4th Edition Review
Good point Jester, one that I was aware of, but neglected to mention above. The Orc does have the potential, of having two healing surges per battle, even if the second is does not carry the defensive bonuses of the Second Wind.
And the strength bonus instead of wisdom is good for a fighter, but it has a drawback; the Orc *may* be less likely to resist attacks on it's will. Strength doesn't mean anything when you're stunned and can't act.
alhoon:
- Fair enough, perhaps convince wasn't the correct word to use, but if you post something in a forum, people are going to respond. My response was indicating a disagreement with your proposed ideas, and I just used convince as a neutral term to illustrate that. It may have been the incorrect one.
- I stand corrected on the gnome's power; I thought you had said it was overpowered.
- I apolgise for the name mistake, but it's a standard rule in the english I was taught to capitalize the first letter of a name. I shall endevor to not make that mistake with your name again, but please realize there was not slight intended.
- And just to point out, it's "Mortavius" not "Mortavious."
And the strength bonus instead of wisdom is good for a fighter, but it has a drawback; the Orc *may* be less likely to resist attacks on it's will. Strength doesn't mean anything when you're stunned and can't act.
alhoon:
- Fair enough, perhaps convince wasn't the correct word to use, but if you post something in a forum, people are going to respond. My response was indicating a disagreement with your proposed ideas, and I just used convince as a neutral term to illustrate that. It may have been the incorrect one.
- I stand corrected on the gnome's power; I thought you had said it was overpowered.
- I apolgise for the name mistake, but it's a standard rule in the english I was taught to capitalize the first letter of a name. I shall endevor to not make that mistake with your name again, but please realize there was not slight intended.
- And just to point out, it's "Mortavius" not "Mortavious."
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
I expect people responding to my posts, that's why I make them.Mortavius wrote:alhoon:
- I apolgise for the name mistake, but it's a standard rule in the english I was taught to capitalize the first letter of a name. I shall endevor to not make that mistake with your name again, but please realize there was not slight intended.
- And just to point out, it's "Mortavius" not "Mortavious."
Example: A few months ago I was a bit against 4th edition. Hesitant.
Jester convinced me to wait and see and realize that many of my gripes were just love for the system I know.
Then again, I was excited about 4th. Now it doesn't seem to live up to my expectations but it's a nice game. I'll play it some times although for the time I prefer 3rd edition.
alhoon isn't a name.
And I apologize in turn for the error in your name. It wasn't intended either.
EDIT: On the topic of what edition to play:
To quote VAN when we were discussing how I intended to steal some things from 4th edition to 3rd. She was particularly against me house-ruling rituals in 3rd edition:
"Look, these changes you want to make, form your edition. Keep your changes if you like them in yours, and leave my edition alone."
VAN's happy with the 3rd edition as it is and doesn't want to change to the new balanced system of 4th. She wants the wizard overshadowing the fighter on damage but not having much hp. She wants the 8th lvl fighter to be able to kill every and all CR 1 creatures with one good swing. She wants the warblade powers, the fighter feats and the system she knows. As she so nicely put she wants us when playing together to keep with 3rd edition ("her" edition
I disagree with many of her points but I don't blame her. She wasn't against 4th edition from the beginning. She just didn't like what she heard about it.
Last edited by alhoon on Fri Jun 13, 2008 11:30 am, edited 2 times in total.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Ah, then you were happier than us. We also buried the bones and got the potion, which I did use (I never rolled so badly, that gave the statues lots of time to hit me instead) but the spirit still did not help us. Probably it needed some extra action, like directly attacking the elf or something. I don't know.Pamela wrote:Hey Alex!
I think the reason that the spirit helped us was because we took care of the bones in the room with the trapped sarcophagi. He also gave our party a hidden healing potion for doing so (we never did get to use it). As the cleric of Pelor, I also warned everybody not to raid the tombs. I read somewhere online that the spirit actually somehow possessed one of the statues (?!) for a round, so it seems to have been written into the game.
