Transposition by Angel?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Excellent post, Ryan. I definitely see where you're coming from more clearly now.
Ryan Naylor wrote:The reason I’m writing all this is because the power of good and the centrality of that struggle between good and evil sometimes seems to me to be forgotten. As I said earlier, people seem very clear that evil exists, but not good: there are no happy endings, there’s no value in opposing evil, good is either weak, nonexistent or hypocritical, and there often seem to me to an adversarial relationship between GMs and players.
I agree wholeheartedly that the existence of good, the happy ending, the value of the good fight are central to Ravenloft. However, I see it differently when it comes to how that relates to angels.

It's true that the original gothic tales were steeped in the religious culture of the times. But that religious culture was overwhelmingly Christian, in the parts of the world where gothic literature was being written. And the original "fallen angel" in Christian tradition, Satan, would have been nearly synonymous with Evil. Paradise Lost was over a century old by this point and Dante's Divine Comedy even older, both of which elaborate on Satan as the ultimate evil, i.e. the embodiment of the corruption of good, having once been good himself. I don't think a fallen angel would have been an alien or modern concept at this point.

I do believe in pure good in Ravenloft, but perhaps it's my upbringing speaking when I say I think that good in Ravenloft is "less good" when its inspired by pure goodness from the Heavens. Ravenloft's remote connection to the Divine is a sort of crucible where good can be put to the test without knowing for certain that there's a reward waiting. One can have faith that there is a reward, and believe it completely, but never know with proof, because there aren't Deities walking the earth, Angelic hosts inspiring humans, free planar travel to Heaven, etc.

So, while this is very a compelling argument:
VRGtFiends/Demons (and all the source material since then) casts fiends as pure, unadulterated, uncompromising, unsalvageable evil. Fine. But that means that, to be true to the genre, celestials are just as pure and unadulterated good
and almost sways me, I don't really want to see a pure angel in Ravenloft. Because it would lessen the human struggle to find good, in my mind. Like I said, I like moral questions, not necessarily answers. If there's a pure angel walking around with all the answers, that does have the potential to turn good into boring, IMHO.

And I don't see Isolde as still 100% pure, due to the existence of the Abominations. Perhaps it is a truly gothic sort of punishment. They are evil inside, so they are cursed by (the agent of a) God with an evil-looking outisde form. And a 19th century audience might buy that without question. But as modern spectators, with a concept of "curel and unusal punishment," it rubs the wrong way. And it seems that a "pure good" being would have seen that, even in the 19th century. (If we are to believe in a concept of good that doesn't change over time, even though human perceptions of it do.)
It’s not an invasion of the mind, body and soul (like a fiendish transposition is), but a partnership.
If that's the case, then the whole question of whether the angel is pure or fallen is irrelevant. (which is ok).

Anyway, I think the relative lack of pure, holy angels in Ravenloft canon, the Unspoken Pact, and the mystery surrounding home-grown deities like Ezra to be as intrinsic to the gothic nature of the setting as the lack of reliable "detect evil" spells. There is pure good and pure evil, and it's the PCs' job to figure out which is which, without direct divine guidance. That would make it too easy, and lessen the purity of the struggle.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by alhoon »

Ryan Naylor wrote: Remember that in certain Abrahamic traditions, outsiders don’t have freedom of choice in the way that mortals do.
I was actually playing outsiders in Ravenloft as creatures of pure malice or goodness didn't have the freedom of choice the way mortals do. I thought that was the way of the game.

IMO, an angel is as incapable of doing evil as much as a human is of flying with his hands. I.e. an angel given a sword and commanded by domination to kill a baby is not capable of doing it any more than a dominated human is able to fly on command.
A fiend is also incapable of doing anything good, but it's easy to taint good with personal gain or selfishness. I.e. a dominated fiend could be sent to give food to the poor if he could use that as a bribe to taint and corrupt them. A fiend however could not anonymously leave medicine in the door of a poor family that needs it to save their kid and leave without uttering a word to corrupt them. He's as incapable of doing that, as a fish is incapable of walking on the street.
In the above two examples the outsiders are not just unable to think of those actions I mentioned. They're unable to perform those actions.

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: And it seems that a "pure good" being would have seen that, even in the 19th century. (If we are to believe in a concept of good that doesn't change over time, even though human perceptions of it do.)
Well, human perceptions do change though, so a 1810 audience would think that all "perfectly good" angels would be like that.
However, I am on the same train. I just don't play Isolde as making abominations. Her aura disrupts people because she's an angel and the world reacts, she's not cursing people.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: There is pure good and pure evil, and it's the PCs' job to figure out which is which, without direct divine guidance. That would make it too easy, and lessen the purity of the struggle.
Well, your game, your rules but the way to resolve that struggle isn't IMO to remove pure good and pure evil creatures. The way to do it is IMO not overuse them.
Yes, IMO an angel should be 100% correct, no struggle. So, when I want moral struggles,wouldn't have an angel nearbyto tell the PCs which choice is the more good one and which is the less good one.



Oh, and IMC, chaotic good angels see things differently than lawful good angels. Different aspects of good if you want.
A chaotic good angel would prefer to martyr himself talking against the evil Lord; He would speak up, get arrested and burned at stake, hoping to inspire others against the evil establishment.
A Lawful good angel would prefer to keep-it-low, helping the humans suffering and brightening their very sad days without direct confrontation. He would provide charity, emotional support etc hoping to keep the morale (and morals) of the people up so that they don't despair and turn to evil and so that they will build up reserves of willpower to rise up against or just endure the evil Lord.
Last edited by alhoon on Sun Sep 16, 2012 1:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

alhoon wrote:[IMO, an angel is as incapable of doing evil as much as a human is of flying with his hands. I.e. an angel given a sword and commanded by domination to kill a baby is not capable of doing it any more than a dominated human is able to fly on command.
It's an interesting take, and certainly fits the gothic ideal of good. But what happens when such an automaton of good is put in a complex moral situation, where the good path isn't so clear? E.g., what if the angel knows that baby will grow up to be Vecna? If you're the DM and you like this version of outsiders, I suppose you could just never put them in such situations. But situations do exist where two conflicting goods compete. Forget about killing. Lets say an angel sees two people falling to their doom and only has time to save one? Perhaps there's some out of the box path that makes the good answer clear and I'm just not able to see it as a human, though such a angel could, because he would be unable not to. But how would I, as a fallible human, be able to write it into a story or game?

