False memories, dreams, and other psychological horrors.

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
Shadow
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 79
Joined: Wed Jun 09, 2004 5:13 pm
Location: Japan

False memories, dreams, and other psychological horrors.

Post by Shadow »

I've become interested in the psychological horror genre lately. Specifically, the whole reality altering minf***k style found in a lot of science fiction/horror (especially seen in sci-fi author Phillip Dick's stories). While scary monsters and depraved villains can be scary for a party, they are nothing compared to learning a horrifying truth about yourself or what you thought to be real. For example, what if a PC learned that several if not all of his memories were fake and was forced to question his identity? What if the party found themselves facing weird dreams and even weirder waking reality, only to start questioning which world was the dream and which was reality? A player defeats an evil clone of himself and starts having weird dreams of being created by a necromancer, leading him to question if he really was the clone.

These psychologic twists make great plots for sci-fi and horror. I can easily see these elements fitting into Ravenloft. We already have a few in the setting (e.g. the Nightmare Court / Lemot Juste). However, to really run such a plot in a game would be very difficult. The players would have to give the DM permission to mess with their character's background ("No, your memories of working as a mercenary are false...your character is really a clone."). Also players who can really get into a twisted plot are needed; this would never work with a "beer and pretzel" game. Could such plots work?
In the darkness of night look toward the stars
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

They'd only work if you inform the players what sort of weirdness they'll be faced with, prior to the campaign's start. Let them know that you might spring such shockers on them in advance -- you needn't say exactly which plot-twists you're considering, but warn them to expect things to happen a la psychological thrillers -- and check that they're still interested in trying such a scenario, before you actually start the game. So long as they've had advance warning, they won't be as inclined to take it personally if you muck with their PCs' heads.

Certainly the players should use different characters for a campaign in which their PCs' backstories may be meddled with, so their "old favorites" from other games won't be unilaterally retconned by the DM. You might even want to meet out-of-game with each player, separate from the rest, to jointly work out their new PC's (apparent) backstory ... and to conspire with those you choose to assign a hidden agenda, if that's the sort of plot you care to run. :wink:

The doppelganger netbook discusses several aspects of psychological horror in RPGs in its DM Appendix, and it contains some salient abilities, strategies, and Madness effects that would be useful in conducting such a campaign. You can download it from our Library, if you're interested.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Yeah, I agree with Rotipher. It's the sort of hing that sounds great to a DM, but is a hard sell to players. Here are a few ways I've seen this sort of thing work well, with Darkon's memory loss:

I believe it was Deepshadow who started a campaign with a bunch of clones waking up in Azalin's lab with no memories. They had to figure out who they were cloned from and why.

Then I think HuManBing had similar ideas here: http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... php?t=2542
I believe he ran with one of them.

Basically, the idea in both cases is to start the PC's with nothing and build up together. So no carefully crafted background is negated by the DM's fiat.


In my campaign, I did a sort of reverse idea. The party was investigating a string of disappearances in Viaki. Once they tracked down the source and were about to enter the lair of the Kargat, I had the players set aside their characters. Then I gave the pre-generated characters to play for a bit, so they could "understand what the victims were going through." Eventually it was revealed that these pre-gen characters were actually their own characters with altered memories. This way, I got to do the mindf--- without invalidating their own characters, only my own pre-gens.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Desertrising
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 230
Joined: Thu Nov 11, 2004 9:30 am
Location: Cedar City Utah
Contact:

Post by Desertrising »

I have actually tried this type of thing before and have found that more often than not players respond pretty negatively to it all. Maybe with some advance warning as suggested by Rotipher, this could be overcome. From my experience the last thing you want to do is suddenly spring it on them.

I personally don't understand it. Times when it has happened with me I have found it quite enjoyable (in game of course). I think the reason for the negative reaction is that it violates some kind of trust issue. Maybe players don't like it because they all believe that DnD should be fair on some level and using mind games that are all in the GM's hands takes that fairness away.

My thoughts anywhoo
Vote Cthulhu! At least then we know we are going to get screwed.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

An approach that works in the (excellent) Planescape Torment PC game was to allow the PCs some limited ability to influence the "past" that you reveal to them. Give them some key points where they can decide what happened in the past, and then tweak their current stats and alignment to fit it.

