4th Edition Review

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Mortavius wrote:I don't have the MM yet, so I can't comment on it, but as for metallic dragons being left out? Well, honestly, how many times have your players fought a metallic dragon? I've been playing since 2E, and I can't honestly think of a time it's happened. So while I know that their stats will be in a future book, I'm not heartbroken that I don't have them in the meantime.
Yes, that is true. But I'm also a Dragonlance fan and my next campaign is going to be there.
I was debating 4e but what's the point if I can't have knights mounted on dragons. That's something you couldn't do in 3e but can in 4e, very nicely, but there are no dragon mount stats.

I guess I just miss the days of 4e where, when you leveled, you didn't just have a choice of 4 powers, with one or two being sub-par for you character. You could pick from multiple different classes and build a truly unique character.
I don't get that "wow" feeling or the urge to design a character.

Especially when I see a free article on a new race released that gives that race more options than any race in the PHB I'm paying good money for...
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

alhoon's review part 1:

As I read the PHB I'll post my reviews. I'll rate each part that seems worthy of rating. Parts that were non-interesting or not new will get a brief review, but nothing more.
I consider 3 to be average.

Gods:
Well, they are mostly like I wanted and envisioned them in my games since the old D&D. Their true form is beyond mortal conception! They're not powerful outsiders that alter reality. They're gods. People don't pray to one god. They pray to the god they need at the time, while clerics and paladins service a certain god.
The write up is very, very good too. Short and to the point with a few bulletpoints of what the deity wants from his/her followers. And of course, those commandments are open to interpretation so holy wars and heretics are in the game.
Also, the commandments seem very reasonable. I.e the good godess of change tells: Change is inevitable, but it needs work to be for the better! Luck favors the bold. Strike back against those that steal your liberty and help others do the same.

My only slight gripes:
- There are gods that I would categorize as Lawful neutral and there's not lawful neutral alignment. :)
- Asmodeous seems to be half the old Bane. Bane seems to be the other half. IMC, Asmodeous will probably take the short way out and Bane will have his portfolio.
- Lolth and Zehir seem to be almost the same with the difference of the vermin they like. I.e Zehir will too not make an appearance IMC.

4.5 out of 5 stars so far.

Abilities, skills, etc: Nothing special that we didn't know about from the reviews. Seems solid and a good start for those not initiated. For 3rd edition veterans, it seems too easy to learn, and that's good.

Levels and powers/level:
Only two at will powers throught your career. At 20th level You have a 2 at will, 4 encounter, 4 daily and 5 utility powers. You also have 12 feats. For some martial classes it's an improvement unless you had the book of nine swords. For most spellcasters is way too low. Your cleric will have only 15 different spells. Less than even the sorcerer in 3rd.
I'm not impressed nor happy about this. Even if they release dozens of books with powers, you'll only have 15 different powers in 20th level.

Many feats though, and that's added possibilities. The abilities rise far more than in 4th edition. I.e you rise 2 abilities by 1 every four levels and all abilities by 1 when you change tier.
1.5 out of 5 stars in this regard.

Races:
Well, they seem solid. Dwarves look too much like they did in 3rd edition. Able to resist poison and having the stability feature. Humans don't have the lead as the must race anymore although they're pretty powerful as races go. You won't be ashamed to admit that you want to play a half elf anymore. :) They are a strong race.
There are some changes from the races we saw at the D&D experience characters. I also liked the short description of three different chars of that race.

Above average in general but still, I believe there's room for improvement.
3.5 out of 5 stars.

Classes: Overall, they're well written and they seem balanced. They're easy to understand. Poor selection of powers as Jester has already pointed out. Still, once you get the feeling of the class you can make your own.