Pam
All in all, I liked the session very much, but that may have been because it was the first time I played with total strangers, so there was a lot of novelty for me in it too. Also, I found that gaming-wise it still looked 3E enough. We were doing most of the same reasonings we would do up til now. But I haven't seen enough to judge 4th Ed, that's for sure.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
- Ivana_Boritsi
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 192
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 5:48 pm
So far, I'm actually liking the 4th Edition rules for Ravenloft. I could see a switch quite easily.
Mainly, because it seems to me, after a few play-throughs that the sudden jump in power has been toned way back. For example, the most powerful powers at 30th level do 7d of damage to something. So no more massive Meteor Swarms that do insane damage.
So, many of the "problem" spells and effects that Ravenloft had to fix are now gone in 4e. No more Detect Alignment. No more Find the Path. No more ESP. No more campaign breaking abilities.
Also, I disagree with Jester's idea that most everyone can cast "spells". Many of the classes, like Fighter or Rogue have purely Martial Abilites, meaning that they are all physical.
Mainly, because it seems to me, after a few play-throughs that the sudden jump in power has been toned way back. For example, the most powerful powers at 30th level do 7d of damage to something. So no more massive Meteor Swarms that do insane damage.
So, many of the "problem" spells and effects that Ravenloft had to fix are now gone in 4e. No more Detect Alignment. No more Find the Path. No more ESP. No more campaign breaking abilities.
Also, I disagree with Jester's idea that most everyone can cast "spells". Many of the classes, like Fighter or Rogue have purely Martial Abilites, meaning that they are all physical.
Now I know, now I can divine. The reign of man is over, and He has come....
-Guy De Maupassant
-Guy De Maupassant
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Still with a couple of feats they can use rituals and many of their powers seem like spells to me. Not to mention the teleport abilities of the eladrin or the invisibility of the gnomes.
I agree though that many problematic spells have been dealt with in 4E. On the other hand a 30th level power dealing 7d10+magic+strength mod =7d10+10 damage is pathetic IMO. A 30th level fighter can't kill a 6th level fighter in one swing with a daily power.
I agree though that many problematic spells have been dealt with in 4E. On the other hand a 30th level power dealing 7d10+magic+strength mod =7d10+10 damage is pathetic IMO. A 30th level fighter can't kill a 6th level fighter in one swing with a daily power.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Ivana_Boritsi
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 192
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 5:48 pm
Yes, that is what's brilliant about 4e for Ravenloft, IMO! No more one-shot kills on bad guys. A small group of werewolves are dangerous at most levels.alhoon wrote:Still with a couple of feats they can use rituals and many of their powers seem like spells to me. Not to mention the teleport abilities of the eladrin or the invisibility of the gnomes.
I agree though that many problematic spells have been dealt with in 4E. On the other hand a 30th level power dealing 7d10+magic+strength mod =7d10+10 damage is pathetic IMO. A 30th level fighter can't kill a 6th level fighter in one swing with a daily power.
The teleport abilities of the Eladrin are only problematic from a prisoner standpoint. And let's face it, it's rare that PCs are put into prison. You can teleport, great. But it's only so far, and it's only once per encounter. After you've blown your wad, the zombie still come and eat you.
That's another thing - running a zombie hordes game in 3.5 was difficult because of all of the area of effect spells. Fireballs and lightning bolts mowed down hordes of zombies. Now, you can only do those things once per encounter. So after you've thrown your big boom, the hordes of baddies are still there.
Overall, because the power has been scaled back, you don't have to deal with as much "superhero" stuff in 4e, IMO.
Now I know, now I can divine. The reign of man is over, and He has come....
-Guy De Maupassant
-Guy De Maupassant
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
You also get 8 stat boosts, so a good L30 fighter should have a Strength score of 24-28.alhoon wrote:Still with a couple of feats they can use rituals and many of their powers seem like spells to me. Not to mention the teleport abilities of the eladrin or the invisibility of the gnomes.
