3.5 Chiurgen Prestige Class, the gothic doctor

Discussing all things Ravenloft

What do you think of LoB's Learned Physician?

Why shouldn't Mordenheims cast spells?
1
10%
A cleric from Lamordia in drag, what's not to like?
2
20%
It's nearly as gothic as Dumbo.
1
10%
It is begging to be replaced by Wyatt's Chiurgeon
6
60%
 
Total votes: 10

User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

3.5 Chiurgen Prestige Class, the gothic doctor

Post by cure »

My disamusement with the uttterly ungothic family prestige classes for the Mordenheims from LoB, has provoked me to convert to 3.5 Wyatt's brilliant Chiurgeon from the Kargatan Book of Secrets.

Suggestions and/or improvements are welcome.

If ultimately satisfying, I suggest that we errata [edit that to: ponder the relevence of] the entire Learned
Physician prestige class, [inexplicable divine] spell casting
  • and all, from LoB [where we are told that Mordenheims can't cast divine spells] and replace it [in our black, twisted gothic hearts] with this.

    And the next step would be to do something similar with LoB's spell casting Scientist who woundn't know a flesh golem of obsession if it slapped him about the ears.

    CHIURGEON
    The chiurgeon is a profession pioneered in Lamordia where its practitioners are generally held in high esteem both within the university and beyond its walls. Outside of that land, chiurgeons can be found in most universities and in the large and small cities, and even the towns, of advanced states such as Dementlieu, Zheresia, Richemulot, Mordent, and Borca. But they are neither numerous nor respected. Practitioners of magical healing openly brand them butchers and most people with gold enough to secure aid from priests freely repeat the accusation. The less well off tend to view chiurgeons slightly more charitably, as they often make their services available at eminently reasonable prices. Still ugly rumours and lurid stories lend even the best of chiurgeons a sinister cast. Only the bravest and most charismatic members of the profession venture openly into more backward lands, where death at the hands of a mob is a threat to be taken seriously. In Falkovnia, however, chiurgeons are readily conscripted into the army where they can easily spend the rest of their lives enjoying, by the abysmal standards of that land, a significant degree of security and comfort. A chiurgeon may also secure similar employment in the navies of our world and the merchant marine.

    Chiurgeons are not to their last atheists, but they do not believe in 'miracle' workers or practitioners of 'magic' generally. In Lamordia chiurgeons and their patients are almost invariably atheists and so are very much made for one another. Elsewhere, chiurgeons have learnt to shun the subject of religion, at least beyond the walls of the university. The attitude of many Barovians towards religion has, however, made that land somewhat less hostile to the chiurgeon than comparable backwaters. When confronted with a manifest display of 'magic' a chiurgeon typically protests that it is either 'smoke and mirrors' or the work of an yet undiscovered natural principle. Anyone actively seeking to persuade a chiurgeon otherwise is likely to be accused of being either naive or a charlatan.

    The least ambitious chiurgeons stay well within the limits of their craft, avoid controversy, flee danger like the Crimson Death, and are a boon to their community. The most ambitious see their work as a crusade, where this may mean saving as many lives as possible, waging war upon death itself, and usually both. The path paved by the good intentions of these chiurgeons is often a grimmer one than any might readily foresee. Chiurgeons as a profession also have something of a propensity for graverobbing. When a legitimate and bountiful source of cadavers is available, chiurgeons committed to high level research can be perfectly law abiding and even upstanding citizens. When this is not the case, they can easily find themselves entangled with the worst sort of people.

    A thug who mistakes a chiurgeon for easy prey may end up being a chiurgeon's patient or worse. Chiurgeons are skilled wielders of scalpels, razors, knives and cutlasses and are deadly if they manage to catch opponents at a disadvantage. It is not uncommon, especially in less urban settings, to find a thoroughly vicious but well trained dog at a chiurgeon's side.

    Chuirgeon

    Hit Dice: d6.

    Requirements:
    To qualify to become a Chiurgeon (Chr) a character must fulfil all the following criteria.

    Cultural Level: 8+.

    Alignment: any.

    Skills: Heal 8 ranks, Knowledge (nature) 5 ranks, Profession (herbalism) 5 ranks.

    Feats: Skill Focus (heal).

