I've been away for a bit for personal reasons and haven't had a chance to read these controversial additions fully. I just want to say a few things for now:
1) Thanks for not devolving into an outright flamewar here. I gather from this thread that brilliantlight got a bit harsher critique than he was expecting. I hope he hasn't taken it too personally. It's always hard to put your work out there and risk people not liking it. I ask everyone to keep that in mind when commenting. We want honest criticism, but we also want to foster an inclusive and civil community. So watch that line plese.
2) in response this:
This is contrary to the goals and methods of a wiki, and specifically Mistipedia policies. If we waited for site-wide consensus for Mistipedia updates, nothing would ever get done. The Mistipedia rules specifically say that non-canon additions are allowed as long they are explicitly labelled as such.HuManBing wrote:I agree. The additions to the wiki are too far off of canon (and culturally too tangential for the feel of the domain) to warrant inclusion as an official site entry.
If they work for individual GMs in their private games, that's fine. But we would need a broader consensus of site-wide support before the wiki should include it.
Agreed, and as long as the {{homebrew}} tag is used at the start of each section brialliantlight has added, hopefully the big banner saying "This section contains Homebrew non-canon info, created by fans" will make that clear. From a quick look, it seems this has been done in some places but not others. I encourage brilliantlight or anyone else who has the time (I don't right now) to add it where needed. Even better would be to also add a reference tag at the end of these sections such as <ref>Non-canon additions by [[User:brilliantlight]]</ref> to clarify which homebrew sections are whose, in case anyone else wants to add their own take. (If you use a <ref> tag, make sure there's also a {{ref}} tag somewhere on the page or there will be an error on the page)Think of it this way: FoS is now the largest Ravenloft site on the net, so it's entirely feasible that a newcomer to Ravenloft might scan the wiki for the "official word" on domains, NPCs, and plot points. For this reason, it's important to keep things relatively close to canon - and to make sure any new fan-made introductions (aka "fanon") are compliant with canon and clearly pointed out as fan-additions.
Still better would be if people also fleshed out the canon sections of these pages, marking them with the {{canon}} label and making sure that anyone looking for the official info can find it, and further highlighting the difference between the canon and non-canon sections. For a decent example of what I'm getting at, see http://fraternityofshadows.com/wiki/Cat ... telligence
I can't find a better one now with references and everything, but that's what I'm getting at.
Anyone, and I do mean anyone, is welcome to put their own homebrew info into Mistipedia, up to and including "{{homebrew}}Strahd is a pirate elf who is fond of showtunes and was falsely accused of killing his brother. He wouldn't hurt a fly.<ref>my silly drunken campaign</ref> {{ref}}" as long as it's labelled and referenced.


