Vivisection for science

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Post by Isabella »

doctor-evil wrote:If there's a roll for simply lying, there should be a roll for the above.
Lying only makes you roll a DPC if you maliciously lie with the intent of causing the person harm (aka, telling someone the bridge is safe or their drink is unpoisoned when it is very much not).

I suspect the above examples fall under "Betrayal". You get the DPC because of the mental anguish that you are (intentionally) causing the person by torturing and murdering a beloved pet. It might also be considered Torture because you are quite clearly Torturing the person who owns the animal, just not physically. Having Animal Cruelty on the list probably opened up a can of worms the game designers didn't want to deal with. Setting a terrier on rats, poisoning rabbit burrows, or shooting feral dogs might also be considered torture or cruel - not to mention sports hunters, and lower CL domains would probably end up with half the village having freaky powers due to failed checks.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
User avatar
Mangrum
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 811
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2003 1:29 am

Post by Mangrum »

doctor-evil wrote:I would strongly disagree about not giving dark powers checks for cruelty to animals.

- A PC who sneaks into a PC ranger's room and slowly kills their dog companion in a brutal way...

- A PC who takes an NPC's child's rabbit and boils it to death because they're angry with the NPC...

- A PC who nails the NPC old lady's black cat to the wall while it's still alive...

Simply stealing someone's purse or lying is worth a powers check, but the above aren't?!
I'd say all of the above are worth powers checks, but all for the same thing: threatening another person.

Here's a question: if torturing an animal is an automatic powers check, why not murdering them? Consider your answer; the fate of virtually every hunter, trapper, butcher, and farmer (to begin with) in the demiplane hangs in the balance.
User avatar
Sareau
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 300
Joined: Wed Jul 15, 2009 11:44 am
Location: Winter Garden, FL
Contact:

Post by Sareau »

I think it's largely a matter of intention and ability-if you can do it quickly and painlessly, but don't-powers check.

Of course, the nature of Ravenloft itself means many of the otherwise innocent people you mentioned may well be on their personal Track of Terror-explains why they were all pariahs in ancient India...
User avatar
Manofevil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1729
Joined: Sat Dec 20, 2003 11:12 pm
Location: Why should I say? No one ever visits!

Post by Manofevil »

:idea: That would include cock-fighting and dog-fighting, both of which are VERY cruel.
Do us a favor Luv, Stick yer 'ead in a bucket a kick it!

So, gentlemen, that's how it is. Until Grissome.... resurfaces, I'm the acting president, and I say starting with this... anniversary festival, we run this city into the ground! :D
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

Isabella wrote:
doctor-evil wrote:If there's a roll for simply lying, there should be a roll for the above.
Lying only makes you roll a DPC if you maliciously lie with the intent of causing the person harm (aka, telling someone the bridge is safe or their drink is unpoisoned when it is very much not).

I suspect the above examples fall under "Betrayal". You get the DPC because of the mental anguish that you are (intentionally) causing the person by torturing and murdering a beloved pet. It might also be considered Torture because you are quite clearly Torturing the person who owns the animal, just not physically. Having Animal Cruelty on the list probably opened up a can of worms the game designers didn't want to deal with. Setting a terrier on rats, poisoning rabbit burrows, or shooting feral dogs might also be considered torture or cruel - not to mention sports hunters, and lower CL domains would probably end up with half the village having freaky powers due to failed checks.
It would also be silly and offensive to a lot of players. I would not play in a game where a farmer who poisoned a rabbit burrow to preserve his crops, or a hunter who liked to have his kills mounted, or a ratcatcher who employed a terrier are all subject to frequent powers checks just for killing animals. It seems unworkable to me, and smacks of the DM imposing his own highly eccentric social/political views on the game universe. YMMV.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
RShini
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 75
Joined: Thu Sep 17, 2009 10:22 pm
Location: Spokane

Post by RShini »

ewancummins wrote:
Isabella wrote:
doctor-evil wrote:If there's a roll for simply lying, there should be a roll for the above.
Lying only makes you roll a DPC if you maliciously lie with the intent of causing the person harm (aka, telling someone the bridge is safe or their drink is unpoisoned when it is very much not).

I suspect the above examples fall under "Betrayal". You get the DPC because of the mental anguish that you are (intentionally) causing the person by torturing and murdering a beloved pet. It might also be considered Torture because you are quite clearly Torturing the person who owns the animal, just not physically. Having Animal Cruelty on the list probably opened up a can of worms the game designers didn't want to deal with. Setting a terrier on rats, poisoning rabbit burrows, or shooting feral dogs might also be considered torture or cruel - not to mention sports hunters, and lower CL domains would probably end up with half the village having freaky powers due to failed checks.
It would also be silly and offensive to a lot of players. I would not play in a game where a farmer who poisoned a rabbit burrow to preserve his crops, or a hunter who liked to have his kills mounted, or a ratcatcher who employed a terrier are all subject to frequent powers checks just for killing animals. It seems unworkable to me, and smacks of the DM imposing his own highly eccentric social/political views on the game universe. YMMV.
I personally would go with intent, there is a difference between setting traps for rats to keep them from ruining store grains or killing piglets (something necessary for the farmer's survival), and catching a rat to burn it's whiskers off and stab it with needles just to watch it shriek in pain.

It is noted animal torture is a common factor in the childhood of serial killers.
"When they open the door and see a ten foot cockroach, they sigh in relief and mutter 'glad it's not a twenty-foot tall cockroach" - or something like that, Stephen King, Danse Macabre
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

RShini wrote:
I personally would go with intent, there is a difference between setting traps for rats to keep them from ruining store grains or killing piglets (something necessary for the farmer's survival), and catching a rat to burn it's whiskers off and stab it with needles just to watch it shriek in pain.

It is noted animal torture is a common factor in the childhood of serial killers.
That's more acceptable to my gaming tastes, although I still would not include run of the mill stuff like bullfighting (even though I find it pretty revolting in real life, I don't feel that imposing my Anglo-American 21st century sensibilities on a fantasy world is usually a great idea).

I suppose you could count truly excessive/cruel stuff as torture: routine or torture: sadistic against 'monsters.'
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

Mangrum wrote: Here's a question: if torturing an animal is an automatic powers check, why not murdering them? Consider your answer; the fate of virtually every hunter, trapper, butcher, and farmer (to begin with) in the demiplane hangs in the balance.
OK, running with this . . . . At what point does Markov actually become a subject of interest to the Dark Powers and why ultimately the Darklordship?

So long as he is just slaughtering pigs as standard fair back on the farm and so long as he is just butchering meat professionally all is well. Even if he really, really enjoys it.

When he starts doing some painful experiments on the meat to be before slaughtering the animals in question all is still well.

When those experiments start to involve the hubris of turning animals into humans the Dark Powers perk up and he eventually fails some checks given his persistence at the task.

He butchers his abominations and sells their meat like the rest. Frankly, I am not sure that this one really should excite the Dark Powers. Were he butchering people and selling their flesh, then clearly so. But we are still talking about animals here, as he is not yet successful, although the results are very strangely transformed. Is he lying? Yes. Harmfully to others? There is no suggestion that the meat is actually bad.

Then his wife confronts him and threatens to expose his monstrousities. Maybe she has a narrow view of the acceptable, and she would have reacted the same way to pretty much any cutting-edge biological research in the field. Who knows. In any case, he kills her, by transforming her, perhaps in the direction of animals, and in any case as part of his research, and she dies hideously over the course of three days. So we have murder. Betrayal, although he would protest that she was the betrayer. And torture, although he would protest that the three days were scientifically necessary. He dumps the body, curiously enough, rather than butchering it for its meat. Apparently, he doesn't believe in cannabalism.

Certainly there is the stuff of Power checks in the final part of the play. Darklordship worthy when the various deeds are taken together without reference to animals however?
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Post by Isabella »

cure wrote:Certainly there is the stuff of Power checks in the final part of the play. Darklordship worthy when the various deeds are taken together without reference to animals however?
Well... It does seem like a lot of Darklords have gotten their domains off a single deed.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

It doesn't matter what feeble protests Markov could mount in his own defense. The Dark Powers are not bleeding hearts- they don't care about your excuses, your bad childhood, your absurb defense on grounds of insanity.

IMO, Markov was guilty of:

Torture of monsters, many times.
His torture sessions/ experiments are way beyond the pale, and his goal is a madman's hubristic dream of playing God- not a benign quest for knowledge. This is not run of the mill stuff. The Dark Powers may not care about bear-baiting, but an evil butcher who tries to turn animals into men through horrific surgical experimentation is a different matter. Markov sought to trangress the limits of nature in a way that an ordinary torturer does not.

10% if he's a sadist, 4% is he's more detached. Roll for each experiment. How many vile experiments did he conduct?


brutal murder of family member: AoUD ,auto-fail!
sadistic torture of a family member (his wife) AoUD, auto fail!

If he was married in church, he probably also broke an oath of his own faith in killing his own wife. That's another powers check with a 10% fail chance.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

FWIW, Markov's fall from grace is something I've been working up for the Sea of Sorrows netbook. I don't want to spoil any surprises for that book, so I'll just say that Markov's surgeries on animals might have caused the Dark Powers to watch him a bit more closely, but he hadn't actually failed any Powers checks before what happened with Ludmilla.


As for the Dark Powers' disinterest in animal cruelty, I'd say that it's justified under the "Atrocity By Your Culture's Standard" rule that keeps the Land of Mists from getting crammed full of darklord illithids and orcs and demons. Animals living in the wild don't have any expectation of a comfortable life or a peaceful death from old age: the overwhelming majority get eaten (often alive) within a few days of birth. Those that survive infancy, will inevitably die by violence, starvation or disease, with only the most social ever knowing the comfort of not being alone when their luck runs out. Fact is, Nature is not kind to animals, even here on Earth. Sorry if that's a nasty thing to proclaim right after Earth Day, but it's also the truth.

So why should Ravenloft -- a setting in which, for whatever reason, the landscape really is actively malignant; just ask the corrupt treants who've been living off its soil -- be more compassionate about the fates of animals than our own world? If hyenas devouring a zebra's guts while it's still alive and screaming is just Nature's pragmatism at work, then a vivissector who examines the guts of a shackled, unanesthetized pig for an equally pragmatic purpose is just being a predator, not a complete monster. By contemporary standards, they're being cruel and ought to go to jail, because humans can and do set the bar for morality a lot higher than Nature does. But to the pig, it's just how prey-animals die.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Sareau
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 300
Joined: Wed Jul 15, 2009 11:44 am
Location: Winter Garden, FL
Contact:

Post by Sareau »

Rotipher of the FoS wrote:So why should Ravenloft -- a setting in which, for whatever reason, the landscape really is actively malignant; just ask the corrupt treants who've been living off its soil -- be more compassionate about the fates of animals than our own world?
I'd say because the Dark Powers are actively seeking out evil for whatever reason-I feel the darklords are all trapped largely from not seeking redemption-if Strahd sought out the latest reincarnation of Tatyana and hooked her up with Sergei's current incarnation, he would easily pass away into the Mists, but he just won't do that.

Same with all the darklords-there's a moral choice they could make that would get them out, but it's something they'd never do.

Why would the Dark Powers care? Because it's one more way to screw over the population!
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

Nature red in tooth and claw!
Good argument, Rotipher.

Now, I should add that it's the transgression against nature of trying to turn beasts into men that makes Markov's experiments powers check worthy, IMO. Raising the dead isn't an 'evil' act, yet it is worth a powers check for much the same reason: there are Things Man was Not Meant to Know, barriers he must not pass.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
doctor-evil
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 88
Joined: Wed Jun 07, 2006 6:18 pm
Location: Washington DC

Post by doctor-evil »

"I personally would go with intent, there is a difference between setting traps for rats to keep them from ruining store grains or killing piglets (something necessary for the farmer's survival), and catching a rat to burn it's whiskers off and stab it with needles just to watch it shriek in pain.

It is noted animal torture is a common factor in the childhood of serial killers."
That's what I was trying to get at - if someone is deliberately trying to inflict pain, or being wantonly cruel, whether to animals, humanoids or any sentient creature, it should warrant a powers check. There's a big difference between killing an animal for food and torturing an animal to death for personal enjoyment. But I guess that is covered under "torture".
I have a rule of thumb (the rule of "ewww") - if PCs do anything that makes anyone go "eww!" or "WTF?!" then that should draw the dark powers attention....
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

Torture against 'monsters' would be my recommendation for handling that stuff, if you class it as powers check-worthy.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Post Reply