I've only skimmed the Book of Exalted Deeds so far, intending to get back to it eventually, but I'm curious what it has to say about dogmatic good in a complex world. These are the sorts of moral quandaries that holy men have debated for centuries with no concrete answers, so I doubt James Wyatt, Darrin Drader and Christopher Perkins have it all sorted out. ;) but I'd be interested in their take on it.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by alhoon »

1. I edited my post.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: E.g., what if the angel knows that baby will grow up to be Vecna?
Plenty of such situations arise in my games... mainly from my Evil PCs that try to use an Angel's goodness against him. :P

In above example:
The angel would NOT be able to kill the infant Vecna. Why? Because he can't make an evil action for the greater good. He just can't strike down and kill a baby. That it will later become an evil God is irrelevant. At the present, it's just an innocent baby.
Is it the right choice? Nope. It's a stupid choise. But it's the good choice.
A bit of gray helps extend the average lifespan of the material plane. But for angels, the average lifespan is NOT the point of being.
PS. an angel with the opportunity to cut down a baby, actually has more options than "kill" or "let him be evil incarnate". The angel can actually take the baby and rise it as a good person.

Anyway: Situations in my (non Ravenloft) angel-heavy games: "There's an angel nearby, he will mess with our plans to do X evil act" "Damn, let's trap a couple of civilians in an airtight room so when the Angel teleports to stop us, we can tell him where they are and he would lose 1 min or so to save them and we can teleport away"
And it worked. Because X evil act was stealing something so the angel prefered to save the innocents.

Then there was an incident with an evil PC abducting kids just to blackmail an Angel to leave. Well, the angel just sacrified his teleport without error ability to teleport the kids away. Near TPK in that battle, for non-violent creatures angels are actually too strong.
How the PCs got away? They promised to not harm kids anymore, and at the time, they believed it. Think of it like a fiend-pact but with an angel. If they broke it, angels would come and attack them.

Non-Ravenloft I love putting outsiders in. So, in order of fairness the numbers of angels in the world is about the same as with fiends. Consider how many evil fiends the good adventurers of levels 7-11 encounter and you'll figure how many angels I place in my non-Ravenloft worlds.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: I've only skimmed the Book of Exalted Deeds so far, intending to get back to it eventually, but I'm curious what it has to say about dogmatic good in a complex world.
The philosophy aspect of the BoED is very good. The prestiges and spells etc is all rubbish. They actually made a kind of poison, that's not really poison, so it's not evil to use. Because it's made to be good. :? More like crusades mentality of "Killing is bad. Unless the other guy is not of our religion"

More or less, there are different takes on goodness for the DM to choose.
The D&D version which is more like "good and evil are like political parties. Good is just treating the other good people better"
VIEW CONTENT:
They clearly state that in the canon D&D universe, good and evil are quantifiable things like blond hair that you have and can be targeted (hence the smite evil, detect good etc). The difference between good/evil in D&D canon world and blondhair or being an elf is... that you choose to be of an alignment unless you're "always evil" like dragons and outsiders that have no choice.
The Gods decided that attacking a good creature or being selfish is evil. They also decided that using poison is evil. They also decided that attacking an evil creature and charity is good. They also decided that using the "not-poison" thing is actually good. So, to go to heaven you can be selfless and offer charity, or just bash evil beasties or poison the evil tyrrant with not-exactly-poison.
THEN they present alternatives. Like the one I use that good doesn't budge, that life isn't quantifiable and there's not "a little evil for the greater good" etc.

THen they present an other alternative that is more like ... unplayable. ALL violence is bad. that kind of thing.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by A G Thing »

Not to quote anyone directly but I think the main thing that people seem to be hung up on for arguments against Angels being used in Ravenloft is that they are these bastions of pure good with no free will. If that is the case then no angel in the history of D&D would ever have fallen because you cannot even in Ravenloft hold a person forced to commit an action responsible for their failure. You don't blame a gun for firing perfectly as you wanted nor a tool used to build a bomb. Thus for them to have some measure of accountability they have to have some free will.

Yes they should have limits to their free will but the fact is that they are not Gods though they do work for them, and while they may think they know better they do not always have the right answers. They may be composed by their creator to do such but they are reasonably intelligent enough to act on their own otherwise they would be asking their god for help all the time. Making mindless drones that feel pain and are forced to do what you want does not seem the purview of any good God and sounds more the actions of a God submitting to its fear to keep control or being a power monger. If the God is commanding them all the time then when they come to Ravenloft without that guidance what do they become but lost constructs. They may mime having personalities but they just act as they would have been commanded and without new instructions they may come into conflict especially when alignment can no longer be detected.

Also if these beings were perfect exemplars of good than they would simply be Good with no other alignment descriptor. What is the use of listing Lawful when they simply cannot do wrong and what is the point of listing Chaotic when they will never randomly have to decide what is or is not right. These ethical alignments on controlled outsiders seem to be more like ziegbiters for constructs preventing them from acting rather than actual moral dilemmas. Without the will to act freely they simply cannot be blamed.

My idea of such goodly outsiders is that yes they are motivated strongly in the direction to do Good and act along their Ethical outlooks in such a fashion but the newest of them are more like innocents whose faith has had no reason to be tested and are confident they are right. The older of them who are experienced have seen suffering and have become confident in a different fashion as well but even they are tested due to abuse of such compassion and maintaining their nature by bending but not breaking under such servitude. The younger know what their god commands of them but it is similar to how a priest who never actually deals with people might know of it in that it is very literal, thus they can quote scripture or perform rituals but in applying it to the real world they have to learn a bit or find that they hold a standard humanity cannot live up to. The older have faced the world and through experience they have found that what holds in heaven cannot always apply exactly below due to limitations of both circumstance and perception thus they have to work around or do the best they can.