    Special: To become a chiurgeon, a character must be trained by a chiurgeon. This often, but not always, takes place in a university setting. Chiurgeons are not necessarily atheists but they do not believe in miracle workers or practitioners of 'magic' generally. A character that can cast arcane or divine spells cannot become a chiurgeon. Likewise a character with ranks in Knowledge (arcane), Spellcraft or Use Magical Device cannot become a chiurgeon without renouncing such 'talent' as fraudulent and making no further use of it (4 ranks may be transferred to another skill with every advancement of a level). A chiurgeon acquiring ranks in Knowledge (arcane), Spellcraft or Use Magical Device or one acquiring the ability to cast arcane or divine spells from another class cannot gain new levels as a chiurgeon but retains all current chiurgeon abilities. A chiurgeon does not attempt untrained Knowledge (arcane) checks. A chiurgeon may wield or bear magic items with neither command words nor ostentatious magical effects, but will vehemently insist that their potency is simply the result of superior craftsmanship. Confronted with a manifest display of 'magic' a chiurgeon will insist that it is either 'smoke and mirrors' or the work of an yet undiscovered natural principle.

    Class Skills: The chiurgeon's class skills (and the key ability for each skill) are Appraise (Int), Bluff (Cha), Concentration (Con), Craft (Int), Decipher Script (Int), Diplomacy (Cha), Forgery (Int), Gather Information (Cha), Handle Animals (Cha), Hide in Shadows (Dex), Intimidate (Cha), Knowledge (architecture & engineering) (Int), Knowledge (geography), Knowledge (nature) (Int), Knowledge (nobility & royalty) (Int), Move Silently (Dex), Perform (Cha), Profession (Wis), Search (Int), Sleight of Hand (Dex), Speak Language, Spot, Survival, and Use Rope (Dex).

    Skill Points at Each Level
    6 + Int modifier.

    Table: The Chiurgeon
    Lvl BAB Fort Ref Will
    1st +0 +0 +2 +2 Medical Science, Diagnosis, Weapon Finesse
    2nd +1 +0 +3 +3 Bleeding, Healing Science, Scalpel attack +1d6
    3rd +2 +1 +3 +3 Surgery, Amputation, Chemistry
    4th +3 +1 +4 +4 Trepanning, Pharmacology, Scalpel attack +2d6
    5th +3 +1 +4 +4 Deft Surgery, Weapon Focus
    6th +4 +2 +5 +5 Skill Focus (Profession (Herbalism) or Craft (chemistry)), Obsession, Scalpel attack +3d6
    7th +5 +2 +5 +5 Transplantation, Poison Use
    8th +6 +2 +6 +6 Improved Critical, Scalpel attack +4d6
    9th +6 +3 +6 +6 Advanced Transplantation, Skill Focus (Profession (Herbalism) or Craft (chemistry))
    10th +7 +3 +7 +7 Reanimation, Scalpel attack +5d6

    Class Features

    All of the following are Class Features of the chiurgeon prestige class.

    Weapon and Armour Proficiency: Chiurgeons are proficient with simple weapons, light martial slashing weapons, and the rapier. Chiurgeons are not proficient with armour or shields.

    Scalpel attack (Ex): When afforded a sufficient opening a chiurgeon puts his knowledge of anatomy to deadly effect. A chiurgeon may make the equivalent of a rogue's sneak attack but only with a melee slashing weapon and only against humanoids, monstrous humanoids, animals and magical beasts.

    Medical Science (Ex): Long study of biological principles, of modern medical technics, and of countlesss cases has afforded the chiurgeon an exceptional talent for healing. A chiurgeon may substitute his intelligence modifier for his wisdom modifier when making Heal skill checks. Moreover a chiurgeon adds a +1 bonus per chiurgeon level to his Heal skill checks when treating humanoids or animals. Although monstrous humanoids and magical beasts may be similar anatomically, the differences are sufficient to deprive a chiurgeon of the clarity of mind that he normally brings to his work and thus this bonus.

    Diagnosis (Ex): A chiurgeon learns to recognise even the most obscure signs of sicknesses and poisoning and to draw sound conclusions from even the scantest of evidence. A chiurgeon adds a +1 bonus per chiurgeon level to his Search skill checks when ministering to humanoids or animals. A chiurgeon may attempt to diagnose illness or poisoning by making a Search check against the save DC of the disease or poison. A diagnosis takes d20 minutes and provokes attacks of opportunity. A fast diagnosis may be completed in d10 rounds with a -5 penalty and provokes attacks of opportunity. A chiurgen loses his +1 bonus per chiurgeon level to his Heal skill check when treating a patient that he fails to diagnose. A chiurgeon may attempt to identify a given magical disease, but will dismiss its supposed 'eldritch' nature as 'groundless peasant superstition' and will be unable to successfully treat it should it require magical curing. A chiurgeon may make a Search check to determine the cause of death by performing a dissection. A dissection takes d6x20 minutes.

