Hey there, d20 rules experts, I need some help. I came up with a unique weapon special ability for my campaign, and while I've got the flavor down, the crunch is giving me headaches.
ELVISH WHIPVINE
This whip, the treasured weapon of the Darkonian elves, resembles a rustic whip dagger (Sword and Fist), leather entwined around twisted barbs and glass shards. But, the leather of the whip is actually wrapped around a vine of ivy that only grows on the sacred tree of the Nevuchar shrine. The elves soak the whips in water once a week to keep the magic of the vine from going dormant. Some even soak it in a weak tea, broth or even watered-down wine, to keep the spirits of the woods happy.
When the whip is well-watered, tiny buds sprout from between the woven strands of leather. When the whip is used in combat, the buds extend into tiny grasping roots that tear at the target (+2 enhancement bonus).
...
OK, so far so good. Now, here's the tough part:
The whip also has the weapon special ability of "Infusion" which I made up, allowing it to deliver liquids to the target on a successful strike. (Presumably, Infusion could be added to any magic weapon, not just these whipvines.) The idea is, you soak the whip in holy water, and it's extra good against undead. You soak it in wolfsbane broth and it's extra good against werewolves. You soak it in poison, and it's poisonous. You soak it in alchemist's fire, and it makes people flammable. You soak it in a potion of some sort, and the target gets the potion effects. Etc. (The idea here was to make an interesting weapon for my Herbalist PC to put her skills to use with.)
Now, I need some rules for this effect that will make it useful, but balanced, and I'd like to keep the Infusion ability at the price of a +1 bonus. So the baseline for comparison is Flaming, which gives +1d6 damage all the time. (Fire resistant creatures excepted) Since Flaming works nearly all the time for free, and Infusion costs some money in the form of liquids, I believe it's safe to make Infusion a little bit better than +1d6.
The open questions are:
1) How long should it take to infuse? The realistic answer is overnight. But is 1 std. action or 1 full round the more interesting answer for game purposes? Rarely do you know what you will fight later that day. It would be nice to be able to change it on the fly.
2) What does the infusion do differently than just throwing the stuff on them? Is it merely just a delivery system that allows you to make a single attack and do both weapon and liquid damage? Or it it more a sustained release that imbues that effect for an extended time? (i.e. Holy water's the baseline. If you soak in 1 25gp flask, does it do +2d4 damage vs. undead and then use up the dose? Or does it do +2d4 vs. undead all day (similar to flaming, but more damage)) If the liquid does get expended, does a miss expend it? Can you control the release and expend it when you choose? (To avoid wasting holy water on a golem, for example.) How many charges can be built up? How long do they last if not discharged?
3) Should it work at all with potions? What about herbs from the Gazetteers like Hermitshawl Elixir (essentially a sleeping potion)?
4) Anything else I'm missing?
I'm sure something workable can be hashed out, but I'm at a loss to do so fairly. Help!
Rules Gurus: Unique Magic Item Help
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Rules Gurus: Unique Magic Item Help
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
I finally got some time to think about this some more. I incorporated some ideas from people at ENworld and gleemax. I went with somewhat of a 4E-ish approach, sacrificing a bit of believability for ease of use and fun factor. Please feel free to critique, and tell me what enhancement bonus you think this would be priced as. (I'm aiming for +1, but I think it might border on +2).
Here's what I've come up with:
The whip can hold five flasks worth of liquid, on top of the plain water needed to keep it from going dormant.
Each flask of liquid takes up a "slot" in the whip. The slot stays full until expended. There are two ways to fill a slot.
1) Overnight Soak
Time to fill: 4 hours
How often you can fill this way: 1/day
Benefit: When activated, any creature hit by the whip that would be damaged by the liquid takes +1d4 damage.
Time to activate: 1 swift action
Duration: 1 day. (At the end of the duration, the slot is empty.)
{this isn't quite as good as "flaming" in damage or cost to maintain, but that should be made up for by the overall versatility of the item compared to flaming}
2) Quick Soak
Time to fill: 1 standard action
How often you can fill this way: 1/round
Benefit: When activated, the next creature hit by the whip is covered with the liquid, which seeps into the whip wounds. If the creature would be damaged by the liquid, it takes the full damage of the liquid, in addition to the whip damage.
