Alchemical crafting in Lamorida - craft (chemistry)
Alchemical crafting in Lamorida - craft (chemistry)
Craft (Alchemy) has been reserved to spellcasters in 3.5 and this presents a bit of a problem in scientifically advanced Lamordia.
I see Lamordia as the leader in gunpowder weapons (pistols, muskets, blunderbusses and bombards). But it is at least ironic that these people who are largely prejudiced against the very existence of magic depend upon it for their gunpowder.
How is this best treated? Every alchemist in Lamordia is secretly a spellcaster? Some alchemists could have but a level in adept and perhaps be only minimally aware of the true nature of what they are doing? Gunpowder could be (embarassingly) imported from Dementlieu? Some sort of gunpowder equivelent of golems of desire?
This creates a similar complication for the prestige classes of Pistoleer and Black Powder Avenger incidently.
Thoughts?
I see Lamordia as the leader in gunpowder weapons (pistols, muskets, blunderbusses and bombards). But it is at least ironic that these people who are largely prejudiced against the very existence of magic depend upon it for their gunpowder.
How is this best treated? Every alchemist in Lamordia is secretly a spellcaster? Some alchemists could have but a level in adept and perhaps be only minimally aware of the true nature of what they are doing? Gunpowder could be (embarassingly) imported from Dementlieu? Some sort of gunpowder equivelent of golems of desire?
This creates a similar complication for the prestige classes of Pistoleer and Black Powder Avenger incidently.
Thoughts?
Last edited by cure on Sun May 04, 2008 7:12 pm, edited 2 times in total.
The cure for what ails you
The skills class/crossclass system in 3.5 is frankly arbitrary and I think it sucks. It makes me more than merely angry; it makes me want to wet my pants, wipe it on the windows, and then run hooting and gibbering through the halls of Congress with my hands in the air.
As a stopgap measure I'm implementing a house rule for all characters where each level, they get to use [1 + Int bonus] number of skill points completely free of crossclass penalties, meaning they can get a 1-1 ratio on ranks, and also to ignore the cross class limit on ranks and treat it as if it were a class skill limit instead (still arbitrary but arguably better). This allows them to bump up a few skills which will still never be quite as good as a "preferred" class of the same level and Int, but still not have to waste skill points and bump up against the 1/2 HD +3 skill points rule.
Another workaround may be to use the Expert NPC class, which gets a lot of flexibility about which skill sets it treats as class skills. But that doesn't really work for PCs too well.
As a stopgap measure I'm implementing a house rule for all characters where each level, they get to use [1 + Int bonus] number of skill points completely free of crossclass penalties, meaning they can get a 1-1 ratio on ranks, and also to ignore the cross class limit on ranks and treat it as if it were a class skill limit instead (still arbitrary but arguably better). This allows them to bump up a few skills which will still never be quite as good as a "preferred" class of the same level and Int, but still not have to waste skill points and bump up against the 1/2 HD +3 skill points rule.
Another workaround may be to use the Expert NPC class, which gets a lot of flexibility about which skill sets it treats as class skills. But that doesn't really work for PCs too well.
After washing the windows, my only comment is to suggest that you could allow the 1+Int bonus relaxation even to skills that are restricted.
I think the spirit of the Expert NPC class should very arguably be allowed to take Alchemy as well, for exactly the reasons you point out about scientists not being spellcasters but nevertheless being very suited for Alchemy.
I think the spirit of the Expert NPC class should very arguably be allowed to take Alchemy as well, for exactly the reasons you point out about scientists not being spellcasters but nevertheless being very suited for Alchemy.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
They could, except the rules as written specifically say that spellcasters and only spellcasters can take ranks in alchemy.gonzoron wrote:Experts can definitely take alchemy. They can select any 10 skills to be in-class, including those usually exclusive to another class.
That said, I like the suggestion of Alchemy being open to Experts too.
The cure for what ails you
Isn't the simples solution to rewrite this rule for your game? There are plenty of Ravenloft alterations to the rules that change classes, races, magic and so forth to fit the gothic mood and the setting. Just decide which classes you feel should be able to use Craft (Alchemy) and keep a note of it somewhere...
