Before I begin the true meat of this post I want to apologize if I am stepping on anyones toes in the 4th ed conversion thread. I read it for quite a while and felt that I wanted to discuss my idea of the Caliban in fourth ed before submitting it to that thread.
I have always been a big fan of the Caliban race. In fact I think from a bottom line role playing potential the Caliban makes one of the most interesting races available in any system. After all you have a creature that is the by product of negative magical effects that is treated with contempt by even the most forward thinking individuals in the land of Mists. However one thing that never really jibed for me was the fact that Caliban's had to be grotesque in form. I felt that dark magic is a very insidious thing and often it can be best used by hiding itself among the good folk of the realm. With this thought in mind I suggest the following fourth edition Caliban race.
CALIBAN
Deformed of either mind or body and sometimes both, the Caliban is a wretched creature formed by dark magic while still in the womb of its mother
RACIAL TRAITS
Average Height: 4'6"-7'0"
Average Weight 90-400 lb.
Ability scores: roll 1d6 aligning the result by counting from STR down toward CHA this ability receives a +2. Roll 1d6 counting down from STR this ability recieves a -2. Repeat above process once more.
(this is to truly reflect the idea of bad magic working on the womb and should create very different kinds of Calibans)
Size: Medium
Movement: 6 squares
Vision: Normal
Skill bonuses: Because of improper raising and inhumane treatment a Caliban looses one skill choice.
Dark Origin: Because of the Calibans nature and the way people react to a Caliban they receive a bonus of +2 to intimidate while receiving a -2 to any diplomacy checks.
Vile Temper: Because of life long abuse and mistreatment once per an encounter a Caliban can choose to add +1d6 damage to a successful attack roll.
That is what I have right now I would love to hear any comments or suggestions.
Thanks
The new Caliban
- Desertrising
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 230
- Joined: Thu Nov 11, 2004 9:30 am
- Location: Cedar City Utah
- Contact:
The new Caliban
Vote Cthulhu! At least then we know we are going to get screwed.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
While the caliban seems balanced for 3rd edition it's a very weak race compared with the rest for the 4th edition. 
There's no such thing as -2 penalty to skills or ability checks in 4th edition. Not even Kobolds have penalties to strength.
So I would suggest the following changes:
- remove the penalties to ability scores. I would love to suggest removing the penalty to diplomacy checks, but I can't.
It seems to on par with the race.
- I would suggest also: One ability of the player's choice gets a +2 and a different one gets randomly gets a +2 as you proposed.
- Give them low light vision
- Give them a +2 to hit roll and 1d6 to damage once per encounter. It works only for basic or at will powers.
There's no such thing as -2 penalty to skills or ability checks in 4th edition. Not even Kobolds have penalties to strength.
So I would suggest the following changes:
- remove the penalties to ability scores. I would love to suggest removing the penalty to diplomacy checks, but I can't.
- I would suggest also: One ability of the player's choice gets a +2 and a different one gets randomly gets a +2 as you proposed.
- Give them low light vision
- Give them a +2 to hit roll and 1d6 to damage once per encounter. It works only for basic or at will powers.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Desertrising
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 230
- Joined: Thu Nov 11, 2004 9:30 am
- Location: Cedar City Utah
- Contact:
Well I can't say what you suggested does not make sense. I wonder if maybe I should do like they did with the Tiefling and make it part of the racial description that other people tend to treat them with distrust.
I will remove the negative to ability scores and I like the idea of pick one and one comes at random so I think I will stick with that one.
There still seems to be something missing...
I will remove the negative to ability scores and I like the idea of pick one and one comes at random so I think I will stick with that one.
There still seems to be something missing...
Vote Cthulhu! At least then we know we are going to get screwed.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
I don't know much about 4e other than what I've read online, but in my experience most players have moved away from randomness in character creation. Gone are the days of 3d6 for abilities, and most people use some form of point buy. The idea being: you want to play the character you choose to play, and you don't want a quirk of the die to say you're stuck with a character you didn't want for the life of the campaign.
What I'm getting at is that while the random +2 boost is a cute way to show the disparate nature of calibans, what player is going to want to play a caliban without knowing what he's getting? I think it's just asking for DM's to handwave and say "pick what you want". I'd rather see 6 different calibans to choose from, one for each stat. They'd all share most of their racial powers, but maybe one or two would vary between the "strong caliban" and the "wise caliban", etc. (Or maybe the racial feats would vary among the subraces.)
But honestly, I can imagine the STR and DEX versions. I can even imagine an INT caliban with a big throbbing brain or something. CON calibans would need work to differentiate their look from STR calibans. But WIS and CHA calibans? I'm at a loss to figure out how those would even be considered calibans and not something else entirely. (It's hard to imagine a mob stoning the deformed guy because he's freakishly charismatic.)
What I'm getting at is that while the random +2 boost is a cute way to show the disparate nature of calibans, what player is going to want to play a caliban without knowing what he's getting? I think it's just asking for DM's to handwave and say "pick what you want". I'd rather see 6 different calibans to choose from, one for each stat. They'd all share most of their racial powers, but maybe one or two would vary between the "strong caliban" and the "wise caliban", etc. (Or maybe the racial feats would vary among the subraces.)
But honestly, I can imagine the STR and DEX versions. I can even imagine an INT caliban with a big throbbing brain or something. CON calibans would need work to differentiate their look from STR calibans. But WIS and CHA calibans? I'm at a loss to figure out how those would even be considered calibans and not something else entirely. (It's hard to imagine a mob stoning the deformed guy because he's freakishly charismatic.)
