Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

HuManBing wrote:
Mortavius wrote:Funny how topics change...this has gone from a discussion about whether Paladins can detect undead (and the ramifications of only being able to Detect Chaos) to a debate about the moralities of the alignment system in D&D and the historical real-world references about Paladins.
This is actually quite typical thread-drift. In most threads that deal with issues of morality (specifically Good vs. Evil), you are almost assuredly going to get a significant debate as to how to interpret the fine points of a given scenario.

And most people have enough variance in their sliding scale of Good vs. Evil that it results in quite a number of different viewpoints. As I mentioned in my post above, the thread about "can you kill werewolf cubs?" generated a very lively debate.
Here's how I would handle a paladin killing werewolf cubs:

First, I ask the important question:
Are the werewolf cubs cute but inherently evil monsters, or are they infants afflicted with a curse?

If they are cursed, non-evil, infants, then killing them is an evil act. It might be the "lesser of two evils", in the eyes of a pragamtist, but I wouldn't let a paladin get away with it.

If they are inherently evil monsters, then killing them swiftly and cleanly is not an evil act. It is permissible for a paladin if there seems to be no alternative that doesn't endanger the innocent or prolong the suffering of the cubs.


Being as werewolves are listed as 'always chaotic evil' in the SRD, the answer in a RAW 3E game would probably be 'kill 'em.' The paladin should use his detect evil ability to double check that these small werewolves are evil, just to be safe.

Now, maybe the werewolves in your game aren't always CE. That could change things quite a bit.

In Ravenloft, the paladin's inability to detect evil means that he may have to be more careful about whom he slays. How can he be sure that these monsters are evil? Can they be redeemed,or are they basically just shapeshifting demons?
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

I agree that paladins are one of those hot button topics that tend to inspire thread-drift. But let's nip this one in the bud, shall we? If you want to discuss good vs. evil, moral absolutism vs. relativism, werewolf cubs and the like, kindly start a new thread. Such topics are fair game for discussion here, but have little to nothing to do with this thread's original purpose.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:I agree that paladins are one of those hot button topics that tend to inspire thread-drift. But let's nip this one in the bud, shall we? If you want to discuss good vs. evil, moral absolutism vs. relativism, werewolf cubs and the like, kindly start a new thread. Such topics are fair game for discussion here, but have little to nothing to do with this thread's original purpose.
Of course you are right. Gonzoron.
:diamabel:
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Five
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 886
Joined: Fri Nov 11, 2011 9:59 am

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Five »

I forgot all about Ravenloft's change to the paladin's ability to detect the presence of evil intent/detect evil (2E/3E). Easy to do I guess considering that I've never had to work with a paladin in Ravenloft, but a slip all the same. With that said, my take changes some.

Can paladins detect undead?

In a pick up and play session (using source material only), no. Detect chaos is just that. A successful hit would read as either chaotic or not chaotic. It's vaguely written for I guess a vague result.

With a tweak to the rules, then yes. As I've mentioned previously, a slight modification to the ability would grant the paladin an edge in reading his detection for what it is. Experience could be calculated into sensitivity, which would potentially narrow the feeling down significantly. It would translate a zombie's aura of hunger into a familiar situational feeling, or whatever the case may be. Intelligence check for the memory recall.

Further still, I don't like the change to the ability. I'd keep it detect evil (it's a defining characteristic of the paladin as published), but throw in a penalty all the same. Every attempt the paladin makes to detect evil is made with a saving throws vs. poison (2E), or a Fort save (3E). Ravenloft itself represents evil on a level not like most other settings, and should be treated with such respect. Success indicates at least a vague hit of evil lurking (if evil is actually present of course). Depending on the evil and the sensitivity of the paladin, then it could be more detailed. Intelligent undead as I've said earlier is always a vague hit (due to abstract applications of their evil), unless they make their opposing save which would obviously result in a negative read. A fail staggers the paladin with a sort of emotional miasma. They simply tapped into the wrong thing (maybe even the environment itself). A DM-specific modifier chart would have to be created of course, but that's pretty much how I'd handle a paladin in Ravenloft specifically.

Can paladins detect undead? I guess it all boils down to whether the DM wants them to or not.
Last edited by Five on Tue Mar 13, 2012 7:52 am, edited 2 times in total.
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."

- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

Five wrote:Can paladins detect undead? I guess it all boils down to whether the DM wants them to or not.
Going with the RAW, which is often easier for me, I'd say, "No." Detect chaos does not detect undead as detect evil does unless they happen to be chaotic and even then it doesn't say "undead or alive." It goes back to the idea of "positive and negative energies are not inherently good or evil" when the canon material certainly portrays undead and other negative energy beings as being evil due to negative energy's corrupting influence. On a metaphysical level the energies do not have the sentience to be good or evil. And in Elder Evils there is an example of positive energy gone bad. Rather the methods to which they're used determine their moral alignment.

So detect evil against undead is detecting the spiritual corruption inherent in the creation of undead. Detect chaos does not detect for such corruption. Besides, paladins get detect undead as a first level spell, which is more useful in determining both the presence, and number, of undead. Ravenloft's alterations notwithstanding.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

Some undead aren't evil, of course.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Five
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 886
Joined: Fri Nov 11, 2011 9:59 am

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Five »

ewancummins wrote:Some undead aren't evil, of course.
Which can open up the roleplaying possibilities even wider. The possibilities of the paladin's detect evil (for the purpose of flushing out undead) are numerous:

Positive. Evil is indeed lurking, but it may or may not be of the undead variety. A failed Intelligence check, combined with a bad interpretation, could make this positive into a false positive and you could end up staking and decapitating Jack the Ripper before he commits his ghastly crimes. Good luck explaining that to the authorities!

Negative. No evil, undead or otherwise, is detected. But as ewancummins pointed out, not all undead are evil so here is where a few challenges for the paladin might stem. Trust in your faith even when your eyes decieve you. That sort of thing.

False Positive. Holy Mike (having used detect evil but failed his saving throw) just dropped to his knees and puked his guts out. It would be quite natural for Mike's allies to read this as a sign of something off the charts evil, and throw them into panic mode. A few times of this odd reaction (balanced with intentionally staggered encounters) will start to cause a bit of friction between Mike's allies and himself, if not then his faith and/or abilities. A great chance for group conflict.

False Negative. "I'm not sensing any evil here guys. This so-called Castle Ravenloft is a joke! I'm going back down into the crypt and take a whiz. Nah, I'll be fine..."

Drop the cheesy humour, and the paladin's Detect Evil (for the purposes of identifying the undead) becomes a great roleplaying tool for not only the player, but the DM too. At least, so I think.

All that said though, Ravenloft has changed detect evil to detect chaos, so all of the above is a bit of a sidetrack...
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."

- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by HuManBing »

Actually, one thing that might be useful from a psychological viewpoint is to view law as sanity (even dogma) and chaos as insanity (or whimsy).

So you might get most people being slightly chaotic (registering as psychologically whimsical) or slightly lawful (registering as hidebound or pedantic). Undead which are normally chaotic evil would lose the "evil" identifier but would show up as raving lunatic minds. On the rare occasion you find a lawful undead, it might register as a forbidding, exacting, completely axiomatic and unforgiving (almost robotic) mind. Azalin might register as that, for example.

That could still preserve some of the dramatic super-sensory potential of the ability, I think.
Post Reply