4th Edition Review

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

alhoon wrote::shock: NOT DMing 4th edition? But it's so much easier for the DM! Not the player BTW, the DM.
Partially on financial grounds (I don't have the money to buy the books) and partially on grounds of principle (I still don't think this edition was necessary and most indicators suggest to me that WotC is doing this for its own wellbeing, not those of its players).

Perhaps the most important issue is that, like I said, I was already starting to grow tired of the d20 game system and to look for something more customizable. I've recently bought a number of GURPS rulebooks and have found somebody who is interested in negotiating to buy the 3.5 books that I acquired last year... shortly before the 4E announcement.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Spotted another flaw: lycanthropes. They're quite messed-up. First off, D&D has swapped to a WoD-style hereditary werebeast system. So their bites no longer turn people into lychans.

Secondly, they only have two forms. Human and animal. No hybrids. Yet all the images of them show hybrids and something capable of weapon and bite attacks.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

1. :shock:

2. I thought you only had a chance to see them for a few hours. Has a friend of yours bought them? What did he/she thinks?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Friend (aka guy with a store) thinks they'll sell well.
Not allowed to take my pre-orded copies home until street date but I can look through a story copy while I hang (WotC is not happy about the broken street dates from buy.com, so he's not taking chances).

Game-wise I'll probably play 4e. It *does* look like a very solid, well thought out game. I'm not regretting my pre-paid purchase.
I just feel underwhelmed and exploited.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

"Thinks they will sell well" is quite different than "thinks it's a good game." :) When I asked what he thinks, I meant if he likes the game Jester.

As for us feeling exploited. I agree. Still, I think I'll buy PHB2 and the book with the spells, the book with the planes, the book with the martial exploits, the MMII etc.
I would have done the same even if the game wasn't forcing me to buy them though. However, I disagree with that policy, I would have been a far happier customer if they sold me a complete set and then offered assessories rather than selling me half the game now, and half the game later before they start offering assessories like the book on elves etc.

I also disagree completely with the "sacrifice difference for balance". Is it difficult to calculate the XP for a vampire if it can be destroyed with sunlight? Yes it is. At one time, it may be piece of cake, just find it when it's sleeping, stake it and expose it. At another time it may be as difficult as it's level indicates.
So what?! De-vampirising the monster just to make it balanced? What kind of crap is that?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Matthew L. Martin
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 176
Joined: Sun Dec 05, 2004 7:49 pm
Contact:

Post by Matthew L. Martin »

Jester of the FoS wrote:Spotted another flaw: lycanthropes. They're quite messed-up. First off, D&D has swapped to a WoD-style hereditary werebeast system. So their bites no longer turn people into lychans.
I'm not sure this is a flaw so much as a double-edged sword. Yes, the werebeast's bite turning someone into a werebeast is a common archetype (at least in Hollywood), but it meant that you couldn't use werebeasts in a game without running the risk of throwing a campaign seriously off-track, especially given the number of hoops you have to jump through to cure lycanthropy in Ravenloft.
I wouldn't object to seeing more developed rules for infective lycanthropy later on (such as when they come to 4E Ravenloft), but I'm fine with saying "some strains can infect others, some can't, some only cause infection under specific circumstances, and some can even make the infection contagious and pass it on that way" and using it as a plot device, adjusting as needed. This is Ravenloft, after all, where no two monsters should be exactly alike.
Secondly, they only have two forms. Human and animal. No hybrids. Yet all the images of them show hybrids and something capable of weapon and bite attacks.
The impression I got from looking at the lycanthropes was that the default was the hybrid, and the shapechanging noted the other shapes.
User avatar
Georg Kristianokov
Criminal Mastermind
Criminal Mastermind
Posts: 147
Joined: Thu Nov 15, 2007 7:45 pm
Location: Pennsauken (Darkon), near Camden (Necropolis)

Post by Georg Kristianokov »

An age old question:


WHAT THE HELL WAS WRONG WITH 2ND EDITION!? :x
Death to the salad eaters!--Verbrekian War cry

I can post almost everything I've written, just PM me!
User avatar
Strahdsbuddy
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 605
Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 4:02 am
Gender: Male
Location: A Finger Lake

Post by Strahdsbuddy »

Georg Kristianokov wrote:An age old question:


WHAT THE HELL WAS WRONG WITH 2ND EDITION!? :x
THAC0, of course!

In all honsety, 3rd edition/d20 made sense from a business standpoint, WotC having just acquired the license. 3.5 was a bit of a head scratcher from a gamer's standpoint, and i don't personally have ay of those books in my colection. 4th Edition...hmmmm, smacks of capitalism.

All i really hope for is Ravenloft ending up in capable hands, even if they are OURS!
Get the Core Genesis Project V4 https://fraternityofshadows.com/Mausole ... ect_v4.pdf

Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
User avatar
Le Noir Faineant
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 4592
Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 12:25 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Barovia

Post by Le Noir Faineant »

My answer to 4e:

Image

Really, sorry, but the more I read about, the worse my impression gets.

All the rule changes are bad enough, but also the many fluff changes.

There's always been an essence of what D&D was.