    Bleeding (Ex): A chiurgeon understands the medicinal value of carefully controlled bleedings. A chiurgeon can as a standard action which provokes attacks of opportunity apply leeches to an open wound or use a scalpel to open a wound. The leeches inflict 1 hit point of subdual damage and the scalpel inflicts 1 hit point of damage. Either affords a +2 bonus to the patient's Fortitude check or the chiurgeon's Heal skill check against the secondary damage of poison. A chiurgeon may also use leeches or a scalpel to afford a +1 bonus to the patient's Fortitude check or the chiurgen's Heal skill check that is made daily against a disease. Normally leaches afford a +1 bonus against the secondary damage of poison and are ineffective against disease. Leeches are fine vermin with 1 hit point.

    Healing science (Ex): Through the application of first aid, medicine, chemicals, needles, clamps, precise physical manipulations and even electrical currents a chiurgeon may accelerate natural healing. Upon making a successful Heal skill check for giving Long-Term care a chiurgeon can immediately attempt a second Heal skill check as a free action which if successful doubles the rate of healing from 2 hit points per level to 4 hit points per level for 8 hours of rest and from 4 hit points per level to 8 hit points per level for a full 24 hours of rest.

    Chemistry (Ex): A chiurgeon often finds himself obliged to manufacture his own anaesthetic and ether. A chiurgeon adds a +1 bonus per chiurgeon level to his Craft (chemistry) skill checks.

    Pharmacology (Ex): A chiurgeon understands the medicinal value of drugs. A chiurgeon may substitute his intelligence modifier for his wisdom modifier when making Profession (herbalism) skill checks. A chiurgeon adds a +1 bonus per chiurgeon level to his Profession (herbalism) skill checks. A chiurgeon may use Profession (herbalism) in place of Craft (poison) to produce plant based medicines or poisons. In particular a chiurgeon can take a poisonous plant and create a medicine that retains from it one or more of its effects either at full strength or at a reduced strength. For example a chiurgeon is in possession of Baron's Bane from Forlorn which has a DC 20, drains permanently 1 point of Wisdom and 1 point of Constitution as initial damage, and does 1d4 points of Wisdom damage and 1d8 points of Constitution damage as secondary damage. With a successful DC 20 Profession (herbalism) check the chiurgeon could produce an immune system suppressing drug with a DC 20 that drains permanently 1 point of Constitution as initial damage and no secondary damage.

    Trepanning (Ex): A chiurgeon may attempt to cure madness by strategically drilling holes into the skull and grey matter of the patient to relieve the pressure that, according to medical science, is responsible for the condition. Each minute of drilling does 1d2 hit points of damage, provokes a Fortitude save with a cumulative -1 bonus to avoid losing 1d6 points of intelligence permanently, and affords a Recovery check (a Madness check against the initial DC) with a cumulative +1 bonus which if successful returns the patient's abilities scores to their previous level (minus any losses resulting from trepanning) and wholely cures the madness. For every five levels in the chiurgeon class apply a +1 bonus to the Recovery check and to the Fortitude save. In any case, a patient suffers 1 point of permanent Intelligence loss as well as must make a Madness check with DC 10 + 1 per minute of drilling.

