Darkon memory loss - 2 puzzles
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Darkon memory loss - 2 puzzles
We know from Gaz II and FtS that anyone who comes to Darkon gets their memory of life outside Darkon erased in 1d3 months, as the quill in Avernus's library writes an account of their life. When the account is complete, their name is inscribed in the Book of Names, along with the date, and the new memories take hold.
Puzzle #1: Would you be affected sooner if you are younger? (Since there is less to write about) If a family including a 5-year-old kid, some adults, and an 80-year-old grandfather moved in, would the kid go first, then the adults, then the grandfather? Or is the variable time simply due to backlog of stories to write? There's only one quill, and presumably many people entering the land each day. Does it do one whole life at a time or switch between them?
Puzzle #2: Leaving Darkon restores your memories. But if you return, they get re-written again 1d3 months later. Do you get a new book in that case? If so, does it cover only the new info or the whole story? Do you get written in the Book of Names again?
(Yes, these seem like nitpicks, but they are actually relevant in my game, since the PC's grabbed the books of some NPC's they know while in Avernus during FtS. One is a 5-year-old child, and another left Darkon and returned several times.)
Puzzle #1: Would you be affected sooner if you are younger? (Since there is less to write about) If a family including a 5-year-old kid, some adults, and an 80-year-old grandfather moved in, would the kid go first, then the adults, then the grandfather? Or is the variable time simply due to backlog of stories to write? There's only one quill, and presumably many people entering the land each day. Does it do one whole life at a time or switch between them?
Puzzle #2: Leaving Darkon restores your memories. But if you return, they get re-written again 1d3 months later. Do you get a new book in that case? If so, does it cover only the new info or the whole story? Do you get written in the Book of Names again?
(Yes, these seem like nitpicks, but they are actually relevant in my game, since the PC's grabbed the books of some NPC's they know while in Avernus during FtS. One is a 5-year-old child, and another left Darkon and returned several times.)
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
-
Jennifer
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 170
- Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 2:47 pm
- Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands
Hi Gonzoron,
My party is from Darkon and I have had to think about these things as well.
The party was mixed with original Darkonese people and some immigrants. One had lived in darkon for more than a year and thought he had lived there all his life and one wandered in recently.
When they left Darkon the real memories came back, which came as a shock to the immigrants, since they now had to doubt everything they thought they knew. To the Darkonese it came as a bit of a shock as well, all the stories were true!
So, to answer your questions, i think that the "new biography" does not appear all at once, but that it is a more gradual proces and happens largely unnoticed, because 1) the person it happens to does not realize something is wrong and 2) because you do not continue to rehash information about yourself which others (presumably) already know.
say for example a character is an immigrant from Lamordia, wandering into Darkon. At first he introduces himself to people he meets daily as Lamordian. After a while he might think he is from Darkon. But he will not reintroduce himself to people he already knows. They might still think of him as Lamordian, but will not keep bringing it up (perhaps also some social taboo to discuss pasts with people, since they so often get very upset). Also I think that even though memories get rewritten, the basic personality will not, a good husband and provider will remain so, but will start a new family, a thief will keep on thieving.
I think the process might go faster for children, since they indeed have less memory to overwrite, but it might be even more unnoticed, since children are known to have fantastical imaginations. (kids say the darnest things). The process might also be more easily explained in the very elderly, as their minds are clearly going.
For re-immigrants, I am not sure. I suppose they would return to their old 'fake' biography and life, with the people they knew.
Jennifer
My party is from Darkon and I have had to think about these things as well.
The party was mixed with original Darkonese people and some immigrants. One had lived in darkon for more than a year and thought he had lived there all his life and one wandered in recently.
When they left Darkon the real memories came back, which came as a shock to the immigrants, since they now had to doubt everything they thought they knew. To the Darkonese it came as a bit of a shock as well, all the stories were true!
So, to answer your questions, i think that the "new biography" does not appear all at once, but that it is a more gradual proces and happens largely unnoticed, because 1) the person it happens to does not realize something is wrong and 2) because you do not continue to rehash information about yourself which others (presumably) already know.
say for example a character is an immigrant from Lamordia, wandering into Darkon. At first he introduces himself to people he meets daily as Lamordian. After a while he might think he is from Darkon. But he will not reintroduce himself to people he already knows. They might still think of him as Lamordian, but will not keep bringing it up (perhaps also some social taboo to discuss pasts with people, since they so often get very upset). Also I think that even though memories get rewritten, the basic personality will not, a good husband and provider will remain so, but will start a new family, a thief will keep on thieving.