Many religions in the past were intolerant or had to change to reach people and Angels would have to deal with the same issues as those priests when new interpretations of the faith were required to live in the world. A chaotic outsider might be more flexible in changing but a lawful one might become trapped by the rules. Heck the chaotic one might become convinced that if one rule could change then why not change others just to be proactive or they might become unable to act simply from lack of clarity. A neutral outsider might try to force a balance between the two that compromises both actions or may get so caught up looking for balance that they cannot decide what is good or evil anymore.

These conflicts between their Good nature and ethical nature usually results in them having to side with doing nothing to avoid doing evil. All this comes simply from interpretation of what they know of their faith but even that may have to change from church to church, situation to situation or person to person. They could simply decide to wait till things become clearer or being proactive they may decide become so overly convinced of their being right on this that they enforce these edicts and may have to punish individuals in the name of the church to straighten out the issue. These actions may be correct or wrong but they have to make a choice for one or the other. They cannot stand by and simply support what they came to fix by going with the flow forever while others abuse the church for what seems evil or questionable ends and when they act they may in fact make the wrong choice.

Their alignments in 3.5 tend to read "Always Lawful Good" or "Always Chaotic Good" or "Always Neutral Good"... It is in that first ethical part of the alignment that you find the ways in which a Good Outsider will more often falter or fall. They take their duties to this concept too far trying to find ways to enforce such behavior and correct problems they see in mortal worship. They take these actions too far eventually when they reach the point that all decisions become black and white not just from a good and evil perspective but from a law and chaos perspective.

Examples of such:
1 Lawful outsiders enforce edicts of the church to exacting standards either to make things fair and orderly or maintain the exact letter of the religious law as a good that does not perhaps serve all of the faithful but is as their God wills it.
2 Chaotic outsiders might begin to try and tear down corrupt systems or change norms only to spread chaos that leads to tragedy or even unintended blasphemy, or may actively begin supporting a cause that while not perfectly moral is striking against an immoral lawful organization.
3 Neutral outsiders would also become convinced that maintaining perfect balance in areas or across the whole faith is necessary possibly to the exclusion of considering good better or greater than evil and just another way of dealing with the problem to ensure that good stays good.

Outsiders who fall due to exaggerating their Good qualities may be overprotective and harsh enslaving creatures into good behavior much as an abusive overprotective parent might. They begin to feel superior rather than compassionate to their charges in an excess that may slowly twist to the negative their once kinder feelings.

Often this results from their poor understanding of their faith or even their feelings of compassion for or superiority to their mortal charges and they begin to take the duty onto themselves. They begin to try and fix problems almost like they were deities but they piggy back on the faith of their Gods they serve. They begin to decide what is good and evil rather than just interpret it and this is outside of their purview granted by the gods. They begin to corrupt though unintentionally the virtues they were sent to uphold or act to benefit mortals to the point where they send the wrong messages about how faith works. Eventually they may even begin to believe they are creating something of worth ignoring faults or failures as simply evil elements or corruption to be fixed. For all their power they are not Gods though they are sent to do their work and may in turn have problems handling it.

In the end since these inflexible beings now believe they are acting in their lords best interest when they discover they are not or have failed they may resent such or snap as they cannot accept that they could be punished for doing what they were told to do. They attempt to prove themselves all the more or to justify their actions and their positions as exemplars with pride and reasoning meant to serve. They however have done wrong and this runs counter to what their nature tells them and what they have been prepared for. Many snap once faced with their failings and may become unstable while others might be able to be turned back on the right path. Still often a servant that has to clean up a masters mess and then is blamed for making it worse resents that master. Especially if they have done so repeatedly and been praised for it before. Gods in D&D are not infallible and may themselves become angry or prideful when failure results from their chosen servants efforts, or the mistake was obvious to perhaps those who went another less intense way.

Now take all these examples above and put such a creature in a land where they can never talk to their gods and may also be influenced by dark powers. A land where they cannot tell who is truly good or evil except through judgement alone but evil holds sway and often from the shadows. Finally a land that twists the very powers they use and that is its self so cloistered from the true radiance of the divine that the people might not recognize it as more than another monster.

Transposing with a person might be a method preferred so as to slowly give the angel a chance to adjust to all these sudden changes. Throwing an angel there otherwise might simply lead to their destruction in mind if not outright. It might also shield them from being detected too soon. Still finding a mortal worthy of such that will guide the angel on the proper action or how the world works could be difficult.

That is mostly how I see this! What do you think? :)
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
User avatar
Trike
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 262
Joined: Wed Jul 11, 2012 12:04 am
Location: North Carolina

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by Trike »

This dances around one of the failures of the alignment system in Dungeons and Dragons. In short, many of the greatest characters in literature were great because they were capable of both good and evil. The alignment system doesn't seem to support this unless you allow characters to easily and quickly shift alignment. Otherwise, why would anyone who was actually playing their good aligned character properly ever need to make a Dark Powers check?

It is certainly possible that angels are not capable of any actions that are not good. But some of you are right, we have examples of fallen angels. Therefore, angels must be capable of actions other than good. Maybe it is only Lawful Good outsiders that have no choice. Maybe the Chaotic part of the alignment scale is what allows variance in actions?

This all reminds me of the movie Constantine.
VIEW CONTENT:
Gabriel is a fantastic example of how an angel could be useful in Ravenloft. In fact, you could easily see a character with the failings of Gabriel becoming a Dark Lord.
If you like the idea that angels simply don't have the capability of evil actions. Then maybe something is terribly wrong with the fallen ones. The typical angel cannot commit an evil act. But there could be some level of dysfunction or insanity in angels. Fallen angels had something wrong with them long before they fell.