    Surgery (Ex): A chiurgeon may attempt to restore lost or missing functionality to joints, limbs, and readily accessible structures and organs such as the tongue, the nose, the eye or the ear. The chiurgeon must make a Diagnosis. For loss connected to physical damage the DC is 20, for loss connected to aging or for functionality missing from birth the DC is 30, and for loss connected to non-damaging magic (the Blindness/Deafness or the Bestow Curse spell for example) the DC is 40. On a successful check the exact cause of the problem is diagnosed correctly and an appropriate surgical procedure is known, save for in the case of loss connected to non-damaging magic. On a failure of less than 5, and on a success in the case of loss connected to non-damaging magic, the exact cause of the problem or a surgical solution is unknown. On a failure of 5 or more the exact cause of the problem is misdiagnosed and an inappropriate surgical procedure is known. Patients would be well advised to get a second opinion, but outside the hospitals and institutions of the largest and most advanced cities such is rarely possible. The length of the surgery is DCxd20 minutes. The exact duration of an operation cannot be foreseen accurately, but the chiurgeon does know that repairing problems connected to physical damage is relatively simple (taking on average 3.5 hours), fixing problems connected to aging or birth defects is fairly complex (taking on average a little over 5 hours), and addressing other problems is very difficult (taking on average 7 hours). The patient loses 25% of his remaining hit points per hour on the operating table to a minimum of 1 hit point (round down). At the beginning of every hour of an operation a to hit roll is made and on a natural 1 the operation fails in the end as a consequence of clumsiness. Should a patient have but 1 hit point when a natural to hit roll of 1 occurs the patient dies on the operating table in 1d4 minutes (unless stabilised and restored to at least 1 hit point with the aid of magic, something that a chiurgeon will resist strenuously on hygenic and ideological grounds). An operation fails if the wrong surgical procedure is attempted. An operation fails if the chiurgeon fails his Heal skill check. A second operation fails automatically if the chiurgeon does not in the interim advance at least one level. An operation that fails because of both a natural to hit roll of 1 and a failed Heal check renders the problem forever incurable by surgery.

    Amputation (Ex): A chiurgeon may remove, with relative safety, part or all of a limb as well as readily accessible structures and organs such as the tongue, the nose, an eye or an ear. For the nose or a ear the DC is 5, for an eye or the tongue the DC is 10, for a hand or a foot the DC is 15, and for a leg or an arm the DC is 20. The length of the operation equals the DC in minutes. The percent of hit points permanently lost equals .5% per minute of the operation and the percent of hit points temporarily lost equals 1% per minute of the operation. Should the patient already be at less than full hit points, which is likely, and should the temporary hit point loss exceed his current hit points, he begins to bleed to death and the chiurgeon must stabilise him to prevent death. At the beginning of the operation a to hit roll is made and on a natural 1 the chiurgeon butchers the job and both the temporary and the permanent hit point loss are doubled. They are likewise doubled if the chiurgeon fails his Heal skill check. In the event of a natural 1 and a failed Heal check the temporary and the permanent hit point loss are tripled.

    Deft Surgery (Ex): An excellent chiurgeon is as dexterous as he is intelligent. The length of a surgery is reduced by 15% per +1 of Dex modifier to a maximum reduction of 90% at +6 Dex modifier, greatly improving the odds for the patient.

    Transplantation (Ex): A chiurgeon may attempt to reattach severed extremities such as toes, fingers, feet, hands, arms and legs as well as cut off or cut out structures and organs such as the tongue, the nose, the eye or the ear. The body part may even come from another creature of the same species (with a -4 penalty). The fresher the body part the better (-1 penalty per 3 hours) although wrapping it in cold wet cloth or better placing it in ice retards decay (by 6 and 12 hours respectively). For toes and fingers the DC is 25, for feet, hands, noses and ears, the DC is 30, for arms, legs and tongues the DC is 35, and for eyes the DC is 40. The length of the surgery is DC x d20 minutes before any modification by Deft Surgery. The patient loses 25% of his remaining hit points per hour on the operating table to a minimum of 1 hit point. At the beginning of every hour of an operation a to hit roll is made and on a natural 1 the operation fails in the end as a consequence of clumsiness. Should a patient have but 1 hit point when a natural to hit roll of 1 occurs the patient dies on the operating table in 1d4 minutes (unless stabilised and restored to at least 1 hit point with the aid of magic.) An operation fails if the chiurgeon fails his Heal skill check. In a failed operation the body part is ruined in the unsuccessful attempt to attach it to the body. An operation that fails because of both a natural to hit roll of 1 and a failed Heal check kills the patient. If the operation is successful and the body part was from another creature, save for a twin, the patient dies in 1d6 days of organ rejection unless either he fails a DC 20 Fortitude save (which cannot be voluntarily failed) or his immune system is suppressed within 24 hours of the transplant by a permanent reduction in Constitution of at least 1 point (typically achieved with a drug derived from Baron's Bane). (Organ rejection is not a disease and cannot be successfully treated with Cure Disease. It can, however, be resolved by Heal.) A body part that is either of a different colour or otherwise is distinguishable from the rest of the body adds +1 to the patient's Outcast Rating.

