Redemption from Act of Ultimate Darkness?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Prisoner of the Mists
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 8
Joined: Sat Dec 13, 2003 2:37 am

Redemption from Act of Ultimate Darkness?

Post by Prisoner of the Mists »

OK, I don't have my rulebooks with me right now, and I can't quite remember what they say about redemption from Acts of Ultimate Darkness. I know that "theoretically" even darklords can find redemption, though none ever has. And I remember that Domains of Dread had some clunky system for redemption from failed powers checks involving a number of redemptive acts equal to the percentage roll of the original powers check...but the 3rd edition doesn't have those percentage rolls anyway. So are there guidelines for redemption?

I've got a good NPC that automatically failed a powers check for violating a sacred vow (by using a divinely granted power to do violence) to save the PC party, and helping her find redemption might make a good adventure hook for the PCs. But how exactly does one redeem oneself for something like that?

Now, this NPC has an evil counterpart -- a fallen priest of the same religion and brother to one of the PCs. The PCs believe they killed him, but he is actually now a darklord off in the Mists somewhere who I plan to reveal at some later date. I can see that the good NPC's redemption might involve the evil NPC somehow, but it can't be helping to destroy him since that is just repeating the whole violence thing. Helping him find redemption would make more sense, but is it fair to make her redemption depend on someone else's actions?

This is a thorny question for me because it's an NPC and whatever the redemptive task is has to offer some opportunity for the PCs to be involved. And by the way, I want this good NPC to survive, not find redemption in some dramatic, self-sacrificing gesture. Any suggestions?
User avatar
Mortepierre
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2004 6:20 am
Location: Belgium

Re: Redemption from Act of Ultimate Darkness?

Post by Mortepierre »

Prisoner of the Mists wrote:OK, I don't have my rulebooks with me right now, and I can't quite remember what they say about redemption from Acts of Ultimate Darkness. I know that "theoretically" even darklords can find redemption, though none ever has.
Incorrect. Soth found redemption in the Spectre of the Black Rose novel, sort of.. (at least enough to get a free ride out of RL)
[b]Mortepierre Malepeste[/b]
[i]Dwarven Necro.. er .. Student of Anatomy[/i]
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

I don't know if that is Canon. Soth didn't found redemption anyway. He was kicked out of Ravenloft.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Moral Machivelli
Rat Blinder
Rat Blinder
Posts: 413
Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2005 3:54 pm
Location: Not Here...

Post by Moral Machivelli »

Hmm. I don't have my books with me either, but I seem to remember that strictly speeking redemption from Acts of ultimate darkness is impossible(Pleese corect me if I'm wrong.) However, I for one would let that slide in this case. But it should be very hard.

Hmm. Can you go into more depth on the darklord, and how the good NPC feels about him.
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

alhoon wrote:I don't know if that is Canon. Soth didn't found redemption anyway. He was kicked out of Ravenloft.
True, Soth was not redeemed when he was expelled from Sithicus. In fact, the Dark Powers seem to have engineered a parallel situation to that which caused his original fall from grace on Krynn (i.e. a choice between averting catastrophe and sparing his family, or destroying them all out of embittered pride), and he consciously chose to forsake his wife and son, while letting Sithicus fall. Soth knew what he was doing, this second time around, too: events didn't leave him the "out" of protesting that he'd thought his elven bride unfaithful, or gotten carried away by his rage.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Prisoner of the Mists
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 8
Joined: Sat Dec 13, 2003 2:37 am

Post by Prisoner of the Mists »

Moral Machivelli wrote: Hmm. Can you go into more depth on the darklord, and how the good NPC feels about him.
Ok. For reference, all these characters are outlanders.

The darklord and the good NPC were trained together as priests of a pacifistic religion, and they are also cousins. As I mentioned before, the darklord is also the brother of one of the PCs, making the good NPC also her cousin.

The darklord character fell from grace after being infected by a werewolf and deciding to embrace the curse rather than fight it. Because he felt wronged by the PC party, he began hunting them to seek revenge, and in the course of this fell in with their major enemy. He decided to join this enemy, who he believed could help him achieve vengeance not just on the PCs but on his whole family (I'll explain why he wants this in a bit).

The PCs finally managed to separate the soon-to-be-darklord from his allies, and his sister tried to appeal to family sentiment to get him to surrender. He refused, and they killed him, but the dark powers decided that they wanted to keep him around to play with a little longer. So they scooped up his dead body, brought him back to life and plunked him down off in the mists with a land and curse of his own. It's been a fair amount of time that he has not been seen, to get the PCs used to the idea that he's dead and ain't coming back.

