RAVENLOFT IS BACK.
- BigBadQDaddy
- Champion of the Maiden

- Posts: 1751
- Joined: Tue Sep 06, 2005 5:47 pm
- Location: The Dread Realm of Minnesota
Asterisk. He's an ill-planned, ill-thought-out blip on the radar in a training product done by some second-tier WotC hacks. He has no place in my campaigns, and from what I can see from online discussion, by general consensus he has no place in the Fraternity either.Dion of the Fraternity wrote:Pirate Strahd is here to stay, for better or for worse.
What dynamic, exactly, dictates that FoS marches in lockstep with Wizards? Because it must have been a recent development indeed...
-
Creepy Old Woman
- Conspirator

- Posts: 33
- Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 6:24 am
What dynamic, exactly, dictates that FoS marches in lockstep with Wizards?
Nothing, of course, except that anything put out by WoTC is considered canon while anything put out by fans are unofficial fanon material. But that's a distinction useful only to purists or official record makers. A DM has his or her prerogative to pick and choose the fluff to be used in an RL campaign, as always.
Having said that, the Shada-Kai of Shadowfell will make some pretty cool ninjas in RL.
Nothing, of course, except that anything put out by WoTC is considered canon while anything put out by fans are unofficial fanon material. But that's a distinction useful only to purists or official record makers. A DM has his or her prerogative to pick and choose the fluff to be used in an RL campaign, as always.
Having said that, the Shada-Kai of Shadowfell will make some pretty cool ninjas in RL.
- Lord Soth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 264
- Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
- Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus
Dion of the Fraternity wrote:Pirate Strahd is here to stay, for better or for worse.
You never know. Just because they made him look like that in EtCR, it doesn't mean it's written in stone and that they can never change him back (For an example of that, compare Elminster in 2E, Elminster in 3E, and Elminster in 4E). But we'll know for sure come January, as Strahd is going to be statted out in Open Grave: Secrets of the Undead (while Sunsword/Bright Blade is appearing in Adventurer's Vault).
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
This is a murky distinction though. Again, the EtCR handling of Strahd* is a good example of this. It's clear to me that the Fraternity has looked at that and decided mostly against using that. Not in any official capacity, of course, but just as a quiet "Ahem... under the carpet" sort of way.Creepy Old Woman wrote:What dynamic, exactly, dictates that FoS marches in lockstep with Wizards?
Nothing, of course, except that anything put out by WoTC is considered canon
This isn't a rant merely against Wizards, though they're the most recent publisher of bad canon material. TSR had plenty of badly thought out darklords, for example. Even White Wolf had a few misses with Champions of Darkness and the like. FoS has had no problem in saying we're going to apply band-aids where necessary - and to just walk away from that material when the material is so bad that they can't fix it.
Conversely, the excellent backstory for the Illithid God-Brain is fanmade, but it works so well that the FoS (rightly) promotes it at every opportunity.
So the canon-fanon distinction is, as you say, of limited applicability. People should be encouraged to go with whatever works best for them. I think FoS should give WotC's output as much weight as they give anything TSR did for 2E, and as much weight as they do for fan made materials.
For us, we may not be professional game testers, and we may not have the art and layout resources that WotC does. But we do have a regard for the setting that goes beyond economic gain and mass appeal, and we are willing to put in the creativity and thought that comes of a love for a favored gaming setting. As FoS gets no endorsement from WotC and is a completely independent site, I'd say its function and loyalties should lie much closer to the informal sounding board for fan ideas than as a mouthpiece for WotC's stuff.
* I have nothing against metrosexual elven pirates. Some of my best friends are metrosexual elven pirates and they know I don't mean this as a slur. We drink beers together and slap each other platonically on the butt in a manly way. Do not call me to complain.
- Lord Soth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 264
- Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
- Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus
This is a murky distinction though. Again, the EtCR handling of Strahd*
That's not a valid comparison, though, as that has no bearing on canon. That was a one-off reimagining of an old adventure for 3E rules, not a revamped campaign setting book. It wasn't intended as a continuation of the older Ravenloft line nor as the launchpoint of a newer Ravenloft line. It's a completely standalone product which future Ravenloft products are in no way beholden to.
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Fair point, and my answer is: who makes that distinction? And on a larger scale, why is this latest Ravenloft announcement any different?Lord Soth wrote:It's a completely standalone product which future Ravenloft products are in no way beholden to.
If it's not, and that's the view I hold, then the Fraternity should not feel beholden to give it any more special treatment or deference than they did EtCR. Of course, if it's really good stuff then use it, in the same way they can refer to really good fan made stuff. But if not, there shouldn't be any assumption that FoS has any contractual or ethical obligation to adopt somebody else's lesser works just because that somebody happens to be WotC.
Remember that we didn't completely ignore EtCR either. If people came to this forum asking for help on running it, the FoS gave them ample help and suggestions. (This is one reason I love this place. Many other forums have the same purist-populist factional thing that we do but much more fierce, and a newcomer might get verbally abused there. FoS is a far more civilized forum.) But it was treated as an optional product that didn't impact the setting as we know it.
