4th Edition Review

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

I'm sure no one will complain if you post it in a nice thread here.

On another note: Those that will convert to 4th against those that will stick to 3rd have changed to 41/37 from 39/39.
Ivana_Boritsi wrote:So, really, it's all about choices at this point. Because if you want to stick with 3e, there's always the Pathfinder RPG.
I don't like it. I'll stick to my own 3rd edition library for 3rd edition games instead of buying a re-published game with few additions.

Jester of the FoS wrote:
And Ezra help you if you want to make someone who is clumsy at combat or a pacifist.
That seems unfair actually Jester. The skill challenge system allows you to rise in levels without ever owning a weapon. And I believe it's far better than what we have seen in 3rd edition. Sure back then you could award arbitary XP for successful skill checks, but the skill challenge, where all the players are supposed to pool resources and also use brains (to get the easy DCs or the +2 bonuses) is very good.
No, a pacifist is far easier in 4th than in 3rd.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

That's a very good point. But you're still going to have tonnes of powers that rely on hitting an enemy.
I know this because my favourite 3e character was a gnome bard who focused on buffing allies. She seldom attacked, ever, and relied on a bow when she did. An impossible 4e character because there's no bard, won't be for two years, and the closest variant is a rogue/wizard/warlock which cannot be done. And all warlock buffs rely on attacking, and attacking in melee.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

The buffer is the cleric/warlord I think, not warlock.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Lord Soth
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 264
Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus

Post by Lord Soth »

Mounted knights aren't possible because there are no lances in the game.


Use the spear. It's one-handed, and does the same damage as the 3.5 lance. It doesn't do extra damage on a charge like the lance, but that damage comes from having Mounted Combat when riding a warhorse, now, so except for the Reach it amounts to the same thing. And if you want Reach then just add it in and treat it as a Military Melee Weapon.

As for the Bard, there're rumors that it'll appear sooner rather then later on DDI. And if it doesn't, then it'll likely appear in the PHB2, which is one year off. And while you can't have a pacifist, you can have a character who doesn't have to kill their opponents. Hit points in 4E mean more then just raw damage taken. They also mean endurance, will, morale, and so on. And on page 295, it says that when you reduce an opponent to 0 hit points, you can choose to KO them or kill them. That's great for anyone who wants to play a character who doesn't want to kill, like Tara Kolyana.
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

WolfKook wrote:
alhoon wrote:...When that book is out you won't need a ranger for two weapon fighting, or multiclassing for finesse fighting and there will be powers for mounted combat.
I know I'll buy that book.
What I don't like is that I'll have to buy that book.
That's exactly why I'll wait three years till 4.5E. :lol:

Seriously, I would like to wait till they put together a whole, consistent game, with enough options to make me happy. I guess I'll check on the SRD, but I don't think I'll buy the books. At least not just yet.
Sort of a Rules Cyclopedia, like they did for OD&D... or a revised AD&D 2nd Ed, that sort of summed up additions over the years...

I know, technically that was a different company, but all the same, I see it happening again, even moreso than with 3E, where they release the Rules Compendium very late.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Lord Soth wrote: As for the Bard, there're rumors that it'll appear sooner rather then later on DDI. And if it doesn't, then it'll likely appear in the PHB2, which is one year off.
Artificer is the next DDI one, coming in July or August.

They've semi-announced the classes for the PHB2, or rather the first letters of their names:
D, R, B, W, I, T, S, S
With only three being in the game before.
We know they're pushing the Primal power source in this book and that the druid has been written, so it's going to be Druid and Barbarian. No room for bard, buy a third book.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

I think it will be druid, sorcerer and bard. For barbarian, buy another book.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

alhoon wrote:alhoon's review part 1:

As I read the PHB I'll post my reviews. I'll rate each part that seems worthy of rating. Parts that were non-interesting or not new will get a brief review, but nothing more.
I consider 3 to be average.

alhoon's review part 2:

About the Monstrous manual this time:

Balance of monsters: Most of the monsters seem balanced with each other. A few have some mistakes though.

For example the beholder is IMO very tough. A 19th lvl party facing a beholder may well have a fatality.
As another example, ogres have very weak powers compared to other monsters of their level. I.e The 8th level brute has an ability to roll an attack roll twice and keep the second roll, rechargable 1/6... :? Compare that with the 8th lvl Cambion's power that gives it whirlwind attack when it charges, and it can also heal. Or with the at will power of another brute, an 8th level demon that can attack twice in a turn (at will).
And before you ask, the Ogre's attack has +11 vs AC and deals 1d10+5 and each of the Bargura's two attacks has +10 vs AC and deals 1d8+6 damage (same average) or 2d8+6 damage if the demon is bloodied... :?