Time to activate or deactivate: 1 swift action
Duration: until the next time you hit with the whip or deactivate. (On a hit, the slot becomes empty, on deactivation, it stays full.)
{this is better than simply throwing the liquid as your standard action, since it's not expended on a miss}
One overnight soak per week in plain water will keep it from going dormant (I.e. losing the +2 enhancement bonus). During that night, none of the "slots" can be filled at the same time. You can deliberately empty a slot and collect the liquid in a bowl or similar device as a full-round action.
Special liquids:
- Potions: All potions can be loaded with the Quick Soak method. (Overnight soak dilutes the magic too much over time to be effective) {note that you can always take a
-4 to hit in order to deal non-lethal (subdual) damage instead of lethal damage with a melee weapon. Although the whip is technically a ranged weapon in 3.0, non-bladed whips deal non-lethal damage anyway, and 3.5 whips are melee weapons, so I'll allow it on the whipvine. This would let you whip a friend to give them a potion without hurting them too much}
- Lycanthrope chemical banes: (e.g. wolfsbane solution for werewolves, skullcap solution for werebats, etc.) although these are usually only dangerous to werebeasts when ingested, when used with the Quick Soak method, they work as though ingested, but at half damage (Fort DC20, initial 1d3 Con, Secondary 1d6 Con). When used with an overnight soak, they do the normal +1d4 damage.
- Herbal infusions: same as potions
- Oil: Quick Soaked oil will spread on the target, but requires a spark of some kind to light.
- Acid: acid will hurt the whip. don't use it.
- Poison: injected poisons work as normal. ingested poisons work at half damage.
- anything weird: as a rule of thumb, if a creature has some sort of aversion to a particular liquid, it will work for Overnight Soak's +1d4, and will do 2d4 damage on a Quick Soak. (same as holy water would do to undead)
While you can fill multiple slots with the same liquid, multiple activations of the same liquid do not stack. If you have an Overnight Soak active, and then do a quick soak of the same liquid, the Quick Soak will override the Overnight Soak for the single attack in which it hits.
Here's what I've come up with:
The whip can hold five flasks worth of liquid, on top of the plain water needed to keep it from going dormant.
Each flask of liquid takes up a "slot" in the whip. The slot stays full until expended. There are two ways to fill a slot.
1) Overnight Soak
Time to fill: 4 hours
How often you can fill this way: 1/day
Benefit: When activated, any creature hit by the whip that would be damaged by the liquid takes +1d4 damage.
Time to activate: 1 swift action
Duration: 1 day. (At the end of the duration, the slot is empty.)
{this isn't quite as good as "flaming" in damage or cost to maintain, but that should be made up for by the overall versatility of the item compared to flaming}
2) Quick Soak
Time to fill: 1 standard action
How often you can fill this way: 1/round
Benefit: When activated, the next creature hit by the whip is covered with the liquid, which seeps into the whip wounds. If the creature would be damaged by the liquid, it takes the full damage of the liquid, in addition to the whip damage.
Time to activate or deactivate: 1 swift action
Duration: until the next time you hit with the whip or deactivate. (On a hit, the slot becomes empty, on deactivation, it stays full.)
{this is better than simply throwing the liquid as your standard action, since it's not expended on a miss}
One overnight soak per week in plain water will keep it from going dormant (I.e. losing the +2 enhancement bonus). During that night, none of the "slots" can be filled at the same time. You can deliberately empty a slot and collect the liquid in a bowl or similar device as a full-round action.
Special liquids:
- Potions: All potions can be loaded with the Quick Soak method. (Overnight soak dilutes the magic too much over time to be effective) {note that you can always take a
-4 to hit in order to deal non-lethal (subdual) damage instead of lethal damage with a melee weapon. Although the whip is technically a ranged weapon in 3.0, non-bladed whips deal non-lethal damage anyway, and 3.5 whips are melee weapons, so I'll allow it on the whipvine. This would let you whip a friend to give them a potion without hurting them too much}
- Lycanthrope chemical banes: (e.g. wolfsbane solution for werewolves, skullcap solution for werebats, etc.) although these are usually only dangerous to werebeasts when ingested, when used with the Quick Soak method, they work as though ingested, but at half damage (Fort DC20, initial 1d3 Con, Secondary 1d6 Con). When used with an overnight soak, they do the normal +1d4 damage.
