HuManBing wrote:
Likewise, vivisection by itself is not the same as torture. Torture is the goal in and of itself - the infliction of pain with no other benefit in mind.
While I suspect that ultimately this is the goal of professional torturers (of whom there are many in our world), it is not evident that such is the unambiguous raison d'être of torture. There can be torture to save one's eternal soul, i.e., confess one's sins, renounce the Devil, and die with some prospect of not going to Hell. There can be torture to the end of preserving civil order as a type of official punishment within a well codified, non-arbitrary system of law that includes, among other punishments, execution, i.e., Renaissance Italy among other places. There can be torture to stop "ticking timebombs", a notion ushered into the world by Israel and adopted, at least covertly, by the US and the UK. There can be torture to gather information on "enemy threats" generally, used covertly by those same three countries and scores of others.
For my money, parallel situations in Ravenloft are all Power check worthy, not because of the absence of supposed benefits beyond the infliction of pain for its own sake, but rather despite the existence of the supposed benefits. The means are damnable, regardless of the ends.
Hence vivisection is not less troublesome than torture on the grounds that the latter is simply an end in itself while the former is not.
Perhaps vivisection that becomes an end in itself thereby becomes damnable and Power Check worthy. But the case of torture doesn't shed light on that as torture is damnable and Power Check worthy by its very nature.
Once, however, vivisection progresses from animal subjects to human subjects the distinctions between torture and vivisection threaten to collapse. Were vivisection done on human prisoners who have been fairly condemned for crimes against their fellow citizens, then it is looking very much like torture. Yes, an operation may be a species of vivisection. But when you or I visit a doctor, any risk that is taken with our health, must be to the end of improving our health. Vivisection on prisoners is pursued with, at best, perfect disregard for their health. The vivisection may be intended as punishment or to gather information, of one sort or the other, but it is a species of torture.
Vivisection is not then a species of torture when its subject freely consents to it, as in surgery or medical research, or when its subject is an animal along the lines argued by Rotipher. For the Dark Powers this is good enough. Of course precisions might well be added. A wild animal on Rotipher's argument can have no expectation of humane treatment. But what about a domesticated animal? Or more to the point, a pet? And that is not even to mention an awakened animal or a familiar. Granted, for us, this answer may not be satisfying. But Ravenloft is not our world. As Mangrum suggests, there is no evidence to suggest that the Dark Powers have a bone to pick with trappers.