4E after-playtest review.

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

4E after-playtest review.

Post by alhoon »

I won't go in discussions about how I like/ don't like the rules. I will tell you how it worked out for me, problems encountered etc while playing.

Setting: Homebrew world, POLight system. Three PCs. They have gained 3 levels so far, going from 8th to 11th.

The game works as a game. Period. :) I.e not as a reality emulator.
It's easy to learn and to play, hard to master. Not as mentally taxing as earlier versions (except OD&D). Tactics are not exactly essential to survive but it saves the chars of a lot of troubles. Gaps in believability and reality exist.

Now, a more expanded list of observations, good and bad.

- For the DM: Far, far easier. Combat runs smoothly and I don't have a headache after 4-5 hours of game. Indeed, I won't miss the christmas tree: "OK, usually the cleric has +11/6 hit roll deals 1d8+5 damage.
Now, divine power active, bless active, bull's strength active, shield of faith active, divine favor active, resist fire active. Oh, bull strength and divine favor were dispelled? Or was it resist fire?"

- They told you "add up the XP from monsters and you'll be fine". They lied. 4 orc raiders = 600 XP. Orc Bloodrager = 600 XP. The battle rager is MORE challenging for a 7th level party because he can hit them while the skirmishers miss.
The system of the XP works if you mix monsters of +/-2 level of the party, not 5.
In fact I'll give you an example from my game: 2 of the chars, 8th level. Target XP 700. Encounter 1: 4 raiders +2 level 4 minions=700 XP. They crushed them. Encounter 2: Battlerager +1 9th level minion = 700 XP. Even with better luck from the PCs, the encounter was good.

- A session of 2-3 hours is completely possible, full of RPlaying and combat. In those 2-3 hours I managed to accomplish as much gmae as I could in 4-6 hours of 3rd edition.

- RPlaying entirely possible. It is tricky to make right skill challenges though. I could open the Monstrous manual and throw a "good" encounter to the PCs in 5 minutes, by adjusting monsters etc.
I haven't figured how to make a "good" skill challenge yet. :( Every time I make a skill challenge I either forget something, something doesn't go as planned and I'm hard pressed to find the alternatives etc.

- They told you monsters are balanced. They lied. Lamia: elite 12th level monster. I downgraded her to 10th level and she pawned the party. We're talking about a possible TPK if I didn't cheat.
7th level red dragon solo: They didn't even have to use all their dailies.
Dragon=1500 XP. 10th level lamia + minions=1200 XP.
Admitedly, I used good tactics for the lamia and the PCs were quite lucky with the dragon. But still she's MORE powerful.

- Downgrading monsters doesn't work very well except for a +2/-2 window, not +5/-5 as the DMG suggests. Also changing tier (i.e dropping from paragon to heroic) is also problematic because the abilities against paragon PCs are more powerful.

- Luck is as important if not more so as in 3rd edition. Many of us believed that "more rolls would equal out the luck factor". In fact there are less rolls and also if you miss with a daily you're in a bad spot (except if you're a fighter).

- Magic items: Now, that's the worst part I have seen so far. :x There are many 7th level items far more useful than other higher level items.
Example: Dwarven plate armor+2 (level 7) compared with a magic plate armor +3 (level 11). The difference to AC is only 1, the dwarven plate heals the character for free once per day and gives +2 to endurance checks. After you pit them through a mummy and give them a challenge in a jungle (endurance or lost HSurge) they wouldn't underestimate the +2 to endurance checks.

