Anyway, I was playing Shadow of the Colossus, and after finishing it-again, after all, it's a short game-I realized, "Wouldn't Dormin be a great patron for a 4E Warlock? After all, he's a pretty dark being, but none of his actions seem to suggest him being evil, just amoral-a natural force, if you would." And lo and behold, this character popped into my head, just waiting to be played:
Math, Templar of Shadow, aka, the Servant of Dormin.
Background: The story of Math starts long before his parents were born, in a far-off world. There, Dormin, an ancient primordial prince, was sealed in a strange valley for fear of his powers. Though his imprisonment was not to last, it was long enough for his priests to die out, and as he was not privy to the destruction of the universe, he dared not show his true form within it.
So, Dormin wandered the universe, looking for a champion, one that would serve as his tool to bring about a new faith in his name. He found it, in the form of Math, an adolescent human desperately looking for a purpose.
As a child, Math never really fit in his home village. Indeed, he was an outcast, divined at birth to have a cursed fate, to be an enemy of the gods. Although his parents did not believe it, most of the town blamed him for their ills, from simple crop failures to monster attacks. He became an exile within his own home, a pariah lost in darkness. It was there that Dormin found him, wallowing in his own misery at his fate. And so, Dormin came to Math, and said:
"We are the guardians of the unknown, the lost and angry. Accept our patronage, and we will give you a measure of our power." And Math accepted.
And so, Math became the Templar of Shadows, a warrior of the night...
Personality: Math embraces his sinister image as an infernal pact warlock. Since he is an enemy of the gods, he might as well enjoy being one. Anyone who knows him realizes the "irredemably evil" part, however, is simply not true. Math embodies the darkness, true, but in it's kind, protective aspect: He would rather be the nebula that life-giving suns are born in rather then the abyss of death. This is not to say he doesn't have a, pardon the expression "dark" side. He seems to believe his own suffering gives him a right to self-pity, and he can be a bit extreme in his methods of protecting others. That said, he is a kind and gentle soul who would willingly die if that would protect the lives of others. All in all, the perfect priest of the Cult of Dormin.
So do you think this guy would fit in a Ravenloft game?
And before you ask: "Math" refers not to the subject, but "Math fab Mathonwy", the uncle of Gwydion in Celtic myth.
The irony is not unintended.
Grade-A-4E-Character: Math, Warlock of Darkness
Grade-A-4E-Character: Math, Warlock of Darkness
I am The Archangel of Night.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
Contradictory backstory. He's not amoral if he's capable of self-sacrifice. To be the enemy of all gods sounds fairly evil as many of those gods offer succor to innocents, not to mention the infernal pact part.
Justifying violence and extremism based off of a selfish notion of self-pity is evil. Many war criminals have done that. Many evil people throughout history had their soft side and either cared deeply for pets, family or their state- it still doesn't negate their evil acts. And yes, cruelty towards other evil beings is still cruelty.
I'll put it this way- the difference between a good person killing an evil being and an evil person doing so is that one does so as quickly as possible without joy while the other either does it slowly or painfully and may take joy in it. Your char sounds like it would be the latter. Also sounds emo to quote what the kids say these days.
He'd be a good character for a forgotten realms or ebberon campaign but in ravenloft I find him emotionally crippled person using that as an excuse to treat others as he pleases for good or ill while in alliance with an evil being to give him the power to do so.
Justifying violence and extremism based off of a selfish notion of self-pity is evil. Many war criminals have done that. Many evil people throughout history had their soft side and either cared deeply for pets, family or their state- it still doesn't negate their evil acts. And yes, cruelty towards other evil beings is still cruelty.
I'll put it this way- the difference between a good person killing an evil being and an evil person doing so is that one does so as quickly as possible without joy while the other either does it slowly or painfully and may take joy in it. Your char sounds like it would be the latter. Also sounds emo to quote what the kids say these days.
He'd be a good character for a forgotten realms or ebberon campaign but in ravenloft I find him emotionally crippled person using that as an excuse to treat others as he pleases for good or ill while in alliance with an evil being to give him the power to do so.
