see it...
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
