Jester of the FoS wrote:I'd rule that large and huge creatures ...
And that Jester is a house rule. I'd use the Strength chart from 3rd edition probably. Many people will find different formulas.
Gotten once said that the 2nd edition was the golden age of house rules. It seems that we get in the silver age of house rules.
NOTE: On the plus side, the DMG many people accused of being short, does a
very good job with the house rules. I admit it gives poor cover on other matters and a pathetic report on the other planes, but in the house rules it rocks.
I have playtested 4th with friends. It seems obvious now:
4th edition is more about gaming and less about realism. Few rules many exceptions.
Realism goes out of the window, house rules are not just needed... they're
mandatory so they're
codified in the DMG making the decision to use house rules so much easier for bookish types that are reluctant to deviate from the norm.
Also house rules are very easy to implement.
Example:
Player: "I charge and kick the ogre's legs as he stands over the stairs. As you remember we have greased the stairs. At the bottom we put broken glass, set wooden spikes and managed to bring the 4-5 poisonous spiders in the area."
3rd edition that would be a hell to calculate. Bull rush, AoOpp, falling damage, piercing damage, attacks by the tiny spiders, saves etc. Of course, the DM wouldn't go through that all and decide on the effects and the damage. It would take some guessing and the PCs may not be happy about the results. Also 90% this attack would do less damage than a full attack or a spell.
4th edition: Strength vs Ogre's reflex defence, +2 for charge.
Assuming the attack hits: The ogre gets a saving throw.
Ogre fails the save: Checking the character's level, let's assume 8 like the ogre's. Page 42: 2d8+5 damage and the ogre is prone. Also it takes 5 ongoing poison damage (save ends) from the spiders.
Ogre succeeds the save. 1d8+5 damage, not prone, no poison damage.
Extras: Greased stairs? -2 to the ogre's saves.
That's it. Two rolls and then damage.
Less than 40 secs of thinking and looking in the DMG. (I have page 42 marked for a reason).
Problems: A 18th level character pulling the same trick would do 3d8+7 damage. Is it realistic that the same push, the same spikes, the same spiders etc would do more damage because the guy that sacrificed the standard action was 10 levels higher?
NO!
Is it fair? Yeap. The damage is on par with the encounter powers of these levels (in fact a bit lower) but above at will attacks.
And let's admit it, setting a trap like that or kicking an ogre in a brazier of fire, or hitting the large chandelier over it to drop on it's head is
more fun.
And in 4th edition, the DM doesn't have to dread if the PCs get creative.
The above chandelier attack would be:
- dex attack vs AC 7-8 (could and should be ignored), damage of the basic attack against the cord or something that holds the chandelier (about 4-5 hp, usually can be ignored). This whole step could be omitted.
- Character's dex attack vs ogre's reflex and would deal 1d8+5 to 2d6+5 damage. It would also make the area bellow the chandelier difficult terrain.
Balance and ease above realism.