- Herbal infusions: same as potions
- Oil: Quick Soaked oil will spread on the target, but requires a spark of some kind to light.
- Acid: acid will hurt the whip. don't use it.
- Poison: injected poisons work as normal. ingested poisons work at half damage.
- anything weird: as a rule of thumb, if a creature has some sort of aversion to a particular liquid, it will work for Overnight Soak's +1d4, and will do 2d4 damage on a Quick Soak. (same as holy water would do to undead)
While you can fill multiple slots with the same liquid, multiple activations of the same liquid do not stack. If you have an Overnight Soak active, and then do a quick soak of the same liquid, the Quick Soak will override the Overnight Soak for the single attack in which it hits.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Not bad, I'd say. It's a little complicated but much less than Evard's Black Tentacles
.
I'd remove the potions use; basically you're allowing to make an attack that inflicts normal damage and also carries a 3rd-level touch spell (vampiric touch comes in mind), and that's not as weak as it seems, also because I'm not sure you want a magic item that makes you check every spell up to 3rd level to see if they could be imbalanced if used this way...
Tha soulknife needs 8 hours to change her mindblade's effect; the overnight soak could take 8 hours in a similar way. After all it's overnight, and nights don't usually last 4 hours
Also I wouldn't make it work for ingested poisons (and generally ingested things), only injected and combat; ingested should find a way to you stomach, not just a wound, and they tend to be quite potent, some even at half effect (like paralysis and unconsciousness ones)
I'd remove the potions use; basically you're allowing to make an attack that inflicts normal damage and also carries a 3rd-level touch spell (vampiric touch comes in mind), and that's not as weak as it seems, also because I'm not sure you want a magic item that makes you check every spell up to 3rd level to see if they could be imbalanced if used this way...
Tha soulknife needs 8 hours to change her mindblade's effect; the overnight soak could take 8 hours in a similar way. After all it's overnight, and nights don't usually last 4 hours
Also I wouldn't make it work for ingested poisons (and generally ingested things), only injected and combat; ingested should find a way to you stomach, not just a wound, and they tend to be quite potent, some even at half effect (like paralysis and unconsciousness ones)
Coltiviamo per tutti un rancore
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
-
Nikolas of the Mists
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 183
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm
Honestly its a lot of work (and mechanics) for a +1 enh bonus value.
If you were to incorporate some of the changes I mention below I would increase it to +2.
+1d6 dmg for the "soaked" dmg type like fire for alch fire, radiant (or creatures weak to holy water in 3.5) for holy water, etc, etc.
The storing thing is cool, but a kick in the nads with mechanics. You might consider the whip just keeping that same damage type (or soak)until it is bathed in another substance. This would allow for overnight soaks and the added versatility of quick soaks.
4E has spoiled me. I am to the point where if a mechanical effect takes longer than a paragraph it better be something damn important.
If you were to incorporate some of the changes I mention below I would increase it to +2.
+1d6 dmg for the "soaked" dmg type like fire for alch fire, radiant (or creatures weak to holy water in 3.5) for holy water, etc, etc.
The storing thing is cool, but a kick in the nads with mechanics. You might consider the whip just keeping that same damage type (or soak)until it is bathed in another substance. This would allow for overnight soaks and the added versatility of quick soaks.
4E has spoiled me. I am to the point where if a mechanical effect takes longer than a paragraph it better be something damn important.
"I wouldn't worry too much about the Vistana with the pistols --
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Thanks for the feedback, folks.
But I guess I can just hand wave that and say a soak can be resumed, with perhaps a bit of extra time (similar to interrupted sleep for a spellcaster.)

You may have a point there. In my campaign, it wouldn't be too much of a problem, since we don't have a potion brewer in the party, and the PC most likely to start is a bard, so the worst spells wouldn't be on her list. And you don't find many people brewing potions that harm the imbiber. I could just say it only works on beneficial potions, but maybe it's not worth bothering.Sorti wrote:I'd remove the potions use; basically you're allowing to make an attack that inflicts normal damage and also carries a 3rd-level touch spell (vampiric touch comes in mind), and that's not as weak as it seems
Yeah, I said 4 mainly to avoid having to deal with what happens to an interrupted soak, since the middle of the night is a prime time for battles.Tha soulknife needs 8 hours to change her mindblade's effect; the overnight soak could take 8 hours in a similar way. After all it's overnight, and nights don't usually last 4 hours
OK, I added that mainly because I really wanted Lycanthrope chemical banes to work, but I guess I can just have them fall back on the "anything weird" rule. Also, part of the point was for my herbalist PC to have an outlet for all the cool "flora" sidebars in the Gazetteers, many of which are ingested. Again, poison isn't going to be too bad, since the user of this whip IMC won't be using (non-herbal) poison. But maybe instead of halving the damage, I can drop the DC? Perhaps by 5?Also I wouldn't make it work for ingested poisons (and generally ingested things), only injected and combat; ingested should find a way to you stomach, not just a wound, and they tend to be quite potent, some even at half effect (like paralysis and unconsciousness ones)
Granted, but that doesn't really bother me. Yes, i'm all for simplification in it's place, but I don't think everything must be simple to be good. I think that the bonus value should be based on power, not complication. And I kind of like the neat little min-game this particular complication creates.Nikolas of the Mists wrote:Honestly its a lot of work (and mechanics) for a +1 enh bonus value.
I was trying to create a bit of a trade-off between overnight and quick. Honestly, the quick soak is a bit of a concession to playability. I originally envisioned only overnight soaks, but I fear that would lead to always soaking it in holy water, since the odds are good you'll meet undead more than anything else.The storing thing is cool, but a kick in the nads with mechanics. You might consider the whip just keeping that same damage type (or soak)until it is bathed in another substance. This would allow for overnight soaks and the added versatility of quick soaks.
Now, even I have my limits when it comes to complication. I'm not going to actively encourage my players to make me puzzle through 3.x's grapple rules.HuManBing wrote:Maybe you could add a grapple mechanic to it? If the whip holder wins a grapple, he can deliver the liquid and whatever effect that entails.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Latest version incorporating the feedback (changes underlined in bold):
The whip can hold five flasks worth of liquid, on top of the plain water needed to keep it from going dormant.
Each flask of liquid takes up a "slot" in the whip. The slot stays full until expended. There are two ways to fill a slot.
1) Overnight Soak
Time to fill: 8 hours (Interrupted soaks follow the same rules as interrupted spellcaster rest)
How often you can fill this way: 1/day
Benefit: When activated, any creature hit by the whip that would be damaged by the liquid takes +1d4 damage.
Time to activate: 1 swift action
Duration: 1 day. (At the end of the duration, the slot is empty.)
{this isn't quite as good as "flaming" in damage or cost to maintain, but that should be made up for by the overall versatility of the item compared to flaming}
2) Quick Soak
Time to fill: 1 standard action
How often you can fill this way: 1/round
Benefit: When activated, the next creature hit by the whip is covered with the liquid, which seeps into the whip wounds. If the creature would be damaged by the liquid, it takes the full damage of the liquid, in addition to the whip damage.
Time to activate or deactivate: 1 swift action
Duration: until the next time you hit with the whip or deactivate. (On a hit, the slot becomes empty, on deactivation, it stays full.)
{this is better than simply throwing the liquid as your standard action, since it's not expended on a miss}
One overnight soak per week in plain water will keep it from going dormant (I.e. losing the +2 enhancement bonus). During that night, none of the "slots" can be filled at the same time. You can deliberately empty a slot and collect the liquid in a bowl or similar device as a full-round action.
Special liquids:
- Potions: Potions can be loaded with the Quick Soak method. (Overnight soak dilutes the magic too much over time to be effective) The whip absorbs and feeds off of the magic of the potion, thus when the potion slot is activated, instead of the potion's usual effect, the whip gains a temporary additional enhancement bonus equal to the level of the spell in the potion. This bonus ends on a successful hit.
- Lycanthrope chemical banes: (e.g. wolfsbane solution for werewolves, skullcap solution for werebats, etc.) although these are usually only dangerous to werebeasts when ingested, when used with the Quick Soak method, they work as though ingested, but with the DC reduced by 5 (Fort DC15, initial 1d6 Con, Secondary 2d6 Con). When used with an overnight soak, they do the normal +1d4 damage.
- Herbal infusions: same as poisons
- Oil: Quick Soaked oil will spread on the target, but requires a spark of some kind to light.
- Acid: acid will hurt the whip. don't use it.
- Poison: injected poisons work as normal. ingested poisons work with the DC reduced by 5
- anything weird: as a rule of thumb, if a creature has some sort of aversion to a particular liquid, it will work for Overnight Soak's +1d4, and will do 2d4 damage on a Quick Soak. (same as holy water would do to undead)
While you can fill multiple slots with the same liquid, multiple activations of the same liquid do not stack. If you have an Overnight Soak active, and then do a quick soak of the same liquid, the Quick Soak will override the Overnight Soak for the single attack in which it hits.
The whip can hold five flasks worth of liquid, on top of the plain water needed to keep it from going dormant.
Each flask of liquid takes up a "slot" in the whip. The slot stays full until expended. There are two ways to fill a slot.
1) Overnight Soak
Time to fill: 8 hours (Interrupted soaks follow the same rules as interrupted spellcaster rest)
How often you can fill this way: 1/day
Benefit: When activated, any creature hit by the whip that would be damaged by the liquid takes +1d4 damage.
Time to activate: 1 swift action
Duration: 1 day. (At the end of the duration, the slot is empty.)
{this isn't quite as good as "flaming" in damage or cost to maintain, but that should be made up for by the overall versatility of the item compared to flaming}
2) Quick Soak
Time to fill: 1 standard action
How often you can fill this way: 1/round
Benefit: When activated, the next creature hit by the whip is covered with the liquid, which seeps into the whip wounds. If the creature would be damaged by the liquid, it takes the full damage of the liquid, in addition to the whip damage.
Time to activate or deactivate: 1 swift action
Duration: until the next time you hit with the whip or deactivate. (On a hit, the slot becomes empty, on deactivation, it stays full.)
{this is better than simply throwing the liquid as your standard action, since it's not expended on a miss}
One overnight soak per week in plain water will keep it from going dormant (I.e. losing the +2 enhancement bonus). During that night, none of the "slots" can be filled at the same time. You can deliberately empty a slot and collect the liquid in a bowl or similar device as a full-round action.
Special liquids:
- Potions: Potions can be loaded with the Quick Soak method. (Overnight soak dilutes the magic too much over time to be effective) The whip absorbs and feeds off of the magic of the potion, thus when the potion slot is activated, instead of the potion's usual effect, the whip gains a temporary additional enhancement bonus equal to the level of the spell in the potion. This bonus ends on a successful hit.
- Lycanthrope chemical banes: (e.g. wolfsbane solution for werewolves, skullcap solution for werebats, etc.) although these are usually only dangerous to werebeasts when ingested, when used with the Quick Soak method, they work as though ingested, but with the DC reduced by 5 (Fort DC15, initial 1d6 Con, Secondary 2d6 Con). When used with an overnight soak, they do the normal +1d4 damage.
- Herbal infusions: same as poisons
- Oil: Quick Soaked oil will spread on the target, but requires a spark of some kind to light.
- Acid: acid will hurt the whip. don't use it.
- Poison: injected poisons work as normal. ingested poisons work with the DC reduced by 5
- anything weird: as a rule of thumb, if a creature has some sort of aversion to a particular liquid, it will work for Overnight Soak's +1d4, and will do 2d4 damage on a Quick Soak. (same as holy water would do to undead)
While you can fill multiple slots with the same liquid, multiple activations of the same liquid do not stack. If you have an Overnight Soak active, and then do a quick soak of the same liquid, the Quick Soak will override the Overnight Soak for the single attack in which it hits.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
