4th Edition Review
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Very big of you. When I read your post I debated removal but opted not to because we've had more heated 2e vs 3e debates in the past and I've made a similar laundry list of 3e problems in the past.
2e was good at its time. Sortof. It wasn't that much of an update of 1e which was brilliant for its time. So, by extension, 2e was brilliant. Heck, if you had all the optional rule books for 1e, you had 2e.
But even then, in '89, there were other, much better game systems. GURPs was introduced three years earlier.
Which makes me think of this cartoon:
http://www.userfriendly.org/cartoons/ar ... 011430.gif
Of course, my big problem with 4e is that you really can't create any character you envision... Not compared to 3e.
2e was good at its time. Sortof. It wasn't that much of an update of 1e which was brilliant for its time. So, by extension, 2e was brilliant. Heck, if you had all the optional rule books for 1e, you had 2e.
But even then, in '89, there were other, much better game systems. GURPs was introduced three years earlier.
Which makes me think of this cartoon:
http://www.userfriendly.org/cartoons/ar ... 011430.gif
Of course, my big problem with 4e is that you really can't create any character you envision... Not compared to 3e.
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Alhoon, your post wasn't really offensive, but somewhat aggressive
No offense taken by the way. But as a long time poster, you know we the moderators do not have trouble maintaining these boards since a few years, which is a blessing, in a large part because people here behave with courtesy and avoid being aggressive or attacking other poster personally.
---
We are not against debate, au contraire.
In the following weeks/months, we do expect a lot of comparisons between 4th and 3rd, and with other edition/systems too. It has already started, and it's perfectly OK. One of the good ways to get all the subtelty of the new mechanics will be through comparisons.
(And we'll have to do it when we adapt RL to 4e)
You may think "2nd ed sucked". I do not, for the reasons I stated above. IMHO, it was as David wrote, brilliant for the time. Flawed? Sure. We can discuss that in any lenght, I do not mind it.
But we I read here that 2e "sucked", I just wanted to express my own views on the matter to rectify a few things
Joël
---
We are not against debate, au contraire.
In the following weeks/months, we do expect a lot of comparisons between 4th and 3rd, and with other edition/systems too. It has already started, and it's perfectly OK. One of the good ways to get all the subtelty of the new mechanics will be through comparisons.
(And we'll have to do it when we adapt RL to 4e)
You may think "2nd ed sucked". I do not, for the reasons I stated above. IMHO, it was as David wrote, brilliant for the time. Flawed? Sure. We can discuss that in any lenght, I do not mind it.
But we I read here that 2e "sucked", I just wanted to express my own views on the matter to rectify a few things
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
2e does suck.
At the time it was amazing. It was fantastic. It was... amaztastic.
But now it sucks.
Time makes fools of us all. How many movies/songs/books were brilliant at the time but after 20 years feel.. amateurish?
I know alot of movies that are considered "classics" feel bloated and slow or poorly paced compared to modern works. I love Spielberg but have never made it through Close Encounters...
At the time it was amazing. It was fantastic. It was... amaztastic.
But now it sucks.
Time makes fools of us all. How many movies/songs/books were brilliant at the time but after 20 years feel.. amateurish?
I know alot of movies that are considered "classics" feel bloated and slow or poorly paced compared to modern works. I love Spielberg but have never made it through Close Encounters...
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Sure it's outdated now. And I know the feeling, haveing watched The Lost Boys movie recently with the kids 
Joël
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
1st edition was good for it's time. As you mentioned, 2nd edition didn't improve it much. IMO it just complicated it and ridded it with a few more mistakes.
About old D&D: I was very, very fond of Old D&D at the time, and perhaps some of my feelings against 2nd edition are based on this.
I was looking, as a child to a favorite game: D&D that excited my fantasy. Easy to make dominions adventures etc. I wasn't old enough to care much about realism and problems. I was 11-12 years old. Later? Later I had fond memories of heroic adventures and I forgived the lack of some stable rules or the missing choices.
