About my current 3rd edition games: It's an extremely high level campaign Around 14-15 level. The spellcasters use spell points, have many very good spells and the fighters have many warblade levels (from book of nine swords). All in all, the party is powerful.
The PCs have left Ravenloft looong ago. It's more like "Our castle is in the prime material and we wander around in the planes looting".
Healing surges in 3rd
As mentioned before, I have given the PCs 3 healing surges.
Not
once in 4-5 sessions has a character use a single healing surge.

OK, much of the game takes place in Ysgard, so they have fast healing. But even on the prime material the healing surges aren't needed.
Even when the PCs were hard pressed, it was either because the enemy could pawn them with "save or our of the battle" attacks, or because the enemy could deal 100+ hp damage in a round. So spending a round to heal just 1/4th of your HP when the enemy on average can deal 3/4 of your HP is a waste of a round.
Wizard & Cleric:
Heh.

Spellcasters as I like them. The wizard pawns the enemy with save or die spells, the cleric heals all damage with a touch, or becomes on par with the fighters by buffing spells.
More rewarding for the player than 4th by far. (Ask her
)
Warblades: the "offensive" fighter deals on average (after buffed by the cleric) 80-120 damage on a round. Whatever doesn't become a potato failing a save vs polymorph any object or isn't obliterated by empowered disintigrate is pulverized by the fighter.
The "defensive" fighter... well, he has never, ever dropped to less than 1/2 hp. AC hitting the roof, increadible saves etc. Does decent damage too.
A bit more interesting than 4th but not by far.
More difficult to play.
DM's difficulty: To prepare for a simple encounter, it takes me as much effort as a
whole session in 4th.
Adjusting monsters is more difficult than 4th's simple rules.
Far, far more draining than 4th for the DM.
Skill challenges: Well, they work as well as with 4th.

However, since the skill ranks a char has aren't "set" as with 4th the DM has to do more preparation for a skill challenge. That means that as usual, implementing them to 3rd takes more work for the DM. However, they enrichen the game and solve that cranky diplomacy loopholes.
I suggest you include them. Before you throw a skill challenge though, check the PCs' skill modifiers. Then you decide as to what the "CR" is for the skill challenge you built. I.e. You build the challenge for your PCs and then check what's the XP reward for it.