This works best if they start off literally as a blank slate - they've lost all their memories, and they have no new ones to replace them with. The game I'm currently running (though on hiatus) has four PCs who all have horrific scars on their bodies, and they've taken up with a Darkonian private agency which basically exploits the memory problem by giving victims some safety and guidance, and doing some research into their pasts... in return for unquestioning service for a certain number of years.

The PCs get a series of flashbacks that firmly place them in Falkovnia. Some things they can't influence (like how they got their scars) but others they can, and they can get certain XP benefits or skills/feats/spells etc. if they make certain choices.

The players liked these, but admitted they were best used at the ends of "present day" adventures, otherwise they tended to distract from the Agency mission at hand. The last that has happened in the dreams is that they've fought off a Falkfuhrer raid (when they could have decided to run) but have been taken captive and are force-marching to the Prison at Lekar.
Shadow
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 79
Joined: Wed Jun 09, 2004 5:13 pm
Location: Japan

Post by Shadow »

Yes, I wouldn't run such an adventure without making sure that the players 1: were aware that such aplot twist may be coming, 2: were on board with the idea. There is nothing worse for a game than players getting angry because they feel that their characters have been messed with. That said, has anyone run a successful psychological horror game (more than one short scenario)? If so, what ideas did you use? How did it work out?
In the darkness of night look toward the stars
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

The closest I've come is having the flashbacks of their abuse and trauma at the hands of the Falkovnians lead to some Madness/Horror checks. This has resulted in one character having an aversion to the sight of blood.

The traumatic experience was actually rather interesting in that it did not have any actual threat to herself. She had found a grievously injured soldier (it turns out, Falkovnian, but she didn't know that at that early stage), and she had healed him and he was slowly getting better. Then her "allies" in the flashback - who were oppressed demihumans in the wildlands - came up and ritualistically surrounded the Falkovnian and slit his throat while she was still cradling his head in her lap. She ended up covered in blood.

Perversely, because of the racial hatred between the militaristic Falkovnians and the tribal demihumans, the rest of the demihuman tribes viewed her as receiving a great honor in being baptized with the blood of a "despicable jackboot". But it didn't stop the horror of her seeing that all her best healing was worth nothing, and that her allies had just slaughtered her patient in cold blood.
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Post by A G Thing »

The closest I had was when the paladin of my group was the only survivor of a botched raid on a vampire mansion.

When he woke up he found himself in a church and surrounded by his old comrades who he saw die for the most part.

This however was just the result of a failed madness check and I had the other players in on the whole thing.

Meanwhile an imagined vampire that had been a cleric of the morning lord that the Paladin was iching to kill was attacking him in his delusion (dealing subdual damage that I claimed as real) and his friends he imagined were aiding in reinforcing the delusion. Of course durring this time one of the more corrupt but affluent nobles that the group had interfeared with on the previous trip decided to attack the Paladin while he was alone and recovering.

So the church/hospital staff after sign of the first real attack which was bearly foiled, decided to pettition for aid from passing adventurers and thus the new characters came in to protect the mentally suffering paladin, while the assassins where planning their next attack.

One by one I had each of the players controling the illusionary versions of their old characters act or do something to contradict them being there at all and as the Paladin managed to disbelieve them they seemed to be pulled away into the darkness again by the vampire. Mix in the fact that occasionally the vampire attacked and a real dagger or such coated with poison was left in the wound and my paladin did not know what to do or think...

The group rallied and killed off the assassins except for one and the paladin was utterly confused and near death but trying to force his character to accept that he misread the situation...

This helped create a stronger bond between them and I think it worked out well but it is the closest I have tried to pulling the whole false circumstance thing in a Ravenloft game...

In other games I have had the characters I wanted to drive in a certain direction have flashes of memories they never experienced, or had strange voices in their dreams that talk of things they should not know of... This drove them onward and they where suprised to learn that those memories where more then premonitions when they started to have reputations out in the world, or the conversations began to turn to suggest opposite aspects to their characters... The players got caught up in the mystery but where always trying to prove the voices or images of themselves wrong... course these images and voices where just magics and worries I placed on the characters to make them think that was what I was suggesting and when the characters where validated in finding themselves to be truly themselves they were relieved and happy and proud, if not a little miffed at me for the toying with them and twisting them around...
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
Post Reply