I.e:
- Most of the world is a hostile wilderness with a few scattered points of civilization.
- The population of the points of civilzation seems to be irrelevant to the setting. The points may be large city-states along with villages in their outskirts with total population in the tens of thousands and may well be 5-6 clustered villages with total population less than 2000 people. What's important is that these places are relatively safe and stable.
- These points of civilization are rarely far reaching. A few miles radius and then wilderness again.
- Distance between the points of light seem to be at least 50-60 miles (usually more) resulting in isolation.
From a bit of guessing and calculations using the DMG presented area (Fallcrest, Winterhaven etc) I figured that the average population density seems to be very, very low.
The Nentir Vale area seems to be 18000 sq miles (47000 sq Km) or comparable to the whole core. This huge area has 5 points of light.
A small city of dwarves, two small towns of mostly humans, a human village, and a cluster of villages. There's also an elf tribe in the forests but they can't be considered a point of light.
One can also assume that on the road that links the points of light are a few more hamlets but the text doesn't mention them. Obviously the DM can drop a village or two more when he needs them for his/her campaign as long as they're sufficiently isolated.
Still, it seems that in this area only 20-30.000 civilized humanoids live. How exactly they can keep the roads mostly safe is beyond me since the area is littered with monsters. It's more like, the monsters don't bother to snuff out the points of light.
Anyway, on the system and Ravenloft: Obviously this type seems to favor Ravenloft more than the rest of the campaign worlds.
However, not all domains are like this. Lamordia, Barovia, Richemulot, Darkon etc seem fine (even if the points of light are a bit clustered). However Borca, Dementlieu etc seem to be very "settled". IMO that's not a problem.
A point of light IMO should have a density of 120-250 people per square mile. I.e a city of 12000 people and 25000 more living in surrounding hamlets should create a point of light about 150-200 square miles (14-15 miles radius). A village of 500 people and 300 more living in surrounding farms and thorps should create a point of light about 8-9 square miles (about 3 miles radius).
In Ravenloft I believe the points of light should be closer together than those presented in the canon 4E. OK, Isolation is good, but it can be accomplished with even 20-30 miles between points of light. It's not that someone could rely on help that's one day's march away.






