Alchemical crafting in Lamorida - craft (chemistry)

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_fire

As to reserving gunpowder to chemical crafting, I can see the argument for doing so, if the scientific is conceived as being a thoroughly modern creature. On the otherhand, if he is ultimately the child of the alchemist, then I think the overlap is better maintained.

It also cashes out in terms of the Pistoleer and Black Powder Avenger. I would think that either alchemical or chemical crafting would suffice as a prequisite. The superstious alchemist has his right to a gun too without delving into the overlapping but ideologically opposed field of chemistry.
Last edited by cure on Mon May 05, 2008 1:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

DeepShadow wrote:Wouldn't this just hamper scientists more by forcing them to take two sets of skills?
Not if alchemists and scientists have radically-different worldviews and philosophies, it wouldn't. Scientists would see the world in Newtonian terms -- mechanistic and explicable -- while alchemists would be mystics of a sort. The two could be rivals, with largely-incompatible beliefs about the fundamental nature of matter: the scientists wouldn't want to study Craft (alchemy), or vice versa.

Much of Gothic literature is about the conflict between rationalism and mysticism, and I think it'd add to the setting's flavor to recognize that, by drawing a sharp line between chemists and alchemists. YMMV, though.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

I didn't realize 3.5 restricted Alchemy skill to casters. That's silly. I'd ignore it. If alchemical items aren't magical, then why would you need magic to make them? I need spells to make a match or some black powder? Naw..I don't buy it.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Not if alchemists and scientists have radically-different worldviews and philosophies, it wouldn't. Scientists would see the world in Newtonian terms -- mechanistic and explicable -- while alchemists would be mystics of a sort. The two could be rivals, with largely-incompatible beliefs about the fundamental nature of matter: the scientists wouldn't want to study Craft (alchemy), or vice versa.

Much of Gothic literature is about the conflict between rationalism and mysticism, and I think it'd add to the setting's flavor to recognize that, by drawing a sharp line between chemists and alchemists. YMMV, though.
...I'm sorry, but I'm still not seeing it. Everything you say here is true, but none of it justifies forcing a character to spend twice as many skill points to do what he's supposed to do.

There's no need to force flavor into two skill sets. You can have flavor with the same sets of skills. We don't make Rokugani monks and Rajian monks and Paridonian monks learn three different forms of the Concentration skill, despite the fact that each group has a vastly different approach to it.

Let your characters argue about chemistry versus alchemy, but don't punish the players.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
Baduin9
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 41
Joined: Mon Aug 07, 2006 3:27 pm

Post by Baduin9 »

Rotipher of the FoS wrote:
Not if alchemists and scientists have radically-different worldviews and philosophies, it wouldn't. Scientists would see the world in Newtonian terms -- mechanistic and explicable -- while alchemists would be mystics of a sort. The two could be rivals, with largely-incompatible beliefs about the fundamental nature of matter: the scientists wouldn't want to study Craft (alchemy), or vice versa.

Much of Gothic literature is about the conflict between rationalism and mysticism, and I think it'd add to the setting's flavor to recognize that, by drawing a sharp line between chemists and alchemists. YMMV, though.
The problem is, there is no such divide. Newton himself, funnily enough, was a professional alchemist, and his theory of gravity is an offshoot of his hermetic ideas (mysterious action at a distance was anathema to science at the time).

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/newton/alchemy.html

The real difference was between operative alchemy (actual experiments) and speculative alchemy (mystical symbolism without experiments). Gothic literature very often treats science as equivalent to hermeticism - see Frankenstein.


http://www.levity.com/alchemy/home.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alchemy
"Dies nostri quasi umbra super terram et nulla est mora."
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

DeepShadow wrote:...I'm sorry, but I'm still not seeing it. Everything you say here is true, but none of it justifies forcing a character to spend twice as many skill points to do what he's supposed to do.
I wasn't trying to force that, really: a character could simply choose one or the other, without any need to do both. Alchemists could still use firearms, they'd just buy gunpowder rather than make it from scratch. Ditto, chemists and those (very) few alchemical mixtures they couldn't make themselves. Even in an absolute worst-case scenario, a character who's crossing disciplines can purchase just one rank in the other skill -- enough to scrape by, along with ability bonuses, when making the other Craft's "exclusive" products -- rather than maxing out both skills.

