Setting: Homebrew world, POLight system. Three PCs. They have gained 3 levels so far, going from 8th to 11th.
The game works as a game. Period.
It's easy to learn and to play, hard to master. Not as mentally taxing as earlier versions (except OD&D). Tactics are not exactly essential to survive but it saves the chars of a lot of troubles. Gaps in believability and reality exist.
Now, a more expanded list of observations, good and bad.
- For the DM: Far, far easier. Combat runs smoothly and I don't have a headache after 4-5 hours of game. Indeed, I won't miss the christmas tree: "OK, usually the cleric has +11/6 hit roll deals 1d8+5 damage.
Now, divine power active, bless active, bull's strength active, shield of faith active, divine favor active, resist fire active. Oh, bull strength and divine favor were dispelled? Or was it resist fire?"
- They told you "add up the XP from monsters and you'll be fine". They lied. 4 orc raiders = 600 XP. Orc Bloodrager = 600 XP. The battle rager is MORE challenging for a 7th level party because he can hit them while the skirmishers miss.
The system of the XP works if you mix monsters of +/-2 level of the party, not 5.
In fact I'll give you an example from my game: 2 of the chars, 8th level. Target XP 700. Encounter 1: 4 raiders +2 level 4 minions=700 XP. They crushed them. Encounter 2: Battlerager +1 9th level minion = 700 XP. Even with better luck from the PCs, the encounter was good.
- A session of 2-3 hours is completely possible, full of RPlaying and combat. In those 2-3 hours I managed to accomplish as much gmae as I could in 4-6 hours of 3rd edition.
- RPlaying entirely possible. It is tricky to make right skill challenges though. I could open the Monstrous manual and throw a "good" encounter to the PCs in 5 minutes, by adjusting monsters etc.
I haven't figured how to make a "good" skill challenge yet.
- They told you monsters are balanced. They lied. Lamia: elite 12th level monster. I downgraded her to 10th level and she pawned the party. We're talking about a possible TPK if I didn't cheat.
7th level red dragon solo: They didn't even have to use all their dailies.
Dragon=1500 XP. 10th level lamia + minions=1200 XP.
Admitedly, I used good tactics for the lamia and the PCs were quite lucky with the dragon. But still she's MORE powerful.
- Downgrading monsters doesn't work very well except for a +2/-2 window, not +5/-5 as the DMG suggests. Also changing tier (i.e dropping from paragon to heroic) is also problematic because the abilities against paragon PCs are more powerful.
- Luck is as important if not more so as in 3rd edition. Many of us believed that "more rolls would equal out the luck factor". In fact there are less rolls and also if you miss with a daily you're in a bad spot (except if you're a fighter).
- Magic items: Now, that's the worst part I have seen so far.
Example: Dwarven plate armor+2 (level 7) compared with a magic plate armor +3 (level 11). The difference to AC is only 1, the dwarven plate heals the character for free once per day and gives +2 to endurance checks. After you pit them through a mummy and give them a challenge in a jungle (endurance or lost HSurge) they wouldn't underestimate the +2 to endurance checks.
-Paragon tier: Now that we moved to paragon levels (haven't tried the new powers yet) the feats seem far more interesting and powerful. Just reading the paragon paths and the powers made my imagination tingle.
Yes, once you're 11th level you feel different, more powerful.
The power gap between 10th and 11th seems almost twice as large as the gap between 9th and 10th.
This gives a sense of accomplishment.
I mean: Fighter: AC 29, heals all the time with dailies and armor. Paladin AC 27, heals 2/day as a minor action. The orc raiders and bersekers have a +8 vs AC.
According to the rules the 3 PCs should now be challenged by an encounter of 1800 XP. However, a group of 10 orc bersekers and 5 skirmishers (2500 XP) wouldn't even pose a threat to them while it would send the village guard running for the hills shouting prayers.
The knowledge that yes, they can save a whole village without breaking a sweat is gratifying.