Cleric: Nothing special
fighter: Seems impressive. Much work has been done to improve this class. Weapon choice is important at last.
Paladin: I didn't read him.
Ranger: I didn't read him.
Rogue: Seems to favor stealth, hit-and-run tactics and he's a capable damage dealer.
Warlock: Well... they have eldrich blast and one more at will power that gives them further bonuses. What of human warlocks? :? THey are supposed to get one more at will power. Do they get the bonus too?
The warlocks have the least customization available to them. As a class they're damage dealers with extras. I.e they deal heavy amounts of damage or they deal damage and also impair their enemies.
warlord: I didn't read him.
Wizard: By far the most customizable class. They take more dailies and utilities than anyone and free rituals. Although they're not near the 3rd lvl spellcasters in damage dealing capacity, they're nukers without equal. The fighter deals more damage to a single target. The wizard blasts and blasts again.

All in all: 3 out of 5. After Jester's review I expected the classes to be worse. For people more interested about balance than me or for the warrior types, it would be an improvement over old editions.

Epic destinies: I Didn't read them.

Skills: More or less what you would expect. Solid and well explained rules. There's a note that the DCs assume far from mundane situations. The DM is advised to ask for skill checks only in dramatic situations (I.e no acrobatics skill every time the characters want to climb a ladder). There is still the take 10 rule, but not the take 20. Cooperation works easier. Up to four other guys can help you for a +2 for each assistant that rolls over 10.
Many DCs increase if you're paragon tier or Epic tier. I hope this means that a lock in a paragon-leveled temple is more difficult to open instead of every lock in the world having a +10 to DC just because you're now a paragon rogue. That would mean that suddenly you got worse.

Feats: Simple to use and implement. Some are more useful than others obviously. They seem like the passive feats of the 3rd edition without as many prerequisites except of stats. It will be a problem for me to choose feats. There are many good feats there.
A few give another kind of power to some classes or improve class features.
Splitting feats from exploits, prayers etc was a good step IMO. As important for the game as the break up of skills/weapon proficiencies of 2nd edition to skills and feats in 3rd edition.
4 out of 5 stars.

Multiclassing: Treated as feats. You can take one feat to "dabble" in the class of your choosing. Then you take one or more feats to start exchanging powers of your class with the 2nd class. At 11th level you can choose to gain powers of your second class instead of paragon path powers or even follow the paragon path of another class.
You can multiclass only to one more class! Thankfully, no more barbarian/fighter/sorcerer/druids.

The multi classing seems limited and it doesn't offer many possibilities IMO. It's really hard to make a wizard in armor wielding a sword, since you don't get proficiency in armor. You have to pay the feats! Still, thankfully no more crazy combinations.
1.5 out of 5 stars.

Equipment: Disappointing. Many weapons do the same thing but that's understandable. However, prices for mundane equipment seem to be far more forced to low prices. A cow costs 10 gp.
Leather armor costs 25 gp. More than 2 cows! Plate armor costs 50 gp. Just twice as much as the leather armor!
Many magic items though, but not all good and no rules to make your own.
1.5 out of 5 stars

Combat: Solid well expressed rules. Easy for referance. Some believability had to be left aside for easy implementation. I don't have much more to add.
4 out of 5 stars.

Rituals: The rules are solid but simplified. About 80% of the rituals are for levels 1-10. :? Where are the rest? Some rituals (like scry) have extremely high costs and are very highlevel while others are accessible very easy. Rising your dead fellow is 8th level. Scrying on your enemy is 24th level and costs a fortune!
2 out of 5 stars, mainly for the small number of rituals available.
Last edited by alhoon on Sat Jun 07, 2008 9:36 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Post by Mortavius »

I would like to add to your review Alhoon, that although it does take a wizard 5 feats to be able to wear Plate armor, he suffers *no* penalty for wearing that armor! Arcane spell failure is a thing of the past; the wizard who spends 5 feats to wear plate gets the same effects as the fighter who spends 1 feat to wear it (yes, Fighters can't wear plate right off the bat; Paladins are the only ones who get that).

And really, if you spend the feats, you're a full wizard wearing plate mail by 8th level. So in the grand scheme, not too far along.

So it seems to be a balancing issue.

As well, in regards to the 15 powers at level 20...well, don't forget about Paragon powers, they're bonuses. As well, chances are very good that those powers will *not* be the same powers you had in previous levels; with retraining being fully integrated, I fully expect players to take abilities then trade them out later on when they outgrow their uses. So in reality, you should have more experience than with just 15 powers at level 20.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

I don't think paragon powers are bonuses. I'll check again. And by spending even two feats on armor (So you can use chain) you're not a fighter mage even if you haven't arcane spell failure. And feats are very important for a character.

