Timeline events post-758
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
You know, I've never really agreed before with the occasional cries to replace aging darklords. I love (most of) the darklords we've got, and I'd rather learn more about them then start anew with something less developed (*cough* Inza *cough*). But when you spell it all out like that...
yeah, those are bunch of elderly badguys we've got.
Just this weekend, when my players found out Elena had been reigning (IMC) for 121 years, they all went "ahhhhhh, I think we've found the darklord." Reluctantly, I admit that maybe it is time for some fresh blood.
yeah, those are bunch of elderly badguys we've got.
Just this weekend, when my players found out Elena had been reigning (IMC) for 121 years, they all went "ahhhhhh, I think we've found the darklord." Reluctantly, I admit that maybe it is time for some fresh blood.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Zettaijin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 670
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Himeji, Japan
I knew I was missing someone important! I thought Markov and Drakov were the only ones left.
There ya go, Malus isn't the baby anymore and Gabrielle is like Jan Brady or something.
"Ivana! Ivana! Ivana!"
There ya go, Malus isn't the baby anymore and Gabrielle is like Jan Brady or something.
"Ivana! Ivana! Ivana!"
Last edited by Zettaijin on Mon Aug 18, 2008 12:47 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Zettaijin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 670
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Himeji, Japan
The age question brings to mind how some of these "ever young" Darklords with important socio-political roles manage to circumvent the fact that their "peers" are not blessed with the same good fortune and that it may attract undue attention.
This is similar to the comic book problem of characters like Batman, Superman and Spider-Man being around for so long and are so popular and even ingrained in our popular culture that we can't hope to ever truly replace them. Yet the world changes.
Tony Stark started out as a WWII vet, but how would a generation raised during the various conflicts in Iraq deal with the idea of a character who could have been a pal of their grandparents? Keeping everything in suspended time where everything takes place in the WWII period is one idea (DC's JSA), but younger folks still want to see the timeless characters in a setting closer to their own time. They want cell phones, the Internet and video game consoles.
In RL, fans want to keep these "timeless characters" while still retaining the possibility of change and time-based evolution. We want to see kids grow up and follow in heir parents' footsteps. We want people to age and become wiser. We want to see people deal with onset of their twilight years. But, not at the sacrifice of "timeless characters", not if it means losing a beloved mortal DL.
So, what do we do? The mists perform invasive memory correction surgery? Ravenloft continuity "reboots" like that of comics for the sake of keeping some characters forever young?
This is similar to the comic book problem of characters like Batman, Superman and Spider-Man being around for so long and are so popular and even ingrained in our popular culture that we can't hope to ever truly replace them. Yet the world changes.
Tony Stark started out as a WWII vet, but how would a generation raised during the various conflicts in Iraq deal with the idea of a character who could have been a pal of their grandparents? Keeping everything in suspended time where everything takes place in the WWII period is one idea (DC's JSA), but younger folks still want to see the timeless characters in a setting closer to their own time. They want cell phones, the Internet and video game consoles.
In RL, fans want to keep these "timeless characters" while still retaining the possibility of change and time-based evolution. We want to see kids grow up and follow in heir parents' footsteps. We want people to age and become wiser. We want to see people deal with onset of their twilight years. But, not at the sacrifice of "timeless characters", not if it means losing a beloved mortal DL.
So, what do we do? The mists perform invasive memory correction surgery? Ravenloft continuity "reboots" like that of comics for the sake of keeping some characters forever young?
-
Nikolas of the Mists
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 183
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm
Yep, I think Strahd's got it right. "Replace" yourself every so often so it looks like turnaround. It might seem a little flimsy, but it keeps the common folk quiet, while the smart people already know not to think, mention or dig deeper into it.gonzoron wrote:Reluctantly, I admit that maybe it is time for some fresh blood.
That being said, Proletarian revolutions are notably ineffective when the ruling class is composed of Gods.
"I wouldn't worry too much about the Vistana with the pistols --
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Perfect analogy! Now do we take the Marvel tactic of Ultimate Ravenloft? or the DC tactic of Crisis on Infinite Ravenlofts?Zettaijin wrote:This is similar to the comic book problem of characters like Batman, Superman and Spider-Man being around for so long and are so popular and even ingrained in our popular culture that we can't hope to ever truly replace them. Yet the world changes.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
I hate to think what you had to do get that math right.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:FWIW, at the other extreme, Baron Lyron Evensong has been bored out of his skull for at least 913,125 subjective years, now.