    Advanced Transplantation (Ex): A chiurgeon can attempt to make a Heal skill check to replace extremities such as toes, fingers, feet, hands, arms and legs as well as structures and organs such as the tongue, the nose, the eye or the ear with the same part from an other species. The other species must be a humanoid or an animal within one size category of the patient. For toes and fingers the DC is 30, for feet, hands, noses and ears, the DC is 35, for arms, legs and tongues the DC is 40, and for eyes the DC is 45. The length of the surgery is DC x d20 minutes before any modification by Deft Surgery. If the operation is successful, the patient dies in 1d6 days of organ rejection unless either he fails a DC 15 Fortitude save (which cannot be voluntarily failed) or his immune system is suppressed within 24 hours of the transplant by a permanent reduction in Constitution of at least 2 points (typically achieved with doses of a drug derived from Baron's Bane). After 1d6 months a patient who received a body part with an extraordinary ability such as low-light vision or darkvision that he did not previously possess masters the use of that extraordinary ability. A body part that is from a creature of a different size than the patient adds +1 to the patient's Outcast Rating. Equally a chiurgeon can attempt to make a Heal skill check to replace an internal organ. When the patient and the donor are of the same humanoid or the same animal species the DC is 40, when of different humanoid or of different animal species the DC is 45, and when one is a humanoid and the other an animal the DC is 50. The species must be of the same size category. A new heart adds 1d6 years of life to an older patient for each difference in age category. A new brain affords its donor a new body and is usually the death of the donor of that body. A brain in a new body takes 2d6 days to master its mundane abilities and 1d6 months to master any extraordinary abilities new to it such as low-light vision or scent that that body might have. Organ rejection again is a problem as described previously

    Reanimation (Ex): A chiurgeon may cheat death itself. As a special boon offered by the Dark Powers, a chiurgeon may restore life, after a fashion, to the recently departed. This boon allows for any one of the following or any thing that a DM should deem comparably horrific: the permanent preservation of the individual on life support; the restoration of the individual in a hideously warped mockery of the norms of its species; the restoration of the individual with its body in pristine condition but its mind utterly broken; the restoration to consciousness of the individual by the suspension of its brain in a fluid filled vat. Five living creatures of the same species and perhaps gender as the individual must be sacrificed as material components and 20,000 gp of supplies are consumed. Reanimation can be applied repeatedly to the same individual in an attempt to remedy the fatal flaws of its newly acquired condition, but this only results in their replacement with other fatal flaws. Normally an individual must be dead not more than twenty four hours, but so long as some attempt is made to preserve the corpse, the Dark Powers may wave this restriction.

    Obsession (Ex): Chiurgeons can channel madness itself to inspired ends. Whenever chiurgeons fail a Madness check it is common for them to be seized by the obsession of creating life. Quickly passing bouts of Madness may only lead a chiurgeon to giving serious thought to the possibility. Long bouts of Madness, especially when triggered by the death of a loved one, may well yield a flesh golem of obsession. DM's should not, however, exclude the possibility of the obsession turning in other directions. Further, it is by no means assured that the obsession itself is always of creating life. The obsession of saving life by preventing the spread of disease, for example, could well lead to the serial murder of prostitutes.

    Power checks:
    -Grave Robbing: A chiurgeon with a conscience but who is unable to obtain bodies legally may seek to plunder the remains of criminals or villans. A chiurgeon unconcerned by such nicities or a chiurgeon who steals the wrong body invites a Powers check.
    -Defilement: A second advantage of the remains of criminals or villans is that they may be excluded from sanctified ground and often are buried unblessed making them difficult to defile. A chiurgeon who defiles a body invites a Powers check.
    -Breaking an Oath: A chiurgeon who takes unnecessary risks with the life of a patient for the sake of his own research invites a Powers Check.
    -Routine Torture: A chiurgeon who maintains a captive as a test subject in the furtherance of his research risks a powers check.
    -Sadistic Torture: A chiurgeon who harvests a body part or parts from a living donor without killing the donor when a cadaver could have been found and used instead invites a Powers Check and potentially engages in an act of Ultimate Evil.
    -Premediated Murder: A chiurgeon who performs an operation or engages in research which he knows will kill the subject invites a Powers check.