Nietzsche could find no other creature that stared into the abyss as long as angels. So, maybe there are no other creatures that face as much threat of the abyss staring back.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by alhoon »

A G Thing wrote: Yes they should have limits to their free will
In my campaign, they have limits to their free will, they're not like obedient dead. ;) You ask about lawful and chaotic. That's different aspects of goodness. In the example I gave in my above post, a lawful good angel would act differently against an evil tyrrant than a chaotic, but both would act selfleshly to improve the conditions of life of those around them. They just have different ways to do it.
Even within those alignment differences, there would be different decisions made by one lawful good angel from another lawful good angel. One may decide to help with the famine problem while the other with the epidemic problem. That kind of thing.
Trike wrote: In short, many of the greatest characters in literature were great because they were capable of both good and evil.
That's correct. But none of the greatest characters in literature are actually... angels. ;)
The freedom of choice makes us humans/elves/dwarves/goblins/hill giants special in my eyes and my campaigns.
Trike wrote:It is certainly possible that angels are not capable of any actions that are not good. But some of you are right, we have examples of fallen angels.
A G Thing wrote: If that is the case then no angel in the history of D&D would ever have fallen
All I'm trying to say could be surmised as "There are no fallen angels or redeemed fiends in my campaign". I understand you may want fallen angels in yours and I certainly see their appeal.

Guys, we're not trying to form a canon here, we don't have to agree. The way I see it we have various oppinions. That's a good thing.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Ryan Naylor
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1285
Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by Ryan Naylor »

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: I do believe in pure good in Ravenloft, but perhaps it's my upbringing speaking when I say I think that good in Ravenloft is "less good" when its inspired by pure goodness from the Heavens. Ravenloft's remote connection to the Divine is a sort of crucible where good can be put to the test without knowing for certain that there's a reward waiting. One can have faith that there is a reward, and believe it completely, but never know with proof, because there aren't Deities walking the earth, Angelic hosts inspiring humans, free planar travel to Heaven, etc... If there's a pure angel walking around with all the answers, that does have the potential to turn good into boring, IMHO.
I don’t think we disagree on this at all. As I see it, Ravenloft operates on two completely different levels: the Dark Powers-eye-view, where good and evil are clear, absolute and immiscible, and the PCs-eye-view, where things are much, much murkier. And you’re completely right when you say there’s no real place for a pure angel to be walking around with all the answers—at the PC level. This is what I was getting at when I was talking about the subtlety required of outsiders.

Take the Exorcist, for example. Let’s assume that because there’s a demon in there, there’s an angel in there too for reasons of balance. And this angel is pure and flawlessly good. Now, I don’t remember a 7 foot tall glowing creature with wings and fiery sword in the Exorcist, and I feel the presence of such a figure might undermine the story the Exorcist was trying to tell.

I do, however, remember Lt Kinderman. Kindly. Brings information to Chris that helps her face the truth that (a) Regan is actually possessed and (b) guilty of desecration and murder. He also helps Karras face truths (a) and (b), encourages him, and generally acts as a facilitator to help Regan and Chris and get the demon out. All in what, 2 or 3 scenes?

This is the way I see angels as being able to operate in Ravenloft: by providing a little word of advice here, a helpful piece of equipment there, a bit of encouragement over there. All from the guise of normal, everyday people. If you were the Dark Powers (which, as a GM, you are), you’d see they were a blazing presence manipulating events quietly for good, but to the people of the world, they’re indistinguishable from normal (good) people. It’s similar to the Vistani, except the Vistani are neutral and the angels are good. Similar to what Alhoon said, there aren’t angels for the PCs to turn to to ask for help; they’re there, but they’re hidden, and they’re helping ways other than “Thou shalt now attack Strahd’s castle, and remember not to drink the red wine.”

As in game evidence that this is how it works, look at Carnival: it explicitly tell us that Isolde’s superiors warned her that she must stay in a human body, and all of her really overt powers (like turning into a ball of light) are blocked (or perhaps, forbidden except in times of great duress). For that matter, look at VRGtFiends: even though you’d expect fiends to squirm around rules whenever they can, the only fiend that doesn’t habitually disguise its true nature behind a human shell is Drigor (who can’t, but still hides himself away from the eyes of mortals) and the Whistling Fiend (who still assumes human form sometimes, and as a tanar’ri, you’d expect it to be the most likely to break the rules). You’ll also notice there are long periods when we don’t know what the fiends are up to; presumably they’re trying to steer those around them to evil with a hint here and a bribe there, which is why we don’t see them.

Also, I would imagine that angels want people to choose to do good of their own free will. There’s a long storytelling history of outsiders not being able to force mortals to good or evil; they have to choose it freely. In which case, perhaps all they can do is make suggestions and hint, rather than being overt?

As for the Abominations, I’m not sure that we know enough about what’s going on inside them to really judge whether it’s a good act or not. On one hand, we know that Isolde approves of the Twisting, cannot control the changes and that it makes a creature’s inner nature become manifest physically. A lot of them seem designed to teach someone a lesson (the Gargantuan and the Living Skeleton are clear examples, where the effects of the Twisting will lessen if Morla becomes her own person and Rasulid becomes a better one). We also know that the Troupers have enacted the Death of a Thousand Knives, which they *believe* to be merciful compared to Isolde’s punishment for murder. Which she has only done 6 times in 10 years, and at least one (and potentially more) of those was a servant of the Gentleman Caller. We also know that the intelligence of the Abominations is vastly reduced (2-4) so they’re little more than animals. We only have Pacali’s word for it that they’re suffering, and he actually quite clearly says he doesn’t know.

What if the 6 Abominations were all servants of the Gentleman Caller (they’re all CE after all), and their form just represents the spiritual corruption of allying with a demon? What if reducing their intelligence is her mercy, so they suffer less in their new forms? It’s only a cruel and unusual punishment if they’re suffering. What if Pacali’s right but his interpretation is wrong: they have some sense of what they used to be and what they did to deserve their current form, but they also know the hope of redemption, and that with enough time and work (thinking good thoughts, essentially), they can return to normal? That’s why Isolde won’t allow them to be killed – because she wants them to have the chance to redeem themselves.

My point here is that whether the Abominations’ existence is a smut on Isolde’s soul or not depends very much on what’s going on inside her head and the heads of the Abominations, and we have almost no access to either. I think it’s an open question.

Of course, even if she’s a fallen angel, she’s still a CG angel. Fallen, but not fallen too far.