To be able to have something similar to a fighter mage you need 2 feats to have chainmail armor, a weapon proficiency feat, student of the sword feat and one more multiclass feat (probably novice power) to have an encounter power of the fighter class.
That's 5 feats and you just fight with a sword in chain armor using one fighter encounter power.
Then you wait until 11th level so you can drop your paragon path powers and gain one at will power of the fighter and one more encounter power (up to 7th level).

And I checked. The table at page 29 includes paragon powers so at 20th level you have 15 powers all in all, including paragon powers. Except if you're a human or picked a feat that gives a power.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Paragon powers aren't additional, just additional choices for that level. Or rather, additional choices in place of one for that level. Don't like the paragon paths? You don't get anything those levels for leveling up. So pick a path and take it's lack-of-choice powers.
:evil:

I'm not the new multiclassing system's biggest fan.
The first multiclass feat is fine, spend it for an encounter power. Sure, it's weak encounter-power wise (normally and at-will. But after that you're down a feat for almost no benefit. Spend a feat to open up new options for powers.
Sure, you can be a rogue that can use a cool wizard encounter power. But powers are balanced, so you're just as good taking a rogue power and adding a feat on top of it.

A heavily multiclassed character has the exact same number of powers (yes, plus one encounter power) only they're down three-ish feats.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Something else came to me about this.
Mortavius wrote:I don't have the MM yet, so I can't comment on it, but as for metallic dragons being left out? Well, honestly, how many times have your players fought a metallic dragon? I've been playing since 2E, and I can't honestly think of a time it's happened. So while I know that their stats will be in a future book, I'm not heartbroken that I don't have them in the meantime.
See, part of my problem wasn't just metallic dragons. I can understand those, because there's already 5 dragons types already, with 2-3 variants of each colour.
But what about: Behir, Black Pudding, Centaur, Chaos Beast, Cloaker, Couatl, Cockatrice, Darkmantles/piercers, Dinosaurs (except ankylosaurus), dragon turtle, ethereal marauder, green slime, grey render, invisible stalker, kraken, merefolk, mimic, mohrg, nymph, pegasus, remorahz, rust monster, sea elves, shadows, sprites (pixies, nixies, etc), Will o’ wisp, and most common animals (lions, tigers, elephants, dire badgers, cat, dog, riding dog, rhino, etc) didn’t make it in although they did have bats, bears, boars, wolves, etc.

I'm paying the same price for the MM as I am for the PHB, only the former is much shorter (albeit not as short as the criminally small DMG) yet I still need to make my own monsters. And buy a second book next year. Just to get the monsters I got in the 3e MM.
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Post by Mortavius »

alhoon wrote:And feats are very important for a character.
Feats are very important, but also incredibly plentiful. You get a feat at 1st, 11th, and 21st level, in addition to one every even level.

And I don't disagree with you Alhoon, they certainly nerfed multiclassing in 4E. But, as a DM who has had players that have exploited and abused multiclassing, this doesn't bother me.
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Post by Mortavius »

Jester of the FoS wrote:But what about: Behir, Black Pudding, Centaur, Chaos Beast, Cloaker, Couatl, Cockatrice, Darkmantles/piercers, Dinosaurs (except ankylosaurus), dragon turtle, ethereal marauder, green slime, grey render, invisible stalker, kraken, merefolk, mimic, mohrg, nymph, pegasus, remorahz, rust monster, sea elves, shadows, sprites (pixies, nixies, etc), Will o’ wisp, and most common animals (lions, tigers, elephants, dire badgers, cat, dog, riding dog, rhino, etc) didn’t make it in although they did have bats, bears, boars, wolves, etc.
Okay, fair enough Jester, but as I got my MM today, what about all the new monsters they added? Blood Fiend, Phane, the Angels, the Archons, Berbalang, Evistro demon, Immolith demon, etc. And that's not counting the existing monsters that we already had, but now have variants for different levels.