I think the process might go faster for children, since they indeed have less memory to overwrite, but it might be even more unnoticed, since children are known to have fantastical imaginations. (kids say the darnest things). The process might also be more easily explained in the very elderly, as their minds are clearly going.
For re-immigrants, I am not sure. I suppose they would return to their old 'fake' biography and life, with the people they knew.
Jennifer
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
thanks for the thoughts, Jennifer. I think my issues are largely opposite of yours though. It doesn't really matter to me (at this point) what happens to the memories of re-immigrants, but rather what happens to the books.
I agree that a child's changed memories could easily be dismissed by adults, but I guess, for my purposes, what I'm really looking for is how much of a 5-year-old's life would be in his book, assuming he only spent a few weeks in Darkon, passing through.
I agree that a child's changed memories could easily be dismissed by adults, but I guess, for my purposes, what I'm really looking for is how much of a 5-year-old's life would be in his book, assuming he only spent a few weeks in Darkon, passing through.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
I actually thought the "regain memories as you leave" feature to be a cop-out. In my campaign, once they're gone, they're gone for good. (Unless you can somehow doctor the book in Castle Avernus.)
There is an agency of sorts that has many detectives in it to find out what they can about people if asked. They charge high rates but in the end if all turns out well, the buyer ends up with a book of as much chronological information as could be found.
An NPC agency in my campaign, L'Agence d'Affaires, does this to its most prized servitors, giving them the book when they retire to allow them to chase their demons if they wish.
There is an agency of sorts that has many detectives in it to find out what they can about people if asked. They charge high rates but in the end if all turns out well, the buyer ends up with a book of as much chronological information as could be found.
An NPC agency in my campaign, L'Agence d'Affaires, does this to its most prized servitors, giving them the book when they retire to allow them to chase their demons if they wish.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Well, cop-out or not, it's there in canon. And I think it kinda has to be there to be at all playable. Not every DM wants to send their party into Avernus, and in non-FtS stituations, most won't leave alive. So unless your players are happy with their carefully constructed backstories erased, there's got to be a bit of an "easy" out, I think.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Re: Darkon memory loss - 2 puzzles
I think it's simply a matter of backlog as far as when the book gets to you, but I also think the librarian monitors the books and selects a good time that won't arouse a lot of suspicion. Thus, with your family scenario, I think it would be easier for it to affect everyone at once, so no one gets wise to the idea.gonzoron wrote:Puzzle #1: Would you be affected sooner if you are younger? (Since there is less to write about) If a family including a 5-year-old kid, some adults, and an 80-year-old grandfather moved in, would the kid go first, then the adults, then the grandfather? Or is the variable time simply due to backlog of stories to write? There's only one quill, and presumably many people entering the land each day. Does it do one whole life at a time or switch between them?
I say you'd get a new book, though I could see a case either way. There should be a clear "volumes 1 & 2" on the spines, knowing how meticulous the librarians can be, so if the PC's were in a hurry and just grabbed them with a glance, you have room for them to discover the mistake, otherwise you owe it to them to put it all in one volume if they did a thorough search.Puzzle #2: Leaving Darkon restores your memories. But if you return, they get re-written again 1d3 months later. Do you get a new book in that case? If so, does it cover only the new info or the whole story? Do you get written in the Book of Names again?
What will it mean to your campaign either way? Maybe you can make the decision based upon what suits you as DM.
OTOH, you could just roll for it, and make it up afterward.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
-
Nikolas of the Mists
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 183
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm
Re: Darkon memory loss - 2 puzzles
What I have used before is that the book isn't really "undone", or erased -- simply filed in a different section for storage. When the individual returns to Darkon and succumbs to memory loss again, the book simply picks up where it left off, explaining away the absence in the period that they were gone. This would also render it unneccesary for the histories of any individual that knows the Darkonese "persona" to be rewritten to accomodate the individual.gonzoron wrote:Puzzle #2: Leaving Darkon restores your memories. But if you return, they get re-written again 1d3 months later. Do you get a new book in that case? If so, does it cover only the new info or the whole story? Do you get written in the Book of Names again?
"I wouldn't worry too much about the Vistana with the pistols --
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
I agree with the first but not the second. My campaign is proceeding on exactly that central motif, and my players tell me that it's at least partially playablegonzoron wrote:Well, cop-out or not, it's there in canon. And I think it kinda has to be there to be at all playable.
But yes I agree that canon has this workaround.