I agree though that many problematic spells have been dealt with in 4E. On the other hand a 30th level power dealing 7d10+magic+strength mod =7d10+10 damage is pathetic IMO. A 30th level fighter can't kill a 6th level fighter in one swing with a daily power.
So, really, it'd 7d10+6+8 or 21-84 damage. And they're pretty much guaranteed to have Power Attack, raising the damage to 7d10+6+8+9 (with a 2-hander) for a range of 30-93.
A good critical would more than quarter an Efreet Karadjin's hit points (okay, more since any good L30 weapon would do more on a crit). Sure, that's only a L28 monster, but anything above that is only Elite or Solo.
Yes, it's not as much as 3e. But that's comparing apples and pears (not quite as different as oranges but still different things).
You still need line of sight for teleport powers.Ivana_Boritsi wrote:The teleport abilities of the Eladrin are only problematic from a prisoner standpoint. And let's face it, it's rare that PCs are put into prison. You can teleport, great. But it's only so far, and it's only once per encounter. After you've blown your wad, the zombie still come and eat you.
So a bag over their head and they're trapped. And a cell without windows and they're stuck.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Well starting with 20 strength is rare even for DBorn or orcs. Most Fighters would start with 16-17Jester of the FoS wrote: You also get 8 stat boosts, so a good L30 fighter should have a Strength score of 24-28.
And dealing 7d10+8(str)+6(weap)+3(PA) once per day is a turn down for me.
You're the top of the top. Archdevils and demon princes soil their pants thinking you may visit. And... once per day you can deal average 55 damage! OK probably you have something else (feats etc) and you deal about 60 damage on average.
Cool! With your daily power you, the world shaker can kill an orc berseker with one hit! The second orc berseker needs probably 2 hits.
Crits are on 20. In 3rd you could have a feat that you insta-critted once per encounter. Or a keen falchion taking the threat down to 15. The confirm critical feat added a +4 to the confirm roll. And you had 4 attacks.
Enter the Warblade:
move and double full attack, with +2 once per encounter. Move and attack with +100 damage.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
But you can do it more than once a day at level 30.
You can do something close to that 4 times per day, plus extra abilities. At level 30 you should have level 29, 25, 20, and 19 daily attack powers. Plus, each fight you can unload with at *least* 4 encounter powers (L27, 23, 17 and 13).
Now a level 30 fighter-kensai with the demigod destiny (+2 to two stats) who started out with 16 strength now has Str26. He never runs out of encounter powers thanks to his L30 feature. We'll give him a falchion because I like them.
He starts with his Belt of Titan Strength, amping up his damage then attacks with No Mercy, his L29 attack. 14d4+8(str)+6(weap)+9(PA)+4(kensai)+10(item). Average of 72 damage. But with his Gauntlets of Destruction all 1s are re-rolled, which probably bumps the average damage up abit. But I'm too lazy to figure that out.
Possibly activating his destiny daily which gives him regeneration 26 for the rest of the encounter.
Oh, and action point.
So Supremacy of Steel follows, forcing it to only make basic attack and doing an extra 12d4+8+6+9+4+10. Average of 67 damage. That's a total of 139 damage in a single round without a critical hit.
But with Heavy Blade master, a epic feat, he crits on a 19-20, and, on a critical, he deals an additional +1d10 (devastating critical paragon feat) +1d12 (vorpal weapon). To say nothing of the vorpal's damage re-roll ability.
Second round, the enemy likely hit him with a basic attack (all it could do after Supremacy of Steel).
He still has all his encounter powers and two dailies. So we'll go with an encounter. Indomitable Battle Strike, dealing 8d4+8+6+9+4. But, wait. He'll aslo activate his sword's daily power as a free action, changing the damage to 3d12+8d4+8+6+9+4 with an average of 66 damage.
Third round. Reaving Strike 10d4+8+6+9+4. For an average of 52.