Your argument about killing baby Vecna needs to be teased apart, because it’s unanswerable without explicating whether Ravenloft is deterministic or not (that is, how powerful Fate is compared to free will). If free will exists, you can’t say that this baby will grow up to be Vecna; you can only say this baby has a strong chance of doing so. In that case, the baby is still an Innocent at this stage, and if I were the angel I’d ensure it went to some very loving and supportive parents and had a proper education in responsibility and ethics. If his fate is set in stone, then I see it as more like putting down a rabid dog. A rabid dog has no responsibility for what it is, but it has no ability to be anything other than what it is, which is a lethal danger to almost all mammal life in that area. Likewise, if baby Vecna has no chance of ever not being a crazy undead wizard god who will cause untold suffering across *all* the planes of existence, then I think you’re probably justified in putting him down. That baby cannot be said to be Innocent. I think it’d probably be a bit upsetting for the angel, though.

Having said that, I think the first example is the one that actually represents the way Ravenloft works.

Your other example (of catching 2 people who are falling, and it only has time to save one): being physically unable to save someone is not an evil act. It’s not even a neutral act. There may be times when trying to save both and failing is the best (most good) way; there may be others when you just have to accept you can only save one, and do it (again, probably a bit upsetting). In some cases, letting the good person die and saving the neutral might be the best thing to do, because (at a spiritual level), the good person has already been “saved” but this gives the neutral the chance to make their life right. So while I’m not qualified to say which is right, an angel (even one incapable of doing wrong like Alhoon is suggesting) is, and would do it.

As a fallible human, you can write it into your game because you completely control the consequences of actions in the world. In essence, moral quandaries become a lot easier if you are actually the god of that world. If the angel cannot do otherwise than choose the best path, whichever path you choose for it is the best path. Of course, as I said before, that is not always clear to people in the world, including the PCs, so it’s still quite simple to have moral debates, murkiness and good angel antagonists.

On AG Thing’s point:

I don’t think they’re automatons. I do think you can be pure good and still have free will. In essence, it’s not that you can’t choose option B, it’s that it would never occur to you to do so. It’s just not in your makeup. Yes, of course you could just stand there and watch the orphanage burn, but who would do that? Then, angels can fall because they become aware of option B and take it instead.

However, my main point is that (going right back to the point of this thread), transposition is not necessarily vile, and that not only is it in theme to have pure good angels in gothic horror, you can do everything with them that you could do with a fallen angel (because humans don’t have the same kind of foresight angels do, and may end up with the wrong end of the stick), and that fallen angels everywhere are an overused and lazy device which guts the power and importance of the struggle of good and evil by making good look weak and hypocritical.

Seriously: think about how many fallen angels there are in D&D: Asmodeus, *all* erinyes, Baalzebul/Triel, Trias the Betrayer, Zalatian XXIII, etc etc. Now think of all the fallen fiends: Falls from Grace and Eludecia (both succubi), and possibly A’kin the Friendly Fiend (although that might be a bluff).

As regards LG vs CG: I think if you’re going to take the D&D alignment system seriously, you need to treat LG and CG as separate things, rather than different interpretations of the same thing. That is, an archon is not Good, and Lawful: it is lawfulgood, and the lawfulness informs but doesn’t adulterate the goodness.

Specifically, an archon believes that the best, if not the only, way to goodness is through order and community (and, you will note, this says nothing about the word of the local law). What is good for one is good for all. Individuals are viewed within the context of society, and an orderly, good society will create and nurture good in all of its members, starting from the youngest. An unjust law is no law at all.

An eladrin/azata believes that freedom, the rights of the individual, and respecting others’ choices are the way to goodness. They prefer to take life as it comes, rather than planning everything. This is not to say they don’t occasionally agree with tradition or law – any rule should be questioned, but questioning is not the same as overthrowing, and sometimes the authority is perfectly reasonable. Freedom entails dealing with the consequences of your actions. Ideally, a free people will still choose to do good, out of mutual respect – do unto others, etc.

Lawful good is not “more good” than chaotic good; it’s a different type. I can’t accept that CG celestials are more likely to fall than LG ones (in fact, the opposite seems to be true).

The reason mortals can act inconsistently with their alignments is that they’re not exemplars – they’re not pure LG in the way an archon is/might be/should be. If you (Trike) see it as a failure, I think you might be misunderstanding or overinterpreting the system.

And finally,
Deewun wrote: Ravenloft is founded in gothic and evolved to pull its references/building blocks from elsewhere in horror. There is a lot to mine with Angels/the Host/law v. good. And I think discounting it is the surest way to miss out on GREAT ideas being added to Ravenloft as a whole, which keeps the setting growing in new and interesting ways.
I get that, and agree. I just think we’re ignoring non-grimdark opportunities.

Also, sorry to nitpick, but Pharazia is the second cousin of Vathek (one of the most famous gothic novels, which is also set in “Arabia”), Vechor is not based on a Midsummer Night’s Dream, and Timor is based on Stephen King’s IT, not Alien. But I do take your point about Ravenloft not being all gothic all the time- e.g. The Shadow Rift/Tepest and my bogeymen are based in fairy tale horror. Still, it's more about themes than trappings (e.g. of Europe rather than Persia).
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by A G Thing »

First to alhoon...

Sorry if I come off confrontational but I was just trying to make an honest debate about it and a lot of the phrasing I read in comments lacked these little details you filled in. I was just thought I was throwing my two cents into the ring with the others in the debate and picked a side I felt I could respond to and use to gain responses on what I was wrong about and learn new things. Of course in most of our posts I guess things are supposed to be implied that we are just debating how we are using/view them and I thought I got that across so my bad. Still my comments are meant to provoke only debate or discussion and I honestly am not worried if you agree or not but I certainly don't want to start any conflict. I am sorry if I don't get that across at first, I just tend to write that way.

I also never meant to imply that your angels specifically were automatons (Only that I think without free will they basically are!) directly in that sense and I was just referencing the entire post mostly because I did not check who had written what.