-Paragon tier: Now that we moved to paragon levels (haven't tried the new powers yet) the feats seem far more interesting and powerful. Just reading the paragon paths and the powers made my imagination tingle.
Yes, once you're 11th level you feel different, more powerful.
The power gap between 10th and 11th seems almost twice as large as the gap between 9th and 10th.
This gives a sense of accomplishment.
I mean: Fighter: AC 29, heals all the time with dailies and armor. Paladin AC 27, heals 2/day as a minor action. The orc raiders and bersekers have a +8 vs AC. :?
According to the rules the 3 PCs should now be challenged by an encounter of 1800 XP. However, a group of 10 orc bersekers and 5 skirmishers (2500 XP) wouldn't even pose a threat to them while it would send the village guard running for the hills shouting prayers.
The knowledge that yes, they can save a whole village without breaking a sweat is gratifying.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: 4E after-playtest review.

Post by Jester of the FoS »

alhoon wrote:- They told you "add up the XP from monsters and you'll be fine". They lied. 4 orc raiders = 600 XP. Orc Bloodrager = 600 XP. The battle rager is MORE challenging for a 7th level party because he can hit them while the skirmishers miss.
The system of the XP works if you mix monsters of +/-2 level of the party, not 5.
In fact I'll give you an example from my game: 2 of the chars, 8th level. Target XP 700. Encounter 1: 4 raiders +2 level 4 minions=700 XP. They crushed them. Encounter 2: Battlerager +1 9th level minion = 700 XP. Even with better luck from the PCs, the encounter was good.
Odd since the raiders have +9 while the bloodrager has +11. Damage is comparable as are hitpoints but the raiders have 4x as many changes to roll and hit.
This might come down to tactics and luck. The bloodrager only attacks a single target, so if the raiders did similar and focused their efforts it *should* be close.
alhoon wrote:- They told you monsters are balanced. They lied. Lamia: elite 12th level monster. I downgraded her to 10th level and she pawned the party. We're talking about a possible TPK if I didn't cheat.
7th level red dragon solo: They didn't even have to use all their dailies.
Dragon=1500 XP. 10th level lamia + minions=1200 XP.
Admitedly, I used good tactics for the lamia and the PCs were quite lucky with the dragon. But still she's MORE powerful.
Also depends on part make-up and powers. A party with lots of close and area powers and fewer weapons attacks should hurt a lamia. But it can really dish out the damage.

Still, monsters are *roughly* balanced with damage, AC, hp. Anything else (swarm traits, additional powers, etc) can really tip the scale and make things go all screwy.
So melee based monsters will tend to be more balanced and solid that casters which can get wobbly balance-wise. An elites and solos, designed to have even more abilities, can also be wobbly.


And still *much* better than 3e. Compare CR7 creatures. The chull, hill giant, flesh golem, and dire bear are all close with hitpoints and damage. But the chull has extra paralysation that can mess you up.
Now compare it to a fire elemental; huge so extra reach, twice the damage...
alhoon wrote:Magic items: Now, that's the worst part I have seen so far. :x There are many 7th level items far more useful than other higher level items.
Example: Dwarven plate armor+2 (level 7) compared with a magic plate armor +3 (level 11). The difference to AC is only 1, the dwarven plate heals the character for free once per day and gives +2 to endurance checks. After you pit them through a mummy and give them a challenge in a jungle (endurance or lost HSurge) they wouldn't underestimate the +2 to endurance checks.
The 'base' items are every 5 levels: +1 item, no additional powers. That's level 1, 6, 11, 16, 21, 26 where it steps up to the next plus.
So a level 5 weapon will *always* be +1 while a level 7 weapon will always be +2. But a level 2 and level 5 weapons, while both being +1, vary on the side-ability.
This is the same with weapons, armour, neck slot, implements, etc.

So you can go for the level 6 item that has no additional powers except the bonus 5% chance of hitting or give up the hit chance for extra coolness, or save for a level and go for the level 7 item.
User avatar
Snake
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 277
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2004 7:01 pm
Location: Lost in the Dread Realms

Post by Snake »

If you are using a +5 weapon, do you have to be level 21-25 to use it, or is that level just for the weapon itself to determine its bonus?
Forgotten Son of Lord Vasili
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

That's just the level range typical of finding such. Players can use whatever "+" they happen to find, so a +5 before level 21 is kind of rare but still useable.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: 4E after-playtest review.

