Comments on Scientist (LotB)?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

A curious, but admittedly metagame, argument for Mordenheim to believe that golems are creations of science and the result of the harnassing of natural processes is the following description from the SRD as to why constructs are immune to an Antimagic Shell: "The spell has no effect on golems and other constructs that are imbued with magic during their creation process and are thereafter self-supporting." This begins to matter in game because of the Dread Possibility of the Smothering of Reason which is the equivalent of a Lamordian wide Antimagic Spell functioning at 2% rather than 100% efficiency. A continuing effect that escapes the smothering the first time must make the roll again daily until it is suppressed. So magic items all eventually cease functioning in Lamordia, but golems go on and on and on. Given that Mordenheim is described as having "studied the sciences, both natural and arcane" (although by his stats he apparently didn't learn enough for even a rank in Knowledge (arcane) or he retrained his skills subsequently) before "deeming it a 'diversion from the Truth'", he might well be sufficiently abreast of the matter to note that golems keep ticking and magic does not. This would reinforce his prejudice against magic and indeed the Smothering of Reason ticked up in efficiency from 1% to 2% in 757 BC.

Now as to the effects produced by the Scientist prestige class, of which Mordenheim is not a member, and for that matter of the Learned Physician Prestige class too, are they subject to the Smothering of Reason?

The Learn Physician's spells are literally described as spells, and his Healing Touch is explicitly described as supernatural, so these two class abilities are manifestly subject to the possibility of failures stemming from the Smothering of Reason.

Whereas the Scientist's tricks "work as spells of the same name, except that each is an extraordinary ability that requires a standard action to use . . . and are not subject to dispelling (unless otherwise noted), antimagic, or spell resistance." So they are not subject to the Smothering of Reason and, for that matter, are not subject to disruption as spells are and do not trigger attacks of opportunity.

So putting words in Victor's mouth, he considers the healing of Learn Physicians to be magical and a diversion from the Truth and the tricks of Scientists to be non magical and part of the Truth.

Now are these scientists and Victor himself in any sense mad?

Victor believes that he has created life, when in was the gods whom he derided and spurned who decided to take their revenge upon him by granting him, after a fashion, the victory that he had long and obsessively fought for. This is to say, I am beginning to suspect, that Victor is in fact unaware of what a golem/construct truly is and how it is ultimately of a different type than mankind. In any case he believes that it is through his own genius that Elise is kept alive, whereas she lives at the will of the Dark Powers as does Victor himself. The goal of creating life has as its motive and its underside the desire of cheating death. Victor believes that he has done this in keeping his wife alive and his methods simply have to be perfected to restore her fully and savour the fruits of his victory. So long as he proudly soldiers on, sustained by the knowledge that he has cured death and created life, Victor is not so much deluded, for how is he to recognise the dabbling of the gods and the Dark Powers in his work, as he is ruinously and criminally obsessed for all his victories are pyrrhic. His adopted daughter is dead at the hand of his creation, his wife is effectively dead at the hands of his creation, and his creation despises him, and his results are not even science since they are not repeatable by others (unless the Dark Powers choose to make them so). Does ruinous, criminal obsession describe a mad scientist? It is surely a crucial part of the very definition of one.

Are the prestige class Scientists obsessed let alone ruinously and criminally so? No. Are they deluded about the nature of their tricks? No more than clerics receiving spells in Ravenloft are and perhaps less. Equally, no more than wizards casting spells are and in Lamordia their tricks are in fact more real as they never fail.

The prestige class Scientist is in fact a perfectly sane being who describes himself as a scientist, who accordingly denies that magic exists, who from his own perspective is in no way making use of magic, but functionally reproduces spells in their every detail so far as their effects are concerned, and borrows the prestige of science from the real world while accepting none of its constraints that serve to distinguish it from magic. The 'Scientist' is a scientist in name only. In fact he is a sorcerer who pretty much chooses to cast either all enchantment spells or all evocation spells or all conjuration spells or a mixed bag of transmutation, necromancy and stealth necromancy spells, with the difference that the spells always work in Lamordia and the similarity that they are no less likely to get him burnt at the stake in Tepest.

Were this sorcerer somehow gothic then there would be perhaps some point to having him rather than a sorcerer that identifies himself as such or rather than having a mad scientist prestige class that actually lives up to its name and its homeland, but this sorcerer is not gothic.

None of this is to deny that with sufficient fluff and good roll playing one cannot make a character gothic and interesting. But the scientist class itself on its merits is neither and should be replaced.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

A G Thing wrote:These tricks still require a Scientific Knowledge Check, power sources, a standard action to use and are still considered extraordinary.
Sorry for not commenting sooner.

Does the fact that as extraordinary the tricks are not subject to disruption and don't trigger attacks of opportunity pose a game balance issue?

Beyond that, A for effort in trying to fix its unbalanced spell casting, but my problem with the class, which may not be everyone elses, bites in respect to the very existence of that spell casting.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

cure wrote:You know, looking over the description of the Smothering of Reason, which will eventually cancel out any continuous supernatural effect, I would say that no incorporeal undead lasts for long in Lamordia (2% chance per day of winking out of existence until the smothering end).
This seems so heavy-handed, and so restrictive, I'd be more inclined to interpret the DreadPoss as saying that critters with continuous supernatural abilities must roll every 24 hours, to see if their powers work on a given day or not. By this interpretation, their Su abilities wouldn't be treated as singular effects that last indefinitely (in which case, one suppression by Reason would snuff them out forever), but as repeated discrete effects with a 24-hour duration, that are automatically re-activated each day.

By that mechanism, an incorporeal spirit would have a 2% chance of vanishing each day, only to reappear 24 hours later. A victim of mummy rot or lycanthropy would have a 2% chance of suffering no ill effects on a given day, rather than being granted a Get-Out-Of-Curse-Free card. A dread doppelganger in Lamordia would have a 2% chance of reverting to its true form for a day, but would probably regain its shapechanging ability 24 hours later (if it isn't lynched in the meantime), and so on.

That way, you aren't forced to exclude all supernatural menaces from the domain (save those spawned in laboratories) in order to utilize the "Smothering of Reason" option. Heck, it even permits the use of the "Wolves of the Sea" DreadPoss in the same campaign, which would be impossible otherwise: Rudolf and his pals would all revert to human form and freeze to death in the icy waters, if their supernatural abilities were indefinitely suppressed.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

cure wrote:None of this is to deny that with sufficient fluff and good roll playing one cannot make a character gothic and interesting. But the scientist class itself on its merits is neither and should be replaced.
So do you intend to put gothic elements into the pistoleer and the crypt raider? The courtier? The rumormonger?

There are plenty of prestige classes in RL that don't have gothic elements themselves. Not everyone has to have such things in their classes. For many characters, gothic is what happens to them, not what they are.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Post by A G Thing »

Cure Wrote
Sorry for not commenting sooner.

Does the fact that as extraordinary the tricks are not subject to disruption and don't trigger attacks of opportunity pose a game balance issue?

Beyond that, A for effort in trying to fix its unbalanced spell casting, but my problem with the class, which may not be everyone elses, bites in respect to the very existence of that spell casting.
Well the tricks are listed in the book as extraordinary and the DMG pg 290 lists that Extraordinary abilities do not provoke Attacks of Opportunity on Table 8-1. Also the class would have to add Concentration to the list but that is not infeasable to do and makes perfect sense in some respects but I imagine it is like using a weapon in some regards, it could be sundered or broken or he could drop it, also the rather unwieldy power sources are a drawback. Next is the scientific knowledge check to use the device/trick... I would for simplicities sake use the scientific knowledge check in place of the Concentration skill for such instances.

As for what bothers you I think you are just hanging yourself up on the fact that they are adapting previous rules for the effect and not making new rules. It is as you stated extrodinary! It is uneffected by most magical hinderences and hang ups! It is meant to be a guide to the more fantastic effects of science fiction and exploration not the limit or even the end...

Looking at the negative energy thing just make the undead act as constructs or turn draining effects into poison or physical draining such as tubes or such. Or perhaps make it some sort of alien influence that science was not meant to toy with animating the corpse. Unintended consequences of mutation or such are very gothic and quite appropriate! This development would boggle a rational mind and be a great way to lead to corruption.

Both Wizards and Scientists exist in Ravenloft and they have defined them fairly good. It is vastly possible with the corrupt nature of the plane that science may unintentionally tap some magical power but it is also equally possible that the dark powers are the cause of this corruption of science. If you are dissatisfied with the effects then just make some original ones using the spell creation system but science makes many effects that were once thought magic possible and I see no rules problem... Heck the spell resistance is quite magical in it's way but I see it more as the powers keeping that faith in science rewarded by convincing the scientist that such "magic" is false or parlor tricks!
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

Just used Vjorn Horstmann in my KD game last night, and it occured to me that he's statted as a wizard in 2E. Perhaps this class would be a good substitute, making Horstmann a Biologist?
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
NeoTiamat
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4119
Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA

Post by NeoTiamat »

I'd advise against it. Horstmann is scheduled to make an appearance in one of my 'projects', and so I took a whack at statting him up as an Expert/Scientist.

He had six Fingers of Death at CR 12. And this is with me trying to do it by the rules.
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

NeoTiamat wrote:I'd advise against it. Horstmann is scheduled to make an appearance in one of my 'projects', and so I took a whack at statting him up as an Expert/Scientist.

He had six Fingers of Death at CR 12. And this is with me trying to do it by the rules.
A class for Horstman here:
http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... php?t=5169

And stats for Horstman here:http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... 1&start=15

PS And not one Finger of Death ;-)
The cure for what ails you
Post Reply