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
"Amoral", not "immoral". Amoral implies rejecting society's view of what's right, which isn't necessarily the same thing as what's really right. If this guy was arbitrarily marked as "born wicked" because of some bogus regional custom, it makes sense that he wouldn't have much faith in mainstream society's judgement. IOW, he could be Chaotic by 3E standards, but not necessarily Chaotic Evil.Archedius wrote:He's not amoral if he's capable of self-sacrifice. To be the enemy of all gods sounds fairly evil as many of those gods offer succor to innocents, not to mention the infernal pact part.
As for the "enemy of all gods" part, the impression I get is that it's a label other people hung on him, not something he chose for himself. Saying that he's come to enjoy the image doesn't seem much different from Elphaba in Wicked contrarily reveling in her "Wicked Witch of the West" title, or Alice Cooper singing about being shunned for his reputation in No More Mr. Nice Guy.
Yes, that's true. But I don't see anywhere in Leleil's post where it says this Math character actually is cruel. A bit spooky, trigger-happy and uncompromising, maybe, but the same things could be said of a lot of PC heroes.Justifying violence and extremism based off of a selfish notion of self-pity is evil. Many war criminals have done that. Many evil people throughout history had their soft side and either cared deeply for pets, family or their state- it still doesn't negate their evil acts. And yes, cruelty towards other evil beings is still cruelty.
Personally, I like the character. Maybe not in Ravenloft, but only because Dormin's creed seems like the sort which, like the faith of Belenus, would swiftly become corrupted -- hence, genuinely evil -- in the Land of Mists.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
I would disagree, amorality implies that the char doesn't believe morality exists. Immorality is where a person acknowledges a system of morality but goes against it.
What this means is that his character wouldn't even believe in the moral system that governs the demiplane and thus not quite fitting with the gothic background.
This still goes back to my original point of there being contradiction here- or perhaps a mislabeling on the part of the OP. If he'll sacrifice himself and act in the manner of an anti-hero = he has morals. It could be argued depending on his actions (of which we have little knowledge) that he could very well be immoral. If he was a sociopath that might smooth this out.
BTW- what are we supposed to think when he's described as a dark personality that's wrapped up in himself in combination with being trigger-happy? That, at least to me implies a more punative attitude. Regardless there is much room for corruption.
What this means is that his character wouldn't even believe in the moral system that governs the demiplane and thus not quite fitting with the gothic background.
This still goes back to my original point of there being contradiction here- or perhaps a mislabeling on the part of the OP. If he'll sacrifice himself and act in the manner of an anti-hero = he has morals. It could be argued depending on his actions (of which we have little knowledge) that he could very well be immoral. If he was a sociopath that might smooth this out.
BTW- what are we supposed to think when he's described as a dark personality that's wrapped up in himself in combination with being trigger-happy? That, at least to me implies a more punative attitude. Regardless there is much room for corruption.
Sorry. I meant to say he's an anti-hero who dosen't belive in conventional morality, not that he doesn't belive in morality at all.
And yes, he has a dark personality, and he is trigger happy, but the latter only on the battlefield-he's perfectly calm, if a bit cynical about other people's motives for helping the party off it.
By "extreme", I meant to say that if a person shows definite hostility or he is decived, he won't hold back-no moral imperative to not coup-de-grace here, folks.
And yes, he has a dark personality, and he is trigger happy, but the latter only on the battlefield-he's perfectly calm, if a bit cynical about other people's motives for helping the party off it.
By "extreme", I meant to say that if a person shows definite hostility or he is decived, he won't hold back-no moral imperative to not coup-de-grace here, folks.
I am The Archangel of Night.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
ah k, clears this up a good bit: ) If I seem persnickety it's only because that's the best way to iron out chars (I do the same thing with NPCs I make). When you attack a creation from every angle so to speak, it's better off for it.
Perhaps if you relegated this individual to myhtological or 'saintly' status within his God's religion. You could then work in sightings of him as a portent to this cult, regardless of if it's actually him, an imposter or a fabrication. He could also be an outsider (which would suit him well). Those are a few ways I've thought of to incorporate him within the setting.
Perhaps if you relegated this individual to myhtological or 'saintly' status within his God's religion. You could then work in sightings of him as a portent to this cult, regardless of if it's actually him, an imposter or a fabrication. He could also be an outsider (which would suit him well). Those are a few ways I've thought of to incorporate him within the setting.