I remind you though, that most of the monsters are well balanced.
3.5/5 stars for balance.

Creativity:
Few monsters are new and even some of the old monsters seem blant. Spellcasting monsters you knew and loved (like lich and naga) have very few powers and limited things to do in battle. Many spellcasting monsters have even less options than warrior monsters!
The presented liches have just 2 or 3 spells and not the powers presented in the DMG!
Dark nagas don't cast spells. They have a cool psychic attack though.

On the other hand, many of the old favorite warrior monsters have nice powers and are more interesting and fun on the board.

2.5/5 stars and this because some of my warrior preferences have cool powers.
NOTE: The rest can be fixed, but it will take some work.

How complete it feels:
Some old favorites are missing leaving me with a "I need to buy the next MManual". How on earth could they omit the Frost giant?! The Spirit naga? Most of the animals!?
Also there are gaps in the monsters. Sure there are some for every level, but not all enviroments are covered well.

The fluff for the monsters seems too limited. I don't understand most of the monsters' place in the world, beliefs etc.
This is frustrating. On the other hand it allows me to fit them in my world as I want and I admit that 10% more space given to fluff would mean 10% less monsters and the MManual has a small number already.

2/5 stars.

Bottom line:
It seems just a good starting poing of reference for you to create your own monsters to populate the campaign world.
It's not so much a monstrous manual as an extended example of how the monster creation rules work.

You can take and drop monsters from there in your game but you'll need to be creating monsters. To be sincere, I don't have a problem with that. I always liked to make my own monsters and now I have about 280 pages full of examples.
But truth be told, for a book with examples, the MManual is very expensive. I would prefer if it was 180 pages instead of 280, had fewer monsters of each type and 10-20 pages full of powers I could use and costed half the money.

3/5 stars.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Apparently, a hill giant carrying 220 lbs of gear is slowed as the weight is too much for him.

Pathetic. Worse than even 2nd edition.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

I'd rule that large and huge creatures can lift/carry more than their score indicates. But that's not going to be in the PHB because there are no large/huge PC races. And it's not really an issue elsewhere because you don't need the stats for a hill giant who has to carry large boulder up a mountain, you need stats for a hill giant only carrying combat equipment and attacking the PCs.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Jester of the FoS wrote:I'd rule that large and huge creatures ...
And that Jester is a house rule. I'd use the Strength chart from 3rd edition probably. Many people will find different formulas.
Gotten once said that the 2nd edition was the golden age of house rules. It seems that we get in the silver age of house rules.

NOTE: On the plus side, the DMG many people accused of being short, does a very good job with the house rules. I admit it gives poor cover on other matters and a pathetic report on the other planes, but in the house rules it rocks.

I have playtested 4th with friends. It seems obvious now:
4th edition is more about gaming and less about realism. Few rules many exceptions.
Realism goes out of the window, house rules are not just needed... they're mandatory so they're codified in the DMG making the decision to use house rules so much easier for bookish types that are reluctant to deviate from the norm.
Also house rules are very easy to implement.

Example:
Player: "I charge and kick the ogre's legs as he stands over the stairs. As you remember we have greased the stairs. At the bottom we put broken glass, set wooden spikes and managed to bring the 4-5 poisonous spiders in the area."
3rd edition that would be a hell to calculate. Bull rush, AoOpp, falling damage, piercing damage, attacks by the tiny spiders, saves etc. Of course, the DM wouldn't go through that all and decide on the effects and the damage. It would take some guessing and the PCs may not be happy about the results. Also 90% this attack would do less damage than a full attack or a spell.

4th edition: Strength vs Ogre's reflex defence, +2 for charge.
Assuming the attack hits: The ogre gets a saving throw.
Ogre fails the save: Checking the character's level, let's assume 8 like the ogre's. Page 42: 2d8+5 damage and the ogre is prone. Also it takes 5 ongoing poison damage (save ends) from the spiders.
Ogre succeeds the save. 1d8+5 damage, not prone, no poison damage.

Extras: Greased stairs? -2 to the ogre's saves.
That's it. Two rolls and then damage. Less than 40 secs of thinking and looking in the DMG. (I have page 42 marked for a reason).