About 2nd edition:
As I grew to become 14-15 years old, I bought 2nd edition. At the time, I didn't have much money. You know, I was using christmas/birthday gifts etc.
I found out that the new system I had invested half-a-year's money wasn't to my liking at all. It offered more complex rules without improving existing ones.
So what I did? I kept mainly the ability score break-out, the new spells, the 20-level break-up of classes... and that's it.
Period. Honestly from a 14-year's-old perspective it wasn't worth half-a-year's money.
At the time internet in Greece wasn't an option. You checked the book and bought it. No reviews.
About 3rd edition: It is one of the most flexible systems regarding character and monster creation rules. It's also open to powergaming and errors. "Woops. It seems that an undead with 4HD, damage reduction 10/+1 and the ability to use finger of death once per day as a 12th level caster isn't actually CR 4..."
Not to mention the overwhelming feel I got that 1st level chars were loosers. 4 1st level chars: 3 goblin warriors, followed by 2 hobgoblins and finally as the climatic, difficult battle: a 1st level goblin rogue and a 1st lvl hobgoblin fighter with a masterwork falchion and wearing (gods!) a suit of chain mail!
Pheeeww we managed to save the merchant with only the wizard dead.
Poor wizard. He had bitten a javelin at the first fight and was down by 2 hp (i.e he had 3 hp). Then the goblin rogue backstabbed him for 11 damage. The cleric was out cold, and the others didn't manage to stabilize him in 2 rounds while fighting the enormous threat.
4th edition: As far as I have seen, too much have been sacrificed for balance. A step backwards. Is this monster's ability too difficult to calculate? Eliminate. Is this power potentionaly making this class step on this class' toes, eliminate.
Not to mention that WotC seems to be selling us half the game, holding the other half in reserve... I hate that.
However the system seems so easy to learn and master that I believe I will like it. It reminds me somewhat of that oD&D days, where things were simple like 1d6 for initiative+dex. Whoever rolls more, acts. It's not love for the new that made me keep my pre-order of 4th edition after Jester's review. It is nostalgia. I want to play again a 1st level hero that kicks many goblins with a band of fellows.
Again, just in case: I liked 3rd edition. I hope everyone understands that I don't try to offend anyone with my post. I'm just criticizing some of what I liked/disliked in D&D so far.
About old D&D: I was very, very fond of Old D&D at the time, and perhaps some of my feelings against 2nd edition are based on this.
I was looking, as a child to a favorite game: D&D that excited my fantasy. Easy to make dominions adventures etc. I wasn't old enough to care much about realism and problems. I was 11-12 years old. Later? Later I had fond memories of heroic adventures and I forgived the lack of some stable rules or the missing choices.
About 2nd edition:
As I grew to become 14-15 years old, I bought 2nd edition. At the time, I didn't have much money. You know, I was using christmas/birthday gifts etc.
I found out that the new system I had invested half-a-year's money wasn't to my liking at all. It offered more complex rules without improving existing ones.
So what I did? I kept mainly the ability score break-out, the new spells, the 20-level break-up of classes... and that's it.
At the time internet in Greece wasn't an option. You checked the book and bought it. No reviews.
About 3rd edition: It is one of the most flexible systems regarding character and monster creation rules. It's also open to powergaming and errors. "Woops. It seems that an undead with 4HD, damage reduction 10/+1 and the ability to use finger of death once per day as a 12th level caster isn't actually CR 4..."
Not to mention the overwhelming feel I got that 1st level chars were loosers. 4 1st level chars: 3 goblin warriors, followed by 2 hobgoblins and finally as the climatic, difficult battle: a 1st level goblin rogue and a 1st lvl hobgoblin fighter with a masterwork falchion and wearing (gods!) a suit of chain mail!
Pheeeww we managed to save the merchant with only the wizard dead.
4th edition: As far as I have seen, too much have been sacrificed for balance. A step backwards. Is this monster's ability too difficult to calculate? Eliminate. Is this power potentionaly making this class step on this class' toes, eliminate.
Not to mention that WotC seems to be selling us half the game, holding the other half in reserve... I hate that.