I think only Gwydion has him beat if you want to count the estimated time before he/it entered RL. In a similar vein, we have Loht and Maeve who've been ruling over their respective courts for over 5000 years in RL alone.
Hindsight is, after all, caused by a lack of foresight.
Death rates exceeded 100% in some towns.
Charles V spent most of his reign aging.
This was beginning of Empire, when Europeans felt the need to reach out and smack someone
Death rates exceeded 100% in some towns.
Charles V spent most of his reign aging.
This was beginning of Empire, when Europeans felt the need to reach out and smack someone
- Zettaijin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 670
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Himeji, Japan
Some have it easier than others.Nikolas of the Mists wrote:Yep, I think Strahd's got it right. "Replace" yourself every so often so it looks like turnaround. It might seem a little flimsy, but it keeps the common folk quiet, while the smart people already know not to think, mention or dig deeper into it.gonzoron wrote:Reluctantly, I admit that maybe it is time for some fresh blood.
That being said, Proletarian revolutions are notably ineffective when the ruling class is composed of Gods.
The ever young mortal Darklords usually don't show much in the way of physical signs of ageing as part of their dark gift. Gabrielle and Ivana, for example, will never look a day over 20. Would their ego allow them to accept a "replacement"? I'm not sure physical signs of ageing being revoked is enough for these ladies. I suspect they'd appreciate others knowing that they never grow old in order to feed their vanity ("I'm never growing old, you on the other hand..."). Furthermore, some, like Ivana again, can't be expected to stay out of the limelight for long, unlike say the reclusive vampires von Kharkov and von Zarovich.
People will see them, a LOT of people. Replacement would involve either memory wipes or drastic physical alterations. Does Lamordia have good plastic surgeons?
Also, not everyone have convenient memory altering powers like d'Honaire who can simply charm anyone into believing whatever he says.
Azalin's Darkon is filled with enough magic and fantasy elements that the idea of an eternal king is not completely implausible (elves live for thousands of years, after all...).
How does Mordenheim deal with his 113 years of age? Wouldn't he be tempted to experiment on himself in order to gain the secrets of eternal life?
Tristen doesn't even really know he's the Darklord - fine - but that he, at 98, is as active as a man a fraction of his age ? That's a bit much to swallow even for guillible ol' Tristen.
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Perhaps what we need, to maintain plausibility, isn't fewer senior-citizen darklords: it's more unaging NPCs who aren't darklords. If there are lots of folk tales and rumors about people who don't age -- cursed souls a la the Wandering Jew, etc. -- or of secret life-extension methods that the rich and powerful hoard for themselves, then the darklords' own agelessness might not stick out like a sore thumb.
Medieval alchemists sincerely believed that immortality was attainable, if you hit upon the right formula, as did whole series of Chinese emporers. We have Ravenloft-specific precedent for rumors of "youth elixers" in Ivan's NPC write-up, the Eternity adventure from DT&DL, and the short story "Objets d' Art" in Tales of Ravenloft. And everybody who's ever heard of her knows that Madame Eva's been around longer than anyone non-undead can remember.
Yes, it's weird that such people have been around so long. But it needn't be as weird to Ravenloft's inhabitants as it is to us. They know that the supernatural exists, and is fickle in its cruelties and favors. Having your wife eaten by a werewolf isn't any less injust than having the local noble outlive you and your grandchildren.
Medieval alchemists sincerely believed that immortality was attainable, if you hit upon the right formula, as did whole series of Chinese emporers. We have Ravenloft-specific precedent for rumors of "youth elixers" in Ivan's NPC write-up, the Eternity adventure from DT&DL, and the short story "Objets d' Art" in Tales of Ravenloft. And everybody who's ever heard of her knows that Madame Eva's been around longer than anyone non-undead can remember.
Yes, it's weird that such people have been around so long. But it needn't be as weird to Ravenloft's inhabitants as it is to us. They know that the supernatural exists, and is fickle in its cruelties and favors. Having your wife eaten by a werewolf isn't any less injust than having the local noble outlive you and your grandchildren.