    Tools of the Trade:

    Chirurgery Kit (+2 circumstance bonus to Heal skill checks consuming in the process one of the kit's ten uses; +2 circumstance bonus to Search skill checks for diagnosis which does not expend in any way the kit's supplies; 5lb, 75gp, CL 7+, varies (20); VRA p 19)

    Healer's Kit (+2 circumstance bonus on Heal skill checks; exhausted after 10 uses; 1lb, 50gp; SRD)

    Leeches (10; tiny vermin; 1 hp; 1sp; VRA p 19)

    Sanguine Pump (1lb, 50gp, CL 9, glassblowing (20), VRA p 19)

    Syringe (10gp, CL 9, glassblowing (20); VRA p 19)

    Chemical Field Fit (portable chemical lab requisite for making Craft (chemistry) skill checks away from home; 10lb, 100gp, CL 5+, glassblowing (20); VRA p 17)

    Anesthetic (ingested, Fort save DC 15, initial damage loss of physical sensation for 5 minutes (1/2 damage from subdual damage, +4 circumstance bonus to stunning effects, -4 Dexterity reduction), secondary damage none; multiple doses extend the effect; 50gp, CL 4+, Craft (alchemistry or chemistry) (25); VRA p. 60)

    Sleepglass Anesthetic (injury, Fort save DC 30, initial damage 6d6 subdual, secondary damage 1d6 temporary Dex; subject remains unconscious until hit points lost to subduel damage are regained; Gaz II, p 90.

    Ether (inhaled, Fort save DC 15, initial damage 3d6 subdual damage, secondary damage none; holding an ether rag over an individual's nose and mouth requires a successful grapple check an provokes a Fort save each round; a creature knocked unconscious by subdual damage is staggered; 50gp, CL 4+ Craft (alchemistry or chemistry) (25); VRA p. 60)

    Immune System Suppressant (injected, Fort save DC 20, initial damage 1 permanent point of Constitution damage, secondary damage none).

    Smelling Salts (automatically wake up a sleeping or unconscious individual; a creature who was knocked unconscious by subdual damage is staggered; 10gp, CL 4+, Craft (alchemistry or chemistry) (20); VRA p. 60)

    Lightning Flash (generates a slight electrical charge that affords a +2 circumstance bonus to Heal skill checks for long term care; 75gp + 40gp maintenance/3 months, CL 8+, BoSc 191-2)

    Plaguemask (+4 circumstance bonus to resist inhaled diseases and poisons including stenches; -4 listen and spot checks; blocks Scent ability; 1gp, 2lb, CL 6+, leatherworking (5); VRA WE)

    Restraint Board (VRA p 19)

    Flavour:
    Straight Razor (1d4, x3, slashing, 1/2lb; RCS p 56)
    Sword cane rapier (1d6, 18-20/x2, piercing, 4lb, 25gp, CL 4+, weasponsmithing (15); VRA p. 12)[/b]
    Cutlass (as per shortsword except slashing rather than piercing)
Last edited by cure on Sat Dec 13, 2008 5:32 pm, edited 49 times in total.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Post by A G Thing »

I actually like it a lot and think it is quite appropriate. I may just have to use that... Thank you for the excellent PrC! :D
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
User avatar
Strahdsbuddy
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 605
Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 4:02 am
Gender: Male
Location: A Finger Lake

Post by Strahdsbuddy »

Not to be redundant from the thrad that cause this one, but THIS class captures the flavor of the setting so well.
Get the Core Genesis Project V4 https://fraternityofshadows.com/Mausole ... ect_v4.pdf

Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

First, let me express my disappointment in you biased polling process. Seriously, you show a lack of respect for people who disagree with you.

Second, while I like the chiurgeon, I would never approve of an errata replacing the Learned Physician. There's room in RL for both.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

DeepShadow wrote:First, let me express my disappointment in you biased polling process. Seriously, you show a lack of respect for people who disagree with you.

Second, while I like the chiurgeon, I would never approve of an errata replacing the Learned Physician. There's room in RL for both.
I tried to provoke thought on four fronts:

1. Given that Mordenheim is a sworn atheist and a sworn rationalist/positivist, and that Lamordia is an elongation of both to the extent that it has been proposed that spell casting is stifled in that land, does it make sense to invent arcane and divine spell casting classes for his 'family'? If it does or if there is no problem here of consequence, people are invited to say yes.

2. Is there a fundamental conflict between science and religion such that using Scientific Knowledge to trigger spell effects is just plain wrong and a better addition to the flavour of Ravenloft would have been the cloistered cleric whose knowledge is compatible with his beliefs? If there is no conflict or no problem worth worrying about, people are invited to say so.

3. I tried to think of the most ungothic thing that I could. A baby elephant that flies with the assistance of his oversized ears and was brought to us 60 years ago by Disney seemed a better choice than Bambi. If people find that there is something profoundly ungothic about a scientific divine spell caster who is no way torn between the commitment of his heart and the commitment of his head, they are invited to say so.