Total damage? 260. Exactly what is needed to drop a L28 Efreet Karadjin. Not enough to bloody the elite L29 godforged colossus (70 points or so away), but there'd be a second character pounding on that.
How much damage would Fighter X have taken in three rounds against an efreet?
An average of 25/round plus ongoing for a possible total of 120.
Oh, except in the first round he activated his regeneration 26. So he'd only have taken the full first round's worth of damage. So his total damage taken would be around 68. Even with a Con of 12 a fighter would have 201 or so hit points, so he'd never even have been bloodied.
You can do something close to that 4 times per day, plus extra abilities. At level 30 you should have level 29, 25, 20, and 19 daily attack powers. Plus, each fight you can unload with at *least* 4 encounter powers (L27, 23, 17 and 13).
Now a level 30 fighter-kensai with the demigod destiny (+2 to two stats) who started out with 16 strength now has Str26. He never runs out of encounter powers thanks to his L30 feature. We'll give him a falchion because I like them.
He starts with his Belt of Titan Strength, amping up his damage then attacks with No Mercy, his L29 attack. 14d4+8(str)+6(weap)+9(PA)+4(kensai)+10(item). Average of 72 damage. But with his Gauntlets of Destruction all 1s are re-rolled, which probably bumps the average damage up abit. But I'm too lazy to figure that out.
Possibly activating his destiny daily which gives him regeneration 26 for the rest of the encounter.
Oh, and action point.
So Supremacy of Steel follows, forcing it to only make basic attack and doing an extra 12d4+8+6+9+4+10. Average of 67 damage. That's a total of 139 damage in a single round without a critical hit.
But with Heavy Blade master, a epic feat, he crits on a 19-20, and, on a critical, he deals an additional +1d10 (devastating critical paragon feat) +1d12 (vorpal weapon). To say nothing of the vorpal's damage re-roll ability.
Second round, the enemy likely hit him with a basic attack (all it could do after Supremacy of Steel).
He still has all his encounter powers and two dailies. So we'll go with an encounter. Indomitable Battle Strike, dealing 8d4+8+6+9+4. But, wait. He'll aslo activate his sword's daily power as a free action, changing the damage to 3d12+8d4+8+6+9+4 with an average of 66 damage.
Third round. Reaving Strike 10d4+8+6+9+4. For an average of 52.
Total damage? 260. Exactly what is needed to drop a L28 Efreet Karadjin. Not enough to bloody the elite L29 godforged colossus (70 points or so away), but there'd be a second character pounding on that.
How much damage would Fighter X have taken in three rounds against an efreet?
An average of 25/round plus ongoing for a possible total of 120.
Oh, except in the first round he activated his regeneration 26. So he'd only have taken the full first round's worth of damage. So his total damage taken would be around 68. Even with a Con of 12 a fighter would have 201 or so hit points, so he'd never even have been bloodied.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Now, this sounds interesting.
Still too dailies in a same encounter are a waste IMO.
I think I'll update to a 30th level fighter my fighter thread and tell you what I think on these levels.
Still my point that he needs a daily to cleave an orc berseker with one hit still stands unanswered. Yet, I agree that he can do some epic things.
I think I'll update to a 30th level fighter my fighter thread and tell you what I think on these levels.
Still my point that he needs a daily to cleave an orc berseker with one hit still stands unanswered. Yet, I agree that he can do some epic things.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Well, a basic 3e would would get his ass kicked. But a broken ToB:Bo9S 'fighter' would slaughter a 4e fighter because their damage is on par with a wizards. Too bad they also have more hitpoints, AC and BAB, so they're really a wizard plus. And a broken 3e fighter would also win (2-handed power attack with a lance while charging: 2d8+100dmg/ attack).
See, thing BIG difference is, the damage may *seem* less impressive, but the amount of damage you can do and the amount of damage you need to do are much closer. There's less disconnect. Wizards may be less but they do it to more targets. Rogues may be more but only to single targets and they're at greater risk of being his and being hurt. Figher's do the middle but have better hp and AC so they can stand up front.