However the system seems so easy to learn and master that I believe I will like it. It reminds me somewhat of that oD&D days, where things were simple like 1d6 for initiative+dex. Whoever rolls more, acts. It's not love for the new that made me keep my pre-order of 4th edition after Jester's review. It is nostalgia. I want to play again a 1st level hero that kicks many goblins with a band of fellows.
Again, just in case: I liked 3rd edition. I hope everyone understands that I don't try to offend anyone with my post. I'm just criticizing some of what I liked/disliked in D&D so far.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
Actually, the problem with magic resistance isn't exactly that. In 1e, at least, magic resistance was given assuming an 11th level caster; if you were less than 11th level, you add 5% to the MR for each level under 11, and if you were over 11th you subtract 5% for every level over 11th. So it was actually exactly the same mechanic as 3e SR, just using percentile dice instead of a d20. So 10% magic resistance is exactly equal to SR 13 in the new system, and 90% magic resistance is the same as SR 29. Of course, expressing it as a percentage means it caps at 100%, so if you're above 31st level nothing has magic resistance anymore.alhoon wrote:And in my 10 years as playing partly 2nd edition... I didn't see one magic staff or something that gave even a +10% bonus to pierce magic resistance.
Not a problem that comes up often, but a good example of how 3e took things like magic resistance, armor class and ability scores and fixed them by removing the totally arbitrary caps usually put on them in 1e/2e.
(I assume this feature of magic resistance was retained for 2e...I've read the 1e DMG/MM a lot more than the 2e versions
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
So I tried making a 4e character.
Rolled-up (okay, point-bought) a half-elf paladin. Had the usual choice between average stats or a few high ones, so opted for high. Which made a choice between high Str or high Dex or high other.
But given the pally abilities, the choice was really Cha vs Str, as all the abilities rely on one or the other with Wis also being a factor.
So I put most of my points in Wisdom and Charisma with others in Con (since I'd be a front-liner).
When it came to powers I picked the two that didn't rely on Strength and one of the two Encounter powers that didn't. Ditto Daily.
For feats there was only really two paladin powers, although I could have picked one of the handful of human, elf or half-elf powers. I picked a paladin-healing power although I might go through the cleric/god powers and pick one of those.
Looking at my selections, I'd pretty much made all the same choices of powers/feats as the "protector" build they offer as a suggestion.
*sigh*
Really, with the exception of my racial power, there was only really two paladin builds, unless I wanted to go with something really screwy (like a high dex bow paladin or something).
I can see this happening alot...
Rolled-up (okay, point-bought) a half-elf paladin. Had the usual choice between average stats or a few high ones, so opted for high. Which made a choice between high Str or high Dex or high other.
But given the pally abilities, the choice was really Cha vs Str, as all the abilities rely on one or the other with Wis also being a factor.
So I put most of my points in Wisdom and Charisma with others in Con (since I'd be a front-liner).
When it came to powers I picked the two that didn't rely on Strength and one of the two Encounter powers that didn't. Ditto Daily.
For feats there was only really two paladin powers, although I could have picked one of the handful of human, elf or half-elf powers. I picked a paladin-healing power although I might go through the cleric/god powers and pick one of those.
Looking at my selections, I'd pretty much made all the same choices of powers/feats as the "protector" build they offer as a suggestion.
*sigh*
Really, with the exception of my racial power, there was only really two paladin builds, unless I wanted to go with something really screwy (like a high dex bow paladin or something).
I can see this happening alot...
- Lord Soth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 264
- Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
- Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus
I didn't expect a starting book to contain as many options as I have build up in the years that I played 3rd. But to contain less options than the PHB?!![]()
The problem there, Alhoon, is that those options were only available to about half the classes. And not even to the same degree. You had three or four classes with a plethora of options, three or four more with some additional options, and the rest had practically nothing. Do some classes get less options? Yes. But every class has equal options, now. That's a far cry from the Fighter having four pages in comparison to the dozens that the Wizard had. Remember, that's the reason the Sorcerer class was invented. Because WotC didn't like the fact that an enormous amount of space was consumed by information which was only useful to a single class. Do Wizards have less options? Yes. Do Clerics have less options? Yes. But there's more to the game then Wizards and Clerics. And it's about time they got an equal share of the attention.
