Here's how I would handle a paladin killing werewolf cubs:HuManBing wrote:This is actually quite typical thread-drift. In most threads that deal with issues of morality (specifically Good vs. Evil), you are almost assuredly going to get a significant debate as to how to interpret the fine points of a given scenario.Mortavius wrote:Funny how topics change...this has gone from a discussion about whether Paladins can detect undead (and the ramifications of only being able to Detect Chaos) to a debate about the moralities of the alignment system in D&D and the historical real-world references about Paladins.
And most people have enough variance in their sliding scale of Good vs. Evil that it results in quite a number of different viewpoints. As I mentioned in my post above, the thread about "can you kill werewolf cubs?" generated a very lively debate.
First, I ask the important question:
Are the werewolf cubs cute but inherently evil monsters, or are they infants afflicted with a curse?
If they are cursed, non-evil, infants, then killing them is an evil act. It might be the "lesser of two evils", in the eyes of a pragamtist, but I wouldn't let a paladin get away with it.
If they are inherently evil monsters, then killing them swiftly and cleanly is not an evil act. It is permissible for a paladin if there seems to be no alternative that doesn't endanger the innocent or prolong the suffering of the cubs.
Being as werewolves are listed as 'always chaotic evil' in the SRD, the answer in a RAW 3E game would probably be 'kill 'em.' The paladin should use his detect evil ability to double check that these small werewolves are evil, just to be safe.
Now, maybe the werewolves in your game aren't always CE. That could change things quite a bit.
In Ravenloft, the paladin's inability to detect evil means that he may have to be more careful about whom he slays. How can he be sure that these monsters are evil? Can they be redeemed,or are they basically just shapeshifting demons?