- Lord Soth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 264
- Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
- Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus
I'm not arguing that a person, FoS, etc, must use whatever the official canon is. I'm just pointing out that A) EtCR isn't official canon, and B) That future official canon isn't beholden to it.
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Where does it say this?Lord Soth wrote:I'm just pointing out that A) EtCR isn't official canon,
I'm not asking this to challenge what you're saying. I'm just seeking clarification, because I may have missed something in the release notes etc.
I'm also sensitive to labelling things as canon or non canon ever since I got burned for asserting that House On Gryphon Hill was non canon. Apparently, that's wrong. The fact that TSR never directly alluded to the events there and sort of retconned it away in a miasma of vagaries apparently is not sufficient to say it's non canon. (!)
Update and edit 2014-02-13: Ryan Naylor has stated that HoGH is non-canon. So evidently I'm not completely insane. Yet.
Last edited by HuManBing on Thu Feb 13, 2014 5:33 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
To be fair to the EtCR Strahd he's never described with a blue jacket and long Lestat hair. That was the artist going with the Dragon cover of a couple years earlier, which was just someone working for hire likely with little reference. Neither artist likely was told what Strahd HAD to look like and neither was likely to buy a 20 buck campaign setting from eBay to make their monthly money.
Look at the cover where they obviously did a homage to the original which is much, much closer.
While I'm *hoping* they asked around the office and got the resident Ravenloft fan to design the new domain (or make their homebrew canon) I'm not holding my breath for quality, although I'm praying my free subscription to Dragon lasts until the end of October....
Look at the cover where they obviously did a homage to the original which is much, much closer.
While I'm *hoping* they asked around the office and got the resident Ravenloft fan to design the new domain (or make their homebrew canon) I'm not holding my breath for quality, although I'm praying my free subscription to Dragon lasts until the end of October....
- Lord Soth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 264
- Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
- Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus
I haven't seen anything that doesn't state it's canon, but likewise, I haven't seen anything that states it is. And given the nature of the book, I see no reason to believe it is.
It was designed as a somewhat generic adventure which could be inserted into any campaign setting. Its very nature should indicate it's not canon, as it was designed to be slotted into Forgotten Realms, Eberron, and even D20 Modern. Yet the events of EtCR aren't canonical in any of those settings. It certainly isn't canonical in the Ravenloft setting as it isn't written as as adventure for the "Ravenloft campaign setting". It's an adaptation of an adventure which was written before there even was a Ravenloft setting.
I haven't seen anything which states it's acknowledged canon. No published works reference it as accepted canon. And if it's not stated to be acknowledged canon, then it's not. That may change, but as of right now, it's as much official Ravenloft canon as Keep on the Shadowfell. Think of it as "Ultimate Castle Ravenloft", like the Ultimates line for Marvel Comics. It exists in its own universe altogether.
Hmm, so in other words, my statement wasn't as factual as I originally came off. Well, I am Lord Soth, so one should always expect me to come off imperious.
But hard fact or no, I think my position is the most sensible one. Of course, next months Dragon may very well treat EtCR as canon. We shall see. But yeah, canon or no, one can always do whatever they like with a setting. I just think it's a bit early to worry about EtCR being considered canon just yet. Though if I'm proved wrong next month, feel free to heap a healthy amount of "I told you so's" on me. I promise not to retaliate... immediately. 
It was designed as a somewhat generic adventure which could be inserted into any campaign setting. Its very nature should indicate it's not canon, as it was designed to be slotted into Forgotten Realms, Eberron, and even D20 Modern. Yet the events of EtCR aren't canonical in any of those settings. It certainly isn't canonical in the Ravenloft setting as it isn't written as as adventure for the "Ravenloft campaign setting". It's an adaptation of an adventure which was written before there even was a Ravenloft setting.
I haven't seen anything which states it's acknowledged canon. No published works reference it as accepted canon. And if it's not stated to be acknowledged canon, then it's not. That may change, but as of right now, it's as much official Ravenloft canon as Keep on the Shadowfell. Think of it as "Ultimate Castle Ravenloft", like the Ultimates line for Marvel Comics. It exists in its own universe altogether.
Hmm, so in other words, my statement wasn't as factual as I originally came off. Well, I am Lord Soth, so one should always expect me to come off imperious.
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
So was Sheriff Von Potato, then! Quite a changeDion of the Fraternity wrote:Pirate Strahd is here to stay, for better or for worse. So with the dragonborn. Change is good, and I welcome change.
In any fan discussion about any setting, there are things universally hated by fans. I hope they won't get in another wildy creative direction.
I welcome change too, I just hope it will keep in the spirit, like the other changes to the setting that were brought in 3e were in tone with what people expect from the setting.
New vampire strains is cool In Ravenloft, Green and Purple Tentacled Martians Aberations from Hell isn't. Why? There is a good taste line somewhere... Change is fun, unless it goes below said line.
Dragonborn IMHO? Not sure, unless it's very very rare like gnomes are in some domains. Design choice for a human based setting. But as a core race in RL? Don't think so.
Joël
Last edited by Joël of the FoS on Fri Sep 12, 2008 4:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)