Now on the spellcasters: The 150 choices Jester mentions are far, far less than I was used to. You said it was bad for spellcasting classes to have all the choices. They could give the fighters the choices they did without cutting down the spellcaster choices. Also in 3rd edition high level spellcasters could do a lot more than 17 different things.
As you said, you didn't expect a starting book to contain as many options as before. The 4E PHB is 320 pages long with eight classes. How much more could they have possibly packed in? What class should have gotten cut to make room for more options for the Wizard? And once again, there's more to the game then just Wizards. No one class should be eating up that much space in the book.
Keep in mind many of the later ones are apparently restricted by weapon. So if you're a long-sword fighter each level you may get a choice from three or two or only one power.
I'm pretty sure you're misreading things. Some powers are better with certain weapons. Chains of Sorrows, for instance, is better if you're using a flail. That doesn't mean, however, that you can't use that power while using a warhammer.
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
True. But that's a manipulative example, as it's a power that grants a benefit with a secondary benefit if you use a particular weapon.Lord Soth wrote:I'm pretty sure you're misreading things. Some powers are better with certain weapons. Chains of Sorrows, for instance, is better if you're using a flail. That doesn't mean, however, that you can't use that power while using a warhammer.
Look at all the 3rd level powers, which all but require the specific type of weapon for the benefit of the power. That's the much more common example.
Likewise, finesse fighters (a swashbuckler for example) are all but removed. All a fighter's powers rely on strength.
Put all together there's probably only four or five varients on a human fighter of a given level. Human axe-fighters will all be fairly similar with the exception of a single power or single feat.
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Okay, but is there another way to make a swashbuckler, using a different class/feat/skill combo?Jester of the FoS wrote:Lord Soth wrote:Likewise, finesse fighters (a swashbuckler for example) are all but removed. All a fighter's powers rely on strength.
I'm not convinced that less variety is a bad thing, really. I've realized after playing a lot of 3.5 that when fighters can be so drastically different from each other, it blurs the definition of "fighter." If "fighter" has room for a dex-based duelist and a strength-based tank, then maybe we need to split it into two classes.
So how do you make a swashbuckler in 4E? If you flat-out can't do it, that's bad, but it's a bit premature to say you can't do it just because it's not filed under "fighter."
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Alternate swashbuckler? Well, rogue might work. And a rapier/dagger ranger would be good too. So, yeah, it is totally possible.
I just don't like every fighter being big strength-based brutes. Every attack strength vs AC. The only variation being weapon (again).
Again, the system itself is rock solid. If you wanted to you *could* sit down and hammer out a wicked dex-fighter. One that didn't overshadow the ranger or rogue and would be based on agile defense instead of offense, so it would still be filling the role of fighter (meat shield or beat stick).
An exploit that prevents an enemy from moving with a quick sword swipe.
An exploit that deflects a blow with an agile dodge.
An exploit that peppers a foe with multiple quick attacks.
I just wish the book I'm paying money for actually had this stuff so I didn't have to make it myself. I'm paying money so I don't have to design the game.
And if I really want these powers I'll have to pay the $30 for the Martial Powers book that WotC has conveniently coming out in 3-4 months.
(too bad I'm leaning to a divine, that book will probably be longer before it comes out)
Yes, fighters have more options than they did in 3e. And yes, there are still multiple different builds. But not enough. It's limited, and deliberately do.
Look through the classes. Each level there's generally two powers per build: a ranged weapon or a two-weapon for rangers, a strength or a Cha for paladins. Each race has around four feats. Warlocks and wizards both have three stylistic variations: star, fey, infernal; wand, staff, orb. Four paragon paths per class (3 for the warlock, one/pact). Four epic destinies.
4 pops up *alot* throughout the class section. Why? Because two recommended builds/designs with two options each level.