Now on to Ryan Naylor
VIEW CONTENT:
Also read what I wrote to Alhoon as I was just trying to debate and I really don't want to start conflict. Plus I really have some questions about your views on how you handle celestials and while I may phrase things kind of aggressively I guess I really don't want to anger you let me know if I come off that way as it is truly unintentional.

In part Your orphanage example is interesting in that you clearly define what is pure good for an angel there and how you consider that to be such. My angels would also defer to this response. However you reference the choice that damns an angel to fall is like choosing to take an evil action or a good action. Are you saying their is no degree in which an Angel could be wrong or believe an action is good that may in fact not be? If so then you have made a scenario where they would never willingly choose evil and that is correct for most representations of angels but that was not really what I was trying to reference in my post. What I was saying was not that they had the freedom to choose easy A and B, Good or Evil but that they must choose. When faced with a situation demanding timely action and not in a clear cut situation I still say that such a pure being can fall from grace when not placed in such a black and white frame and given the fact that they are not so one dimensional can have other influences even if this is an instinctual default, and these influences can weight them down over time or with severity as they are not perfect in my game. Yes they may regret their actions or not want to do them but in order to do good they have to justify them. These are the choices I am trying to highlight and perhaps I did not state that well enough before.

As an example of this... How does a celestial under your standards handle this problem? A known evil plague is spreading through town with no cure found and while death is not completely certain it is deadly and debilitating enough that panic is sweeping through the people. The city has been surrounded by its nations army that will allow aid in but no one may exit until the disease is cured. Now none of these people have acted badly yet but at the rate of progression of spread in a week it is thought that everyone will be infected unless the sick are killed and the town cleansed. But the sick have a narrow hope for survival and some do not want to die but they risk others through no fault of their own. Still surviving requires contact with healers and supplies and while quarantine methods may work in a smaller infection this epidemic struck too quietly and spread out too fast for such to be effective now without severe risks. Even now fears of anyone exhibiting a symptom could lead to ones family being ostracized as well. The gods have stated that they cannot or will not cure the disease outright but that the Angel should do what ever it can to help the people. Does the angel kill these people to save the uninfected if they are there to intervene? There is a chance that some infected will survive but statistically speaking killing them to save the uninfected would probably result in more total survivors. What is the good course of action can they take?

Anyways perhaps angels in your games are capable of no wrong in any fashion because they simply do not think of it as an option. But where does their duty to their god intersect to their own decision making? For all their power a celestial usually serves the deities of good and for all the intentions of these divine beings it is known that to do good for others sometimes you have to get your hands dirty when others don't agree and the stakes are high enough. If their god tells them that for the good of the world they must put a tyrant on the throne of a great empire and must insure that several other good forces that do not see this bigger picture and must remain ignorant of it are defeated and subjugated and given only the vaguest of reasons why with the assurance that it is for the best would they do it? They are free to choose the least destructive means to do so but by doing such they risk the completion of edicts of a power greater than them that is telling them failure in the emplacement of this minor evil now is worse than the resulting greater evil this act will bring. Evil done now for a greater good later. They could even refuse to do such based on trust and faith in the gods but it also shows a fear for the staining of ones own hands or of being betrayed or used.

The way you reference the above orphanage incident also seems to imply little danger to the celestials soul or even body but they can be a hero and thus save the children. Obviously that task was just for reference of the decision making of the angel however but I wonder if the stakes were higher how an angel in your game would handle it. If sent on a mission to risk their own lives or existence would they still be unflinching and unselfish. Certainly you could argue they are selfless by nature, but it dehumanizes angels all the more to have them show no fear or have no desires beyond service (Still they are not human so not too much of a problem in some regard). Being fearless in the face of a large peril when you could suffer a fate worse than death is unreasonable for any being capable of suffering such however and though it may appear brave it also seems insanely fatalistic. If they suffer fear then does it over take them? If not then do they really suffer fear at all then? Also if they are so self sacrificing then one has to ask what is the limit to their selflessness? Can you push an angel too far to where it loses self control of its actions to save its self? Is it not responsible then?

On to another part of your response in that you say I am comparing alignments against one another as to which one is most good. I really was not trying to do that but I was trying to give examples of failings for each such alignment for a celestial. I know NG, CG and LG are all evenly good and it just affects their decisions. When I was talking about flexibility I was more referencing how sticking too close to these ingrained biases to Law, Chaos, Neutrality and even Pure Good could result in limitations in thinking for Celestials' that may cause them to have trouble with certain problems. I consider them to be individuals much as you do but as such I also consider that some may be more experienced, younger, smarter or such just as I am sure you do. Still beyond that they all have these traits in common with others of their type and they are part of their type in the rules which implies to me that they deal in law or chaos or such because it is a part of their nature as well. Sure certain individuals may break type or such and if that is the case I would treat them as such.

Your example of the Lawful Good Archon poses an interesting question for me as to how your Archon would handle this scenario. Lets say this Archon is placed in a kingdom that is suffering from severe famine due to circumstances outside of its control that came about outside of the trade season making conditions harsh. They are tasked with insuring that the kingdom survives. Now originally the law of the land is that in such times the king and those in power get twice the amount that others do due to rationing. This is to ensure that the government does not collapse and can still function as they request aid. However this famine is costing the kingdom much in the way of their treasury and to help spur the economy and convince other kingdoms to help them they begin to also try to ration more food to the merchant class. If they do not do this they believe that they will not recover economically or make the in roads necessary to save the kingdom before their meager supplies run out. While they explain this and that it is a hard decision they meet resistance from the laborers and farmers who are providing what little food they have to divide and products to sell. These citizens are at first asked and grudgingly accept the initial hopeful estimate and then when things continue to decline they begin to revolt and now just short of full riot or desertion they are being forced to do such when they begin to resist to help save the kingdom as a whole. Progress would be slow and it may be a risk that will let many go hungry to try and save the majority but the other way might make them all more comfortable but make success in revitalizing much harder to achieve. Is changing the law unjust? Is forcing them to continue wrong? Short of dissolving the kingdom since it goes against its orders how does the Archon salvage the situation? The kingdom is not trying to destroy its people but it did ask them to take a risk and so far that risk has not paid off. If the kingdoms rulers and merchants succeed then it will end the famine sooner but surely they would be doing much worse if they did not have this extra support. The townspeople outside these groups are being asked to carry much of the burden and they will suffer more before results appear from their efforts so naturally when things start to seem like they are not working they are claiming foul. They are only being forced because they have lost faith and are hungry enough to become scared and the kingdom is only using force because this is the only option they have to stop the panic from destroying their best chance for survival for them all.