4. The chiurgeon strikes me as a superior creation for being logically coherent, historically representative, and an answer to how Lamordians/atheists/rationalists/positivists get medical treatment in the Lands of the Mists. If people agree, they are invited to say so.

As to tone, yes it is provocative, but it is my opinion that a lack of respect was shown to Mordenheim, rationalism/positivisim, their divine and arcane opposites, and the flavour of Ravenloft generally in the creation of the Learned Physician and the Scientist. If one disagrees, there are two perfectly respectable ways of saying so within the poll and the further way of not participating in it.

What there may not be, is space for 'fence sitters.' If you like the chiurgeon but don't want to pass unfavourable judgement upon the classes that provoked me to attempt its revival, there is no option asking whether one thinks that it is a nice addition to the status quo. Still, option two would seem to be a place for such opinion to go and moreover would not 'bias' the results in favour of the chiurgeon.

Lastly, the tradition of polls on the site is that of them having an edge rather than that of them merely blandly asking questions.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

Just a random spelling question.

I've seen the word spelled with two "R"s. In the novel King of the Dead, the Oerth medics are called "chirurgeons". Is the PrC spelled differently? Or did Gene DeWeese get it wrong?
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

HuManBing wrote:Just a random spelling question.

I've seen the word spelled with two "R"s. In the novel King of the Dead, the Oerth medics are called "chirurgeons". Is the PrC spelled differently? Or did Gene DeWeese get it wrong?
The spelling connected to this class is all over the map. For example the "Chirurgery Kit" from VRA p. 19. Out of respect to Wyatt and to avoid ambiguities as to revival versus a new creation out of whole clothe, I simply adopted his spelling. But the more I think about it, the less I like it. The "Ch" is good. But the remaining letters are up for debate. Suggestions?
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

cure wrote:If one disagrees, there are two perfectly respectable ways of saying so within the poll and the further way of not participating in it.
I don't see any respectable way to voice disagreement. The first two force someone voting to join in your base assumptions, namely that the physician is casting spells rather than using scientific methods that are summarized as spell effects to save space. Thus, the poll requires that someone agree with you in order to disagree.
What there may not be, is space for 'fence sitters.'
I'm not a fence sitter. I disagree with you. Strongly. There is no place for me on that poll.
Lastly, the tradition of polls on the site is that of them having an edge rather than that of them merely blandly asking questions.
Either-or fallacy: you had more options than either bland questions or biased ones. It's possible to have an edge to your questions while allowing room for a discussion. As it stands, I can only assume you aren't interested in anyone else's opinions.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

While I will add this class to my options for doctors in RL, I am quite glad it wasn't in LotB. The disgrace they made of Artisa Juvenoth was enough to reinforce the welded-to-the-rails aspect of the Mordenheim legacy. I'd like to leave some options as to how PC's slide down the slippery slope and where they end up at the end, and this prestige class gives only one option--flesh golems.

As a counterpart to the learned physician, it's fine. As a replacement in an errata, I think it stretches the definition of "errata" well past the breaking point. An errata means the author made a mistake, not that you disagree and want someone else to have written the chapter.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

I am very interested in any opinions/suggestions that can improve the chiurgeon and that address how atheists/rationalists/positivists/Lamordians get cured without compromising their beliefs. Both the flavour (gothicness) and the mechanism (elegance) of this is open for discussion here. The broader issue of science, Lamordia and magic might be best treated in the discussion of the Scientist prestige class were I am also interested in opinions/suggestions.

Polls are blunt instruments and are always informed by the assumptions of their creators. Rather like televised political debates, where we can invite the two leading candidates, or three candidates, or four candidates, or five candidates, or all the candidates, however many there are, and each possible decision would be vehemently contested by someone, and perhaps rightly so.

Now if it were not my belief/assumption that there is something rotten in the prestige classes of the Mordenheims, I wouldn't have had a matter to address. But it is my belief/assumption that there is something rotten, and on that bases I have attempted to revive what to my eye was a lost treasure, and on a whim I included a poll to test the reception of the converted class in respect to the issues that I thought it would address. A poll that asked the question, Is the chiurgeon a nice addition to the Mists?, may be eminently fair to you who do not agree that there is a problem to address, but it tells me nothing of whether others think that the problem that I broached for discussion has been solved, which to me is no less a fair question.
Last edited by cure on Sat May 24, 2008 5:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

DeepShadow wrote:I'd like to leave some options as to how PC's slide down the slippery slope and where they end up at the end, and this prestige class gives only one option--flesh golems.
The almost from "almost invariably" is there precisely as an invitation for DM's to ponder what other obsessions involving the creation of life might exist and ultimately what other obsessions might take root. Jack the Ripper was in the back of my mind throughout the rewrite. Tomorrow, however, I will change the "almost invariably" to "usually", "typically" or "often."