This game has lost it for me.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Georg Kristianokov wrote:An age old question:

WHAT THE HELL WAS WRONG WITH 2ND EDITION!? :x
The edition had serious flaws. I never ever played 2nd edition as it was. We used tons of house rules and changes because the 2nd edition sucked.

1. Why save vs wands (representing dodging/cover) was different than vs dragon breath (also representing dodging/cover)?
Save vs spells and staves now. Why staves had a different save than wands?
Not to mention that a single save vs spells gave the same chance to resist charm (which was based on willpower) and to resist a fireball (which was based on dodging/cover)
Also ability or level of the caster didn't matter. Only of the defender. If Kimp the apprentince casted charm person on fighter X or Magazoth the wizard champion of the planes, X had the same chance to resist the spell.

2. Fighter stats/Non fighter stats: Non-warriors couldn't get strength over 18 while every fighter with 18 strength had 18+. Also non warriors couldn't get more than 2 bonus hp per level, while warriors could get 4. That means that an invoker with 17 con had +2 hp while the dwarf warrior had +3 hp with the same con.

3. Speaking of specialist wizards: Invokers needed 16 con. Illusionists 15 dex. OK perhaps it was that difficult to master invocation and have one extra slot per day. Why if you lost that 16 con or 15 dex you also lose the +1 against your school's spell? Or the -1 penalty to the targets of your school spells?

4. Strength: The most idiotic weight lifting system of all. Not to mention the opening of doors or bending bars. Str 20: the strength of the stone giant. Poor fellow! He wasn't strong enough to rise from the ground if he fell! :? Yes, he had +3 to hit and +8 to damage, but he couldn't lift his own weight.
Oh, and the fact that every stat went up to 25.
Now was the following unheard of:
- DM: "Brag the brute, use your 18/74 strength to bend the bars of your prison cell"
- Brag: "I rolled 89 on the d100. Failed!"
- Skemp the wimpy halfling rogue: "I rolled 02! I did it. Skemp the wimpy has bent the bars!"

5. rogues: Rogue a: 75% on opening locks vs an easy lock (+5% on the try) has 20% chance to fail. Rogue b: 35% on opening locks against the same lock. Has 60% chance to fail. And if you failed... you couldn't try again until you got a level!
Not to mention that the starting 1st level rogue was a total failure. His percentage chances to do something right were so dim that it was painful.

6. Multiclassing. No you Cheater! You can't have your elf decide to learn magic later!
You human, you want to take another class? From thief to mage, right? OK. Do you have 17 intelligence? 15 dex? Because if you aren't naturally talented in the profession you want to abandon you can't change it. Oh, and after you changed your class, you couldn't progress your other class ever.

7. Demihuman level caps. "Hey! These guys live for so long that if we left them unchecked they will conquer the world with their armies of 20th level characters!" Well... it's not time that gives opportunities for level advancement.
And if Gravan the dwarf, the thrice dragon slayer, the orc purger, the giant toppler managed to live 100 years as a 12th level adventurer he should be able to rise in level

8. Age. Same problem as with 3rd edition actually. Elves spent half their lives in the human equivalent of 70-90! :shock: :x A race of venerable creatures that thankfully do not have social security. 90 years to become adult (equivalent of 15-16) and at 350 they are already venerable. The span for all the rest demihuman races is also distorted like this, making them races of venerable creatures.
Now, couldn't anyone ever think: "Since at 350 the elves are venerable, why should they live for 3d100 more years and not 4d20 more years?" If a character wanted to play an old elf wizard he could pick someone at the age of 355. The character would most probably live for 10+ more years! How many campaigns that include venerable elves span more than 10+ years?
I bet my magic sword that in 4th edition the problem will be unsolved.

9. Demihuman character classes. No, there couldn't be an elf bard. Nor a dwarf wizard. And all gnome mages were illusionists.

10. Psionics. LoL. At 6th level you could use disintigrate.

11. For some reason, clerics got bonus spells with wisdom. Wizards didn't get from intelligence. Also wizards could have a maximum number of spells of a given level in their books depending on intelligence. For example 14 intelligence was... 7 spells IIRC? 6?

12. diseases did permanent ability damage. Energy drain didn't have a fort. A spectre touches you BAM! 2 levels down. Perhaps with restoration you could get 1 level back but restoration was 7th level spell then. "Easy come, easy go" as a DM said once. A friend has lost 3 levels and the cleric was just 13 level, so he couldn't cast restoration (not to mention he was unconsiouss in a different part of the city). Easy come? Three levels?



And these are on top of my head. If I pick up my 2nd edition books and start reading again, I'll find more examples.

2nd edition was the worst D&D edition ever. Old D&D rules had some of these limitations, but at least the game was simpler.
One of the reasons that I'm wary of 4th edition is that it seems to take a step backwards towards 2nd edition!
Last edited by alhoon on Sat May 31, 2008 8:42 am, edited 3 times in total.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

Georg Kristianokov wrote:An age old question:


WHAT THE HELL WAS WRONG WITH 2ND EDITION!? :x
In terms of fluff, nothing. 2e was and is the gold standard for awesome writing, complete boxed set coverage, and comprehensive detailing. I own campaign setting boxed sets for Ravenloft, Dark Sun, Birthright, Forgotten Realms, Dragonlance, Spelljammer, and Planescape and they are sorely missed from 3E.