Two real choices: the minimum needed for a choice. So if you're playing at a table of five people and there's two of one class they won't necessarily be identical. One might have light-blade power 1 while the other has light-blade power 2. One paladin has Cha power 1, the other paladin has Cha power 2
When you look at the book, the sheer amount of size the class section takes up, it does look like alot.
But there's alot of blank space, alot of white at the bottom of pages. Alot of big fonts at each new level and each power's name. To say nothing of the page-and-a-half used each chapter on a big splash picture.
And go through the feats. Looks like alot too. Well over a hundred feats. But there's actually maybe 20 more feats than in the 3.5 book. Maybe.
Too bad your characters get more feats in 4e. 18 at level 30. More depending on class/race. Compared to the 11 or so you'd get in 3e. 25% more feats per character, 15% more feats in the book.
Of course, the 3e PHB really only has feats for levels 1-20 where you get 7 feats. So for a fair comparison we should bring in the DMG's epic feats, which would probably equalize the number of feats.
-4e, where there's the same number of feats in the book, but where you qualify for less due to race and class while you earn much more.-
I was advancing my test-paladin through to level 30. He qualified for 30, maybe 35 feats. But, by level 30 he'd gain 18 feats. 18/35... why that's just over 50%. Again, a choice of 2/level.
Of course, he's also a half-elf so get gets all the elf and human feats. If he'd just been a human paladin he'd get 19 feats but qualify for 28-30. Closer to 65% then.
I know I'm being overly sensitive. I know I'm acting jaded. I just look at the book and it's pathetic magic item section and think "if they moved that to the DMG, shrunk the fonts for the sub-titles, power names and power levels, kept the chapter art to 1/2 a page, and maybe didn't have 1/10th of page blank for a fifth of the book, then there'd be 50+ pages freed. Easily.
Wow, that's enough for 5 more pages for each class with 10 pages free for feats. And that's keeping the same page-count.
I just don't like every fighter being big strength-based brutes. Every attack strength vs AC. The only variation being weapon (again).
Again, the system itself is rock solid. If you wanted to you *could* sit down and hammer out a wicked dex-fighter. One that didn't overshadow the ranger or rogue and would be based on agile defense instead of offense, so it would still be filling the role of fighter (meat shield or beat stick).
An exploit that prevents an enemy from moving with a quick sword swipe.
An exploit that deflects a blow with an agile dodge.
An exploit that peppers a foe with multiple quick attacks.
I just wish the book I'm paying money for actually had this stuff so I didn't have to make it myself. I'm paying money so I don't have to design the game.
And if I really want these powers I'll have to pay the $30 for the Martial Powers book that WotC has conveniently coming out in 3-4 months.
(too bad I'm leaning to a divine, that book will probably be longer before it comes out)
Yes, fighters have more options than they did in 3e. And yes, there are still multiple different builds. But not enough. It's limited, and deliberately do.
Look through the classes. Each level there's generally two powers per build: a ranged weapon or a two-weapon for rangers, a strength or a Cha for paladins. Each race has around four feats. Warlocks and wizards both have three stylistic variations: star, fey, infernal; wand, staff, orb. Four paragon paths per class (3 for the warlock, one/pact). Four epic destinies.
4 pops up *alot* throughout the class section. Why? Because two recommended builds/designs with two options each level.
Two real choices: the minimum needed for a choice. So if you're playing at a table of five people and there's two of one class they won't necessarily be identical. One might have light-blade power 1 while the other has light-blade power 2. One paladin has Cha power 1, the other paladin has Cha power 2
When you look at the book, the sheer amount of size the class section takes up, it does look like alot.
But there's alot of blank space, alot of white at the bottom of pages. Alot of big fonts at each new level and each power's name. To say nothing of the page-and-a-half used each chapter on a big splash picture.
And go through the feats. Looks like alot too. Well over a hundred feats. But there's actually maybe 20 more feats than in the 3.5 book. Maybe.
