I'm especially tying this back into "Roots of Evil," but essentially what I'm getting at is the idea, from the Vistani's POV (and yes, IDHTBIFOM--that's really useful, Roti!
But when you get right down to brass tacks, the thing that makes so many of the Ravenloft monsters scary and nasty is the fact that they're in Ravenloft, playing by the Dark Powers' "house rules." The vast majority of said nasties, when sent into places like Krynn, the Forgotten Realms, or Oerth, can be dealt with properly and permanently by the direct application of force in traditional FRPG style.
Consider werewolves--and lycanthropes in general, really. Scary, yes...but the real nastiness behind a werewolf encounter isn't that it might kill your character but that it might tag your character with lycanthropy. Out of Ravenloft you toss a remove curse on it and hey, problem solved.
Then there are the darklords. I mean, half of the things have the "Undying Soul" keeping them going. Drop Draga Salt-Biter back into the Sea of Fallen Stars and wait for the next wandering drow ranger to sail by, and the problem is permanently solved. Hazlik was just one guy from a nation of evil wizards, and a laughable failure in that society, at that! Meredoth's a fragging scary max-level necromancer, and yet his home nation of Alphatia on Mystara, during the period when he was there (when Alphatia owned Norwold and was granting domains...man, those CM modules were fun adventures...) had one thousand max-level wizards running around in its population.
Heck, let's go right to the top of the list: Azalin Rex himself, the biggest, baddest darklord of them all (except maybe Gwydion, but I don't know enough about him to say). Take Azalin and drop him back into Oerth as-is, with Darkon and all his darklord powers intact, and he's still just barely beating out the Horned Society for third place on the Nastiest Evil Nation On Oerth hit parade (after Iuz and, ironically, his own home nation of the Great Kingdom...and I may be missing a couple, because I haven't read my good ol' 1st Edition World of Greyhawk setting in ten years or so...). Put him back as Azalin the Lich, with no nation and no evil curse, and he's just another Iggwilv or Acerack or Zuggtmoy or whomever--sure, a big nasty guy, but one of a herd of big nasty guys.
In conclusion: if the meta-goal is to have these evil creatures do the least amount of damage to the least amount of people, the universe is better-off dumping them out of Ravenloft and out into places where the natural laws enable them to be more easily killed. Mind you--that doesn't address at all some of the other meta-issues (such as "Ravenloft doesn't exist for darklords to be killed, but to imprison them and torture them, possibly over centuries!" or "And just what makes you think those so-called 'innocent people' getting hurt in Ravenloft really exist--or if they do exist, that their souls aren't just lemures, larva, and manes being pulled out of the Lower Planes and getting reincarnated to give 'em a second chance at life and to work off their sins through the beneficience of the Higher Powers?") but from the point of view of "What's the best way to kill Azalin" point of view, the answer really seems to be, "Help him escape to Oerth and let Mordenkainen and Bigby do the job for you."
Discuss.