And even if the line between real-world early chemistry and alchemy was actually insignificant, that's just not how it's been portrayed in Ravenloft: if a Lamordian scientist described chemical processes in the mystical terms of alchemy, everything we know about Lamordia tells us he'd get laughed at. That may not be true to the period, or (ironically) even true to the original Frankenstein, but it is true to how Victor Mordenheim's die-hard rationalism has permeated all of Lamordian thought ... which is what I'd thought this thread was about, specifically.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
impworks
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 70
Joined: Thu Apr 10, 2008 5:29 pm
Contact:

Post by impworks »

Apologies but I'm going to grossly over simplify and abuse 2000+ years of the history of science...

Well the real line of interesting argument at the time was those who did thought experiments and didn't believe they needed to be supported by real experimental evidence and those who thought experimental evidence was required.

The Invisible College fell into the later camp. When Charles II was restored to the English monarchy he broke with the advisors he'd had in exile and made the Invisible College the Royal Society. Their approach eventually led to progress as evidence supported theories led to new discoveries.

Alchemy on the other hand was substantially based on Aristotle's theory of the elements. This didn't stop alchemists discovering things or making compounds but they would have struggled to make progress that would result in real discoveries.

Now my personal opinion is that the real question here from a game design point of view is: Is there an argument for having two skills?

If there isn't then the best fix for this for the problem of only wizards having alchemy is to say that in Ravenloft anyone can take Alchemy but only a wizard can make certain substances while anyone can make others.

However if Alchemy and Chemistry can achieve different things because they work with different parts of the fabric of the universe (ie Aristotle's model of elements and atom based chemistry reside side by side) then there is an argument for two skills.

Skill systems (along with pretty much everything to do with how a game system defines characters with numbers) are usually imperfect because even fictional real worlds are messy places where things don't neatly fit into boxes. The real alchemy is trying to find the best set of numbers for the setting while keeping a game playable and without resorting to Sixth normal form ;-)
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Post by A G Thing »

Honestly I must agree for one skill but just limit what a non magic using practicioner can do if that bothers you...

I can see any aspiring alchemist making most anything non magical with his alchemy tools that a wizard could. Acid, Alchemist's Fire, Tindertwigs, Poisons, Antitoxins, Smokestick's, Sunrods(Though perhaps different in discription), Tanglefoot bags, not to mention the other supplementary items that are in other books. Anything reasonable could be produced

Also in the more primitive settings I can see a wizard using minor magics and such to help in preperations and containment of substances that gives him a slight edge but I always viewed the skill as if it was the equivilent of chemistry and I have never followed the rule of blocking it from use to non magical practicioners.

I see it as more possible for higher cultural level domains then lower ones but I don't think it should be impossible and the dark powers tend to make even mundane efforts possible if twisted such as dread golems and even lamordian science is odd and unrealistic if you look at the prestige classes... Just don't make it an issue or perhaps there is more of a social and methodological devision about it and the Magic users and the Chemists each have methods to the same result but view the others creation as corrupt or false. Both can make thunderstones but both see different methods that work differently...
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

Too bad we didn't have complete cultural levels for items and alchemical items in particular.

Chemists could either be prohibited from, or have a penalty when, making older items (more properly belonging to alchemy and magical tradition) and alchemists could either be prohited from, or have a penalty when, makiing newer items (more properly belonging to chemistry and modern science).
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

Gunpowder isn't hard to make, really. An expert with craft: powder manufacture ought to be able to make it. You only need three ingredients. Charcoal is made from wood- plenty of that around. Saltpeter can be mined from caves [bat guano] or extracted from stables/cesspits. Sulfur in its elemental form can be mined from natuarlly occuring deposits.

