alhoon wrote:
So, a smart fighter is a "broken" one?
A fighter that uses Tome of Battle is not broken, but half-4th edition already. Tome of Battle was their test of 4e mechanics.
Lances are there for a reason. Do you prefer the "oops. No mounted combat" of 4th edition?
There is mounted combat. There is a feat in PHB, rules in DMG and mounts in Monster Manual, with special effects. There are just fewer rules because it is simpler to work out.
And, frankly, abuses like that let to the bland simplicity of 4e where every fighter can do pretty much the same thing with only the tiniest of variation.
The choice between flail and greatsword is NOT the tiniest of variation. It now has much greater impact in the game play.
For the other options you suggested:
1) mounted knight. I don't see why this is not possible under 4e rules.
2) range weapons. Yes you have to choose ranger for that. You cannot be a "defender" and an archer at the same time. But you can still play an interesting archer, so I don't see the problem
3) two weapons. As point 2
4) finesse fighter. You absolutely need multiclassing with rogue (with either one as the base class) but it's very interesting (the light blade powers, together with a few of the rogue powers, and sneak attack once per encounter, yam).
5) unarmed. THIS is a real example of what you want to say. There is no decent unarmed fighting yet, and we have to wait for at least the Martial Handbook near the end of the year. I agree that 4e at the moment is not ready to switch to it.
Personally, I am playtesting the 7thSea conversions, and I am very happy, but we will need at least one more month to get out something decent.
I am planning to end my Eberron campaign around August, and start preparing an FR/Ravenloft/7thSea one (in that order. It's more like a Masque over Toril, with guns and sea powers near the coast) - but we cannot start before late September (the Player's Guide comes out early September), and still some players will switch characters after a few months, when PHII will come out.
As for DDI, I am not at all sure about your estimation Jester. We do not live in a period 7 years before.
1) There is no full text SRD. It's just an index. So the full rule database of DDI is AWESOME, particularly if you play by distance (I am playing through MSN for years).
2) More and more people use tools like MapTools etc. The real issue about DDI here is whether people would switch to something that demands payment. My answer is yes, if they have already switched for other reasons: If the DM and one player have switched to have the article content, Dragon, Dungeon and rules database, they MIGHT convince the other players to pay for the subscription. Or not. IMO, WotC will soon be forced to allow for something more than guest passes: at least one "free player" per DM.
In the end, I think DDI will not be *necessary*, as nor Dragon, nor Dungeon nor the SRD were *necessary*, but considering the fact that no campaign setting will receive ongoing support in paper books (but it will be supported by Dragon and Dungeon), there will be no full-text SRD, and some of the previously for-free content in WotC site will be now in DDI, the need to use DDI will be far more intense than in the past. I can see 20% of hardcore gamers paying the subscription by 2010.