How to handle Knowledge (Ravenloft)?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

Knowledge (local) is a bit of a misnomer; it covers culture, local events, people of note, laws, all manner of things about known population centers. It also encompasses the user's ability to absorb information about new (settled) locations. It's one of those skills a player may need to roll again after new information is discovered--until they've pieced things together (say three or four successful checks over in-game hours or days).
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
Nathan of the FoS
Fiendish Enforcer
Fiendish Enforcer
Posts: 5247
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
Location: San Francisco CA

Post by Nathan of the FoS »

gonzoron wrote:Well, that's pretty much what I want to do, since it keeps all the secrets for when they get there. But it's kind of boring and pointless, no?
Not necessarily. It means they don't need a local guide, and you could give them some fun tidbits with the "sites of interest" bit that will at least give them hints about what questions to ask when they get there. But, yeah, for Know (geography) when you're not actually in the domain--I don't think you can expect more, as a PC.
Nathan of the FoS wrote:I'd put most "people" information under "local" and most political information under "local" and/or "nobility/royalty."
So has anyone actually gotten "local" to work? I mean, do you have people spend ranks for each local area? Or just let local really mean "global," as in local, but everywhere you go?[/quote]

NeoTiamat's solution is rather elegant, I think--each 2 ranks of Know (local) adds a domain to the list whose local conditions you're familiar with. In other domains you take a -10 to checks and have no chance for info beyond DC 15 or thereabouts.
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

I do like that approach, but then you have the problem that all domains are not created equal. For a Core-born PC, knowledge about Mordent is going to be far easier to come by than knowledge about Sri Raji. And knowing all there is to know about Darkon is a lot more to learn than all there is to know about Odiare.

It was I that asked for a Knowledge (geo) roll in response to the question: "What do have I learned about Nidala?" Should I have asked for all three rolls? (geo, Nob/Roy, and local)? And if I implement NeoTiamat's system now, and say, "which domains do you choose?" you can bet Nidala would be on the list, despite the relative dearth of info on the place available to someone who's never left the Core.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
DocBeard
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2165
Joined: Mon Nov 05, 2007 5:35 pm

Post by DocBeard »

What I do, or did before I upgraded, was compress history, local, nobility, and politics into two skills, Knowledge(History) and Knowledge(Modern). I reserved the right to ask my players to make a roll if they were saying things that, while normal Ravenloft gamer knowledge, would be more difficult for the character to have access to. Anything shady fit under Gather Information, which I had work as a 'Streetwise' skill for rumor-finding and general moxious activities.

I mean honestly, the knowledge skills were so arbitrarily defined that they suffered from the old White Wolf, "A starting character doesn't have the kind of skills a competent adult would have." syndrome, depending on how strict an individual DM was about knowledge skills being how much you know and can talk about knowing, rather than a skill like swimming or craft.
User avatar
Nathan of the FoS
Fiendish Enforcer
Fiendish Enforcer
Posts: 5247
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
Location: San Francisco CA

Post by Nathan of the FoS »

gonzoron wrote:I do like that approach, but then you have the problem that all domains are not created equal. For a Core-born PC, knowledge about Mordent is going to be far easier to come by than knowledge about Sri Raji. And knowing all there is to know about Darkon is a lot more to learn than all there is to know about Odiare.

It was I that asked for a Knowledge (geo) roll in response to the question: "What do have I learned about Nidala?" Should I have asked for all three rolls? (geo, Nob/Roy, and local)? And if I implement NeoTiamat's system now, and say, "which domains do you choose?" you can bet Nidala would be on the list, despite the relative dearth of info on the place available to someone who's never left the Core.
So it has to be domains the person has visited...seems reasonable to me. :) I'd say, yeah, all three rolls would be best, just cuz they cover pretty different things. If they say, "That Know (geography) info was really wimpy!" just say, "OK...Know (local) and (nob/roy), then."
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Heehee! Check this out. Here's what I finally came up with:
Knowledge (RL) 39 on The Mists:

Common Knowledge: The World's End Mists surround and divide all the lands of
the world. Everyone knows that the Mists hold hidden dangers, and are best
left alone.

DC15: The Mists act as a barrier that can hinder travel for all but the
Vistani, who seem to have some unusual connection with the Mists and never
get lost in them. Non-vistani who enter the Mist can easily be lost, as
navigation is nearly impossible, with no visible landmarks. Time and
distance can seem to become meaningless in the Mists, and modern compasses
simply rotate aimlessly within them.