Well, if one looks over the history of Malken, errata can have considerable scope.

But for the record, I think giving Mordenheim a family beyond the wife on life support and the daughter who Adam killed (right?), was a mistake and penning prestige classes that focused on knowledge, which in no way seperates them from Azalin and his ilk, rather than on positivism, rationalism, atheism, and hubris, which is the lifeblood, to varying degrees, of Lamordia and the bases of the interest of the Dark Powers in Mordenheim, was an error well deserving of being errataed.

How is the Learned Physician representative of Lamordia in a way that is not equally true of Dementlieu, Richemulot, Mordent or Borca? Dementlieu has the stage magician, Falkovnia the raptor knights, Mordent the lamplighters, Richemulot the sewar crawlers (now what was their name?), and Lamordia? A pair of classes that fail to underline and exploit what makes Lamordia distinct.

You are rich, a Lamordian, dying, and refuse the 'aid' of those ridiculous Ezrighties, well good luck with your transplant. That is Lamordian. And gothic.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

I guess what really gets my dander up, cure, is the proposal to add it to the errata in place of the Learned Physician. As a former coworker with Skip on Masque of the Jade Horror, and as an author myself, I'm appalled that you even think you have the authority to do this. An errata is for when the author makes a mistake.

If MotJH had been published, I'd have been pretty put out if someone who didn't like my Taipan prestige class tried to push their alternate version into a proper errata.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

cure wrote:Well, if one looks over the history of Malken, errata can have considerable scope.
That wasn't errata. That was declared non-canon. There's a resounding difference.
But for the record, I think giving Mordenheim a family beyond the wife on life support and the daughter who Adam killed (right?), was a mistake and penning prestige classes that focused on knowledge, which in no way seperates them from Azalin and his ilk, rather than on positivism, rationalism, atheism, and hubris, which is the lifeblood, to varying degrees, of Lamordia and the bases of the interest of the Dark Powers in Mordenheim, was an error well deserving of being errataed.
That's a thematic difference, which doesn't belong in an errata.
How is the Learned Physician representative of Lamordia in a way that is not equally true of Dementlieu, Richemulot, Mordent or Borca?
He credits science for his healing powers. He doesn't pray. When he heals you, he uses an array of scientific tools.
Dementlieu has the stage magician, Falkovnia the raptor knights, Mordent the lamplighters, Richemulot the sewar crawlers (now what was their name?), and Lamordia? A pair of classes that fail to underline and exploit what makes Lamordia distinct.
In your opinion. You have every right to make your opinion known. You have no right to foist it on future players of the game as part of an otherwise legitimate rules corrections.
You are rich, a Lamordian, dying, and refuse the 'aid' of those ridiculous Ezrighties, well good luck with your transplant. That is Lamordian. And gothic.
According to one narrow definition of "gothic," yes. There are other definitions. As deeply as I wish that Ravenloft would have picked one definition and stuck with it, an errata is not the place for that. That's what a setting bible is for. If we as authors had had a setting bible at the beginning, we would have been spared many such atrocities. Alas, it didn't happen.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

cure wrote:I am very interested in any opinions/suggestions that can improve the chiurgeon and that address how atheists/rationalists/positivists/Lamordians get cured without compromising their beliefs.
So you have interest in opinions on how to fix a problem. What about opinions on whether the problem needs fixing?
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

cure wrote:
HuManBing wrote:Just a random spelling question.

I've seen the word spelled with two "R"s. In the novel King of the Dead, the Oerth medics are called "chirurgeons". Is the PrC spelled differently? Or did Gene DeWeese get it wrong?
The spelling connected to this class is all over the map. For example the "Chirurgery Kit" from VRA p. 19. Out of respect to Wyatt and to avoid ambiguities as to revival versus a new creation out of whole clothe, I simply adopted his spelling. But the more I think about it, the less I like it. The "Ch" is good. But the remaining letters are up for debate. Suggestions?

Assuming the term derives from the Greek words for "hand-work" (i.e. surgery), both of the Rs should probably be included.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Post Reply