And you use Dailies when you need too.
That's advice that's not in the DMG but should be. If you give them a chance to rest before the Big Bad, they're going to unleash all their Dailies at once and obliterate it. You always need a couple encounters between the BBEG, where PCs can waste a Daily or have to choose between finishing them quickly or having fewer resources for the end boss.
See, thing BIG difference is, the damage may *seem* less impressive, but the amount of damage you can do and the amount of damage you need to do are much closer. There's less disconnect. Wizards may be less but they do it to more targets. Rogues may be more but only to single targets and they're at greater risk of being his and being hurt. Figher's do the middle but have better hp and AC so they can stand up front.
And you use Dailies when you need too.
That's advice that's not in the DMG but should be. If you give them a chance to rest before the Big Bad, they're going to unleash all their Dailies at once and obliterate it. You always need a couple encounters between the BBEG, where PCs can waste a Daily or have to choose between finishing them quickly or having fewer resources for the end boss.
- WolfKook
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 573
- Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Bogotá, Colombia
- Contact:
Well, my general impressions from what I've heard (I haven't put my hands on any 4E books, so I may be wrong, and am ready to be corrected if need be):
Races: I like the idea of making members of the same class but different races different. The race powers are also interesting, though some of them (The fey step, for example) seem a little over-the-top for my tastes (I could also see the fey step transforming into mist step in RL). The race muster, on the other hand, is not really satisfying for me: I mean, I get the charm of playing a half-demon, a half-dragon or a half-fey but, in terms of culture and background, the terms "Tiefling" and "Eladrin" are not as evocative as, say, "Gnome".
Classes: Making the characters have something to do every round is a great improvement over the previous versions of the game, but I think it's a little overdone. Fighters, for example, already had something to do every round: Their "at-will power" was to swing weapons around. Giving them another at-will power means they have to choose between the cooler, and more effective power, and swinging their sword. As Jester pointed out, I would prefer to use the power 99% of the time.
Also, even though I hated vancian magic as much as almost everyone else, the concept of resource management was interesting for me, cause it made strategy matter more than it seems to matter with 4E. I know there are per-encounter powers and per-day powers, but with them, the question has shifted from "what" spells to use to "when" to use them.
Finally, the lack of real options -which Jester has already referred to -is a let down, especially after 3E and all the publicity behind 4E. I guess people interested in 4E will have to wait till accesories came out to get real options for at-will, per-encounter and daily powers, to have real creative options for their characters. I didn't like all the multiclassing from 3E, but as alhoon pointed out, it allowed to develop a specific character concept, and the idea of prestige classes was great as a mechanical analogy to earning a title, or acceptance in a special elite group. Again, paragon paths and epic destinies seem to lack evocative "umph" for me.
Skills: I know they had to cut the list down, to prevent conceptual problems -Move Silently and Hide in Shadows, Search and Spot -, and to remove low-profile skills -Like Forgery or Use Rope -, but it seems they cut down the list A LOT, and that they focused mostly on combat skills. I like the idea of skill challenges, but from what I've read, it would seem that they would work no matter what skills you use. I hope I'm wrong.
Alignment: For me, it became more difficult to explain. Before, I would tell my players that their characters could be Good/Neutral/Evil, and explain them the Lawful/Neutral/Chaotic axis. After that, the alignment combinations would come almost naturally. With 4E, I will have to explain the 5 choices one by one, and the definition would not be so trivial.
Combat: I don't understand why it's more fluid than it was in 3E (If someone could explain that to me, I'd be most grateful), but I welcome the change. The sorting of the maneuvers in alphabetical order seems to be a big plus.
Magic and Spells: I appreciate the division between spells and rituals, and I like that rituals could be performed by almost anybody, provided they have the right feats (The "wizard" concept seems diminished by this, though). I would like rituals to be more interesting, with strange components besides gp, and wizards to have more spell options, but -as alhoon said -I can do that myself.