The Eladrin/Azata example you posed in contrast seems to state this as if I am saying that Chaotic Outsiders are all going to tear down society. In truth I think you are assuming that I am talking about all such outsiders when in fact my examples are meant to highlight those that are mistaken in how to act or are not recognizing the faults in their behaviors. I see my Chaotic Good outsiders behaving similar to yours but only when they are not struggling to adapt to conflicts like those above. What solutions would such an outsider have to such questions as I posed above? They may have just as much trouble as any other being even with their willingness to bend or ignore rules especially since they know that unrestrained chaos is bad. When pushed into a corner we all fall back on our natures and often we have to deny them to do good.

You state the mortals can act inconsistently with their alignments being why they are not exemplars but in truth the way I see it, angels and other celestials may try to stay pure in their good but that makes them more faulty then mortals. A mortal has far more challenges to overcome to face down the evils that rise before them and while they may fail or succeed they are not predisposed or even given the boons an outsider has. They choose to be good or evil and while good is always white and evil is always black they have more to worry about to survive than just the balance of these two things. Goodly outsiders live in dimensions suited to their natures and needs and when traveling the mortal world they cannot be truly killed and do not suffer infirmities or other hindrances. They have perhaps love for all but they while experiencing emotions do not have the full context or depth of mortals on the meaning of those emotions without some personal experiences. For them they have all of eternity short of dying in service on some distant plane knowing their purpose and even what is expected of them. They get their messages directly from the Gods and know more of the meanings to existence with a certainty mortals don't have. They have freewill but are bound to service of good and dogma of deities. Their lives may be hard and longer and such but you compare them to mortals as if they were so much greater. What being if it seen as such would not wonder if it truly is superior to mortals? Why wouldn't a race of thinking beings have individuals that falter from such a demanding path?

You also referenced that more celestials fall than fiends rise up from hell/abyss. But the nature of good and evil is often summed up in the statement of "doing what is right or what is easy!"... Being good is hard in many cases and while simple times may allow for easy good the more complex the nature of the situation the more likely even seemingly obviously good actions can have larger consequences. Evil however never has to be complex unless it wants to stay such. A demon may work in secret toward a larger goal but it could also blow its cover to destroy a town and ruin such a plan and this does not make it good but it still acted in its nature. An angel that had to work its way into an evil organization to prevent a doomsday scenario would be evil if they ruined the plan to stop a evil act and revealed themselves simply by being unwise or impulsive though they acted in their nature. By your measure that celestial would never do such thus this may not work for yours but lets offer you this conundrum. If an angel cannot be corrupted by their own choices then do they have freewill? A fallen angel is not a lazy device, (Overused perhaps!) as when used correctly it is poignant, and in honesty when done correctly it does not make evil look greater or good look weaker. Good and Evil are constantly in conflict so naturally even their greatest servants can become conflicted as well. With freewill there is the potential for good or evil actions thus even these exemplars as you put it must be capable of performing actions opposite of their nature no matter how pure they claim to be. I just don't see how it can work otherwise. If sins can be forgiven then even the blackest of demons can rise back to a celestial but good is harder than evil. And evil being easier does not make it more powerful only more tempting to those who cannot see it clearly for what it is.

I get that it is your game and opinion and I really was not trying to change it but as for baseline Ravenloft and the D&D game as it stands there is a precedent for it. I was more trying to find ways in which they did work not so much to highlight reasons why not but if it came off as an attack that was the farthest thing from my mind. I really read the posts and maybe I misread them. It is so hard sometimes for me to not see a debate and keep my meaning clear and neutral though I honestly am always trying to do such. I meant. I never meant your way of using angels is wrong and I thought it was interesting enough to add my own comments on how I use them even in Ravenloft.
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

This is just my own house rule, but any outsider that changes ethical and/or moral alignment loses that alignment subtype as well (fallen celestials are no longer Good, redeemed fiends are no longer Evil, etc.). Alignment subtypes, to me, represent an inherent part of their makeup and to stray from it means literally losing some spiritual part of themselves. That's my two cents on fallen angels and such.

One of the main reasons I disagree with transposition by celestial is mostly mechanical. Evil attracts evil in Ravenloft; powers checks, fiendish reality wrinkles vs. celestial disruptions, that sort of thing. Therefore it makes no sense that a celestial would answer a failed powers check because it doesn't call out to them. Fiends would pick up on this, and the system of land-based powers is designed to tempt fiends until they lose their reality wrinkles and any hope of ever escaping. Celestials' reality disruptions erode the planar fabric, possibly tearing holes in the dimensional walls that they could escape through if it went on long enough. This could also be an explanation for why the Scroll of Return must be written on the skin of a celestial. Part of the magic that enables escape comes from the eroding abilities the "donor" had.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by alhoon »

A G Thing wrote:Sorry if I come off confrontational
Nope you didn't come off as confrontational. All is good. I just wanted to be clear. I was at no time feeling "pressured" to accept one opinion or another, I just said my opinion and just in case, I added that it's OK if we don't agree.

As for the plague: IMO and IMC, killing innocents is not an option for the angel. IMO in the angel's eyes death by a terrible disease it's bad and all and you suffer, but after death, you go to your eternal reward.
So IMO, the angel would be more about healing with his magical abilities, or spending time with the diseased sinners to comfort them and try as hard as possible to give them redemption before they die from the disease. As Ryan said, I wouldn't use a 8' tall glowing guy with feathers and a huge sword that cleaves down sinners, but an inobtrusive and easy to miss old man, that speaks the right words of hope and comfort to the ailing and dying guy, brings him cool water and runs to bring him his estranged son so they can make up before the dying guy perishes.