I think this point actually really just comes down to personal preference. I understand where you're coming from, when you say those monsters aren't there, but from my point of view, I just won't use most of them, and if I find I need one, chances are I can use something in it's place. And you're right, I bet some of those will appear in future books, but 3E did that too. The Catoblepas was a monster in 2E, but didn't appear until like the MM2 or 3 in 3E. And there were others too.

It's a natural thing, I think. Would you want to buy an MM for 4E if all it had was monsters you had already seen, updated to the new edition? I certainly wouldn't, and I bet a lot of people would agree with me. I think it just comes down to preference, what people feel are "iconic" D&D monsters that should always appear, and what can be left for another book.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Most of the new monsters are "eh" at best. A few have neat abilities but only a couple have really fired up the imagination. They're the same, new, 'cool' monsters that filled the MM3-5. If didn't want those monsters in 3e and never bought those book (even for cheap when 4e was announced and 3e books dropped in price). New monsters are okay, but not in place of classics that have been used for 35 years.

This is kind of my problem with 4e. Monster Manuals 2-5 didn't sell well. The best way to sell more books is to cut the number of iconic, must-have monsters in the first MM and add them to MM 2 and 3.

Sure, there might be some dispute over what's iconic. Like if a chaos beat is worth having in the main book. But a pegasus? A rust monster? I think those are *slightly* more iconic than a balhannoth or a banshrae or a berbalang.

See that list above? Maybe half of those will be in MM2. As well as some new demon lords and their cultists. And likely a whole bunch of monsters from MM1 with new variants.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

About the monstrous manual, many monsters are criminaly simple. Others even seem weak compared to others. Others had traditions thrown out of the window.

Example: The lich in the MManual. It doesn't have the abilities from the DMG!
Ogres seem weaker than other 8th level brutes because they don't have any serious powers.
Only vampire minions are destroyed in sunlight.

Jester: The lycanthropes have 3 forms. Human, Hybrid and animal as explained to their text. The Hybrid and Human form are however the same stat-wise except from the bite attacks etc.
I also like their new weakness to silver. It stops their regeneration. I.e only one guy in the party needs a silver weapon.
The MManuals BTW did sell well. At least MM2 and MM3.

I agree though that WotC is keeping monsters up its sleeve for later.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Post by Mortavius »

You know what? I agree with both you Alhoon and Jester on the point that I'm sure some of those monsters will be in future MMs. But it makes perfect sense from a marketing stand-point.

Jester, you already said in your first few posts that they are a business, and they have to make money. Now, you also said that they seem to be over-doing it this time around; I don't necessarily agree with you, but I do see your point. I'm a little surprised myself that the Rust Monster wasn't in there (I can do without the Pegasus; for me that's right up there with Metallic Dragons as monsters my players never fought). But I also see all the new monsters, and new variants, and dog-gone it if it doesn't just fire up my imagination. I dunno, I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one.

Anyhow, if it hasn't already been gleaned from my posts, I'm favorably inclined towards 4E. I like the changes and decisions they have made, and my group is loving it too. *shrugs*
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

The game itself seems fine and fun, if a little high-powered. And I'm all for the release of 4e to make the company money, and the release of future books and -inevitably- editions, to also make money.

I'm against weakening the Core products and purposely diluting their quality to sell future products. I'm against making the main, best-selling product inferior to shakily prop-up a future product and make it seem less extraneous or of higher quality.

I brought this up elsewhere (WotC boards) and it was compared nicely with CDs.
Record companies have to release CDs and other music formats, and they have to re-release classic albums of big-name bands.
Imagine if they did a new, big remastered re-release of the Beatles greatest hits ever. However, it was only a 2-CD set, and it was missing Yellow Submarine and Helter Skelter and a couple others, AND it had multiple filler tracks of covers and remixes. But, don't worry Beatlemaniacs, they have a Greatest Hits Ever vol. 2 coming on in eleven months with *most* of the missing tracks and a few additional covers and remixes along with alternate copies of the tracks on Vol1 (live versions and such). But, unlike volume 1, which was in production and cleaning for two or three years, this new set is being done and set-up in less than a year, and with much less staff and quality-control folk looking over the result.
How would you feel about those CDs?
How would you feeling about spending money on all of them? Of supporting a company that did that?
User avatar
Pamela
Sorority Shadow
Sorority Shadow
Posts: 931
Joined: Tue Sep 13, 2005 3:48 am
Location: Have gun, will travel
Contact:

Post by Pamela »

A greatest hits CD is not a very good metaphor for comparison. I've always found the idea of "Greatest Hits #2" as a bit of an oxymoron. Greatest hits are also in the end just collections of favourite bits from the past.