Post by alhoon »

Jester of the FoS wrote:
alhoon wrote: In fact I'll give you an example from my game: 2 of the chars, 8th level. Target XP 700. Encounter 1: 4 raiders +2 level 4 minions=700 XP. They crushed them. Encounter 2: Battlerager +1 9th level minion = 700 XP. Even with better luck from the PCs, the encounter was good.
Odd since the raiders have +9 while the bloodrager has +11. Damage is comparable as are hitpoints but the raiders have 4x as many changes to roll and hit.
This might come down to tactics and luck. The bloodrager only attacks a single target, so if the raiders did similar and focused their efforts it *should* be close.
The bloodrager has +11, the raiders +7 with the axes. So against the Paladin's 25 AC at that level, the raiders had to roll 18+ to hit while the bloodraider [/i]14+[/i]. Now, add the charge (the raiders throw axes, so they don't charge[/i].
Also the bloodrager retaliates every time he's hit! When I played him, he was unlucky and missed the attack that would heal him 50+hp. The party also used dailies on him and for a change, they had some good rolls. Their luck was better than with the raiders.
Anyway, the Bloodrager was attacking 2-3 times per round for the whole combat with a +11 while the raiders were dying so missing attacks. All in all, the BRager attacked about 9-12 times while the raiders attacked about 15-20 times. However their attacks deal far less damage and they have only +7 to hit rolls with their throwing axes.

Jester of the FoS wrote:
alhoon wrote:- They told you monsters are balanced. They lied. Lamia: elite 12th level monster. I downgraded her to 10th level and she pawned the party. We're talking about a possible TPK if I didn't cheat.
7th level red dragon solo: They didn't even have to use all their dailies.
Dragon=1500 XP. 10th level lamia + minions=1200 XP.
Admitedly, I used good tactics for the lamia and the PCs were quite lucky with the dragon. But still she's MORE powerful.
Also depends on part make-up and powers. A party with lots of close and area powers and fewer weapons attacks should hurt a lamia. But it can really dish out the damage.

Still, monsters are *roughly* balanced with damage, AC, hp. Anything else (swarm traits, additional powers, etc) can really tip the scale and make things go all screwy.
So melee based monsters will tend to be more balanced and solid that casters which can get wobbly balance-wise. An elites and solos, designed to have even more abilities, can also be wobbly.

And still *much* better than 3e.
Agreed on all points. Also the Lamia has climb and used it to climb on a tall rock where the PCs needed athletic rolls to climb, dicing out free attacks to those climbing. Oh... and she heals with those free attacks. :?
So the terrain and tactics helped the Lamia... but close to TPK?! 10th level elite against 3 9th level chars?!
And really that at will range 5 power, sustainable, 3d6+4 damage/round attack is too much. If the Lamia doesn't move, she can sustain 2 such attacks and attack a third target...
Jester wrote: The 'base' items are every 5 levels: +1 item, no additional powers. That's level 1, 6, 11, 16, 21, 26 where it steps up to the next plus.
So a level 5 weapon will *always* be +1 while a level 7 weapon will always be +2. But a level 2 and level 5 weapons, while both being +1, vary on the side-ability.
This is the same with weapons, armour, neck slot, implements, etc.

So you can go for the level 6 item that has no additional powers except the bonus 5% chance of hitting or give up the hit chance for extra coolness, or save for a level and go for the level 7 item.
Yes, but can you really claim that this level 11 plate +3 is more useful than the dwarven plate +2 (level 7)? And the level 11 one costs far more.
The "base item every 5 levels, extra powers" thing doesn't work. That's why they had to say "Sell at 1/5th the value. Because 90% of the people that had a good magic item of level 7-8 will sell the level 10s and 11s.

ALSO: Don't forget the good points.
It's so easy to play that I dread DMing 3rd edition now. My sister loves 3rd so I'll do it, but really 4th is so much easier.
Better? IMO no. However the simplicity overcompensates me for the lack of realism and the lack of choices.
Really Jester, you should try DMing it before saying "I don't like 4th!"

It is a GAME. I have forgot that it doesn't have to be a perfect emulation of reality at the cost of dozens of calculations. I prefer playing 3rd, DMing 4th.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

It doesn't help that dwarven armour really is some awesome armour and has one of the best powers. It's probably under-leveled.

But it is only available as chain+, so anyone with cloth or leather would be better off with the +3 and solid AC rather than the armour they cannot wear.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Bloodthread is also good. Anyway that's what I was talking about. There are balance issues with the items.

Also what about the black iron plate armor? resist 5 fire and necrotic. Good against the dragon. Good against the deathpriest of orcus. Good against the tiefling heretic. (All these were adventures/encounters I played)

Jester of the FoS wrote: I've also been hard on 4e because the game is set-up to play how they want you to, not how you want to.
However I agree with Jester here. It's my biggest problem with 4th edition. Not as bad as Jester says but yes, it is there. It's limiting.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Re: 4E after-playtest review.

Post by Isabella »

alhoon wrote: Also the bloodrager retaliates every time he's hit!
Well, no.

pg. 268 In the Player's handbook, says you can take only one immediate action per round.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Hmmm... yes, I remember. I played it wrong then. To think, I used this rule today with my chars. :)
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

OK, At first the 4th ed "adventures" we were playing were just close tied encounters with a similar theme. I.e "Orcs harassing town. Go lair. Enc1 in the woods, enc 2 out of lair. Enc 3 trap, enc 4 boss A, enc 5 boss B. Threat terminated, Adventure over" These encounters were I admit unimagitive. Monsters I have made or used from the MManual, with little terrain effects. OK in the lamia combat that "little" terrain effect almost caused a TPK. :oops:

After familiarizing enough with the system I made a more "real" 4th edition adventure. You know with deeper plot, surprises encounters that were more deep etc. I added drama points with the PCs running through trapped terrain with a Drow outpost crushing on them piece by piece and enemies on tow and it was rewarding. It was also increadibly easy to play and fast.

I enjoyed DMing this adventure. Now I'll revert back to 3rd for a few sessions. :)

FINAL OPINION: 4th edition is more "cinematic". It's what you would expect to see in a movie expressed with words. The PCs are heroes, far far away from everyday guys.
It's what I want to play if I want a small group of heroes to delve in a dark temple and crush enemies heroically.

I believe it's really hard to capture the feeling I want in my Ravenloft games in 4th edition. It's far easier to capture the feeling I want in my heroic games though.

3rd edition has more options and far more realism. For me Ravenloft should be played in 3rd edition, where your 3rd level fighter can be felled with a critical from an axe, where there's ability damage and energy drain.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Strahdsbuddy
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 605
Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 4:02 am
Gender: Male
Location: A Finger Lake

Post by Strahdsbuddy »

Great summary, Alhoon. To tie it in with the other (inflamatory) post about if it IS D&D, the answer is certainly yes, considering what OD&D came from. WotC wanted a game geared towards combat, once again in an attempt to bring in new players. At some point my players have all said soemthing to the affect of "Rambo could survive that, and my guy is 12th level!" Fine. Depending on the style of play, it works just fine.

If you play Revenloft the way i think the majority of us do, healing surges and the like don't really matter. I think that is the reason for the stubbornness of conversion, particularly on this board, is that a character with a ton of skills quietly infiltrating a secret society has the advantage over the character with a ton of combat options.

Now, if only Wizards realized just how different a game they created, they could perhaps produce BOTH, like in the old D&D/AD&D days. THe different styles of play would fit the different styles of gamers.
Get the Core Genesis Project V4 https://fraternityofshadows.com/Mausole ... ect_v4.pdf

Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
User avatar
Snake
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 277
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2004 7:01 pm
Location: Lost in the Dread Realms

Post by Snake »

alhoon wrote:FINAL OPINION: 4th edition is more "cinematic". It's what you would expect to see in a movie expressed with words. The PCs are heroes, far far away from everyday guys.
It's what I want to play if I want a small group of heroes to delve in a dark temple and crush enemies heroically.

I believe it's really hard to capture the feeling I want in my Ravenloft games in 4th edition. It's far easier to capture the feeling I want in my heroic games though.

3rd edition has more options and far more realism. For me Ravenloft should be played in 3rd edition, where your 3rd level fighter can be felled with a critical from an axe, where there's ability damage and energy drain.
After finally playing a session in 4th I have to say this right here best summarizes 4th edition in my opinion. 4th is a fun system if you want to delve into a dungeon and beat things down. If you and your group's style is the "Kick down the door" style, than 4th will likely work out for you. I found though that creating a deep and complex story with 4th was quite difficult, and I have to say I missed 3rd editions spells in the back of the book by the end of the session. :?

Anyway, my two cents.
Forgotten Son of Lord Vasili
User avatar
Zettaijin
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 670
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
Gender: Male
Location: Himeji, Japan

Post by Zettaijin »

I'd like more example of why a complex story cannot be as easily woven with 4e...

That is, no editions of AD&D were ever, to my knowledge, anything more than rules used to translate actions and random occurences into dice rolls. Fluff exists slightly outside of these rules and, really, fluff doesn't (or at least shouldn't) require that many dice rolls.

I can see how character creation could be an issue, but then again, seeing as how we're only talking about non-combat skills (I assume), it's not that hard to house rule something.

Or maybe I'm just not familiar enough with 4e yet...
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

On the contrary, you can make very complex stories in 4th edition. Also you can gain a level without ever taking a weapon out.

You can have a complex and deep story without a game system at all! Just with a single d6.
Look at all those nice movies with deep story and immersion. They don't have a game system. :)

However, this is not what 4th edition is made to do. The abilities and powers are just too "cool". 8) Not dark flavored, not moves every soldier or veteran could pull out. They're cool.
Refreshingly cool when you use the "beat the evil beastie" power. A very nice break for me from the 3rd edition cyceon of rules and balance juggling.

You know, it's the kind of game you can call 4 friends to your home and tell them "Look what I got here! It's a game about heroes beating up evil monsters, plowing in dark places the sun has never seen! You know, like X movie!"
They will say "Woooo!" :shock: "Let's play!"

And you sit down and play. You explain the rules in 30 mins and start off with the premade chars. After 3-4 hours of play (some monopoly games are longer than that), they go home happy they killed the evil monsters and saved the princess.

It's not a game that focuses on deep campaigns. You can do it, certainly, but it's not what it was made to be.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Zettaijin
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 670
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
Gender: Male
Location: Himeji, Japan

Post by Zettaijin »

Some would argue that AD&D as a whole was never meant for complex storytelling.

Who cares about story when you have fireball spells?

I remember my first game of 1st ed. AD&D from way back. One of my fellow players got his wizard up in levels to a point where he could cast the dreaded third level spells...

Somehow, finding occasions to drop fireballs onto unsuspecting orcs seemed more important than the fact that he was walking into town with a blood stained wizard's robe.

Cool powers always existed in the form of wizards' spells.

I won't even get started on the my first Dark Sun experience - 20+ strength scores at 3rd level? Multiple attacks?

There's that lure of number crunching in AD&D whatever the edition, as if the game was MADE for combat and breaking skulls.

Face it, when you play AD&D, there's always a little Red Mage by your side reminding you that charisma scores are the least important for a min/maxer and that anything can be justified with proper fluff. You might choose not to listen, instead going with the Black Mage and dropping fireballs on everything, but you can't ignore his presence...
Post Reply