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Desertrising
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 230
- Joined: Thu Nov 11, 2004 9:30 am
- Location: Cedar City Utah
- Contact:
Again you have brought up some excellent points.
About the Charismatic Caliban.
While the standard Caliban is ugly and deformed the Charismatic Caliban is eerily beautiful. The positive charisma actually reflects a Caliban who does not even have to ability to remain almost unnoticed, there is just something wrong with something so beautiful.....
That is kind of the idea. I am still waking up so I will probably edit this post in a couple hours so it makes more sense.
About the Charismatic Caliban.
While the standard Caliban is ugly and deformed the Charismatic Caliban is eerily beautiful. The positive charisma actually reflects a Caliban who does not even have to ability to remain almost unnoticed, there is just something wrong with something so beautiful.....
That is kind of the idea. I am still waking up so I will probably edit this post in a couple hours so it makes more sense.
Vote Cthulhu! At least then we know we are going to get screwed.
-
Nikolas of the Mists
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 183
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm
I think I mentioned the 4E Racial building template in the conversion thread, but I will mention it again briefly here.
Attributes: A race gets two +2 fixed stat bonuses. If they get to choose the stat bonus (like humans) they only get one +2 stat bonus.
Skill Bonuses: A race gets gets two +2 fixed skill bonuses. If the racial traits or racial encounter power is stronger than normal, this might be reduced to one +2 skill bonus. (Balancing races in this way is rare and often only used in racial templates at the Monstrous Manual)
Racial Traits: Select racial traits (usually 3-4). These are the quirks and differences that set the race apart from other races out there.
It is important to note that no racial trait is a penalty or restriction -- these traits are all value added abilities. In terms of power it is often two passive racial traits of minor strength, one passive trait of medium strength, and one used trait of higher strength that is a racial encounter power.
Examples of minor passive racial traits are automatic skill training in one skill, bonuses to saving throws, or a weapon proficiency. Examples of a mid range passive racial trait are powers that affect movement ie a dwarf's Stand Your Ground or an Elf's Wild Step, add a minor bonus to one specific Defense, or grant a fixed bonus feat.
Racial traits that reflect a race's origins (ilke elves and eladrin being considered fey) do not count against racial trait limits.
Racial Encounter Powers: Many races have Encounter level powers that are unique and special to them. This encounter power is usually the strongest and most defining ability of all their racial traits. The strength and usefulness of a racial encounter power often defines how many racial traits the race will have. Stronger encounter powers often mean that the race has 1 minor trait, 1 mid range trait, and 1 strong trait (the encounter power); while weaker encounter powers might result in an additional minor, or even mid range racial trait.
Please note that even within these guidelines there are still some exceptions. Some races like dwarves or half-elves might not have encounter powers at all which means they receive additional minor, mid range or potentially even strong versatile passive abilities. The Tiefling is an exceedingly strange case because they receive one minor passive ability, a mediocre mid range power which is actually their encounter power of Infernal Wrath, and their high strength ability is actually their passive fire resistance. Effectively tuning an encounter power down to a mid range power, and granting a strong passive ability can be inherently imbalancing if you're not careful. I honestly think that when they designed the Tiefling they made a huge mistake -- it is the only passive racial ability in the book that scales up by level, and it scales up as an ability that is really good (a Resistance).
Attributes: A race gets two +2 fixed stat bonuses. If they get to choose the stat bonus (like humans) they only get one +2 stat bonus.
Skill Bonuses: A race gets gets two +2 fixed skill bonuses. If the racial traits or racial encounter power is stronger than normal, this might be reduced to one +2 skill bonus. (Balancing races in this way is rare and often only used in racial templates at the Monstrous Manual)
Racial Traits: Select racial traits (usually 3-4). These are the quirks and differences that set the race apart from other races out there.
It is important to note that no racial trait is a penalty or restriction -- these traits are all value added abilities. In terms of power it is often two passive racial traits of minor strength, one passive trait of medium strength, and one used trait of higher strength that is a racial encounter power.
Examples of minor passive racial traits are automatic skill training in one skill, bonuses to saving throws, or a weapon proficiency. Examples of a mid range passive racial trait are powers that affect movement ie a dwarf's Stand Your Ground or an Elf's Wild Step, add a minor bonus to one specific Defense, or grant a fixed bonus feat.
Racial traits that reflect a race's origins (ilke elves and eladrin being considered fey) do not count against racial trait limits.
Racial Encounter Powers: Many races have Encounter level powers that are unique and special to them. This encounter power is usually the strongest and most defining ability of all their racial traits. The strength and usefulness of a racial encounter power often defines how many racial traits the race will have. Stronger encounter powers often mean that the race has 1 minor trait, 1 mid range trait, and 1 strong trait (the encounter power); while weaker encounter powers might result in an additional minor, or even mid range racial trait.
Please note that even within these guidelines there are still some exceptions. Some races like dwarves or half-elves might not have encounter powers at all which means they receive additional minor, mid range or potentially even strong versatile passive abilities. The Tiefling is an exceedingly strange case because they receive one minor passive ability, a mediocre mid range power which is actually their encounter power of Infernal Wrath, and their high strength ability is actually their passive fire resistance. Effectively tuning an encounter power down to a mid range power, and granting a strong passive ability can be inherently imbalancing if you're not careful. I honestly think that when they designed the Tiefling they made a huge mistake -- it is the only passive racial ability in the book that scales up by level, and it scales up as an ability that is really good (a Resistance).
"I wouldn't worry too much about the Vistana with the pistols --
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