If you must have a CD metaphor, then use the comeback CD of a big-name band. Are you still able to recognise the band when you hear it? Are they doing more than rehashing themselves and recycling old hits? Does the entire album hold together? Is it good enough that you want to listen to it again and again, saying, "They've still got what it takes!"?
His only real danger is if stupidity is contagious and lethal. In which case, we’re all dead…-Gertrude
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

Jester of the FoS wrote:
Mortavius wrote:I don't have the MM yet, so I can't comment on it, but as for metallic dragons being left out? Well, honestly, how many times have your players fought a metallic dragon? I've been playing since 2E, and I can't honestly think of a time it's happened. So while I know that their stats will be in a future book, I'm not heartbroken that I don't have them in the meantime.
Yes, that is true. But I'm also a Dragonlance fan and my next campaign is going to be there.
I was debating 4e but what's the point if I can't have knights mounted on dragons. That's something you couldn't do in 3e but can in 4e, very nicely, but there are no dragon mount stats.

I guess I just miss the days of 4e where, when you leveled, you didn't just have a choice of 4 powers, with one or two being sub-par for you character. You could pick from multiple different classes and build a truly unique character.
I don't get that "wow" feeling or the urge to design a character.

Especially when I see a free article on a new race released that gives that race more options than any race in the PHB I'm paying good money for...
Hi Jester, also a DL fan here. Moreso, at the moment, than RL fan (ok, I'm changing allegiances). And I should say I find strange you saying you can't have knights ridigin dragons in 3E. There's a Prestige Class precisely for that. Perhaps that's what you're saying, anyway, and it's a 5-level class, but there is one.

Also, do you mean you miss the days of 3e? or some previous edition?
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

Hi all,

I've also played a 4E game this saturday at a Game Day event held here. I played the same adventure referred to before by Llana (have to check) and I liked it, but it was too brief to get any real feeling.

Our group didn't have much problem with the initial hobgoblins, and I was amazed by the ease with which I could run jump to stand on a sarcophagus and attack in the same round. It seemed more than in 3E, but very similar all the same, anyway.

Then in the second main fight, we were battling an Elf wizard (we never got the hint he was a necromancer) and two animated statues (the DM didn't say they were golems, and at level 2, I don't think they should be) and 4 skeletons.

Impressions from the fight: we didn't have a wizard in the party, but we had two fighters. We lost (TPK) and part of it may have been bad strategy: the rogue simply desisted from attacking the elf after missing the first shot. But I also had many bad rolls and couldn't seriously hurt the statues.

What it seemed to me is that the elf wizard never ran out of things to do. I don't know what level he was, but he was constantly reinvigorating his skeletons, meaning that we at last destroyed 3 of them with great difficulty. This while half the party was trying to hold off the two statues. I managed to score a reliable daily power against one of them, for 3d12+5 damage, but they were around 70 or 80ph, so this is not much. Plus, they had a nasty ability to knock the opponent prone and strike again as he got up, meaning that they are too strong for one of two lone PCs that still get to be attacked by other enemies.

Healing surges are nothing much: you need the cleric to activate them. I didn't understand if that was one per round or two per encounter, but it was notably insufficient. Second wind can be used only once per encounter, again insufficient. And I really was disheartened when I used my per encounter power trying to be able to deal 2d12+5, only to miss the attack and lose that power.

So, all in all, I liked the experience because I like gaming, but I was not totally thrilled with the powers at my disposal. The only At-Will powers were cleave and a power that always dealt 3dmg even if I missed, but against statues that big, that really was not much.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Post Reply