- Lord Cyclohexane
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 512
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
- Location: Tanelorn, OH
Re: Darkon memory loss - 2 puzzles
Great questions! I've been trying to think of things like this, as I want to do a game where everyone starts as Darkonian natives, and so concerns like these are also of interest to me. Here's my thoughts on it (reject if undesirable):
But as to whether the 5-year-old's memory would be wiped first? I'd say not. I'd say that a major variable in the "time until mindwipe" would be how many people you enter Darkon with and thus how much correlation needs to be done for false memory creation. I believe that Gaz II mentioned that, when a group of people enters at the same time, their false memories still carry referents to each other so that they remain as one group. As such, I think that none of the people would have their memories wiped first, but rather that they'd all have their minds wiped simultaneously, that it wouldn't be until the Quill had finished writing the lifestory of every member of that group and had linked all of their stories together, it wouldn't be until then that any of them had their minds wiped.
So the 5-year-old's story might have been completely written to the last detail, but the 5-year-old might have still retained his memory while waiting on the others to have their stories finished.
Or, I guess to clarify a bit: I don't think that the person's memories are wiped immediately after the book is written. I think the 5-year-old's book would have every detail in it, as the Quill would have finished the writing during those few weeks that the 5-year-old was in Darkon. However, the 5-year-old's memory would not have been wiped yet.
As to what kind of time difference there would be in writing the 5-year-old's lifestory vs the 80-year-old's life story would, I think, be a couple of days. Say perhaps that it can cover a decade per day?
But whose story would be written first, out of that group of individuals? Perhaps it'd be best to start with the youngest, as (s)he would have the least number of referents to other individuals and so would be the best starting point for creating the web of social interaction for rewriting the group as a whole. Not to mention, family members tend to sacrifice a lot of their own desires to provide a better life for the children, which also includes older children being taught to sacrifice for the younger ones... I dunno.
Anyway, though, the question was whether the 5-year-old's book would have every detail of the kid's life in it after only being in Darkon for a few weeks. I'd say that it is most definitely possible and is quite likely, unless there is a reason that you'd like to have had the Quill cut off mid-word, missing those last few crucial details of the kid's story, so as to add some mystery to your plot.
Anyway, this is my opinion as to what is most palatable, along with way more rambling than is relevant... Take what you will and throw out the rest.
If you hadn't destroyed your own book, I'd say the Quill just sticks with the previous entry and adds a few notes to the end. Since I'd say each lifestory doesn't take too long to jot down, the 1d3 still makes a good metric as the length of entry isn't a real variable in how long you have until mindwipe. It'd maybe take a day tops to add any additional details to the end of your previous book.
<><><><><><>
A question for you, though, as your entry made me think of it: Since crossing Darkon's border will cause you to regain your memory, what would happen to the book with your lifestory if you took it across the border with you?
Would the book be destroyed and the Quill would have to create a new book? Would you retain your false Darkonese memories since there's wouldn't be a domain border between you and your book, same as if you'd remained in Darkon with the book? Will it flip its information and instead contain the detailed history of your false persona?
And, for your above case: If you take someone else's book across the border, what happens to their memory? If the kid is still in Darkon and you take his book out, will he regain his true memory?
Since there is only one Quill but many stories to write, I'd say that the time variable is due to the backlog of people's stories to write and would be unrelated to the age of the individual. I figure it'd only take a few days to write any particular individual's lifestory (I doubt the Quill would write down detailed notes about "slow time" like eating meals, sleeping, etc that the individual did, so it shouldn't take too long). But, most likely, the Quill won't start writing about that individual until they've been in Darkon for a few months.gonzoron wrote:Puzzle #1: Would you be affected sooner if you are younger? (Since there is less to write about) If a family including a 5-year-old kid, some adults, and an 80-year-old grandfather moved in, would the kid go first, then the adults, then the grandfather? Or is the variable time simply due to backlog of stories to write? There's only one quill, and presumably many people entering the land each day. Does it do one whole life at a time or switch between them?
But as to whether the 5-year-old's memory would be wiped first? I'd say not. I'd say that a major variable in the "time until mindwipe" would be how many people you enter Darkon with and thus how much correlation needs to be done for false memory creation. I believe that Gaz II mentioned that, when a group of people enters at the same time, their false memories still carry referents to each other so that they remain as one group. As such, I think that none of the people would have their memories wiped first, but rather that they'd all have their minds wiped simultaneously, that it wouldn't be until the Quill had finished writing the lifestory of every member of that group and had linked all of their stories together, it wouldn't be until then that any of them had their minds wiped.
So the 5-year-old's story might have been completely written to the last detail, but the 5-year-old might have still retained his memory while waiting on the others to have their stories finished.
Or, I guess to clarify a bit: I don't think that the person's memories are wiped immediately after the book is written. I think the 5-year-old's book would have every detail in it, as the Quill would have finished the writing during those few weeks that the 5-year-old was in Darkon. However, the 5-year-old's memory would not have been wiped yet.
As to what kind of time difference there would be in writing the 5-year-old's lifestory vs the 80-year-old's life story would, I think, be a couple of days. Say perhaps that it can cover a decade per day?
But whose story would be written first, out of that group of individuals? Perhaps it'd be best to start with the youngest, as (s)he would have the least number of referents to other individuals and so would be the best starting point for creating the web of social interaction for rewriting the group as a whole. Not to mention, family members tend to sacrifice a lot of their own desires to provide a better life for the children, which also includes older children being taught to sacrifice for the younger ones... I dunno.
Anyway, though, the question was whether the 5-year-old's book would have every detail of the kid's life in it after only being in Darkon for a few weeks. I'd say that it is most definitely possible and is quite likely, unless there is a reason that you'd like to have had the Quill cut off mid-word, missing those last few crucial details of the kid's story, so as to add some mystery to your plot.
Anyway, this is my opinion as to what is most palatable, along with way more rambling than is relevant... Take what you will and throw out the rest.
I'd say, as above, that backlog is the biggest variable in the time delay. Since you left and re-entered, you're back at the end of the line and have to wait until the others are finished. After those 1d3 months to work through the backlog, the Quill starts adding the few additional details to your story since leaving and re-entering Darkon and then rewipes your mind.gonzoron wrote:Puzzle #2: Leaving Darkon restores your memories. But if you return, they get re-written again 1d3 months later. Do you get a new book in that case? If so, does it cover only the new info or the whole story? Do you get written in the Book of Names again?
If you hadn't destroyed your own book, I'd say the Quill just sticks with the previous entry and adds a few notes to the end. Since I'd say each lifestory doesn't take too long to jot down, the 1d3 still makes a good metric as the length of entry isn't a real variable in how long you have until mindwipe. It'd maybe take a day tops to add any additional details to the end of your previous book.
<><><><><><>
A question for you, though, as your entry made me think of it: Since crossing Darkon's border will cause you to regain your memory, what would happen to the book with your lifestory if you took it across the border with you?
Would the book be destroyed and the Quill would have to create a new book? Would you retain your false Darkonese memories since there's wouldn't be a domain border between you and your book, same as if you'd remained in Darkon with the book? Will it flip its information and instead contain the detailed history of your false persona?
And, for your above case: If you take someone else's book across the border, what happens to their memory? If the kid is still in Darkon and you take his book out, will he regain his true memory?
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Heh. Wanna really blow your mind? What might happen if you used the Quill of Law on the biographies, rather than just the Book of Names? Would editing the text of a biography change the corresponding person's memory? Could you, say, cross the names off the spines of two books, re-write each name on the opposite book's spine, and switch those two peoples' memories? Or, even if you can't change their false recollections on the spot, could revising the contents of a person's life story change the contents of the memories they'd get back, upon leaving the domain?
Also, if you know the system, can you beat it? If so, how? Can you pen your own life-story and have it smuggled into the library, so the quill will think that job's already done and not bother to erase your memories?
Also, if you know the system, can you beat it? If so, how? Can you pen your own life-story and have it smuggled into the library, so the quill will think that job's already done and not bother to erase your memories?
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Well, let me rephrase.HuManBing wrote:I agree with the first but not the second. My campaign is proceeding on exactly that central motif, and my players tell me that it's at least partially playablegonzoron wrote:Well, cop-out or not, it's there in canon. And I think it kinda has to be there to be at all playable.
But if your PC's are just passing through, it's gotta be just a weird feature of this one domain, and not a permanently life-altering experience.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Here's a weird one:
Would Darkon's memory loss work on the Shadow Fey? If so, would their new memories extend back into false history, since their time in the temporal fugue wouldn't fit in Darkon's history?
Would Darkon's memory loss work on the Shadow Fey? If so, would their new memories extend back into false history, since their time in the temporal fugue wouldn't fit in Darkon's history?
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
-
Nikolas of the Mists
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 183
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Good point. The amount of detail that the Clockmaker relates regarding life in the Rift would seem very strange if he/she couldn't remember living there.Nikolas of the Mists wrote:The Clockmaker from VRGttShadowFey fluff is a Darkonian Fir Fey if that helps
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