In all the games I've ever played, we completely ignored the class restriction on Craft: Alchemy. We never had any problems with it, and I have no idea why it was restricted in the first place.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
- A G Thing
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1216
- Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
- Gender: Female
- Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan
Well It does say that but that is not the way it has to be... We all know realistically that these things can be crafted by science so a learned person should have no problem doing such. Just make it so that perhaps there is a superior MW alchemy lab available in CL 9 settings only and thus the skill can be preformed by the experts that study it, with the proper tools that is.
Superior Quality Alchemy Lab
Cost: 800gp
Weight: 70 lbs
Benifits: To a spell caster this Alchemy Lab provides a +4 circumstance bonus to Craft (Alchemy) checks to create alchemical items.
However due to the superior quality of the Lab and the advances it uses a non spell caster with at least 5 ranks in Craft (Alchemy) may make alchemical items but the bonus is as a standard +2 alchemy lab.
This is to represent the mage using minor magics or arcane techniques that make the lab even more efficent.
Also of note is the Scientist Prestige Class in the LotB supplement which allows the character to mimic magic type effects with abilities given to the class and it does not have a magic prerequisite.
Superior Quality Alchemy Lab
Cost: 800gp
Weight: 70 lbs
Benifits: To a spell caster this Alchemy Lab provides a +4 circumstance bonus to Craft (Alchemy) checks to create alchemical items.
However due to the superior quality of the Lab and the advances it uses a non spell caster with at least 5 ranks in Craft (Alchemy) may make alchemical items but the bonus is as a standard +2 alchemy lab.
This is to represent the mage using minor magics or arcane techniques that make the lab even more efficent.
Also of note is the Scientist Prestige Class in the LotB supplement which allows the character to mimic magic type effects with abilities given to the class and it does not have a magic prerequisite.
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
I'm not a 3E fan-but the Forgotten Realms for 3E had something called Regional Feats...if you were from that region, you could take it, as it was common to folk of that region. Think of Tolkein's Rohan Riders for example, nearly everyone in that culture understood horsemanship-or a Magic-heavy society where everyone could take a Feat that turned Use Magic Item into a Class skill...
So:
Feat-Lamordian Alchemist. This allows non-spellcasters to take the Craft(Alchemy) skill as a Class skill. Requirements-Lamordian upbringing.
Easy patch.
So:
Feat-Lamordian Alchemist. This allows non-spellcasters to take the Craft(Alchemy) skill as a Class skill. Requirements-Lamordian upbringing.
Easy patch.
"And did she ever come out?"
"Not Yet".
"Not Yet".
I was posing this not only or even principally as a problem that I am having, but rather as one that perhaps needs fixing within the rules as written for Ravenloft generally.impworks wrote:Isn't the simples solution to rewrite this rule for your game? There are plenty of Ravenloft alterations to the rules that change classes, races, magic and so forth to fit the gothic mood and the setting. Just decide which classes you feel should be able to use Craft (Alchemy) and keep a note of it somewhere...
I think it is a case where we unthinkingly accepted a 3.5 rule change that might have been better rejected or at least tweaked.
And I am fishing for good suggestions as to tweaking, rather than simply advocating straight away that it be rejected and errataed.
The cure for what ails you
Sorry I didn't mean the last line to sound like I thought this rule was causing just your game a problem. I've never been that fussed by official errata for any game - personally in the end the only game that any modification matters for is the one I'm running. Not that I'm a big "fixer" of D&D - as a complex rule system the problem with all fixes and tweaks is those difficult to spot knock on effects. This seems to be one of those unanticipated bugs.
One tweak would be to allow any character educated in a CL9 domain to take Craft Alchemy ignoring the restriction (possibly CL7 and CL8 as well given when gun powder first came in to use) or if that seems wide open limit it to the scholar and expert classes.
An alternative that might resolve this would be to add a new Craft Skill - maybe called Natural Philosophy - which allows the creation of some alchemical substances and items along with potetially some other similar items specific to it. Place different restrictions on who can take it.