Problems: A 18th level character pulling the same trick would do 3d8+7 damage. Is it realistic that the same push, the same spikes, the same spiders etc would do more damage because the guy that sacrificed the standard action was 10 levels higher? NO!
Is it fair? Yeap. The damage is on par with the encounter powers of these levels (in fact a bit lower) but above at will attacks.
And let's admit it, setting a trap like that or kicking an ogre in a brazier of fire, or hitting the large chandelier over it to drop on it's head is more fun.
And in 4th edition, the DM doesn't have to dread if the PCs get creative.

The above chandelier attack would be:
- dex attack vs AC 7-8 (could and should be ignored), damage of the basic attack against the cord or something that holds the chandelier (about 4-5 hp, usually can be ignored). This whole step could be omitted.
- Character's dex attack vs ogre's reflex and would deal 1d8+5 to 2d6+5 damage. It would also make the area bellow the chandelier difficult terrain.


Balance and ease above realism.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Well, to get nit-picky, the ogre is making a saving throw to negate most of the damage. Which doesn't seem to be how saving throws work (as a duration counter). It gives the ogre an unfair advantage with two rolls to negate the damage (PC's and their own).
Nikolas of the Mists
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 183
Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm

Post by Nikolas of the Mists »

alhoon wrote:Example:
Player: "I charge and kick the ogre's legs as he stands over the stairs. As you remember we have greased the stairs. At the bottom we put broken glass, set wooden spikes and managed to bring the 4-5 poisonous spiders in the area."
My 4E resolution would be a lot different.

Str vs Fortitude defense (p287 PHB for bullrush move)
Ogre Acrobatics Skill Check => Balance or fall (p180 PHB)
Damage according to fall distance
Treat the wooden spikes as a variant pit trap (p87 DMG)
Spiders vs Ogre AC, take minor damage, save vs ongoing damage

Obviously the Ogre will be suffering from one or more conditions as a result of this move. It will be prone if the attack is successful, but also possibly dazed or stunned (save ends).

I think this is an an example of what makes makes 4E really good -- there are multiple ways to approach a situation now as a GM. The quick way they describe in the DMG, or a mechanical way, both of which are valid.
"I wouldn't worry too much about the Vistana with the pistols --
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Your way is more complicated. :) How does falling step by step on stairs affect falling damage anyway? And the spiders would be so low in level that they couldn't hit the ogre, while in my example I consider that some of them crawl in his armor. :)
The example in page 42 is quite like what I propose.
Using your way, the Ogre in that example could avoid the damage too, or the brazier could do damage like a variant of a trap etc etc.

In effect, I believe you think 3rd edition with 4th edition rules. Your example is more realistic but more time consuming and probably less balanced which is against the philosophy of the 4th edition.

Use whatever you like, but I believe my example is faster and solid enough to stop arguing. I.e players wouldn't start arguing about how much the attack bonus of the spiders is, that the spikes are sharper or not that weak to break etc.

Though I admit that the bull rush should be against fortitude. :)
Last edited by alhoon on Fri Jun 27, 2008 2:09 am, edited 1 time in total.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Nikolas of the Mists
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 183
Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm

Post by Nikolas of the Mists »

Was assuming that it was a stairway as you said stairs, not ladder.
Balance check would be for the entirety of the stairs (or ladder).
Spiders would have been given a bonus irrelevant to their level/CR (ie something like die roll +4 vs AC).

Basically it was going to work as a bullrush into a "trap".

All of that scenario took about 2 minutes to work out in solid mechanics, and given that they'd set it up the grease you have already had time to consider some options.

If you tried that thing against the PCs they'd scream bloody murder, so I see no reason to not give the same benefit to the NPCs.
"You get bullrushed by the attack. No you can't try and be safe with a balance check. By the way you hit the ground and fall on some spikes, no you can't make a REF defense for that either. Oh and spiders bite you. No they don't need an attack roll. By the way, you'll be rolling for poison saves on your turn now."

I also prefer the pure mechanics way for some things because each roll can describe exactly how the action goes down, meaning that all of their brilliant plan might not work out as they intended.

Is it more rolling? Yes. I do think tho that the fast mechanics were made for if you're not able to come up with appllcable game mechanics quickly, or if such mechanics don't already exist.
"I wouldn't worry too much about the Vistana with the pistols --
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
Post Reply