I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Hi gang,

I've been away for a bit for personal reasons and haven't had a chance to read these controversial additions fully. I just want to say a few things for now:

1) Thanks for not devolving into an outright flamewar here. I gather from this thread that brilliantlight got a bit harsher critique than he was expecting. I hope he hasn't taken it too personally. It's always hard to put your work out there and risk people not liking it. I ask everyone to keep that in mind when commenting. We want honest criticism, but we also want to foster an inclusive and civil community. So watch that line plese.

2) in response this:
HuManBing wrote:I agree. The additions to the wiki are too far off of canon (and culturally too tangential for the feel of the domain) to warrant inclusion as an official site entry.

If they work for individual GMs in their private games, that's fine. But we would need a broader consensus of site-wide support before the wiki should include it.
This is contrary to the goals and methods of a wiki, and specifically Mistipedia policies. If we waited for site-wide consensus for Mistipedia updates, nothing would ever get done. The Mistipedia rules specifically say that non-canon additions are allowed as long they are explicitly labelled as such.
Think of it this way: FoS is now the largest Ravenloft site on the net, so it's entirely feasible that a newcomer to Ravenloft might scan the wiki for the "official word" on domains, NPCs, and plot points. For this reason, it's important to keep things relatively close to canon - and to make sure any new fan-made introductions (aka "fanon") are compliant with canon and clearly pointed out as fan-additions.
Agreed, and as long as the {{homebrew}} tag is used at the start of each section brialliantlight has added, hopefully the big banner saying "This section contains Homebrew non-canon info, created by fans" will make that clear. From a quick look, it seems this has been done in some places but not others. I encourage brilliantlight or anyone else who has the time (I don't right now) to add it where needed. Even better would be to also add a reference tag at the end of these sections such as <ref>Non-canon additions by [[User:brilliantlight]]</ref> to clarify which homebrew sections are whose, in case anyone else wants to add their own take. (If you use a <ref> tag, make sure there's also a {{ref}} tag somewhere on the page or there will be an error on the page)

Still better would be if people also fleshed out the canon sections of these pages, marking them with the {{canon}} label and making sure that anyone looking for the official info can find it, and further highlighting the difference between the canon and non-canon sections. For a decent example of what I'm getting at, see http://fraternityofshadows.com/wiki/Cat ... telligence
I can't find a better one now with references and everything, but that's what I'm getting at.


Anyone, and I do mean anyone, is welcome to put their own homebrew info into Mistipedia, up to and including "{{homebrew}}Strahd is a pirate elf who is fond of showtunes and was falsely accused of killing his brother. He wouldn't hurt a fly.<ref>my silly drunken campaign</ref> {{ref}}" as long as it's labelled and referenced.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by Joël of the FoS »

What Ron said.

I think brilliantlight's propositions are as valid as anyone's. It has its own atmosphere and is interesting.

I also think they are not canon, but by any means, that doesn't mean it should not be archived. Think of Mistipedia also as an extention of Domain-of-the-month, which had many fan made stuff and propositions that were not always canon. As long as they labelled as such, there is no problem.

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

Bluebomber4evr wrote:
"Red Box" Domains & Denizens book, pages 39-40
Ravenloft 3.0 Campaign Setting, pages 170-172
Ravenloft Dungeon Master's Guide, page 19

While they're all brief, there's enough info that you've contradicted (like the names of the darklord's sons, and the fact that their culture is conservative and strongly dislikes foreigners). I don't mean to pile on or have you feel that I'm picking on you, so please don't take this as a personal attack because it's not... but you did ask us what we thought of your changes. To me, the changes you've made to to Rokushima Taiyoo are like the changes Champions of Darkness made to Barovia: out-of-synch with established canon, wildly inconsistent, and tonally inappropriate. If that floats your boat for your own game, go for it. But as far as I'm concerned, that means that it should not be on the main Mistipedia page for Rokushima Taiyoo.

I guess I can change the influences to oni. As far as being conservative that means different things at different times. Conservative is basically defined as a society, people or movement that changes only slowly. Ancient Rome and Greece are usually considered conservative cultures but they also had hedonistic practices among the upper classes. You had very loose sexual practices, rampant drug use, huge feasts and lots of entertainment among the upper classes. Despite all that the Romans are considered to have been very conservative.
Last edited by brilliantlight on Sun Dec 16, 2012 1:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

HuManBing wrote:I agree. The additions to the wiki are too far off of canon (and culturally too tangential for the feel of the domain) to warrant inclusion as an official site entry.

If they work for individual GMs in their private games, that's fine. But we would need a broader consensus of site-wide support before the wiki should include it.

Think of it this way: FoS is now the largest Ravenloft site on the net, so it's entirely feasible that a newcomer to Ravenloft might scan the wiki for the "official word" on domains, NPCs, and plot points. For this reason, it's important to keep things relatively close to canon - and to make sure any new fan-made introductions (aka "fanon") are compliant with canon and clearly pointed out as fan-additions.


Brilliantlight, I remember you were open about expressing skepticism about other posters' fanon in older threads. (E.g. "Personal canon" thread, "How do you see Drakov" thread.) Please understand that others also will scrutinize your fan work, and this goes all the moreso if it's actually placed on the site's public reference services, like the wiki. It's not personal against you, but some quality control is necessary, especially if it carries the imprimatur of the site's "this is canon" endorsement.
Falkovina has lots of canon information on it and its dark lord was well developed and lots of information on as well. Neither is true about Rokushima Taiyoo. Almost nothing known about the domain outside it was based roughly on Japan, the names of his sons (which I admit I missed) and that he is a ghiest. That is about it. No real background on his history, no real background on the domain, no real background on the sons. In fact almost nothing is known about the domain. We know a lot about Drakov, that he was a mercenary captain, that he was particularly brutal, that he impaled his enemies, where and when he entered Ravenloft, that he kept invading his enemies and losing. As far as Falkovnia we know quite a bit as well. It is a military police state, that it oppresses demi-humans, that it practices slavery, that it is the breadbasket of the core, that although it got crushed every time it invaded the country itself is well defended. The reason I picked this domain is that its canon information is very, very thin. You can't say that about Drakov and Falkovnia.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by HuManBing »

That's true, but also part of the "thin canon" for Rokushima Taiyoo is that it's a clearly Japanese-inspired domain. This makes your reliance on Mediterranean cultural tropes somewhat puzzling.

Regarding my changes to Drakov, you expressed your personal opposition to my changes in a forum thread - and that's perfectly fine. That's what forum threads are for. And that's what we're doing now in our feedback to your proposed tweaks. I will also mention that both of those Drakov threads specifically solicit non-canon alterations, so your points about canonicity are moot, even if correct.

Regarding the mods' input, I had made an assumption that FoS' wiki (similar to video game discussion wikis or fiction discussion wikis on other sites) had a specific requirement for canonicity (something along the lines of "forum for fanon, wiki for canon") which is an apparently incorrect assumption. Accordingly, my points regarding those issues can likewise be considered moot.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

HuManBing wrote:That's true, but also part of the "thin canon" for Rokushima Taiyoo is that it's a clearly Japanese-inspired domain. This makes your reliance on Mediterranean cultural tropes somewhat puzzling.

Regarding my changes to Drakov, you expressed your personal opposition to my changes in a forum thread - and that's perfectly fine. That's what forum threads are for. And that's what we're doing now in our feedback to your proposed tweaks. I will also mention that both of those Drakov threads specifically solicit non-canon alterations, so your points about canonicity are moot, even if correct.

Regarding the mods' input, I had made an assumption that FoS' wiki (similar to video game discussion wikis or fiction discussion wikis on other sites) had a specific requirement for canonicity (something along the lines of "forum for fanon, wiki for canon") which is an apparently incorrect assumption. Accordingly, my points regarding those issues can likewise be considered moot.
Except my thread did NOT say non-canon. Although there is quite a bit known about Drakov there is quite a bit of room for interpretation and my take on him contradicts nothing that I know of. It all could fit quite easily in the canon. Being a German-American I naturally think in Greco-Roman terms as most of European culture is heavily influenced by it. But human beings are human beings. Lust, envy, spite, and hate are hardly European monopolies any more than love, generosity, charity and mercy are. There is drug abuse and alcoholism and prostitution in Asia as well as Europe and the US along with honesty, sobriety and sagacity. From what I have read there have been depraved Chinese royal courts where drunkenness and promiscuity were common. When you put someone on a throne and say that they were chosen by God through either "Divine Right" or "Mandate from Heaven" they have a tendency to abuse power and indulge their vices. It isn't Asian or European but human. I am thinking of changing the ice devil to an ogre magi (which Oriental Adventures says is a kind of oni anyways and none of the rest of the oni seemed to fit) and replace the succubus with a hebe-no-onna as I assume the sacrifice after mating is cultural (since it says the sacrifice is a grand ritual and not an immediate devouring) rather than instinctual. If that is the case than one of them could have decided that sacrificing someone OTHER than their meal ticket is the way to go as they are free willed.
Last edited by brilliantlight on Sun Dec 16, 2012 7:53 pm, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by Joël of the FoS »

HuManBing wrote:Regarding the mods' input, I had made an assumption that FoS' wiki (similar to video game discussion wikis or fiction discussion wikis on other sites) had a specific requirement for canonicity (something along the lines of "forum for fanon, wiki for canon") which is an apparently incorrect assumption. Accordingly, my points regarding those issues can likewise be considered moot.
Well if you remember Ricoba, many people liked it better than Richemulot, other people's campaign still have Soth in his seat, or have Bluestpur as the Moon, etc.

Sometimes a new and interesting point of view can occur, even if I completely agree this isn't canon.

But it can represent a cool option for other people.

---

Gentlemen, I think we are now very close to a nitpicking ugly fight, and that isn't the tradition on our boards. I think it's quite cool and plaisant that we have to moderate the boards very rarely, so let's keep it that way!

Please move back to civil discussions on Rokushima Taiyoo pros and cons, or I'll close the thread. Thanks for your understanding.

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by HuManBing »

Joël of the FoS wrote:Well if you remember Ricoba, many people liked it better than Richemulot, other people's campaign still have Soth in his seat, or have Bluestpur as the Moon, etc.

Sometimes a new and interesting point of view can occur, even if I completely agree this isn't canon.

But it can represent a cool option for other people.
Agreed on all counts. I might make a few fanon contributions of my own, in that case.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

I made some changes. I removed all references of forgeiners, replaced the ice devil with an ogre mage and the succubus with a hebe-no-onna and made a few other minor adjustments. It should look a bit more Oriental now.
User avatar
vipera aspis
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 351
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2005 8:38 pm
Location: Chicago

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by vipera aspis »

Hey you guys ever see Imprint? That was a total Asian Island of Terror. Minor darklord and all. Plus sinister mist.
my bones among the rocks and roots
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:I encourage brilliantlight or anyone else who has the time (I don't right now) to add it where needed.
I've gone ahead and done this, marking all of these additions properly as non-canon and citing them. Please continue to mark any future additions similarly.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Post Reply