DC20: The Mists do not confine themselves to the Misty Border around the
lands. They have been known to descend anywhere in the world, boiling up
from the earth, and snatching up people, depositing them elsewhere, or
sometimes abducting them completely, never to be seen again. Perceptive
explorers and merchants have recently found certain "currents" in the Mists,
called Mistways, places where entering the Misty Border in one particular
location _usually_ leads one to another specific location... most of the
time. Though not as fool-proof as Vistani-guided travel, Mistways are far
more reliable than simply walking into the Mist and hoping.

DC25: Powerful priests of Ezra, called Anchorites, seem to have some control
over the Mists, like the Vistani do. They believe their goddess willingly
became one with the Mists, and aids them in navigating the trackless
expanse. While the Mists sometimes simply appear out of nowhere, rumors also
speak of more insidious appearances by the Mists. Whispered tales tell of
folk who wandered lost for days in a small grove of trees, or of back alleys
that became twisting labyrinths. During these strange episodes, the Mists
can sometimes be seen lingering thinly about, but are usually not seen at
all, though the strange occurrence is usually blamed on the Mist anyway. The
unfortunates who encounter this phenomenon are called "mist-led."

DC30: Throughout history, the Misty Border has sometimes pulled back,
revealing lands that weren't visible before. The denizens of these lands
often describe having lived for centuries on their own, surrounded only by
the Misty Border. From their perspective, the mists rolled back, revealing
new lands surrounding them. Other times, the people report living on a world
WITHOUT an omnipresent Misty Border, and the Mists simply descended one day
and abducted the entire realm! One book records the insane ravings of a
madman, who claimed that such places were artificial constructs, formed out
of the Mist itself.

DC35: At the best guesses of sages and scholars, the Mists are a
manifestation of the Near Ethereal, the spirit world, strands of the cobwebs
that bind the world together. But there seems to be an intelligence behind
the Mists, some force that controls them for unknowable reasons. People
often seem to become Mist-led at exactly the worst time (such as while being
chased by a pack of wolves), and the Mists have been known to snatch certain
individuals, while leaving others behind. Also the Mists only seem to abduct
people and their belongings or homes, never random objects, wildlife alone,
or empty wastelands. If the Mists are intelligent, they definitely have an
interest in people, and the things that people create and hold dear. Some
rare accounts tell of people who say they hear the Mists calling to them,
driving them to do evil things.


Knowledge (Geo) 25 on Nidala:

DC15: Nidala is the only inhabited region in a land called collectively The
Shadowlands, somewhere deep within the Mists. The Shadowlands also includes
the abandoned ruins of the land of Avonleigh, and the untamed wilderness of
the Phantasmal Forest. The settled lands lay to the east of the Theospine
mountains, which bisects Nidala from north to south. The climate is
temperate and contains mostly mountains, forests, hills, and plains. Several
rivers and streams flow down from the mountains, and pool in one freshwater
lake, Lake Amenta.

DC20: The Kingdom of Nidala is kept safe by the Knight-Protector, a holy
warrior who rules from the capital city of Touraine, the largest settlement
in the land. Dozens of smaller settlements dot the lands east of the
mountains, where the folk live off of bountiful fish, shellfish, game,
assorted grains, hogs, cattle, and sheep. The Nidalans also harvest timber
and mine mineral deposits, and live in relative peace, as the
Knight-Protector's warriors and clerics have all but eliminated dangerous
creatures from eastern Nidala.

DC25: The largest of the outlying settlements are Iasgair (a fishing
village), Caorann (primarily a lumberjack community), and Srath (built
around a limestone quarry.) Legends tell of a "Mistway" of moderate
reliability connecting Nidala to Northern Darkon, though many others have
reached Nidala by boat, from either Sea, arriving in one of the rivers, or
even in Lake Amenta. Rumors abound of bandits and monsters lurking in the
uncivilized West, outside the reach of Nidala's knights. The crystal clear
waters of Lake Amenta are said to conceal a gateway to a mystical kingdom.
(I took a little liberty on the Know (geo) to slip in a little of Know(Nob/Roy) just to avoid another question, roll and answer.)

And when the player shared this info with the others, here's what one said:
(Note that the whole party's interest in Nidala is mainly due to one PC's dead mother who fled the place for some reason.)
Nidala sounds like a really nice place.

I am not sure why people would leave it for anywhere else in ravenloft.
Bwahahahahaha!!! My work is done....


Thanks for the help, everyone!
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Post Reply