Or he would try to keep the order in the city so that mobs wouldn't kill the diseased. Or he would do something else based on the angel's disposition.

Anyway, what I'm trying to say is that the best people I know off, even in fiction is not Rambo types that kill enemies. It's selfless "little" people that go the extra mile, organizing charity for the kids with cancer, spending time with old people without relatives in nurseries etc.
My grandfather for example: He gave up a lot to help others, knowing he would never get more than a thank you. He was the type that when dying from bone cancer, he would try to hide the extent of his discomfort so we won't be worried about him. He died poor and in pain. And happy. It may sound weird, but he was happy. I don't know how. He was though. His last words to me, days before he died was to tell me some of his happy memories.
Last edited by alhoon on Mon Sep 17, 2012 6:15 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Ryan Naylor
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1285
Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by Ryan Naylor »

High Priest Mikhal wrote:One of the main reasons I disagree with transposition by celestial is mostly mechanical. Evil attracts evil in Ravenloft; powers checks, fiendish reality wrinkles vs. celestial disruptions, that sort of thing. Therefore it makes no sense that a celestial would answer a failed powers check because it doesn't call out to them.


I don't think anyone's suggesting that (or at least, I'm not). The idea is that extreme good actions could attract a celestial in something like a transposition, not evil ones.
Celestials' reality disruptions erode the planar fabric, possibly tearing holes in the dimensional walls that they could escape through if it went on long enough. This could also be an explanation for why the Scroll of Return must be written on the skin of a celestial. Part of the magic that enables escape comes from the eroding abilities the "donor" had.
Good idea.
User avatar
Hazgarn
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Mar 26, 2008 12:17 am
Location: Sacramento, CA
Contact:

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by Hazgarn »

Here's a thought, though. If celestials really are that disruptive of the planar fabric of Ravenloft, would it even be possible for a Ravenloft native to survive transposition?

I'd think even if they could, then the resulting effects on the environment around the subject of the transposition would be a red flag that something "evil" was going on... Which could potentially be a very interesting plot hook.
Deranged Comics Fan
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
Ryan Naylor
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1285
Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by Ryan Naylor »

Look, I'm not arguing about the existence of fallen angels. As my examples show, I am clearly aware that they exist. I just don't care. The original question was whether an angel could transpose into Ravenloft. Everyone immediately started talking about fallen angels, or angels-as-dicks, and the point I was trying to make was that angels-as-angels is overlooked and in theme with gothic horror, whereas having nothing but fiends and fallen angels and angels-as-dicks running around is not. That's all.

I also play Planescape, and another important point in all this is that outsiders (both fiends and angels) have to work differently in Ravenloft as compared to other campaign settings, as Gonzoron already implied, because the themes and atmosphere of Ravenloft are different to other campaigns. Part of the miscommunication may be because that isn't being clear.
A G Thing wrote: However you reference the choice that damns an angel to fall is like choosing to take an evil action or a good action. Are you saying their is no degree in which an Angel could be wrong or believe an action is good that may in fact not be?
Or a neutral one. And no. But with high Int, high Wis, spell casting abilities, supernatural powers and aeons of experience, they're going to be wrong minimally. In Pathfinder, a ghaele like Isolde has Int 16, Wis 19 and a huge number of skill ranks, including Sense Motive +20.

The lowest CR fiend we have (apart from imp familiars) is the Chateaufaux barbazu at CR 5 (who probably doesn't count, because he has the amnizu to work with) or the Whistling Fiend at CR 6. The next cluster is Drigor, the Black Duke, Baltoi etc in the mid-teens. A ghaele is CR 13. These are powerful creatures. I wouldn't use a low CR celestial for that reason - they're too fallible, which is not how I think an angel should be used in Ravenloft. Only the angels the powers of good know will do their job properly without guidance will be sent to Ravenloft.

A known evil plague
What is an evil plague? One that causes suffering or one that is genuinely and supernaturally evil? Otherwise, pretty much what Alhoon said. For that matter, I'm an angel and I can cast remove disease and fly, so I can pretty easily separate the sick from the healthy.
If their god tells them that for the good of the world they must put a tyrant on the throne of a great empire and must insure that several other good forces that do not see this bigger picture and must remain ignorant of it are defeated and subjugated and given only the vaguest of reasons why with the assurance that it is for the best would they do it?


Then your god is a dick too. However, as an angel I have faith in my god (pretty much by definition). Or I go serve a different god who isn't a dick.
I wonder if the stakes were higher how an angel in your game would handle it. If sent on a mission to risk their own lives or existence would they still be unflinching and unselfish. Certainly you could argue they are selfless by nature, but it dehumanizes angels all the more to have them show no fear or have no desires beyond service (Still they are not human so not too much of a problem in some regard). Being fearless in the face of a large peril when you could suffer a fate worse than death is unreasonable for any being capable of suffering such however and though it may appear brave it also seems insanely fatalistic.
Yes, it would be unflinching and unselfish. It's an angel. It's not human. I'm not saying it wouldn't feel fear; I am saying it would do the right thing. It is a physical embodiment of the best mortal life can aspire to be. That's what it's for.
You state the mortals can act inconsistently with their alignments being why they are not exemplars but in truth the way I see it, angels and other celestials may try to stay pure in their good but that makes them more faulty then mortals.
Then clearly to see things differently to me. If an angel is made out of pure good, and love is good, then in what conceivable way could you say an angel doesn't have the full context or depth of love that a mortal does? It's built into its very soul. Its flesh even. As is humility and courage, for example.
Ryan Naylor
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1285
Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm

Re: Transposition by Angel?

Post by Ryan Naylor »

Hazgarn wrote:Here's a thought, though. If celestials really are that disruptive of the planar fabric of Ravenloft, would it even be possible for a Ravenloft native to survive transposition?

I'd think even if they could, then the resulting effects on the environment around the subject of the transposition would be a red flag that something "evil" was going on... Which could potentially be a very interesting plot hook.
That's what I was saying earlier.
Post Reply