Since manure/guano and trees are both pretty common, I'd suggest limiting the sulfur supply. Have large deposits occur only in a handful of domains- mostly in the NW Core. Then have the local powers-that-be restrict export of elemntal sulfur. Maybe establish some local monopolies [including monopolies on powder manufacture].
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

Having access to the ingredients doesn't necessarily mean you'd know the right proportions and methods of mixing them, to maximize the powder's force while minimizing the chance of accidental discharge. My guess is that this information would be rather closely guarded by makers of gunpowder, much as other artisans hoard their techniques for making fine glassware or pottery. Yes, experts should be able to make it, but not every expert or firearm-user should know how.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

I absolutely agree that not every firearm user would make his own. It wasn't like that historically [not that Ravenloft is the same as Earth, of course]. It's not economical, for one thing. You cannot fit a sulfur mine or a powder mill into your backpack, after all.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
impworks
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 70
Joined: Thu Apr 10, 2008 5:29 pm
Contact:

Post by impworks »

Gunpowder may be easy to make now but it wasn't always like that. 300+ years of chemistry and industrialisation have gone into that. Explosives were, and still are, a well funded area of research.

Poor quality gun powder is fairly easy to make but it is unreliable and may blow up your weapon or simply fizzle and not launch the projectile properly. Even when it does neither it's hard to predict how well it will work making guns unreliable. Do you want that when a werewolf is coming at you on a hill top?

Refining good quality charcoal wasn't perfected until the Napoleonic wars when experiments were carried out to discover which wood produced the best charcoal for Gunpowder of different types and how to refine it.

Saltpeter again is hard to refine to a pure form in a pre industrial society. Some countries, such as Italy, had ample supplies of raw ingredients but controlled exports. Others (like the countries of the British Isles) went to extrordinary lengths to collect material suitable for producing it. Hard floors were taxed and people were required to urinate on their earth floor. Petermen would go around digging up peoples floor and carting off the earth to be processed into Saltpeter. Many petermen were recruited from thugs along with a few bandits and even some highwaymen turned to it as an alternate source of income. I know Falkovnia isn't a big user of gunpowder but if they were I can imagine this kind of activity there.

Constant grain size is difficult to achieve if you want to produce more than a single persons supply by hand.

There is a constant risk of explosion and fire. Until special implements made to avoid creating sparks were invented this was a serious danger. Large scale works used barges to transport materials around site because carts were too risky.

Many countries made it illegal for people to manufacture gun powder by hand at home because they would blow up not just themselves and their property but their neighbours and their property too.

Modern manufacturing and storage makes explosives remain reliable for longer. Water degrades gun powder if it is exposed

On top of that counties had to protect their production facilities from their enemies. The secrets of their recipes were carefully guarded state secrets. The domains with good quality gunpowder will be fighting a constant war to protect the secret and their production facilities or their enemies will overwhelm them with swords and arrows.

Dangerous Energy: The Archaeology of Gunpowder, that I mentioned earlier covers the process and its development in the real world in the UK.

All in all there are lots of opportunities for adventure associated with the process.
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

All good points.

Open warfare seems to be largely absent from Ravenloft. This might retard the development and spread of firearms and powder manufacture.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

Absent compared to other game-settings, perhaps, but the fear of warfare is still there. That's most obvious in Falkovnia's neighbors, but it's also a factor in places like the Amber Wastes (Pharazian religious militarism) or in perennial hotbeds like Invidia. Even Nova Vaasa has been getting more imperialistic, under Othmar's regime.

Not to mention how plenty of nations have "false history" of internal strife and/or foreign invasions. We know those things didn't happen, but very few natives even suspect that it's untrue. Nor does the average NPC-on-the-street have a clue how universal the "closing the borders" phenomenon actually is: even if they have heard that Azalin and Hazlik conjure barriers to guard their respective nations, most border-closing phenomena would be inexplicable mysteries, attributed to the Mists' weird caprices rather than any deliberate attempt to seal domains' boundaries.

So, I think there's ample motivation for the proprietary attitudes which impworks describes. Again, we know the domains' borders guard themselves, making most conventional military defenses superfluous, but few outside the FoS or the darklords' own ranks know that information in-character ... and neither of those groups is telling. :wink:
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Post Reply