Races: I like the idea of making members of the same class but different races different. The race powers are also interesting, though some of them (The fey step, for example) seem a little over-the-top for my tastes (I could also see the fey step transforming into mist step in RL). The race muster, on the other hand, is not really satisfying for me: I mean, I get the charm of playing a half-demon, a half-dragon or a half-fey but, in terms of culture and background, the terms "Tiefling" and "Eladrin" are not as evocative as, say, "Gnome".
Classes: Making the characters have something to do every round is a great improvement over the previous versions of the game, but I think it's a little overdone. Fighters, for example, already had something to do every round: Their "at-will power" was to swing weapons around. Giving them another at-will power means they have to choose between the cooler, and more effective power, and swinging their sword. As Jester pointed out, I would prefer to use the power 99% of the time.
Also, even though I hated vancian magic as much as almost everyone else, the concept of resource management was interesting for me, cause it made strategy matter more than it seems to matter with 4E. I know there are per-encounter powers and per-day powers, but with them, the question has shifted from "what" spells to use to "when" to use them.
Finally, the lack of real options -which Jester has already referred to -is a let down, especially after 3E and all the publicity behind 4E. I guess people interested in 4E will have to wait till accesories came out to get real options for at-will, per-encounter and daily powers, to have real creative options for their characters. I didn't like all the multiclassing from 3E, but as alhoon pointed out, it allowed to develop a specific character concept, and the idea of prestige classes was great as a mechanical analogy to earning a title, or acceptance in a special elite group. Again, paragon paths and epic destinies seem to lack evocative "umph" for me.
Skills: I know they had to cut the list down, to prevent conceptual problems -Move Silently and Hide in Shadows, Search and Spot -, and to remove low-profile skills -Like Forgery or Use Rope -, but it seems they cut down the list A LOT, and that they focused mostly on combat skills. I like the idea of skill challenges, but from what I've read, it would seem that they would work no matter what skills you use. I hope I'm wrong.
Alignment: For me, it became more difficult to explain. Before, I would tell my players that their characters could be Good/Neutral/Evil, and explain them the Lawful/Neutral/Chaotic axis. After that, the alignment combinations would come almost naturally. With 4E, I will have to explain the 5 choices one by one, and the definition would not be so trivial.
Combat: I don't understand why it's more fluid than it was in 3E (If someone could explain that to me, I'd be most grateful), but I welcome the change. The sorting of the maneuvers in alphabetical order seems to be a big plus.
Magic and Spells: I appreciate the division between spells and rituals, and I like that rituals could be performed by almost anybody, provided they have the right feats (The "wizard" concept seems diminished by this, though). I would like rituals to be more interesting, with strange components besides gp, and wizards to have more spell options, but -as alhoon said -I can do that myself.
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
William Blake
-
AlltheMyriadWays
- Conspirator

- Posts: 7
- Joined: Sat May 26, 2007 3:28 am
Skills with Non-Combat uses:WolfKook wrote:Skills: ...but it seems they cut down the list A LOT, and that they focused mostly on combat skills.
Acrobatics
Arcana
Athletics
Bluff
Diplomacy
Dungeoneering
Endurance
Heal
History
Insight
Intimidate
Nature
Perception
Religion
Stealth
Streetwise
Thievery
Knowledge Skills
Every single skill can be used outside of combat.
This is likewise incorrect. You set what skill checks are required, and what their DCs are quite specifically. If a player tries a skill that you haven't got on the list of possibilities, the DMG recommends you push the player for an explanation. If the player has a good idea that makes sense (and that you just didn't think of), let them roll it. Otherwise, keep it to the skills that you prepared checks for.I like the idea of skill challenges, but from what I've read, it would seem that they would work no matter what skills you use. I hope I'm wrong.
Some skill challenges will be more open ended, of course, and some more restricted as far as what is allowed.