Basically, he feels like he was betrayed by everyone who was supposed to be on his side. When he was cursed, his companions did not help him, leaving him "no choice" but to embrace his new power. But he is filled by such self-loathing, knowing full well how far he has fallen (especially since he is now undead) that he wants to eradicate all reminders of his former life in the vain hope that this would bring him peace of mind. I haven't fleshed it out in great detail yet, but his domain is a twisted reflection of his home city and the surrounding forests. He controls most of the wilderness, but the elves keep restoring the forests and he is unable to conquer the city. His gruesome appearance and the legends of the locals make it impossible that we will ever gain acceptance, so he merely continues his futile war to eradicate city and forest both. I haven't figured out how closely related the elves and humans in the domain are to the ones from the PCs' home world. I don't know if it would be creepier for the PCs to meet doubles of their relatives or to meet ALMOST-doubles whose histories and features are slightly off.

The thing is, the good NPC and the darklord have had very little "on-screen" time together. She was introduced AFTER he became an enemy of the party, and their characters have functioned mostly as foils to each other. She is not a permanent member of the party, and was not involved in the adventure that led to the darklord's death. But her first failed powers check has caused her to start paralleling the transformation that he underwent, and she has certainly expressed anger at the PCs for killing him in the first place, so the connection is very strong.

The only other thing I can think of that might be helpful in figuring this out is that the failed powers check caused her eyes to be replaced by cold blue points of light (think lich). If she is redeemed, I figure she will be left without eyes entirely, although not necessarily blind. Since she has precognitive abilities, it seems to fit.
Prisoner of the Mists
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 8
Joined: Sat Dec 13, 2003 2:37 am

Oh yeah

Post by Prisoner of the Mists »

Oh yeah...how the good NPC feels about the darklord. She loved him when he was her cousin and they were in training together. She is probably in a bit of denial about how evil he became (using past tense because she thinks he's dead). However, she also sees his fall and eventual fate as a dark reflection of herself and, with this failed powers check, is horrified at the thought that she might be doomed to the same path.
User avatar
Moral Machivelli
Rat Blinder
Rat Blinder
Posts: 413
Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2005 3:54 pm
Location: Not Here...

Post by Moral Machivelli »

Hmm. If she's fearful of falling, she's bordering on redeemed alredy. To finish it off, I would recomend you send her and the party to the DL's new domain(either by the random mists, or persuing someone to a "New land"), and have them hear stories about the DL's actions (Make sure that these are on a new level of horror, far worse than what the Party have know him to do before). She, refusing to believe that her cousin could have fallen that far, runs away from the party, to find him, and to prove that he hasn't really become that evil. When she finds him, all sorts of things could happen. Here's two off the top of my head.
  • She finds the cousin in the middle of one onf his more barbaric actions. She sees just what her cousin has done, what happens when they use violence, for whatever reason, and the inevitable result. This understanding results in her redemption

    She falls into the cousins arms in his castle, or stronghold, telling him of what people have said about him, what the party said of him, asking him to tell her that these things aren't true. He slightly stunned by this, admits them, then laments how far he has fallen, She breaks down in tears. Enter the PCs. after whatever happens next, when they find the Npc, She has lost her eyes, as you sugested.
Those are just ideas though.
User avatar
Bluebomber4evr
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 450
Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2004 9:08 pm
Location: United States of Whatever
Contact:

Post by Bluebomber4evr »

Was Soth even kicked out? It was my understanding that the DP simply grew bored of him and looked the other way when he had the opportunity to escape. I guess I just need to read Spectre of the Black Rose for myself! :lol:

Anyway, redemption shouldn't be possible after an Act of Ultimate Darkness. Someone who commits one of those is permanently one of the damned...though they might escape, they'll never be redeemed.
Bluebomber4evr: The Justice, not you, since 2002.
Ravenloft: Prisoners of the Mist Persistent World for Neverwinter Nights: www.nwnravenloft.com
User avatar
Moral Machivelli
Rat Blinder
Rat Blinder
Posts: 413
Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2005 3:54 pm
Location: Not Here...

Post by Moral Machivelli »

Bluebomber4evr wrote:Was Soth even kicked out? It was my understanding that the DP simply grew bored of him and looked the other way when he had the opportunity to escape. I guess I just need to read Spectre of the Black Rose for myself! :lol:

Anyway, redemption shouldn't be possible after an Act of Ultimate Darkness. Someone who commits one of those is permanently one of the damned...though they might escape, they'll never be redeemed.
You mean they can't be redemed through the standerd rules. However, if the penitant truly is repentant (As she is in this case) then it should be possible. Very, Very hard (In my example the party are coming close to directly opposing a darklord, hardly a recipy for helthy living) Most of the people who comit AoUD don't really regret what theve done afterwards.
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

Personally, I'd stick with the notion that AoUD can't be redeemed. It's not just a question of whether a person is sorry they did something that dreadful, but also of whether they're capable of going back to being the same person -- recapturing their inner peace, in effect -- after they've fallen so far. The worst of deeds should leave a lasting mark on a person's self-image and faith in themselves, IMHO: a crime sufficiently extreme to qualify as an AoUD isn't, and shouldn't be, something you can ever truly put behind you. Learn from it, yes; make amends for it, if possible ... but not just shrug off and forget it'd ever happened, no matter how many selfless acts you might perform in compensation.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Eric the Light Bringer
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 67
Joined: Wed Jan 03, 2007 2:06 pm
Location: Ontario, Canada

Post by Eric the Light Bringer »

Hi all...

I don't think a darklord can ever or should ever be redeemed...

My simple belief is a darklord and their domain are one and the same (like Strahd and Barovia, "I am the Land") and the darklord is not just a simple prisoner of their sins in RL but now permanently a part of the RL demiplane..."redemption" of a darklord would be akin to tearing out your own heart, for both the darklord and the Dark Powers (who IMO, like the darklords are part of the demiplane)

A darklord that is slain creates a void in the demiplane that is usually filled with the “next” greater evil in the domain...and if there is nothing that can fill that void than the demiplane “grows over” the void, similar to the body healing a wound.

I think of the old original Arkandale darklord (Nathan?) Timothy he may have been weak enough to lose his domain, but he was trapped on his boat (was it ever considered a pocket domain? I can’t remember). At that time there has to be even worse evils than the elder Timothy, but even though he was relieved of “his” domain he was still imprisoned...

And a being of such evil that fails numerous power checks and is given “their” own domain by the Mists (proto-type matrial that creates the domains and the false histories/beings?) or a fiend’s power rituals (can’t remember if that is the proper term)...maybe it is less an “imprisonment” and more “merging of souls” with the Dark Powers/Demiplane...

Hmmm...makes RL feel less like an imprisoning demi-plane and more like a living, sentient plane...

:)
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

True, a darklord should NEVER be redeemed, unless that's actually the goal which a DM has set for the entire campaign ... not just a particular adventure or story-arc, but the whole thing.

OTOH, we were actually discussing AoUD, not darklordship. Committing an AoUD doesn't necessarily qualify as a "Go Directly To Domain, Do Not Pass Intermediate Terror-Track Steps" card, unless it's something truly over-the-top (like murdering the brother a part of you really does love, to possess a girl that same part of you knows damn well will never, ever, ever forgive you for doing so).

As written, the rules say that an AoUD can't be redeemed -- no matter what, you can never undo that Powers check failure -- but that doesn't mean that a penitent character couldn't make amends enough to stay at "The Caress" for the rest of her life, never falling any farther into darkness than that. It'll likely haunt her, and the DPs will keep their mark on her just in case she weakens, but such a character can be every bit as Good as someone who's never failed a Powers check: she's just not as innocent.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
hidajiremi
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 242
Joined: Thu Jun 03, 2004 1:13 am
Gender: Male
Location: Lexington, KY
Contact:

Post by hidajiremi »

In my first Ravenloft campaign, the party redeemed a darklord, but that was one of the major goals of the campaign almost from the beginning.

One of the PCs was from Odiare, but had spent the last couple of years living under the Darkonese curse. When she regained her memories of how an evil puppet had butchered her parents, she swore revenge against him. As she discovered more about how the demiplane worked, though (she was a wizard specializing in dimensional studies), she came to realize that killing a darklord actually does very little to stop evil. She then spent several years in-game researching (during downtime) a way to undo a darklord's curse. She then used her mastery over dimensional magic to become a good outsider. Finally, she went to Odiare and confronted Maligno, enveloped him in her reality wrinkle so that his connection to his domain was muted, used polymorph any object to turn him into a real little boy, then made it permanent and used an artifact they had found to cast atonement on him, redeeming him for his past evil. While this didn't remove the dark powers' attention, it did wipe the slate clean, allowing Maligno the chance to be good or evil by his own choice. Given the choice, he chose to be good and traveled to Darkon himself to forget the horrors of his past.

In my current campaign, he's one of the PCs, and he just got his memory back. XD

Jeremy Puckett (Hida Jiremi)
"Children are innocent and love justice, while most adults are wicked and prefer mercy." G.K. Chesterton
User avatar
Moral Machivelli
Rat Blinder
Rat Blinder
Posts: 413
Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2005 3:54 pm
Location: Not Here...

Post by Moral Machivelli »

As written, the rules say that an AoUD can't be redeemed -- no matter what, you can never undo that Powers check failure -- but that doesn't mean that a penitent character couldn't make amends enough to stay at "The Caress" for the rest of her life, never falling any farther into darkness than that. It'll likely haunt her, and the DPs will keep their mark on her just in case she weakens, but such a character can be every bit as Good as someone who's never failed a Powers check: she's just not as innocent.
Ture, and that is normally what I'd recomend. But this really dosn't sound like an AoUD. Using divine powers for Violence? A powers check, I'll grant, but it really dosen't sound (to me at least) Like an AoUD.
Post Reply