I did like the new "Heaven's Bones" novel; no, it's not Ravenloft as we remember it, but isn't ANY new (reasonable) Ravenloft material better than NO Ravenloft?
RAVENLOFT IS BACK.
- Catman Jim
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 859
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 12:58 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Sunny Florida
This is good news, and something I would actually pay for, perhaps just for a single issue of the Insider.
I did like the new "Heaven's Bones" novel; no, it's not Ravenloft as we remember it, but isn't ANY new (reasonable) Ravenloft material better than NO Ravenloft?
I did like the new "Heaven's Bones" novel; no, it's not Ravenloft as we remember it, but isn't ANY new (reasonable) Ravenloft material better than NO Ravenloft?
I only wish I had retired sooner!
A new domain is one thing; but we're talking about the prospect of Ravenloft being folded into the core! It's an altogether different order of magnitude. But what if the unthinkable happens? What if Ravenloft won't fold?
What if the engines can't take it? What if the core starts to overheat? Can it be shut down or jettisoned before meltdown occurs?
What if the engines can't take it? What if the core starts to overheat? Can it be shut down or jettisoned before meltdown occurs?
- kourkenko
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 131
- Joined: Tue Jan 24, 2006 9:39 am
- Location: Warsawa (Poland) / Troyes (France)
my only answer will be that Ravenloft is a game...
And you can do what you want with a game... the rulebooks are here just for the fluf, nothing else, and the dices are here to make noise behind the DM screen (thank you Mr. G gygax for this wonderful words ^^).
I play Ravenloft since the I6, i was really young at this time, but the memories of my numerous death in our numerous try to kick strahd has always follow me... So, when i'd read EtcR, i'd kick what don't please me. If the Halfing vistanis, a pirate strahd and a rakshasa (in the web supplement) suit a group of players, better for them ! It don't suit me. so i doesn't use them...
Do the same !!! We have no need to reject what WotC make. We have just to decide if we'll use this or not...
To close my post, i will add a little thing. Ravenloft need new blood to keep existing or we will not attract new blood by rejecting every time all new concerning Ravenloft. If ravenloft, in 4th Edition have a mood which do not fit you, don't use it but, please, don't reject it.
If a neebie come here, what is he going to see ?
A lot of old players who don't adapt... And what will be ther reaction ?
You know the answer...
Now i ask a little question : it's really what you want ?
And you can do what you want with a game... the rulebooks are here just for the fluf, nothing else, and the dices are here to make noise behind the DM screen (thank you Mr. G gygax for this wonderful words ^^).
I play Ravenloft since the I6, i was really young at this time, but the memories of my numerous death in our numerous try to kick strahd has always follow me... So, when i'd read EtcR, i'd kick what don't please me. If the Halfing vistanis, a pirate strahd and a rakshasa (in the web supplement) suit a group of players, better for them ! It don't suit me. so i doesn't use them...
Do the same !!! We have no need to reject what WotC make. We have just to decide if we'll use this or not...
To close my post, i will add a little thing. Ravenloft need new blood to keep existing or we will not attract new blood by rejecting every time all new concerning Ravenloft. If ravenloft, in 4th Edition have a mood which do not fit you, don't use it but, please, don't reject it.
If a neebie come here, what is he going to see ?
A lot of old players who don't adapt... And what will be ther reaction ?
You know the answer...
Now i ask a little question : it's really what you want ?
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
It's unclear from the quote whether it means that the Ravenloft setting will be folded into the 4E rules' cosmology, or whether the larger game-implementation concepts that form a framework for Ravenloft -- Fear/Horror/Madness checks, customized monsters and NPCs that are more than just stat-blocks, the evoking of dread and uncertainty in one's players, etc -- are being incorporated into the new system, so 4E DMs can use them in their campaigns regardless of setting. As 4E is slanted so heavily to D&D-newbies, it could be that the Ravenloft title (and case-study domain) will simply be used to give newcomers a "How To Spook Your Gaming Buddies" lesson.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Well lets fight this wrong perception by first not saying it, à la Lennon killer namekourkenko wrote:Ravenloft fans are the worst of all...
To me, that Ravenloft is a more subtle realm explains why many fans will jump to the barricade when thing go really wrong - which isn't very often IMHO.
What made fan irks in the last years? Sheriff Von Potato, EtCR, CoD, and a few other very rare things.
Doesn't say we are the meanest, just that we know how things should/could be
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
Doesn't really matter what they do,,,,,, Ravenloft lives here on our site!Nathan of the FoS wrote:And if "folding it into the core" means they tell us "This is where Ravenloft exists in the new cosmology", that's nothing to cry in our beer over.
In a word, they can hardly "ruin" the setting with one magazine article. So let's not get too worked up about this.
I never said noone should have it- I'm saying that I don't think Wizards can do it right. I must add that I was under the impression that they were doing an overview of what they want the basic setting to be.
If it's a new domain and basic rules for 4th ed that's fine. If they eventually redo the setting, it will have an impact on what happens at this site- even if people don't realize it. If Wizards does Ravenloft redux, I can only hope they do it in a way acceptable to the fans that have been around for a few years (or decade + in some peoples' cases).