Last edited by Rotipher of the FoS on Mon Aug 18, 2008 2:24 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
According to the novel, Victor doesn't much care about eternal life: if he can't have Elise with him, healthy and whole, to share it, it'd just be an eternity of loneliness and guilt. He thinks that his (and Elise's) prolonged lifespan is a side-effect of some experiment he'd performed in the past, although he isn't sure which.Zettaijin wrote:How does Mordenheim deal with his 113 years of age? Wouldn't he be tempted to experiment on himself in order to gain the secrets of eternal life?
Maybe he believes his age and Malken's are tracked separately? That would make them physically closer to 49, if they timeshare the body equally. Still some gray hairs for both of them, but not quite so far into Dirty Old Man territory.Tristen doesn't even really know he's the Darklord - fine - but that he, at 98, is as active as a man a fraction of his age ? That's a bit much to swallow even for guillible ol' Tristen.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Zettaijin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 670
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Himeji, Japan
I think your idea has merit, Rotipher. However, it would take a LOT of immortal NPCs to cover up the tracks and quell potential meta-gaming.
Moreover, it's not as if every noble is going to accept having a few of his/her peers be forever young while he/she is doomed to age. Ivan certainly seems resentful about that fact and what happens if he and other powerful but evidently mortal beings decide to take the secret of their "elixir of youth"/whatever manner of trickery gave them this wonderful gift by force?
Remember that humans can associate regardless of social class and other characteristics when faced with a common foe and killing everyone isn't exactly much of an option for said foe.
And having such relatively easy access to near immortality cheapens things a bit.
The mythical un-ageing characters such as the Wandering Jew and Le Comte de St-Germain are not wealthy socialites so much as mysterious characters who appear as plot devices, red herrings and curiosities. More importantly, the ramifications of these characters living through various ages are not explored fully because they more often than not appear in self-contained stories.
Gothic fiction writers had it easy: all they had to contend with were more or less self-contained stories based on a romanticized version of a medieval past with touches of supernatural antics to spice things up. We have to deal with an ongoing world which evolves even as we sleep.
The moral is we can't have our cake and eat it too. We'll have to make sacrifices (more magic or accept the death of some important people) or else deal with the ever slightly frustrating Deus Ex Machina in the Dark Powers reworking memories time and again.
Moreover, it's not as if every noble is going to accept having a few of his/her peers be forever young while he/she is doomed to age. Ivan certainly seems resentful about that fact and what happens if he and other powerful but evidently mortal beings decide to take the secret of their "elixir of youth"/whatever manner of trickery gave them this wonderful gift by force?
Remember that humans can associate regardless of social class and other characteristics when faced with a common foe and killing everyone isn't exactly much of an option for said foe.
And having such relatively easy access to near immortality cheapens things a bit.
The mythical un-ageing characters such as the Wandering Jew and Le Comte de St-Germain are not wealthy socialites so much as mysterious characters who appear as plot devices, red herrings and curiosities. More importantly, the ramifications of these characters living through various ages are not explored fully because they more often than not appear in self-contained stories.
Gothic fiction writers had it easy: all they had to contend with were more or less self-contained stories based on a romanticized version of a medieval past with touches of supernatural antics to spice things up. We have to deal with an ongoing world which evolves even as we sleep.
The moral is we can't have our cake and eat it too. We'll have to make sacrifices (more magic or accept the death of some important people) or else deal with the ever slightly frustrating Deus Ex Machina in the Dark Powers reworking memories time and again.
- NeoTiamat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
I'm with Gonzoron on this one. I'd sort of liked the idea of Darklord churn, but never really thought about it that much. But when you spell it out like that..... ouchies.
That said, some Darklords carry their age better than others. Drakov, ironically, works as a decrepit, elderly tyrant brooding on past glories even as his health fails. Dominic D'Honaire is 62, yes, but for an elder statesman that's not too bad. It'll be decades before he starts becoming egregiously out of place.
It's the Darklord's whose youth has been part of the deal, or the ones that are excruciatingly old that have problems. Pretty much all of the pretty young women fall into the first group (while doing research for the VRS:Dopp, I realized that the beautiful, sprightly Ivana is older than me geezer of a Doppelganger). Elena is a good example of the latter.
For those people, they either need a character update (how are they handling age?), they need to be replaced, or if they're not aging, how are they covering for it? Because as is it just feels.... odd.
That said, some Darklords carry their age better than others. Drakov, ironically, works as a decrepit, elderly tyrant brooding on past glories even as his health fails. Dominic D'Honaire is 62, yes, but for an elder statesman that's not too bad. It'll be decades before he starts becoming egregiously out of place.
It's the Darklord's whose youth has been part of the deal, or the ones that are excruciatingly old that have problems. Pretty much all of the pretty young women fall into the first group (while doing research for the VRS:Dopp, I realized that the beautiful, sprightly Ivana is older than me geezer of a Doppelganger). Elena is a good example of the latter.
For those people, they either need a character update (how are they handling age?), they need to be replaced, or if they're not aging, how are they covering for it? Because as is it just feels.... odd.
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Sounds like the basis for a new secret society to me!Zettaijin wrote:Ivan certainly seems resentful about that fact and what happens if he and other powerful but evidently mortal beings decide to take the secret of their "elixir of youth"/whatever manner of trickery gave them this wonderful gift by force?
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
NeoTiamat wrote:For those people, they either need a character update (how are they handling age?), they need to be replaced, or if they're not aging, how are they covering for it? Because as is it just feels.... odd.
Well, let's see...
Alfred Timothy - Assuming his fellow werewolves actually care how old his human form looks, he can probably claim its appearance is a gift of the Wolf God ... either that, or he's just worn that shape so little, since he left his father, that it hasn't had a chance to age.
Dominic - Not old enough to need reconciling. Maybe in twenty years, it'll be a concern.
Drakov - With the hyper-macho mentality prevailing in Falkovnia, I can easily picture a popular belief that his bedding of so many, many women, in itself, has a vitality-enhancing effect. Also, the cult of personality that surrounds him might well tie Vlad's vigor to that of the nation: so long as Falkovnia remains strong, so will he.
Gabrielle - As an illegitimate part-Vistana presumably wouldn't have a birth certificate, Gabby's actual age had probably never been common knowledge. People who see her still looking so young may well believe that she'd actually killed Bakholis when she was just out of puberty, but had claimed to be several years older, knowing no one would accept an adolescent as Invidia's new leader.
Harkon Lukas - Most people probably believe the story that a bunch of different bards have adopted this name, over the years. Shapechanging powers make adopting a different identity, or making his current guise seem to "age", an easy task.
Hazlik - Sooner or later, this guy can pull his body-switching stunt, with or without committing genocide at the same time. If a DM wants to hold off on his taking over Eleni's body, he could do the same thing to some unlucky lab-rat victim, purely to extend his lifespan.
Ivana - Given her ego and the nature of her curse, there may be rumors that she really doesn't look that young at all, but cloaks herself in illusions via some sort of magic item. Servants who've accidentally caught a glimpse of her sleeping would have started this story, which she hates ... in fact, the stories about Vital Venom may have originally been started by Ivana, to refute the notion that she's a hideous old crone.
Jacqueline & Louise Renier - Definitely a problem. There are old, hidden caches of magic underneath Pont-a-Museau, according to Scholar of Decay; perhaps it's suspected that the sisters found something down there, many years ago, that extends their lives? (Speculating about what it was wouldn't be wise, of course....
Malocchio - While looking too young will never be a problem for the Dukkar, the circumstances of his origin would be looked on with a big dose of skepticism by anyone who doubts the existence of fiends. Lots of people outside Invidia probably take it for granted that his claim to the Aderre name is spurrious, as he's obviously too old to be Gabrielle's child ... but then, there's nothing new about usurpers rising to power in Invidia.
Mordenheim - This one's best excused by the nature of the domain, and of his curse that his discoveries will forever remain obscure. As they already believe he creates life, residents of Lamordia might well suspect that he can extend his own; however, their concommitant belief that his experiments have rendered him insane, and their DP-imposed tendency to forget all of his scientific accomplishments, bars them from trying to take advantage of this.
Tristan/Malken - Again, these guys may account for their own unaging state by assuming their years are counted separately. As for popular views on their longevity, the Hiregaards' long lifespans can't account for it alone; my bet is that Tristan is suspected of using some sort of alchemy to extend his life, as he's surely looked into potential alchemical cures for his "other side". Malken's continued appearances will have been written off as a criminal dynasty which hands down the name.
Von Kharkov - Aside from stealing Strahd's inheritance schtick, Urik may actually decide to "marry" Lady Adelaine someday, so his next identity can be a "half-elf" and last longer. Just a thought for the future; for now, coming back as his son seems to be working.
Sound good...?
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow

