What is your explanation for the Dark Powers?
What is your explanation for the Dark Powers?
As we all know, the DPs are, canonically, impossible to define. This isn't about that.
Rather, I want to know, if you, the memebers of the Faternity choose to ignore canon and define them for your games, even if only for a single campagin with the definition of what they are being different in another, do to explain them. Their motives, there origin, their actions...Anything really.
Being the 4E fanatic I am, I state them to be primordials who, intreseted in the mortal races capacity for evil, choose to create a world where they could experiment with it. They have a slightly good motive for this-Without the soul-crushing evil of the darklords, the natural order of the gods, who they seem to like, can go on-but as admitted by them, they really just want to toy with the darklords.
This also allows epic play, since once Ravenloft PCs reach that tier, they are sure to attract the attention of the Archons who were created by the DPs-and these being Ravenloft Archons, they are not at all nice.
Rather, I want to know, if you, the memebers of the Faternity choose to ignore canon and define them for your games, even if only for a single campagin with the definition of what they are being different in another, do to explain them. Their motives, there origin, their actions...Anything really.
Being the 4E fanatic I am, I state them to be primordials who, intreseted in the mortal races capacity for evil, choose to create a world where they could experiment with it. They have a slightly good motive for this-Without the soul-crushing evil of the darklords, the natural order of the gods, who they seem to like, can go on-but as admitted by them, they really just want to toy with the darklords.
This also allows epic play, since once Ravenloft PCs reach that tier, they are sure to attract the attention of the Archons who were created by the DPs-and these being Ravenloft Archons, they are not at all nice.
I am The Archangel of Night.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
I consider the DPs to a part of the Ancient Brethren, kin to the Lady of Pain and The Serpent.
Hindsight is, after all, caused by a lack of foresight.
Death rates exceeded 100% in some towns.
Charles V spent most of his reign aging.
This was beginning of Empire, when Europeans felt the need to reach out and smack someone
Death rates exceeded 100% in some towns.
Charles V spent most of his reign aging.
This was beginning of Empire, when Europeans felt the need to reach out and smack someone
- WolfKook
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 573
- Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Bogotá, Colombia
- Contact:
The mists are the result of an ancient and powerful vistani curse which allowed them to trap a creature into a misty pocket domain, in eternal solitude. It was used sparely, only for the most henious of crimes.
But the curse went wrong when a particularly clever and depraved soul began studying the misty cage, and discovered that it reacted to evil deeds, trying to entrap those who commited them. Thus, he found a way to extend the prison, and its powers, by tempting people to make all the wrong moves in the presence of the mists. But his own evil acts caused that he was also stolen by the mists.
And there, the realm not being more than a block by then, he found the same people he had tempted to join the mists. And they were upset, and wanted revenge. So, this evil person was the first to die within the misty prison.
But the mists did not allow his soul to rest. Instead, it remained trapped within them. But it retained enough malice and enough knowledge of the mists to try and seek revenge by manipulating the mists for his own purposes.
He fused with the mists, and manipulated them against his enemies, destroying them, and using their souls to increase the power he had over the mists. At the end, all of them were one with the mists, granting them conciousness... If a perverted conciousness which with the pass of eons has forgotten its ancient origins and started feeding on hate and fear.
But the curse went wrong when a particularly clever and depraved soul began studying the misty cage, and discovered that it reacted to evil deeds, trying to entrap those who commited them. Thus, he found a way to extend the prison, and its powers, by tempting people to make all the wrong moves in the presence of the mists. But his own evil acts caused that he was also stolen by the mists.
And there, the realm not being more than a block by then, he found the same people he had tempted to join the mists. And they were upset, and wanted revenge. So, this evil person was the first to die within the misty prison.
But the mists did not allow his soul to rest. Instead, it remained trapped within them. But it retained enough malice and enough knowledge of the mists to try and seek revenge by manipulating the mists for his own purposes.
He fused with the mists, and manipulated them against his enemies, destroying them, and using their souls to increase the power he had over the mists. At the end, all of them were one with the mists, granting them conciousness... If a perverted conciousness which with the pass of eons has forgotten its ancient origins and started feeding on hate and fear.