Too bad your characters get more feats in 4e. 18 at level 30. More depending on class/race. Compared to the 11 or so you'd get in 3e. 25% more feats per character, 15% more feats in the book.
Of course, the 3e PHB really only has feats for levels 1-20 where you get 7 feats. So for a fair comparison we should bring in the DMG's epic feats, which would probably equalize the number of feats.
-4e, where there's the same number of feats in the book, but where you qualify for less due to race and class while you earn much more.-
I was advancing my test-paladin through to level 30. He qualified for 30, maybe 35 feats. But, by level 30 he'd gain 18 feats. 18/35... why that's just over 50%. Again, a choice of 2/level.
Of course, he's also a half-elf so get gets all the elf and human feats. If he'd just been a human paladin he'd get 19 feats but qualify for 28-30. Closer to 65% then.
I know I'm being overly sensitive. I know I'm acting jaded. I just look at the book and it's pathetic magic item section and think "if they moved that to the DMG, shrunk the fonts for the sub-titles, power names and power levels, kept the chapter art to 1/2 a page, and maybe didn't have 1/10th of page blank for a fifth of the book, then there'd be 50+ pages freed. Easily.
Wow, that's enough for 5 more pages for each class with 10 pages free for feats. And that's keeping the same page-count.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
I talked about this with a few friends. They disagreed with us Jester.
They said "picking from 2 from 3 character powers in addition of having the feat? That's more choices than fighter in 3rd has!"
I said "yes, but for example there aren't powers for archers, except if you copy the ranger or make up your own". They asked me "Is it difficult to copy the ranger's powers ro make your own?".
Well... I didn't convince them. They see the few choices per level for the fighter as a good thing and they were also happy that spellcasters had fewer options! ! ! ! One of them doesn't like spellcasters so he was happy that they are on the same page as far as choices go with the martial classes. The other one who likes fighters and also clerics and paladins thinks that at least, fewer options makes cleric simpler to play.
They said "picking from 2 from 3 character powers in addition of having the feat? That's more choices than fighter in 3rd has!"
I said "yes, but for example there aren't powers for archers, except if you copy the ranger or make up your own". They asked me "Is it difficult to copy the ranger's powers ro make your own?".
Well... I didn't convince them. They see the few choices per level for the fighter as a good thing and they were also happy that spellcasters had fewer options! ! ! ! One of them doesn't like spellcasters so he was happy that they are on the same page as far as choices go with the martial classes. The other one who likes fighters and also clerics and paladins thinks that at least, fewer options makes cleric simpler to play.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Well, fighters often had a feat each level, and many more choices with feats. So not really.alhoon wrote:They said "picking from 2 from 3 character powers in addition of having the feat? That's more choices than fighter in 3rd has!"
And even if you ignore feats, fighters are really the class that gets hit the hardest with choices in 3e.
A better example might be monks, who have similar choices in 3e. Deflect arrows or stunning fist? Improved grapple or combat reflexes?
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
I really like this idea of retraining - each level you can change one feat or one power or one skill.
Thsi way your character focuses and improves in the way you are going, and you get rid of outdated caracter creation oddities and bad past decisions.
I did that in a RL campaign. I had a guy trained with the crossbow, but then the bow proved easier/more convenient to use so I switched when gaining a level, including feat.
Since our team plans to stay in 3e for a while, I'll implement this idea.
Joël
Thsi way your character focuses and improves in the way you are going, and you get rid of outdated caracter creation oddities and bad past decisions.
I did that in a RL campaign. I had a guy trained with the crossbow, but then the bow proved easier/more convenient to use so I switched when gaining a level, including feat.
Since our team plans to stay in 3e for a while, I'll implement this idea.
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Another weird thing I read on the net from other posters: I'm not sure I like the new "healing surge" in "second wind": any character get 25% of hp back ("you dig in your resolve and endurance to find an extra burst of vitality")...
OK, you get less dependant on clerics, but then clerics are much less useful. I'll find more about 4e clerics...
OK, you get less dependant on clerics, but then clerics are much less useful. I'll find more about 4e clerics...
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