However, there were several game mechanics that didn't hold together cohesively, and which I respect 3.5 for clearing up (or attempting to clear up).

Saving throws were arbitrary. 3E makes them into a flat bonus, and leaves the difficulty up to the DM.

THAC0 was okay, but it was based on AC, which was an arbitrary system. As with saves, 3E made AC and BAB into a flat bonus.

Nonweapon proficiencies were arbitrary. Some had far greater "untrained" penalties than others. Some would have a mere -2, others would have a -5 or more. These were straight-up checks against your attribute, which on a d20 can lead to weird effects (a Str 6 wizard making a roll that a Str 13 Cleric fails, for example). The change to a ranked skill system was more flexible, in my opinion, even if the system they ultimately chose for 3E has some serious problems of its own. (FWIW, Call of Cthulhu has the same problem, and GURPS has it but addresses it by classing the skills into Easy, Moderate, Hard, and Very Hard, each with their own standardized penalty.)

A similar streamlining of the attribute bonuses happened, and it was a welcome development. Now a Strength of 18 gave you the same bonus as a Charisma of 18.

Magic Resistance, like saves, were unilaterally defined. It didn't matter if the caster was L1 or L20, the MR and the save vs. spell would be the same no matter what. The same thing held for thieving skills. 3E fixed this with an opposed roll mechanic, and it remains mathematically one of the (very few) things I like about it.

So there were reasons for me to make the switch from 2e to 3e. However I'm not seeing a similar level of revision and mathematical "housekeeping" in 4E, so I am not interested in investing in it.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Huh... I have forgot that magic resistance percentage.

You want more reasons why 2nd edition sucked?

13. Mind flayer 90% magic resistance. Again, Kimp the apprentice and Mazagoth the wizard champion of the plains had the same chance to affect the mind flayer.
Laaaater on, there was a spell that Mazagoth at least could have casted that gave him a bonus to pierce the magic resistance of a certain creature. It needed a round to be cast of course, and that bonus was 1% per level. So Mazagoth would have about +25% chance to affect the mind flayer or about 35% chance.
And in my 10 years as playing partly 2nd edition... I didn't see one magic staff or something that gave even a +10% bonus to pierce magic resistance.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

Well I think 2e is getting a bad coverage here and need more respect. It wasn't that bad, as it was all that we had at the time. Remember? We even played with it and had fun :) Sure, it was also the golden era of the house rules, but it worked!

2e was basically a lifting over 1e, while 3e was a complete remake of the game. 3e benefited from 20 years of experience and corrected many strange things about the first incarnations of D&D (1e/2e), so I think it's unfair to compare 2e with our knowledge of 3rd ed and what this new system corrected.

But all systems have their own flaws. If you think hard enough (which alhoon is proving here :)), you'll find impossibilities and logic flaws in any system (the giant unable to lift his own weight), but other than a laugh, did it really change anything in the game?

Yes, the 3e system for save against spell, based on spell level + caster Int, is much better conceived than 2e. But the rod staff wand breath spell save system worked too... Don't forget most of it was a legacy of the first Gygaxian D&D game, and nobody wanted to change it that dramaticaly until 3rd ed. 1e/2e was not the best game, as 3e showed it could be improved a lot, but hey, it gave us D&D so I'll never complain that those previous editions "sucked" ;)

Can we go back to 4th ed review now?

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

^ QFT.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

AN APOLOGY

I sincerely apologize here for all those offended by my posts. Yes, I hate 2nd edition. I don't hate people playing 2nd edition. As Gotten said, it was all that we had at the time... we were unlucky. :)

The people that used to play 2nd edition or even still play it and there are some are not fools nor morons.

The people that thought of 2nd edition are not fools nor morons. I respect them and their hard work. I don't like the product of that work but that's me. The people that made 2nd edition or the people that played second edition made a game.
As such Millions of people (including me) had fun playing that game with all its shortcomings.
In my opinion, these shortcomings were many. I had fun playing 2nd edition with a few changes at start and more later but in the end... I too had fun with 2nd edition. :) Making those changes was part of the fun BTW.
And in case you ask: Most of the people didn't like my changes, they prefered the simpler and easier 2nd edition rules with a few modifications.
Then 3rd edition came and I saw that most of my grips with the game have been rectified in an increadibly simpler way.
When I tried to explain some of my 2nd edition house rules to friends they used to tell me:
"Man, we're not so good with physics and math so we can't understand these strange diagrams and equations you propose. We don't like the notion of asserting the velocity and the density of the air and then looking at the large table you made using a computer to calculate the range of a giant's rock attack!"

I specifically apologize to HuManBing and to Georg. Georg, my remarks were against 2nd edition not against you. You asked what was wrong with 2nd edition... a very very long list IMO and perhaps accidentaly I offended you in my answer. That was never my intention.
Gotten, in case I offended you with my post, I apologize too. I don't think my post was offending but I have some difficulty realizing it sometimes.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Post Reply