Extremely odd question, but just had to ask

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Hell_Born
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 738
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Queensland, Australia

Extremely odd question, but just had to ask

Post by Hell_Born »

My taste in D&D settings is rather diverse, and amongst my collection I have both Ravenloft and an interesting little OGL setting called "Infernum", which is based around struggling to survive -as demon, mortal or fallen angel- in Hell. Now, the way Infernum handles the various races -by treating them as different classes- means that it would technically be possible to play as an Infernum demon in Ravenloft. Of course, this is the last thing I'd do, as for all the complaints made by some over the various demihuman races (like the new tieflings and dragonborn), they're still far more easy to justify than actual full-blooded demons. But then, a voice in the back of my mind started wondering: would it actually be possible to pull it off? To have a valid and flavorful demon character, rather than being an uber-powergamer? To answer this question, I came here; I figure if anyone would be able to answer it, its the more experienced Ravenloft veterans.

For those of you who don't know Infernum (which would probably be most of you), here's the basics of the Demons.

*The demons owe their existence to a renegade faction of angels, who were kicked out of heaven and imprisoned in hell. Furious, they forced themselves upon the native lifeforms (mindless beasts called spawn), then mercilessly experimented upon the resulting offspring, finally culling them into the nine breeds of modern-day demon: Artificer, Beast, Deceiver, Fiend, Hulk, Imp, Malcubus, Stalker and Slaver.

*The demons, knowing that any who survived winning back heaven would be slaughtered, decided that they didn't want to be cannon fodder and promptly tricked their masters into a situation where they could finally strike at them, killing and eating most and chasing the others right out of hell. Since then, Hell has more or less ground along, locked in an apparently endless cycle of treachery and murder.

*Demons of Infernum, unlike D&D demons, aren't intrinistically Evil- they have the same capacity to choose as any mortal race. Unfortunately, various circumstances mean that most do end up being evil, simply in order to survive.

*Demons feel all the same emotions (more or less) as mortals do, but theirs are inherently stronger and exert more control over their behavior- a demon is far more driven by instinct and impulse than a human.

*Demon emotions are also darker hued, which means that when they try to better themselves, their own nature often sabotages their efforts. For example, with most mortals, the sight of a person in pain tends to cause empathy. For demons, their natural emotional reaction to someone suffering is a dark joy; what use to a killing machine is the ability to feel pity or regret for hurting someone? Demons can learn to empathise or sympathise with those who are in pain, but they must learn how to do this, teach themselves not to be pleased that they aren't the one suffering.

*Because of this, demons often have trouble even comprehending the concept of positive emotions. Take love for example- demonic reproduction involves hurling a living demon into a pit of enchanted acids, where they die a hideous death from simultaneously having their flesh dissolve and their organs turn into fanged maggot-things and chew their way out. After 6 months in the pit, the larva pupate and emerge as fully grown demons. They have no family, no friends, nothing- they're totally alone from the moment they first become sentient to the moment they die. Lust, jealousy, possessiveness- these they understand, these they can comprehend. Romance or familial devotion? These are as alien to them as quantum mechanics would be to a squid.

*Then there is the question of sustenance. To survive, demons must torment souls to extract a substance called iliaster. If they don't eat this, they die an agonising death as their body consumes itself, physically and spiritually. They must inflict pain, or die in pain themselves, weak and helpless.

So, can anyone answer my question? Your opinions and theories are what I'm here to hear.
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."

"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Post by Isabella »

That last point poses a bit of a problem for any race claiming they can "choose" to be good - same with the mind flayer conundrum of previous editions. If they aren't horribly, soul-crushingly evil to fellow sentient beings they die an agonizing death from starvation? Some choice. Even if your demon gives money to charity and bakes brownies for orphans on its day off, i don't really think anything counteracts the torture/murder bit.

Other than that, sure it could be pulled off, for a given value of Ravenloft. Most concepts can be pulled off, it just takes a DM or player that's capable of pulling it off well. Everyone would have to agree to the view of Ravenloft that includes PC demons, but so long as everyone is clear on what's going on, why not?

Of course, the way I see it working is likely not the way you do; the first thought that came to mind was a Vampire: the Masquerade type scenario, with each individual demon scheming against each other over the centires in Ravenloft, questing for power or escape, using their own progeny, lesser demons, mortal pawns, or their own brute strength to get their bidding done. A bit different, but could still be worth trying, although I think that game would be better suited for a larp or php rather than tabletop.

As for a singular player demon, if you trust the player, why not? Dr. Faust always had Mephistopheles following him around; instead, your party would have a menacing creature as their ally, one they're not sure they can trust, but can they afford to drive it off and earn its ire? Dare they trust it's assertions that it wants to mend its ways? Can they really keep that thing around, knowing that if they're caught with it, there will be hell to pay?

Two problems I see:

1) People who do not get to play as an uber-cool demon might get miffed.

2) That "you can be good! Promise! It's your choice! Only if you're good, you die a horrible, agonizing melting death. But it's YOUR choice, which makes you even eviler for doing this to survive."
Seriously, chuck that out or work around it. What a load of crock.

IMO, of course. :P
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
User avatar
Hell_Born
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 738
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Queensland, Australia

Post by Hell_Born »

Just to clarify, demons extract iliaster from the souls of the dead, not from the living (though there area few ways to take it from the living, which doesn't hurt them). And unless they destroy a soul (which means reducing its HP below -50), it will be fully healed in... I think it's an hour or so, off the top of my head. In game terms, they need a daily 'feed' of one point per level... and a good torturer can get enough power to sustain a 1st level demon for 4 days (demons can 'hold' extra iliaster in reserve and consume that instead of drinking it fresh) by inflicting a mere 5 points of damage.

Also, isn't there some kind of 'twitch' of the morality if it's the souls of evil creatures they're using for sustenance (and there's certainly plenty of those in Ravenloft)?

Either way, truly good behavior is definately all but impossible for a demon, as its very nature means it must inflict pain or die, but... maybe I'm reading things wrong, but doesn't that give it a certain air of tragedy? I'm not too hot at interpretating emotions though, so I'm most likely completely out of the loop here...
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."

"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Post by Isabella »

Hell_Born wrote: Either way, truly good behavior is definately all but impossible for a demon, as its very nature means it must inflict pain or die, but... maybe I'm reading things wrong, but doesn't that give it a certain air of tragedy? I'm not too hot at interpretating emotions though, so I'm most likely completely out of the loop here...
It does, if that's your sort of thing (it's not really mine). It does not, however, strike me as terribly Gothic, even if one compares them to vampires - vampires rarely starve to death IIRC, for one, and they're also dead to start with (the assumption one could make is that the correct choice for them would be to die, as they are already dead). One might argue that if truly good behavior is all but impossible, they actually are intrinsically evil. (That's obviously not correct, as you can always choose to die. But I digress.)
Back when the common assumption on mind-flayers was they had to eat sentient brains to live, a lot of people didn't care for that either. (I never really asked if it made them more tragic, but the impression I get is "no.")

It also does not strike me as something I'd want to play.
Your mileage may vary, of course. Just because I don't like (hate) it doesn't mean a thing - you really just need to find some players who think it's groovy.

Of course, not seeing the whole text on that aspect of demon life, one doesn't know if there are any work arounds. The description you gave suggested not.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
User avatar
Hell_Born
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 738
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Queensland, Australia

Post by Hell_Born »

I suppose Dissolution is something that could be removed from a demon brought to Ravenloft- perhaps they find they have an instinctive ability to tap the dark energies of the demiplane for nourishment, so they only need iliaster to fuel their powers. Which means the decision is no longer "torture or die" but rather "torture or be (almost) powerless"; without iliaster in their reserve, they cannot access their more supernatural powers and are restricted to their physical capabilities. They cannot spit hellfire, or control machines, enter dreams or control thoughts. They are limited solely to the abilities of their flesh and bone- their claws, their muscle, their minds. In this scenario, a would-be 'redeemed' demon has a choice to face; does it dare to inflict pain so that it can become strong enough to crush the monsters that prowl the night, or does it refuse this power, leaving it just barely above the abilities of a mundane human?

Also, as I pointed out before, if the demon is feeding on the soul of a creature that, in life, was extremely evil (a mass-murderer or one of Drakov's councilmembers (same thing really) or some kind of "Always Chaotic Evil" monster), is it really such an evil act? Feeding on iliaster isn't good, yes, but does it really make it impossible for a demon to be an anti-hero (really the best it can hope to be) instead of a villain?

The entry on Dissolution from the Infernum book goes like so... (repeated pretty much word for word)
The demonic nature is one of all-consuming, insatiable hunger. Demons desire iliaster, the stuff of souls and free will, above all else. The more powerful a demon grows, the more it must consume each day. This terrible hunger drives the Infernum forward - or at least pushes it along its closed vicious circle of suffering. The demons on top of the heap get more iliaster, so they grow more powerful, so they need more iliaster to survive, so they conquer and slaughter their kin to climb even higher.

A demon needs to consume one point of iliaster per level per day. This consumption can come from the demon's reserve or it can feed on fresh iliaster. Most demons keep just enough in their reserve to cover a single day's requirements, meaning that they must starve themselves for a single day before entering Dissolution. In the cities, the common practice is to feed once a day at sundown, but in higher society, lavish feasts and banquets lasting all night are preferred.

The fate of a demon denied sufficient iliaster is a horrible one; if the emon misses even a single day's feeding, it enters the state called Dissolution. The demon's body begins to feed on itself, converting its tissues and ichor into iliaster. The physical signs of a Dissolute demon are obvious. Its hide is drawn tight across its crumbling skeleton. It becomes progressively paler and starts shedding fur and scales.

Dissolution has the following effects (paraphrasing here):
*For every one point of iliaster the demon fails to consume, it gains one temporary negative level. Each negative level inflicts a -1 penalty to attacks, saving throws, ability checks and skill checks, as well as causing it to count as being one level lower for all purposes- such as calculating saving throws against its abilities. It loses access to one mutation of its choice (and can break mutation chains by picking low-level ones) and reduces its iliaster reserve and requirement by one, to a minimum of one.

*If the demon has a number of temporary negative levels equal to its character levels, and then gains more negative levels, it begins converting temporary negative levels to permanent ones instead.

*Once the character has a number of permanent negative levels equal to character level, it dissolves into a puddle of plasm and is destroyed.

*A demon can rid itself of temporary negative levels by consuming and spending a sufficient quantity of iliaster; equal to five times its current effective level (character level minus TNLs). Under normal circumstances, it can't lose permanent negative levels.
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."

"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Post by Isabella »

Hell_Born wrote: Also, as I pointed out before, if the demon is feeding on the soul of a creature that, in life, was extremely evil (a mass-murderer or one of Drakov's councilmembers (same thing really) or some kind of "Always Chaotic Evil" monster), is it really such an evil act?
Well, in Ravenloft, the answer to almost every question that contains the phrase "is it really such an evil act?" is "Yes. Yes it is." :P

In fact, it' says its evil right there in the Core Ravenloft rules, on the DPC chart.
Torture, Routine, of an Evil NPC or monster - 4% chance of failure (2% if your GM considers it to be altruistic torture... which is debatable).

But I do get what you're saying. I'm just being technical now. :roll:
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

The mere fact that a soul once belonged to an evil creature shouldn't make it okay to torture the snot out of it, IMO. Torture isn't just evil because it causes pain, but also because it inherently desensitizes and corrupts the individual who inflicts the pain. If you give a child a teddy bear, and that child gleefully procedes to "torture" it in various grotesque ways, what does that say about the child? The toy can't feel pain, so he's not really hurting anything, yet it's still a callous, malicious thing to do. And an evil soul, while it may be dead, is infinitely more "alive" than the teddy bear.


I love the idea of making the Infernum demon's powers contingent on feeding off pain: it's a classic moral quandry, and a natural outgrowth of literary themes of diabolism in general (i.e. bargaining away one's soul for power). But making the feeding mandatory for survival is just asking for trouble, not least because the Dark Powers could make hash of such a character in a heartbeat (e.g letting the PC think they've caught an evil soul, when it's actually an Innocent geist they're tormenting).
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Hell_Born
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 738
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Queensland, Australia

Post by Hell_Born »

Isabella
Not to mention the fact that it's debateble if it's truly an evil act if the demon's very phisiology demands that it do so or die, but yeah.

No offense intended, but if I put up the details on the various types of demons from Infernum, could you give me your opinion on which ones would fit and what sort of campaign style/focus they might blend into?


Rotipher
One would have to wonder whether a demon would be vulnerable to power's checks though. In the Infernum rules, demons don't need to worry about gaining corruption for torture (as Protracted Torture is only Sin Rating 9, while demons are Corruption Level 15/20, depending on where you look), as they are tainted by virtue of what they are.
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."

"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
User avatar
Hell_Born
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 738
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Queensland, Australia

Post by Hell_Born »

Normally I would have waited for a reply, but I just felt like doing this.

Artificer
These demons look more or less indistinguishable from dwarves; short, stocky humans with strong, supple fingers. The biggest difference, at first glance, is their nails are longer and pointy than dwarves normally let them grow- a closer examination will reveal they're actually made of iron instead of keratin (Artificers have a 1D4 damage claw attack and are Small size). As they grow more powerful, an Artificer appears to be encased in baroque plate armour- this is actually a form of iron exoskeleton that they sprout as they develop. They also gain the power to mentally communicate with machines; first a kind of machine empathy, then the ability to telekinetically control them, and finally the power to physically merge with them by touching them.

As their name suggests, Artificers are the artisians, forgemasters, scientists and general labourers of Hell. They are the foundation of the modern Infernum; the wonderous engines and cunning torture palaces that process millions of souls a day were built by them, the weapons of the demonic legions were forged by them, the war-beasts and bio-mechanoids were bred and trained by them. The vast blackened economy of torment relies upon their efforts. Small wonder that the Artificers as a whole are obsessed with freedom, for they have been enslaved by the other breeds of demons since the angels were dispatched. Artificers are the prime movers in the Free City Heresy, which preaches that all beings -mortals and demons- are equal and deserving of freedom.

Beast
It is impossible to classify these demons by terms of appearance because they are so diverse- a beast is a roughly humanoid form made either from traits of an actual human blended with one or more animals, or a nightmarish bipedal conglomeration of various animal components. But don't let their bestial appearance, which grows all the more freakish as they increase in power, fool you, for they are cunning and cruel and amoral even by demon standards, the most wicked and intelligent of all the breeds. Sorcery is their birthright, and they take to it with great fervour. They are the scholars who invented the torture palaces, the sorcerers who bind souls and entrap their fellow demons in weapons and armor in dark rituals, the advisors who whisper dark lore and foul secrets into their chosen master's ear.

Deceiver
The political masters of the Infernum, bred to be officers and intelligence agents, the Deceivers are (as their name suggests) smoothly treacherous and deceitfully cunning. In appearance, they are the most human breed- the only difference between a Deceiver and a human is that the Deceiver, like all demons, is genderless, though even that is not a certainity; a Deceiver who chooses to assume a gender in their youth truly assumes it, making them the only demon breed (bar the Malcubi) who can create children without dying. But, even with a gendered Deceiver, there is always some tiny flaw, some fatal imperfection that gives them away. A stub of a tail, cloven hooves in place of one or both feet, an eye of mismatched hue or an unnaturally chill touch, any of these can mark the demon for what it is.

The powers that come to them as they grow are powers of deceit and deception, the power to sense the thoughts and desires of others, to possess their bodies, to mesmerise with a glance or mark a binding tie upon them. If forced to combat, the most powerful Deceivers can even spit gouts of hellfire at their foe, though this is something they prefer to avoid using.

Fiend
The dark knights of hell, Fiends were bred to be flying cavalry, now serving as the elite warrior breed and the heralds and messengers of the Infernum. These cruel, arrogant demons have a vaguely draconic form and great, bat-like wings, though far more terrifying is their mastery over hellfire, the greenish-black soul-scorching energy of Hell. Soaring high above the plains of the Pit, Fiends are feared and respected by all who catch sight of them.

Hulk
These terrifying brutes are far from the smartest demons, but what they lack in brains they more than make up for in brawn- Hulks weren't bred for discourse, they were made to break angels. Even the least Hulk is a walking mountain of muscle and armor plate, and as they grow older they only grow larger, becoming the biggest demons in the Pit. Their tremendous strength and terrifying rages make them death incarnate to anything that comes into grip, and an Elder Hulk garbed in the full splendour of its wargear is amongst the most fearsome sights in Hell.

Imp
In startling contrast to the Hulk, the Imp is the smallest and weakest demon breed in hell- it even develops the power to shrink to even less size, making it an excellent scout or stealth operative. But it is their minds that are their greatest advantage, for Imps are as cunning and manipulative as they are frail and weak. Imps are almost invariably in service to some demon or another, but that suits them fine, for they almost always end up as trusted servants with their master's ear. The best place for an Imp is on the shoulder of a far more powerful demon, whispering advice and suggestions.

Malcubi
The Malcubi are unique amongst the breeds in that they along are gendered by default, rather than needing to attain power before they can acquire a reproductive system. Now demons of lust, they are also the demons most able to discover love- like any mortal, they can feel parental affection for their children, and though this feeling is as alien to them as it is to any other demon, it doesn't mean that they can't feel it. In appearance, Malcubi resemble exotically beautiful humans (men or women), though the strong sprout batlike wings that grant them the power to fly. Their powers grant them limited control over a being's emotions, making them first preternaturally alluring, then granting them the power to first observe dreams, then to use their dreams as a gateway. The most powerful of all Malcubi can also infect a victim's mind with their presence, dominating their thoughts entirely.

Slavers
Tall, menacing humanoid figures, Slavers are as vital to the Infernum as Artificers, perhaps more so, for these cruel and malicious brutes work and torture the souls of the damned, churning out ever more iliaster to feed the hungry hordes of hellkin. Often corpulent due to their ready access to iliaster and coin, one should not make the mistake of judging them slow- for all their bulk, even the largest Slaver can move like lightning if it desires. Slavers develop the power to physically reshape souls to their likings, as well as potent mental attacks.

Stalker
Hunters of souls, the infinately long arm of the Infernum, explorers of the unknown caverns, these lupin demons run endlessly, eating up the long miles, remorselessly tracking down their chosen prey. A Stalker... how to describe it? Take a humanoid jackel. Then twist its body around at the waist so that its head and feet point in opposite directions. Starve it to the point of emaciation. Then double the length of its arms and legs before adding more joints than it really seems to need. The powers of the Stalker revolve around hunting, both directly and indirectly. Focused on the here-and-now of the hunt, Stalkers are the most independent of all the breeds. What matter the petty squabbles of the Houses in the borderlands? What matter the whims of the nobles when there is prey to be tracked? A Stalker is always scenting for the tang of blood on the wind, ears always pricked for the slightest sound. They never lose the trail and never stop hunting.
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."

"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
Amicus
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 53
Joined: Wed Jun 18, 2008 7:20 pm
Location: Tampa FL

Post by Amicus »

Would it be possible for a demon to extract iliaster from the soul of someone that they personally did not torture? Because there must surely be a lot of pre-tortured souls wandering around Ravenloft. Don't undead often arise from restless souls tortured by one thing or another (hunger, rage, unrequited love, etc)?

Maybe the demon could disguise themselves as a monster-hunting priest, who feeds on anguished spirits even while exorcising them. Between adventures, perhaps they can sustain themselves by extracting iliaster from the corpses of people who have died of painful illness or for some other reason equivalent to torture.

Maybe the nature of Ravenloft allows iliaster to pool up in places of great spiritual darkness or lingering emotion, like sinkholes of evil? The demon would have to seek such places out in order to recharge.
User avatar
Hell_Born
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 738
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Queensland, Australia

Post by Hell_Born »

In the rules as written, those ideas wouldn't work, however Ravenloft has always been more about flavour then rules...

In Infernum, souls manifest in Hell either by falling from the sky or when a Corruption Level 10+ human dies. Souls -Damned- appear as slightly translucent versions of their original self, though the more damage they suffer the more 'generic' they become, becoming less defined in appearance as a result of the pain they suffer. Damned secrete iliaster as a kind of fluid in response to torment, but this actually evaporates unless the soul is fitted with an extraction kit, which holds the iliaster. There are four types of iliaster; plasm (pain), agony (extreme pain), strain (exhaustion) and sorrow (psychological torment). Demons don't have to personally torture a soul to be able to feed upon it, but souls only produce iliaster if suffering. Souls are, however, preternaturally resilient; you need to take a damned to -50HP to destroy it, and it can still function perfectly well (if somewhat weakened) at anything more than -25Hp. Physical damage heals, without tending, at a point a day- ability damage heals at a point an hour.

The idea that iliaster 'production' might work differently in Ravenloft has its appeals. The Land of Mists is one where the spiritual and material worlds aren't that distinct, so the idea that iliaster could "pool" in places like sinkholes of evil does make a kind of sense. It also has a sort of metpahoric irony; the demon is, essentially, an embodiment of the concept of "evil feeding on evil".
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."

"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

Hell_Born wrote:One would have to wonder whether a demon would be vulnerable to power's checks though. In the Infernum rules, demons don't need to worry about gaining corruption for torture (as Protracted Torture is only Sin Rating 9, while demons are Corruption Level 15/20, depending on where you look), as they are tainted by virtue of what they are.
If the Infernum demon's trying to reform, it might well make itself susceptible to Powers checks, by that very decision. It could start the game with a fairly tainted nature, by virtue of its many past offenses, so would need to perform a lot of good deeds merely to get to the level of corruption of a normal human being. This would be the best option for an Infernum-demon PC in Ravenloft, as it'd be a very dramatic role to play, and refraining from using its powers would help keep it on par with non-demon party members.

If it isn't trying to redeem itself, an Infernum-demon might instead be given a reality wrinkle and tempted to perform power rituals, like any other extraplanar fiend. This would be a good premise for a villain, as it would be a free agent unconfined by domain borders, yet could have a lot more personality than most D&D fiends of a similar power-level.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Hell_Born
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 738
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Queensland, Australia

Post by Hell_Born »

Good points, thanks for bringing them up. Just so you know, though, in Infernum the demon "race" is actually handled as a class of its own; breed (subtype) determines natural attacks, class skills, hit dice and save progression, but everything else is handled as though they were taking levels in a class. Which, I think, should bring them back into balance against other classes. I actually put up details in a different topic, if I should link there.

Actually, while I'm one the subject, which is the better "taint mechanism"; Ravenloft Power Checks or Infernum Corruption? With Corruption, evil acts have a "Sin Rating", and committing them awards "Sin Points" equivalent to the amount of XP one would get from completing an equal level Challenge Rating encounter (so a Sin Rating 20 gives "Sin Points" equal to the XP one would get for completing a CR20 encounter). Sin Points build up like Experience Points; when you have enough, you gain a "Corruption Level". This has no effect on your stats, but makes you more resistant to corruption (the mechanisms of this I don't get, but I think it has something to do with the fact you get less/no XP for lower CR encounters)... though, on the same hand, if your CrL reaches 10+, you remain in Hell as a Damned soul if you die, and at 16+ you become vulnerable to Covenants.

In case you're curious, Sin Ratins go from SR1 (Malicious Deceit) to SR20 (Denying the Will of Gods). I can list up the various sins noted in Infernum if anyone's interested.
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."

"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
User avatar
Archedius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 568
Joined: Mon Aug 21, 2006 8:11 pm

Post by Archedius »

when I look for what races might be allowed in RL I ask myself several questions:

1) Is this race capable of failing powers checks as a normal person would be?

2) Would this race be actually able to socially interact with most domain populations (even if it's negatively- the essence of the question is whether they'd be driven out or lynched)?

3) Would the race by its nature be inured to some of the horrors of Ravenloft?

4) Is the race morally neutral with an equal capacity for both good or ill?

Based on all of those- I'd be cautious about allowing demon PC's.
User avatar
Hell_Born
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 738
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 1:51 am
Location: Queensland, Australia

Post by Hell_Born »

Well, I can't say what the answer would be for 1, but for the others...
2: Malcubi and Deceivers look almost entirely human, so they wouldn't have much more difficulty fitting in than any human who's failed a Power's Check (or has 16+ Charisma). Artificers look like Dwarves, or perhaps even Gnomes, and so can pass themselves off for those races (for good or bad). Hulks and Slavers are more or less warped humans, so might pass as Calibans. Imps, Fiends, Beasts and Stalkers are too physically inhuman to blend into polite society... though there is a mutation that lets a demon (of any type) assume a human (or demihuman) appearance at will. There's also one that lets them turn into an animal, but that's harder to get.

3: hard to say. Violence and gore, yes, they'd be resistant to them. More subtle, cerebral type horrors? No, they'd fall to them like a human would. A farmer's hut ransacked, splattered with blood and body parts wouldn't fase them. Being hunted through the woods by something unseen, yet definately there, something intelligent, malicious and hellbent on killing them? Yes, that would scare them- especially if they have no iliaster to power their more spectacular abilities.

4: yes, they are morally neutral, but they must struggle against their very natures to truly be good. Isn't there precedent for that? Or in the "anti-hero" type character? Someone who accepts their dark nature and tries to use it to keep the outer darkness back from the light?
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."

"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
Post Reply