If your interested in the history of explosives there is a book
published by English Heritage "Dangerous Energy: The Archaeology of Gunpowder" which discusses the development of gunpowder manufacturing in the UK including plans, elevations and other information from English archaeological digs. The writing is a bit dry since its an academic work...
http://www.amazon.com/Dangerous-Energy- ... 1850747180
Either a full blown manufacturing site or a converted grain mill (which is what happened during the English Civil War / War of Three Kingdoms) would make an interesting site for an adventure...
One tweak would be to allow any character educated in a CL9 domain to take Craft Alchemy ignoring the restriction (possibly CL7 and CL8 as well given when gun powder first came in to use) or if that seems wide open limit it to the scholar and expert classes.
An alternative that might resolve this would be to add a new Craft Skill - maybe called Natural Philosophy - which allows the creation of some alchemical substances and items along with potetially some other similar items specific to it. Place different restrictions on who can take it.
If your interested in the history of explosives there is a book
published by English Heritage "Dangerous Energy: The Archaeology of Gunpowder" which discusses the development of gunpowder manufacturing in the UK including plans, elevations and other information from English archaeological digs. The writing is a bit dry since its an academic work...
http://www.amazon.com/Dangerous-Energy- ... 1850747180
Either a full blown manufacturing site or a converted grain mill (which is what happened during the English Civil War / War of Three Kingdoms) would make an interesting site for an adventure...
- Jakob
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 472
- Joined: Thu Aug 05, 2004 3:43 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Near Milano, Italy.
- Contact:
No. Craft (alchemy) can be used by spellcasters to create alchemist's fire, acid and the like. Anybody can use it to create firepowder.Craft (Alchemy) has been reserved to spellcasters in 3.5 and this presents a bit of a problem in scientifically advanced Lamordia.
Here's the SRD page, so you can check.
I coloni rovinavano la foresta costruendo il capolavoro dell'uomo civilizzato: il deserto.
- Luis Sepúlveda
- Luis Sepúlveda
"To make an item using Craft (alchemy), you must have alchemical equipment and be a spellcaster. If you are working in a city, you can buy what you need as part of the raw materials cost to make the item, but alchemical equipment is difficult or impossible to come by in some places. Purchasing and maintaining an alchemist’s lab grants a +2 circumstance bonus on Craft (alchemy) checks because you have the perfect tools for the job, but it does not affect the cost of any items made using the skill." SRD
What am I missing Jakob?
What am I missing Jakob?
The cure for what ails you
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Simple solution? I think impworks already gave it to us.
Add a Craft (chemistry) skill to the roster of skill options, much as Ravenloft already adds Craft (gunsmithing) or Craft (clockwork) skills. Craft (chemistry) requires no spellcasting ability, and is utilized for the production of nonmagical compounds and mixtures such as gunpowder, antitoxins, or invisible ink. Kits or workshops designed to assist Craft (alchemy) checks also assist Craft (chemistry), or vice versa. Ranks in Craft (chemistry) do not count toward the requirements for the alchemical philosopher prestige class, and this skill cannot substitute for Craft (alchemy) for purposes of creating alchemical golems.
Granted, this overlaps with Craft (alchemy) in most respects ... but then, Craft (alchemy) already overlaps Craft (poisonmaking). Many skills aren't mutually exclusive.
Add a Craft (chemistry) skill to the roster of skill options, much as Ravenloft already adds Craft (gunsmithing) or Craft (clockwork) skills. Craft (chemistry) requires no spellcasting ability, and is utilized for the production of nonmagical compounds and mixtures such as gunpowder, antitoxins, or invisible ink. Kits or workshops designed to assist Craft (alchemy) checks also assist Craft (chemistry), or vice versa. Ranks in Craft (chemistry) do not count toward the requirements for the alchemical philosopher prestige class, and this skill cannot substitute for Craft (alchemy) for purposes of creating alchemical golems.
Granted, this overlaps with Craft (alchemy) in most respects ... but then, Craft (alchemy) already overlaps Craft (poisonmaking). Many skills aren't mutually exclusive.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow