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
William Blake
Funny, I was just thinking about this. I really don't know much about Ravenloft yet, but I've been reading through a decent pile of game material lately, and this is what I've come up with in my own mind:
Ravenloft exists in the Ethereal Plane, right? And what else travels the Ethereal Plane? The spirits of the dead, on their way to their final rest. Now, once a soul is dead, it no longer has any reason to fear death-- that aspect, which was essential to its survival on the Material Plane, is suddenly null and void. Further, it makes no sense for a soul to carry those fears into the afterlife with it. So all these lingering fears are shed within the Ethereal Plane.
It is this essence, the castoff residue of mortal fears, that forms the substance of Ravenloft-- it is, quite literally, a Demiplane of Dread. As Lovecraft observed: "The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear; and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown." Therefore the Demiplane manifests as a place where the fears of the unknown are made flesh; it is a place of secrets, mystery and lurking terror just outside the firelight. Also, since humans, of all the races, are most concerned with their own mortality, the Demiplane most strongly reflects humanity.
And it is hungry. Formed of the soul residue of mankind's collective dread, the Demiplane is itself a living organism; fearful for its own mortality, jealous of its own survival. A vast, churning amoebic entity of Mist, it roams the dim vaults of the Ethereal, ravenously seeking out and digesting the bitter dregs of lingering fear, growing ever stronger, more aware.
It is this self-awareness, this primal coalescensce of the shed vitality of uncounted souls, from which springs the guiding force of the Dark Powers. They are One, and Many: a gestalt intellect, many-voiced, fractured, conflicted as mankind is itself conflicted. They are aware; they hunger.
Dread is their substance; it is their one need, their meat and drink. Once unthinking, they were content to rove blindly, straining the dark energy from the Ethereal like some placid leviathan. Now they wonder at its source; they sense the reality of other planes. They scent distant souls, heavy with dark emotions, ripe with potential. Misty tendrils surge forth to breach the barrier, drawing in this bright source of vitality.
The Powers are pleased. Carefully husbanded, these souls will fuel an endlessly renewable feast of dread-- a banquet of infinite variety on which to batten. But the garden must be cared for. Tended.
...
That was a little over the top, wasn't it? Sorry about that. Anyhoo... in this model, the Dark Powers evolve spontaneously from mankind's own fears; they are the thoughts of the Demiplane itself, and their primary concern is self-preservation. They subsist on a very narrow spectrum of human emotion, and they cultivate the Demiplane to maximize this output. Strictly speaking, they are not concerned with good or evil. However, the presence of evil creates more opportunity for dread, so they seem to favor evil. They seek out beings from other planes that taste like they would generate the most dread.
Maybe the domains themselves are absorbed from other worlds; maybe they are simply patterned, doppelganger-like, on places in other worlds, or created ex nihilo by the Dark Powers. Even if the latter is the case, the people themselves are no less real than those of the Material Plane, since their souls are created from the soulstuff of the Material Plane.
So who are the Vistani? Perhaps they too are an aspect of the Demiplane, but of a different sort; more like white blood cells (ow! Ow! Somebody's-- stop cursing me!). They circulate constantly, acting to maintain the body's overall health, quite independently of the Dark Powers. They may not be happy about it, but it's their job. Since the Demiplane favors the experiences of humanity, the Vistani were forced to adopt human form to survive. This explains why they have a suite of extraordinary abilities, and also why they don't approve of intermixing with humans-- it would be like a blood cell and an intestinal bacterium getting married. It's probably not good for you.
Ravenloft exists in the Ethereal Plane, right? And what else travels the Ethereal Plane? The spirits of the dead, on their way to their final rest. Now, once a soul is dead, it no longer has any reason to fear death-- that aspect, which was essential to its survival on the Material Plane, is suddenly null and void. Further, it makes no sense for a soul to carry those fears into the afterlife with it. So all these lingering fears are shed within the Ethereal Plane.
It is this essence, the castoff residue of mortal fears, that forms the substance of Ravenloft-- it is, quite literally, a Demiplane of Dread. As Lovecraft observed: "The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear; and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown." Therefore the Demiplane manifests as a place where the fears of the unknown are made flesh; it is a place of secrets, mystery and lurking terror just outside the firelight. Also, since humans, of all the races, are most concerned with their own mortality, the Demiplane most strongly reflects humanity.
And it is hungry. Formed of the soul residue of mankind's collective dread, the Demiplane is itself a living organism; fearful for its own mortality, jealous of its own survival. A vast, churning amoebic entity of Mist, it roams the dim vaults of the Ethereal, ravenously seeking out and digesting the bitter dregs of lingering fear, growing ever stronger, more aware.
It is this self-awareness, this primal coalescensce of the shed vitality of uncounted souls, from which springs the guiding force of the Dark Powers. They are One, and Many: a gestalt intellect, many-voiced, fractured, conflicted as mankind is itself conflicted. They are aware; they hunger.
Dread is their substance; it is their one need, their meat and drink. Once unthinking, they were content to rove blindly, straining the dark energy from the Ethereal like some placid leviathan. Now they wonder at its source; they sense the reality of other planes. They scent distant souls, heavy with dark emotions, ripe with potential. Misty tendrils surge forth to breach the barrier, drawing in this bright source of vitality.
The Powers are pleased. Carefully husbanded, these souls will fuel an endlessly renewable feast of dread-- a banquet of infinite variety on which to batten. But the garden must be cared for. Tended.
...
That was a little over the top, wasn't it? Sorry about that. Anyhoo... in this model, the Dark Powers evolve spontaneously from mankind's own fears; they are the thoughts of the Demiplane itself, and their primary concern is self-preservation. They subsist on a very narrow spectrum of human emotion, and they cultivate the Demiplane to maximize this output. Strictly speaking, they are not concerned with good or evil. However, the presence of evil creates more opportunity for dread, so they seem to favor evil. They seek out beings from other planes that taste like they would generate the most dread.
Maybe the domains themselves are absorbed from other worlds; maybe they are simply patterned, doppelganger-like, on places in other worlds, or created ex nihilo by the Dark Powers. Even if the latter is the case, the people themselves are no less real than those of the Material Plane, since their souls are created from the soulstuff of the Material Plane.
So who are the Vistani? Perhaps they too are an aspect of the Demiplane, but of a different sort; more like white blood cells (ow! Ow! Somebody's-- stop cursing me!). They circulate constantly, acting to maintain the body's overall health, quite independently of the Dark Powers. They may not be happy about it, but it's their job. Since the Demiplane favors the experiences of humanity, the Vistani were forced to adopt human form to survive. This explains why they have a suite of extraordinary abilities, and also why they don't approve of intermixing with humans-- it would be like a blood cell and an intestinal bacterium getting married. It's probably not good for you.
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
I always thought of the DPs as overgods--gods to the gods themselves. Ravenloft is nothing more than a giant lab, everyone and everything in it a part of some unfathomable experiment. They're a cold and detached neutral, beyond even the gods' understanding of good and evil. Those who get caught in their trap are just made part of the experiment. They don't care what happens to Ravenloft; their test subjects determine their own fate and the fate of the artificial world.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
- Guardian of Twilight
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 428
- Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2005 2:34 pm
- Location: Mordent
Hello. I thought that I'd contribute to this thread with a link to a previous one to add a bit more from other members in the past. 
http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... sc&start=0
http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... sc&start=0
Seek not in the shadows, for there ye shall find secrets too terrible for mortal man to bear.
-Mordentish proverb
-Mordentish proverb
Hmm a thought struck me the other day, what if rather than being gods, over gods, unfathomable celestial beings etc, what if the dark powers are the subconcsious desires of the dark lords themselves? (Bear with me on this).
Every DL manifests evil in some form as part of their personality, and controls or rules their actions and behaviours. They are obsessively evil without remorse, unrepentant and completely convinced they are right. However as all mortals have subconcious urges, why not the dark lords?Perhaps this is their self-loathing, or perhaps a way to try and constrain the concious half of their personality? The DP's and Ravenloft itself is therefore simply these thoughts and urges given a physical form.
As such the DP's were born the night of Sergei's wedding, and the unconsious desires of Strahd became the first of their number. His subconcious created a prison that would torment him for eternity. As time went on perhaps rather than certain beings gettting drawn into the mists on the whim of higher powers they instaed reached a state where their subcocncius desire to constrain themselvs tipped the scales and somehow like attracted like. This therefore makes the DP's a gestalt entity formed of all the DL's themselves.
I admit there is probabley holes a mile wide in this (such as how it affects non-mortal darklords ala Gwydion) but it explains a few things like; why the DL's curses are so finely tuned to their characters, why the lands and domains so accuratly reflect the charcter of the DL's, how Soth got out (simply his capacity for evil diminshed so far as he stagnated that there was no longer a need for the prison), and possibly why only certain evil beings are brought into the mists.
And it also adds a really lovely sense of irony to Azalins continued attempts to either escape or put one over on the DP's....
Every DL manifests evil in some form as part of their personality, and controls or rules their actions and behaviours. They are obsessively evil without remorse, unrepentant and completely convinced they are right. However as all mortals have subconcious urges, why not the dark lords?Perhaps this is their self-loathing, or perhaps a way to try and constrain the concious half of their personality? The DP's and Ravenloft itself is therefore simply these thoughts and urges given a physical form.
As such the DP's were born the night of Sergei's wedding, and the unconsious desires of Strahd became the first of their number. His subconcious created a prison that would torment him for eternity. As time went on perhaps rather than certain beings gettting drawn into the mists on the whim of higher powers they instaed reached a state where their subcocncius desire to constrain themselvs tipped the scales and somehow like attracted like. This therefore makes the DP's a gestalt entity formed of all the DL's themselves.
I admit there is probabley holes a mile wide in this (such as how it affects non-mortal darklords ala Gwydion) but it explains a few things like; why the DL's curses are so finely tuned to their characters, why the lands and domains so accuratly reflect the charcter of the DL's, how Soth got out (simply his capacity for evil diminshed so far as he stagnated that there was no longer a need for the prison), and possibly why only certain evil beings are brought into the mists.
And it also adds a really lovely sense of irony to Azalins continued attempts to either escape or put one over on the DP's....
"I had a dream, which was not all a dream.
The bright sun was extinguish'd, and the stars
Did wander darkling in the eternal space..."
The bright sun was extinguish'd, and the stars
Did wander darkling in the eternal space..."
I love your view on the DP's Amicus. Nice 
I have thought about this in different versions and actually; everytime I started a Ravenloft campaign I changed what the Dark Powers are.
In my first campaign the Dark Powers served as a balancing entity to the evil/good on the Prime Material planes. Since the dominance on the prime materials is good, evil had nowhere to settle, sort of speak.
The Darp Powers worked to that balance and got corrupted in the progress, getting greedy and sometimes taking from other planes what they could not handle (excuse for Vecna).
In the cmapaign I'm running now, I'm working on a more epic run. Ravenloft is a prison for an old evil or mad God(s). I haven't decided if it is 1 God or a small pantheon of lesser Gods (like the troll Gods in the books of David Eddings The Elenium). However, imprisoning a God(s) is not easy and wasn't done perfectly. This God has found a way to escape his prison. It needs vessels to escape. So over the centuries this God has slowly gathered vessels (Dark Lords) to add to his collection and slowly the demiplane appeared around his prison, basically making his prison physical. The prison is based on chaines around the "godly powers" of the God(s). Escape is simple, they have to momentarily give up their power to the vessels (Darklords), which will break their chains. Of course, they need enough vessels so as to not create extremely powerfull vessels that would hold on to their new power.
The escape of the God(s) will be quite the mad and epic battle for the PC's who have to stop them from escaping. Of course it will take quite a while before the PC's know what everything is about. I want to keep it low as long as possible to keep the Ravenloft flavor in it. I still have to change a few thing so as not to make it FR epic, but that will come with time.
The Vistani are the prison guardians. In the first place spirits, but when the core was formed they took shape as Vistani. Of course, taking physical shape has also changed their minds and has made them more vulnerable to "worldly things"........ corruption, greed, etc.
Of course some of the major players have also been given a role in this whole prison setup. Like Isolde and GC. Howerver, I always start my campaigns with an idea in mind and expand it partially according to PC actions and characters and maybe new moods I have
. So dunno how it will work out as of yet.
I have thought about this in different versions and actually; everytime I started a Ravenloft campaign I changed what the Dark Powers are.
In my first campaign the Dark Powers served as a balancing entity to the evil/good on the Prime Material planes. Since the dominance on the prime materials is good, evil had nowhere to settle, sort of speak.
The Darp Powers worked to that balance and got corrupted in the progress, getting greedy and sometimes taking from other planes what they could not handle (excuse for Vecna).
In the cmapaign I'm running now, I'm working on a more epic run. Ravenloft is a prison for an old evil or mad God(s). I haven't decided if it is 1 God or a small pantheon of lesser Gods (like the troll Gods in the books of David Eddings The Elenium). However, imprisoning a God(s) is not easy and wasn't done perfectly. This God has found a way to escape his prison. It needs vessels to escape. So over the centuries this God has slowly gathered vessels (Dark Lords) to add to his collection and slowly the demiplane appeared around his prison, basically making his prison physical. The prison is based on chaines around the "godly powers" of the God(s). Escape is simple, they have to momentarily give up their power to the vessels (Darklords), which will break their chains. Of course, they need enough vessels so as to not create extremely powerfull vessels that would hold on to their new power.
The escape of the God(s) will be quite the mad and epic battle for the PC's who have to stop them from escaping. Of course it will take quite a while before the PC's know what everything is about. I want to keep it low as long as possible to keep the Ravenloft flavor in it. I still have to change a few thing so as not to make it FR epic, but that will come with time.
The Vistani are the prison guardians. In the first place spirits, but when the core was formed they took shape as Vistani. Of course, taking physical shape has also changed their minds and has made them more vulnerable to "worldly things"........ corruption, greed, etc.
Of course some of the major players have also been given a role in this whole prison setup. Like Isolde and GC. Howerver, I always start my campaigns with an idea in mind and expand it partially according to PC actions and characters and maybe new moods I have
Tresspassers will be shot......
Survivors will be shot again.
Survivors will be shot again.
- Valacan de Brek
- Conspirator

- Posts: 9
- Joined: Wed Jul 02, 2008 2:58 pm
One of the things that was mentioned in the AD&D domains of dread hardcover book was that the DP might be jailers and that they are protecting the world from evil by locking them away in Ravenloft. That's also why if you do evil deeds and fail powers checks you loose control of your PC. That's also why the darklords are always taunted and punished by something in their realms. That's what I've always thought.
- Lord Soth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 264
- Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
- Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus
Although the counter-argument to that would be, if they're jailers, then why do they imprison the good along with the evil? Plenty of paragons of goodness have been dragged off by the Mists. Not to mention all the innocent people who're being preyed upon by the horrors the Dark Powers have imprisoned. And to top it off, they don't imprison all evil. Just specific types of evil. Azalin gets dragged in but not Manshoon? Lord Soth is pulled in but not The Gorgon? And so on.
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Sacrifices have to be made for the greater good? Evil doesn't exist nor profile itself without good (and the other way around)? Both "excuses" for having good people in Ravenloft.
As for who they select, that could be "jailer" specific choice, but they can't draw away all evil, that is impossible. Although it becomes a very black-and-white explanation ....
As for who they select, that could be "jailer" specific choice, but they can't draw away all evil, that is impossible. Although it becomes a very black-and-white explanation ....
Tresspassers will be shot......
Survivors will be shot again.
Survivors will be shot again.
- WolfKook
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 573
- Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Bogotá, Colombia
- Contact:
Maybe they have to make some "mistake" that makes them vulnerable to the DPs. It's not just being irredeemably evil, it's also being overcome with fear, self-loathing, hopelessness, or some other will-weakening emotion, if just by an instant. It's in that instant that the DPs get the chance to "attack".
Again, I have problems with Vecna and Gwydion... But I still like the theory.
Again, I have problems with Vecna and Gwydion... But I still like the theory.
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
William Blake
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
In regards to Gwydion, one vital thing people forget about him is that he wasn't "chosen" by the Dark Powers. The Arak busted into the Land of Mists, and he tagged along behind them. Making him a darklord need not have been something the DPs did voluntarily. Rather, it might've been a hasty act of damage-control on their part: the one way they could keep such a powerful entity from busting up their pet project. Once they had him trapped, they couldn't afford to revoke his status, as it'd undermine much of the Core to boot him out again.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
Or (my favorite recurring idea on this point) the Shadow Rift is actually Gwydion's reality wrinkle, and he's not a true darklord (in the sense Strahd et al. are) at all.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:In regards to Gwydion, one vital thing people forget about him is that he wasn't "chosen" by the Dark Powers. The Arak busted into the Land of Mists, and he tagged along behind them. Making him a darklord need not have been something the DPs did voluntarily. Rather, it might've been a hasty act of damage-control on their part: the one way they could keep such a powerful entity from busting up their pet project. Once they had him trapped, they couldn't afford to revoke his status, as it'd undermine much of the Core to boot him out again.
The same idea might be applied to Ebonbane, actually--its "domain" is actually the part of the Shadowlands that falls within its reality wrinkle.
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:


