Vivisection for science
Vivisection for science
Let's say that there is a medical degree offered at the University of Dementlieu. Included in the program as a requirement is the dissection of humanoid corpses and the vivisection of animals.
I am curious about the consequences of the latter on alignment and for Power Checks.
For Power Checks this seems to be unambiguous routine torture of a monster worth a 4% chance per bout of attracting the attention of the Dark Powers:
"Torture, Routine: Routine torture is the act of inflicting pain to extract information. This is an evil act even when performed toward an ultimate good. Many so-called heroes have been seduced into evil through the misconception that the ends justify the means. Common examples include torturing an enemy to learn the location of her headquarters, battle plans, or even the location of hostages."
Right?
Would it make any difference if the vivisection was performed on fairly condemned, evil criminals?
What then about alignment? Let's assume that there are no laws in Dementlieu banning cruelty to animals. So that should exclude law and chaos from the discussion. What about good and evil? Can a good aligned physician in training perform vivisection on animals without consequence for his alignment? And can a neutral aligned physician in training perform vivisection on animals without consequence for his alignment?
Would it make any difference if the vivisection was performed on fairly condemned, evil criminals?
Other thoughts on the matter?
I am curious about the consequences of the latter on alignment and for Power Checks.
For Power Checks this seems to be unambiguous routine torture of a monster worth a 4% chance per bout of attracting the attention of the Dark Powers:
"Torture, Routine: Routine torture is the act of inflicting pain to extract information. This is an evil act even when performed toward an ultimate good. Many so-called heroes have been seduced into evil through the misconception that the ends justify the means. Common examples include torturing an enemy to learn the location of her headquarters, battle plans, or even the location of hostages."
Right?
Would it make any difference if the vivisection was performed on fairly condemned, evil criminals?
What then about alignment? Let's assume that there are no laws in Dementlieu banning cruelty to animals. So that should exclude law and chaos from the discussion. What about good and evil? Can a good aligned physician in training perform vivisection on animals without consequence for his alignment? And can a neutral aligned physician in training perform vivisection on animals without consequence for his alignment?
Would it make any difference if the vivisection was performed on fairly condemned, evil criminals?
Other thoughts on the matter?
The cure for what ails you
I know I'm opening a can of worms here, but I think in cases like this it would depend on if the person doing the act feels it to be cruel or not.
I remember a Planescape adventure where there were some guys vivisecting and experimenting on modrons (legal outsiders that look like constructs).
One was a woman who thought they were like constructs and didn't even feel pain, so for her it wasn't an evil act; it was like cutting a golem.
Another one was a man who knew they were outsiders and feeling pain and he enjoyed it, so for him it surely was an evil act.
We assume a scientist is doing it For Science, but as the torture power check reminds, in D&D the end does NOT justify the means for good people, so it depends on whether the scientist feels he's torturing somebody but doesn't care (evil) or thinks lesser animals can't feel pain the way superior animals do, so he's not doing anything wrong (neutral).
BTW, in my campaign we removed the alignments altogether and the world became a simpler and more realistic place
I remember a Planescape adventure where there were some guys vivisecting and experimenting on modrons (legal outsiders that look like constructs).
One was a woman who thought they were like constructs and didn't even feel pain, so for her it wasn't an evil act; it was like cutting a golem.
Another one was a man who knew they were outsiders and feeling pain and he enjoyed it, so for him it surely was an evil act.
We assume a scientist is doing it For Science, but as the torture power check reminds, in D&D the end does NOT justify the means for good people, so it depends on whether the scientist feels he's torturing somebody but doesn't care (evil) or thinks lesser animals can't feel pain the way superior animals do, so he's not doing anything wrong (neutral).
BTW, in my campaign we removed the alignments altogether and the world became a simpler and more realistic place
Coltiviamo per tutti un rancore
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
On the other hand, the excuse 'it is for science' is often abused. You could say I'm a scientist in real life, but luckily I only have to deal with numbers and other such abstractions, so my work does not have much of ethical issues.
But even then, and even believing that science is the best way to reach knowledge, I don't think it should approach everything, or trample everything. And there are limits that should be respected. Killing and torturing in the name of science for me is not justifiable, much less so if it deals with unwilling human beings.
So the question is: should we sacrifice progress if the way to do it offends morality or causes suffering to human beings? In my view, unequivocally yes. So what, we progress a bit slower, but then again, we're not in a race against time, are we?
But even then, and even believing that science is the best way to reach knowledge, I don't think it should approach everything, or trample everything. And there are limits that should be respected. Killing and torturing in the name of science for me is not justifiable, much less so if it deals with unwilling human beings.
So the question is: should we sacrifice progress if the way to do it offends morality or causes suffering to human beings? In my view, unequivocally yes. So what, we progress a bit slower, but then again, we're not in a race against time, are we?
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
I'm not really an expert on vivisection (>.>) but when it comes to animals, there are probably ways to mitigate the cruelty and thus, the powers check. An animal could be sedated before the procedure, for instance. I don't know if that would mess up the scientific results, but it would mean the subject shouldn't be in any pain. Given that your average farmer isn't likely to fail powers checks for killing animals, I would assume the scientist wouldn't either.
People and sentient monsters are a more complex matter. Once again, you can still probably sedate them to avoid the "Torture" bit, but there's still the fact you're killing them. But then again, if you're talking about a condemned criminal, you have to ask if an executioner takes a powers check for killing people sentenced by the state.
IMO, it's one of those morally dubious things that means you're not good aligned, but you probably shouldn't fail a DPC for. On the other hand, it could quickly lead into things you can fail a DPC for, like grabbing people who aren't condemned criminals, infecting people with diseases before vivisection, or deciding sedatives are messing up your experiment.
People and sentient monsters are a more complex matter. Once again, you can still probably sedate them to avoid the "Torture" bit, but there's still the fact you're killing them. But then again, if you're talking about a condemned criminal, you have to ask if an executioner takes a powers check for killing people sentenced by the state.
IMO, it's one of those morally dubious things that means you're not good aligned, but you probably shouldn't fail a DPC for. On the other hand, it could quickly lead into things you can fail a DPC for, like grabbing people who aren't condemned criminals, infecting people with diseases before vivisection, or deciding sedatives are messing up your experiment.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
I think that there was a spell in 2nd edition for vivisecting a living animal, and it required a powers check, as it was keeping the animal alive and in pain for days.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Well, abusing animals is a traditional first step for more heinous crimes. Yango's cruelty to animals is traditionally mentioned in his background, cumulative in an attempted sacrifice of his baby sister to Zhakita.
But yeah; torture's torture. You might use the "good cause" excuse as a way to give someone a bonus, but as long as its actually done, well, roll em.
To clarify; say Batman holds a criminal upside down to aid in his interrogate roll. This is kind of mean, but he hasn't actually committed a crime yet; if Batman drops the criminal straight up, that's a powers check, even if the info he got saves lives. If he takes precautions to ensure that the criminal is in far less danger than he thinks(A mattress hidden in the dumpster, for example, or weights that break off in water so the crook can easily swim to safety, or blindfolding the crook so he or she believes they are much higher than they really are.), this should be taken into account, possibly even mitigating the roll. On the other hand, a particularly brutal interrogation might be grounds for a powers check in and of itself, especially if blood is shed or bones broken.
The same goes for vivisection; if you take measures to ensure that it is not an act of sadism, that should be taken into account, but not totally mitigate the powers check. Personally, I take a step back when people get antsy about the particulars of an action; if my gut says, "You BASTARD!", its worth a check, intentions or no.
But yeah; torture's torture. You might use the "good cause" excuse as a way to give someone a bonus, but as long as its actually done, well, roll em.
To clarify; say Batman holds a criminal upside down to aid in his interrogate roll. This is kind of mean, but he hasn't actually committed a crime yet; if Batman drops the criminal straight up, that's a powers check, even if the info he got saves lives. If he takes precautions to ensure that the criminal is in far less danger than he thinks(A mattress hidden in the dumpster, for example, or weights that break off in water so the crook can easily swim to safety, or blindfolding the crook so he or she believes they are much higher than they really are.), this should be taken into account, possibly even mitigating the roll. On the other hand, a particularly brutal interrogation might be grounds for a powers check in and of itself, especially if blood is shed or bones broken.
The same goes for vivisection; if you take measures to ensure that it is not an act of sadism, that should be taken into account, but not totally mitigate the powers check. Personally, I take a step back when people get antsy about the particulars of an action; if my gut says, "You BASTARD!", its worth a check, intentions or no.
"Is there anything keeping us from checking that place out tonight?" Besides sanity, naturally.
- Manofevil
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1729
- Joined: Sat Dec 20, 2003 11:12 pm
- Location: Why should I say? No one ever visits!
A better example would be Peter Cushing's Dr. Knox. Knox, you may remember, was the doctor who bought corpses from Burke and Hare for the purposes of vivisection without realizing that B&H had murdered them. I cannot remember the the namne of the movie but Cushing's performance was monumental. It's on every once in a while here, I'll see about getting the title if no one else here knows it.Sareau wrote:I believe that it should call for a Powers check-"It's for the good of Science!" is an overused excuse. Perhaps a callous researcher's path needs to be fleshed out for amoral types like Peter Cushing's Baron Frankenstein...
Do us a favor Luv, Stick yer 'ead in a bucket a kick it!
So, gentlemen, that's how it is. Until Grissome.... resurfaces, I'm the acting president, and I say starting with this... anniversary festival, we run this city into the ground! :D
So, gentlemen, that's how it is. Until Grissome.... resurfaces, I'm the acting president, and I say starting with this... anniversary festival, we run this city into the ground! :D
- ewancummins
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 28523
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm
Animals aren't moral agents. They don't have reason and free will. Yes, you can argue with that view in the real world, but it seems clear that it's written into the game on a basic level (always true neutral, low INT scores). Awakened animals and intelligent monster species are a another matter, of course.Mangrum wrote:I think it's pretty clear that the Dark Powers don't particularly care about animals.
I don't think a bullfight is a powers check. I don't think medical experiments on animals are powers checks. It isn't a question of what we might think about real world animal welfare from our early 21st century mainstream American perspective, but what draws the interest of the Dark Powers in Ravenloft. I tend to agree with Mangrum; the DPs don't care much about animals. Cruelty to animals, however deplorable we may find it, just doesn't rise to the attention of the Powers.
Last edited by ewancummins on Wed Apr 14, 2010 2:04 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
- ewancummins
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 28523
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm
Ah, but that's not vivisection. Vivisection means that the subject is alive.Manofevil wrote:A better example would be Peter Cushing's Dr. Knox. Knox, you may remember, was the doctor who bought corpses from Burke and Hare for the purposes of vivisection without realizing that B&H had murdered them. I cannot remember the the namne of the movie but Cushing's performance was monumental. It's on every once in a while here, I'll see about getting the title if no one else here knows it.Sareau wrote:I believe that it should call for a Powers check-"It's for the good of Science!" is an overused excuse. Perhaps a callous researcher's path needs to be fleshed out for amoral types like Peter Cushing's Baron Frankenstein...
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Precisely the point I was going to make.ewancummins wrote:Ah, but that's not vivisection. Vivisection means that the subject is alive.Manofevil wrote:A better example would be Peter Cushing's Dr. Knox. Knox, you may remember, was the doctor who bought corpses from Burke and Hare for the purposes of vivisection without realizing that B&H had murdered them. I cannot remember the the namne of the movie but Cushing's performance was monumental. It's on every once in a while here, I'll see about getting the title if no one else here knows it.Sareau wrote:I believe that it should call for a Powers check-"It's for the good of Science!" is an overused excuse. Perhaps a callous researcher's path needs to be fleshed out for amoral types like Peter Cushing's Baron Frankenstein...
But vivisection has been performed on human beings, and I thought that was the initial intent of the question. How many of you don't feel revolted or disgusted inside after reading this account? Just to know...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vivisection
Regardint the executioner: I don't think there should be PC for his actions unless he actually does it for pleasure, because punishment is an essential part of any justice system. It is at the basis of morality too, I think. There is right, there is wrong, wrong should be punished. I think the only reason for religious systems to include an otherwordly punishment is the recognition that human justice can't possibly cover all and so they have to scare people into thinking that they'll be caught anyway, after they're dead. But if the idea of punishment simply disappears, society will collapse, because we're not all nice people. So, it's a necessary tenet of society. And if you view morality as an early code of conduct for society, then punishment, and even capital punishment, may be acceptable to that morality.
That does not include torture, though, for these are two different things. Torture is the unnecessary infliction of pain and suffering. As for animals, I still think torturing animals for pleasure is disgusting. But it could simply be seen as barbaric. Here, we have an old custom (disappearing nowadays) in rural areas that is the killing of the pig, done in late autumn. It is made in a public feast, a bit of a ritual of sorts, and it is done in such a way that the pig actually bleeds to death. It sounded horrible to me, but I was explained that this was the way to get all the blood possible. Do I think this is evil? Not really, but I'm still ambiguous on this one. That vivissected frog in wikipedia, on the other hand, made me cringe.
Of course, these are entirely personal and tentative opinions, and open to debate if anyone would like to engage in them. I'm not a philosopher and only think about this amateurishly, which also means I'm not familiar at all with the literature on this one.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
The Flesh and the Fiends (1960)-- and frankly, while Cushing's performance is good it's Donald Pleasance as Hare who walks away with the movie.Manofevil wrote:I cannot remember the the namne of the movie but Cushing's performance was monumental. It's on every once in a while here, I'll see about getting the title if no one else here knows it.