If we get new blood, I want the new blood to know the special qualities and roleplaying possibilities the setting offers. I don't want them to think of Ravenloft as simply a place to slaughter scary monsters. We know that's not the case, but it will be hard to get it out of their heads if that's their first impression of Ravenloft. That is what I rail against : )
BTW, I know I'm very opinionated. It's what I do. My previous post may have been a bit heated in tone, but that's because I took offense at us being called 'the worst fans' which is clearly not the case.
Our specific tastes and preferences are what help make these forums the richest source of campaign material I have ever come across.
If it's a new domain and basic rules for 4th ed that's fine. If they eventually redo the setting, it will have an impact on what happens at this site- even if people don't realize it. If Wizards does Ravenloft redux, I can only hope they do it in a way acceptable to the fans that have been around for a few years (or decade + in some peoples' cases).
If we get new blood, I want the new blood to know the special qualities and roleplaying possibilities the setting offers. I don't want them to think of Ravenloft as simply a place to slaughter scary monsters. We know that's not the case, but it will be hard to get it out of their heads if that's their first impression of Ravenloft. That is what I rail against : )
BTW, I know I'm very opinionated. It's what I do. My previous post may have been a bit heated in tone, but that's because I took offense at us being called 'the worst fans' which is clearly not the case.
- DasSoviet
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 111
- Joined: Tue Aug 12, 2008 7:08 am
- Location: Saudi Oilberta, Canuckistan
- Contact:
I'm assuming you haven't visited the Candlekeep or Planeswalker forums in the since 4th was released, my friend, or you wouldn't be making that claimkourkenko wrote:Ravenloft fans are the worst of all...
Actually, I think the modular nature of Ravenloft, the ability to easily ignore the portions you don't like, and add entire continents to the setting without disrupting it's flow, makes Ravenloft fans probably one of the more approachable groups... simply because, if they don't like it, they'll just pretend it doesn't exist.
But to be perfectly honest, the less WotC does to Ravenloft, the better. After seeing what they did to Forgotten Realms, the setting that drew me into DnD in the first place, and seeing what they're not going to do with Eberron, the setting my current group favours the most, I'm really dreading what they might do to the Realms of Dread to make them more newbie/gamer friendly.
Still, as I don't plan on changing away from 3.5 for some good long years, it doesn't matter. I can take a new domain and use it's ideas in my game far more than I can use a post Spellp...er... Time of Unparallelled Darkness Ravenolft.
Greetings, Citizens! A reminder: Happiness is mandatory. Those not enjoying themselves shall find themselves terminated.
-
Creepy Old Woman
- Conspirator

- Posts: 33
- Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 6:24 am
- kourkenko
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 131
- Joined: Tue Jan 24, 2006 9:39 am
- Location: Warsawa (Poland) / Troyes (France)
for the sentence "the ravenloft's fans are the worst of all", you can see it on multiples post in the wizards board... I know that ravenloft is a much more mature game than any other of Wotc or the 4th edition herself (the manga look don't suit me ^^). But it's a little elitist for me to keep our point of vu so rigid, no ?
For the forgotten realms, you will not approve my opinion but i like the changes...
Why ? because the realms was in the second and third edition the only place where you can kick a tree and a level 20 wizard will fall at your feets. The potency of the Ubber magic users always minimized the importance of the players
When i play for the first time this game, i feel only useless. Why the world need a noob level 1 when every wizard everywhere is level 20 ?
Look at every book of the FR. Ubber wizards will appear everywhere... Not ubber rogue or warrior, no, only wizard.
I find this really really boring... and yes, I had a DM which loved the big wizards...
Yes i like what they had do for the realms
And for the planewalker and candlekeep site, i never see a mention of there fans in the wizards boards (can be because I go seldom there...)
Yes 4th edition is not my taste but Pirate strahd and halfing vistani is always better that no Ravenloft at all. Myself, i wouldn't switch my ravenloft campaign to the 4th, i don't want. I will use the pathfinder rules.
As i'd say, it's just my opinion. I don't approve, but i don't reject.
(i reject only the dragonborn, they are inadapted and inopportunely for any game)
For the forgotten realms, you will not approve my opinion but i like the changes...
Why ? because the realms was in the second and third edition the only place where you can kick a tree and a level 20 wizard will fall at your feets. The potency of the Ubber magic users always minimized the importance of the players
When i play for the first time this game, i feel only useless. Why the world need a noob level 1 when every wizard everywhere is level 20 ?
Look at every book of the FR. Ubber wizards will appear everywhere... Not ubber rogue or warrior, no, only wizard.
I find this really really boring... and yes, I had a DM which loved the big wizards...
Yes i like what they had do for the realms
And for the planewalker and candlekeep site, i never see a mention of there fans in the wizards boards (can be because I go seldom there...)
Yes 4th edition is not my taste but Pirate strahd and halfing vistani is always better that no Ravenloft at all. Myself, i wouldn't switch my ravenloft campaign to the 4th, i don't want. I will use the pathfinder rules.
As i'd say, it's just my opinion. I don't approve, but i don't reject.
Last edited by kourkenko on Fri Sep 12, 2008 8:54 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Dion of the Fraternity
- Lurker Maximus

- Posts: 1092
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
- Location: Baguio City, Philippines
- Contact:

