Don't forget the adept class and the actual witch class from the DMG.
So will you adapt the FR mechanics of Circle Casting and rewrite the Halan Witch PrC along the lines of the Hathran?
I'm very interested in seeing this done.
Hallowed Witch PrC
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
I would, except I think pure FR circle casting ought to exist among the Rashemani and the Mulan, and I'd hate to see Hallowed Witches become an ajunct to that. The FR book hints at other forms of circle casting; I'm thinking this is one of those others.The Giamarga wrote:Don't forget the adept class and the actual witch class from the DMG.
So will you adapt the FR mechanics of Circle Casting and rewrite the Halan Witch PrC along the lines of the Hathran?
I'm very interested in seeing this done.
The general idea of normal FR circle casting is that the group gets together and buffs the leader with extra spell slots and whatnot. The general idea of the Hallowed circle is that the group gets together and actually casts a spell together that none of them could cast separately. The Chosen feat already accounts for that concept for the most part, even if it needs a little tweaking. So the real question is, what kind of spells would be appropriate for a group to cast together?
The Fates of Carnival present an interesting precedent, because they appear to can cast a spell together that allows all three of them to serve as "caster;" that is, they all read the thoughts of the spell's target, rather than just one of them acting on behalf of the group. One might argue that they are affected by the Twsiting, but they are Skurra, and their version of detect thoughts is given in the Guide to Witches as the standard for three-member covens. So it seems safe to say that spells cast by a circle must have a single target, but they have more than one caster, for all intents and purposes.
One wonders about spells with a target of "self".
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Okay, time to get more detailed about this circle concept wrt the Chosen feat. If the circles they form cast spells by expending their given 0-level spells, that would keep things somewhat balanced. Two Chosen could cast two 0-level spells individually or a 1st level spell together. Three could cast a 2nd level spell, four a 3rd level spell, and so on. This loses balance when you get to around six or more, I'm thinking. Then again, the worst offenders wouldn't be as big a problem as you might think, because if ten people got together to cast a Wish...they would all have to pay the XP cost! That's a pretty hefty price for a spell that doesn't even work right in RL!
BTW, as much as I like the numerology of the coven membership benchmarks, I don't think I'm going to enforce it at a statistical level unless I have to. It's just too big a headache to keep track of the extra numbers. They may gravitate towards these numbers because of tradition, but I won't force it in my rules.
So, assuming they must all be present to cast a spell, AND assuming they expend their daily spell slot to do a circle casting, AND assuming they can only change the selected spell once a month, AND assuming that they each have to pay all the hefty costs such as XP AND assuming that the most powerful spell possible would be a 9th level spell with 3 levels worth of metamagic feats for a 13 member coven...what's the absolute worst they might do? Let's see:
Gate, Wish and Miracle all require XP, so that's out. Offensive spells would almost always be out; assuming you knew days ahead of time that you needed an offensive spell, casting it while you are being attacked is nigh impossible. There go Energy Drain, Implosion, Meteor Swarm, Wierd, Power Word Kill, Crushing Hand, Wail of the Banshee, Time Stop and Storm of Vengeance. Summoning extraplanars would be a bad idea in RL, and they'd probably know that, so there goes Elemental Swarm. That leaves a collection of oddities; for completeness' sake I'll list them all, but I'll highlight the ones that seem most likely/useful for a group:
Astral Projection
Etherealness
Heal, Mass
Soul Bind
Summon Monster IX
True Resurrection
Antipathy
Foresight
Regenerate
Shambler
Shapechange
Summon Nature’s Ally IX
Sympathy
Freedom
Imprisonment
Mage’s Disjunction
Prismatic Sphere
Refuge
Teleportation Circle
Dominate Monster
Hold Monster, Mass
Okay, some of these are a little disconcerting. Foresight especially seems lika huge boon to give to a dozen-odd people who just happen to find kindred spirits. I'll look at these and lower level spells and see what I can do to balance things without overcomplicating the issue.
BTW, as much as I like the numerology of the coven membership benchmarks, I don't think I'm going to enforce it at a statistical level unless I have to. It's just too big a headache to keep track of the extra numbers. They may gravitate towards these numbers because of tradition, but I won't force it in my rules.
So, assuming they must all be present to cast a spell, AND assuming they expend their daily spell slot to do a circle casting, AND assuming they can only change the selected spell once a month, AND assuming that they each have to pay all the hefty costs such as XP AND assuming that the most powerful spell possible would be a 9th level spell with 3 levels worth of metamagic feats for a 13 member coven...what's the absolute worst they might do? Let's see:
Gate, Wish and Miracle all require XP, so that's out. Offensive spells would almost always be out; assuming you knew days ahead of time that you needed an offensive spell, casting it while you are being attacked is nigh impossible. There go Energy Drain, Implosion, Meteor Swarm, Wierd, Power Word Kill, Crushing Hand, Wail of the Banshee, Time Stop and Storm of Vengeance. Summoning extraplanars would be a bad idea in RL, and they'd probably know that, so there goes Elemental Swarm. That leaves a collection of oddities; for completeness' sake I'll list them all, but I'll highlight the ones that seem most likely/useful for a group:
Astral Projection
Etherealness
Heal, Mass
Soul Bind
Summon Monster IX
True Resurrection
Antipathy
Foresight
Regenerate
Shambler
Shapechange
Summon Nature’s Ally IX
Sympathy
Freedom
Imprisonment
Mage’s Disjunction
Prismatic Sphere
Refuge
Teleportation Circle
Dominate Monster
Hold Monster, Mass
Okay, some of these are a little disconcerting. Foresight especially seems lika huge boon to give to a dozen-odd people who just happen to find kindred spirits. I'll look at these and lower level spells and see what I can do to balance things without overcomplicating the issue.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Resurrecting this thread for wiki's sake. Want to offer options to DM's regarding the Three Fates. Might still use it IMC too.The Giamarga wrote:Foresight is generally seen as severely underpowered for a 9th level spell.
But I would probably scale the spell level differently, so that 13 non-casters simply cannot cast a 9th level spell. How does it scale for the members of the PrC ?
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Re: Hallowed Witch PrC
Resurrecting this tread for discussion of a PF conversion of the strange 2e and 3e rules for halan witch circle casting.
Esp. the possibility of non caster circles (as the Fates Three) integration with hag covens, the witch class and the coven hex and an update of the list of castable spells interest me.
Here's a link to Ryan's pathfinder hag template.
And here's a link to Ryan's proposed Coven feat in the Carnival thread
Esp. the possibility of non caster circles (as the Fates Three) integration with hag covens, the witch class and the coven hex and an update of the list of castable spells interest me.
Here's a link to Ryan's pathfinder hag template.
And here's a link to Ryan's proposed Coven feat in the Carnival thread
